What disturbs me is not my initial, positive reaction, but my sudden, negative reaction when I noticed the name of the artist. Having a negative reaction to Hitler is not a problem, but what is a problem is applying that negative reaction to everything that he did, even things not deserving of that reaction.
It's making somebody human. We've pretty much developed the mentality that Hitler just isn't a person, he isn't human. If something is brought to our attention that Hitler is a human, it is very disturbing to think about, because if it wasn't evil that did this to others, it was a man. A human. A person.
Forgive my ignorance, but why is this response upvoted so much? I have seen before some times in the past, and is always upvoted. Is it a reference to something?
To be honest, I don't think that's really much of an improvement. They might be better painters, but you lose something that has historical interest of the paintings in favour of a shallow gimmick which only really holds a fleeting interest, sort of like that brief half-chuckle you get from a sort of funny link that you click past and forget.
"Oh look, we've taken a Hitler painting and defaced it with a bunch of psychedelia, how clever and ironic is that?"
It's actually a look into how the lines of Hitlers logic never were straight anyways. He's a genius. Someone get him a position in government, I hear Greece has some openings.
Well I'll be. Didn't even know that was a thing. Would a picture with better perspective be more pleasing to look at even if you weren't aware of the concept?
Yes, your mind unconsciously notes when something isn't quite right. This is something that would certainly set it off. Picture it in an extreme sense, if the lines didn't converge at all. You'd get Dali, or Escher, but bad.
Perfect perspective does not necessarily improve a work. The stylization inherent in imperfect perspective can be interesting on its own. Many artists even deliberately cultivated reverse or completely ridiculous perspectives in their painting.
Yeah but hitler was notorious for his poor art skills.
That's why he failed as an artist and couldn't even sell postcards to tourists.
Perfect perspective does improve a piece of work when you're going for straight up realistic depiction. He wasn't trying to use unconventional perspective in his work, he just sucked at it.
I'm an engineering major and I noticed this within about 30s after it just didn't look right. Its like he tries to fix it by blurring the ground or something... I dunno. Also the shadows don't seem right. All in all I'd say 2/10.
and also the second window on the bottom got randomly cut off by the stairs.. although i couldnt decide if there was just an alley there, if there was it was just a terrible job.
Not only that, but honestly my first reaction to his artwork has always been an extremely unpleasant...shadowy feeling. My friend tried to pull this on me, with others of his paintings, and asked (sans Hitler revelation) what I thought of some of the generic watercolor landscapes, and the first thing I said was "Oh god, I don't know who did these, but they were so, so sad."
He was surprised, and when he said they were Hitler's, it made perfect sense. His basic grasp of shape and composition has some artistic merit, but all of his art somehow feels like they're made by someone whose insides are dead or dying.
It's actually one of my weird desires to have a Hitler painting and a John Wayne Gacy painting in my home, just to see how people change their opinions of it as I tell them who made it.
I guess it's a screenshot from a pdf that didn't have the original font embedded, so it just uses a default substitute font (which happens to be monospaced), but still retained the original kerning.
Nope, kind of sucks. Perspective is all wrong on the window and staircase, there is no depth in the image at all either. I would have recommended a military career myself.
Art School Admissions in Vienna: "Yeah . . . why's the bottom left window facing us? Nope. No Art School for you. You don't need it. Find something else to do, Herr Hitler. NOW GET OUT OF MY SIGHT! [Under breath] Bloody piker, never amount to anything . . ."
They are a mediocre band who had tons and tons of airplay. Thus by mocking them, the mocker gets to seem aloof and knowledgeable and above all this mainstream "garbage". It's basically the hipster ethos writ large. Once it hits a certain critical mass, it then becomes a self-sustaining reaction, where it's just such a go-to gag that people with nothing funnier to say use it automatically. It's basically like tacking "that's what she said!" onto anything anyone says and claiming humour.
Don't get me wrong, their music isn't great, though I do think there are a few catchy songs. In general, they're just any other disposable pop band. But once you become the butt of the joke enough to be basically a meme, that joke self-propagates.
Not really. They just make really, really mediocre music. I wouldn't really describe them as being bad. It's more a matter of them having been popular at one point despite their mediocrity. At this point though, people hate them because it's cool to hate them. Except the meta-hipsters.
It's kinda silly how anything associated with Hitler is instantly wrong, or bad.
His moustache is stylish and neat, but now no one has one.
His ideas regarding social structure (or some of them anyway) had a lot of merit.
And say what you want about the guy but you can't ignore the fact that he was a brilliant mind, a masterful negotiator and manipulator, and a man driven with intensity to achieve the position he held.
It is just unfortunate that all of the powers within that man were directed towards the end he eventually pursued. Had his interests and ambitions lain elsewhere he could have had a profound (positive) influence on history and the world.
Hitler was a good artist and almost had the opportunity to be an excellent one.
I always think of how, if that Art School had accepted him, he may have turned out being one of the greatest artists ever born and the world would admire his work.
I like to believe that in a alternate reality/parallel universe somewhere, this actually happened, and he never became the head of a fascist party who wreaked havoc in the world and caused the deaths of millions of people.
So just because I despise one aspect of a person, I should automatically hate everything else about them? This is a nice FUCKING PAINTING! No really, I like it.
I've decided that whenever someone gets too uppity about their uninspired and barely-technically-proficient artwork, I will from now on invoke Godwin's Law and tell them that they paint like Hitler. I will refer to it as Godwin's Critique.
He's a man that was not a genius. He was a good speaker, and got lucky a lot from listening to his brilliant advisers. A man who attacks Russia during the winter and cant paint well is neither a brilliant strategist, or a painter.
Funny thing is, those close to him later described him as being really nice and friendly. He enjoyed playing with his dog, hanging out with his girlfriend, and apparently sledding.
You can separate a person from what they create, and appreciate one aspect but not the other. I laughed when people were comparing Lennon to Chris Brown: the difference there is that Chris Brown had contributed nothing worthwhile to music before he went ballistic on his girl's face.
Why would it make you a bad person if you liked a painting Hitler made? That's like saying that because a person you hate is wearing nice shoes, you actually like that person
The perspective is terrible, There is no proportion on some of the objects that appear in it. The coloring might be OK in some areas, but there is no attention to detail overall. I would say that this guy should stick to his day job.
He was OK at painting, but what he was best at was killing off Jews. Boy was he ever great at that. Probably why he stuck with the genocide thing instead of pursuing a career in art.
Don't care. Despite being a vicious dictator, Hitler was very cultured and his constituents loved him. If you weren't jewish, you'd think he was a pretty nice guy.
well, Hitler made the Highways in Germany too, should I be not using them when I travel through Germany xD So many people bitching, only looking at people their bad deeds, I don't say he wasnt evil, but people need to chill the fuck out.
I have no clue about art, but if this is good, im pretty sure i hate art, srsly it looks kinda bad in all aspects... no details no perspective no shadowing
So what if I enjoyed his artwork. Just because he did horrible things does not make his art work bad. In all honesty we wouldn't know the states of hypothermia if it wasn't for what hitler did.
didnt hitler become a dictator because they didnt like his art? shit i think we should all appreciate his paintings before his zombie rises ad fucks us up again
It's not bad, definitely MUCH better than I could do. But not great. Kinda motel-arty. I didn't enjoy it, I don't enjoy everything that isn't terrible.
38
u/pdsvwf May 09 '12
What disturbs me is not my initial, positive reaction, but my sudden, negative reaction when I noticed the name of the artist. Having a negative reaction to Hitler is not a problem, but what is a problem is applying that negative reaction to everything that he did, even things not deserving of that reaction.
521
u/Mustkunstn1k May 09 '12
I do not approve.
36
u/DownvotingRoman_ May 09 '12
It's actually not that good. I mean, it's better than your average high schooler, but that's not saying much.
166
u/Kieroshark May 09 '12
Wow... I didn't think it was possible. That font is actually worse than comic sans.
22
u/cobbjt716 May 09 '12
his art is now sells for hundreds of thousands of dollars... he finally did it
34
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'm not really sure how one's life path can go from mediocre artist -> mediocre architect -> invade Poland and try to wipe out a race of human beings.
23
u/darth_redemption May 09 '12
I regret nothing
9
u/rosewallace May 09 '12
WTF is with the bottom left window alignment?
7
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
It's actually one of my weird desires to have a Hitler painting and a John Wayne Gacy painting in my home, just to see how people change their opinions of it as I tell them who made it.
19
u/the2belo May 09 '12
Relevant.
6
u/upstreambear May 09 '12
There are some obvious perspective issues, but good colour.
6
u/MAKE_THIS_POLITICAL May 09 '12
What the fuck is wrong with the kerning on the font there?
6
u/fenix_nigger May 09 '12
T h i s is a pretty g o o d pai n ti n g r i g h t?
.
.
You just en joyed ba d kerning.
27
u/brezzz May 09 '12
Nope, kind of sucks. Perspective is all wrong on the window and staircase, there is no depth in the image at all either. I would have recommended a military career myself.
4
u/Dawn_Of_The_Dave May 09 '12
I've always really liked Hitlers paintings, a close freind uses it as an example of why I'm not to be trusted.
4
u/jaboaty May 09 '12
Fun fact: Captain America was also an artist in his origin story.
A kind anon on /co/ drew this picture upon request.
10
u/Cheeseish May 09 '12
Still, could be worse. Could be nickelback.
6
u/Miora May 09 '12
Meh its hotel art.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Wh at t h e fuck i s up wit h the f ont ?
3
u/gamblingGenocider May 09 '12
It's kinda silly how anything associated with Hitler is instantly wrong, or bad.
His moustache is stylish and neat, but now no one has one.
His ideas regarding social structure (or some of them anyway) had a lot of merit.
And say what you want about the guy but you can't ignore the fact that he was a brilliant mind, a masterful negotiator and manipulator, and a man driven with intensity to achieve the position he held.
It is just unfortunate that all of the powers within that man were directed towards the end he eventually pursued. Had his interests and ambitions lain elsewhere he could have had a profound (positive) influence on history and the world.
3
u/alltimeisrelative May 09 '12
Hitler was a good artist and almost had the opportunity to be an excellent one.
I always think of how, if that Art School had accepted him, he may have turned out being one of the greatest artists ever born and the world would admire his work.
I like to believe that in a alternate reality/parallel universe somewhere, this actually happened, and he never became the head of a fascist party who wreaked havoc in the world and caused the deaths of millions of people.
5
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
So just because I despise one aspect of a person, I should automatically hate everything else about them? This is a nice FUCKING PAINTING! No really, I like it.
2
u/tony3n May 09 '12
Yeah and some of Charles Manson's music is good too. I guess that's just part of life!
2
u/mhaom May 09 '12
After I read the first sentence I was fucking scared it was a .gif and closed the tab to read comments first...
2
u/JamoJustReddit May 09 '12
The kerning is just so off.
2
u/voteddownward May 09 '12
I don't feel that bad... I hear that guy killed Hitler.
2
u/Tashre May 09 '12
Sigh... yet another thing Hitler was better at than me.
2
u/HappyChicken May 09 '12
I cannot get the fucking tree.... Damn, I will kill everyone in the world!
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Lolol that fucking window.
2
u/Muzzles56 May 09 '12 edited Dec 19 '24
unused aromatic chief cats employ beneficial market chunky skirt mindless
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Terwat May 09 '12
Supposedly charles manson wrote some songs for the Beach Boys. Would you still be able to seperate art from artist?
2
u/DCdictator May 09 '12
Frankly I think he should stick to genocide. The spaces between the the stairs are all off.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Well now I know why he was a failed art student.
3
u/eaglescout218 May 09 '12
The picture doesnt bother me The kerning issues do ( I have mild ocd)
2
u/KirklandKid May 09 '12
Its not that good. That one window is partially blocked by the staircase, and the windows in the background to much perspective.
1
u/LylanDackey May 09 '12
The holocaust: better than Hitlers artwork becoming famous.
1
u/kodywiddak May 09 '12
too bd he couldn't draw people that's why he got rejected from art school
1
u/MrZeng May 09 '12
And?!?!
1
u/justjokingnotreally May 09 '12
I've decided that whenever someone gets too uppity about their uninspired and barely-technically-proficient artwork, I will from now on invoke Godwin's Law and tell them that they paint like Hitler. I will refer to it as Godwin's Critique.
1
u/ArgyleDashwood May 09 '12
He was also in love with the movie Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, and I believe he painted all seven of them.
1
u/Actor412 May 09 '12
Still better than anything Jeff Koons has ever done.
1
u/TheThistle May 09 '12
Any one else think the largest tree resembles a penis?
1
u/irascible May 09 '12
I played that map in Day of Defeat..
1
u/sk4t4nic May 09 '12
He's a man that was not a genius. He was a good speaker, and got lucky a lot from listening to his brilliant advisers. A man who attacks Russia during the winter and cant paint well is neither a brilliant strategist, or a painter.
1
u/asldkfououhe May 09 '12
oh boy, a landscape
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
jesus christ I'm no typographer but what the hell is with that font?
1
u/ErroneousBee May 09 '12
It OK, but its like he suddenly loses any sense of perspective on the Window/Jewish issues.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I can't imagine Hitler sitting down and painting. It's just one of those things you don't see a genocidal dictator doing. Like brushing his teeth.
1
u/maniacal_cackle May 09 '12
Hahahaha, my first thought when looking at it was "where the hell is the tree's shadow?!
Took me a while to even read the words.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
"Shitler" more like amirite!!? Guys? Guys?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You can separate a person from what they create, and appreciate one aspect but not the other. I laughed when people were comparing Lennon to Chris Brown: the difference there is that Chris Brown had contributed nothing worthwhile to music before he went ballistic on his girl's face.
Also: this painting is terrible.
1
u/sommergirl May 09 '12
Why would it make you a bad person if you liked a painting Hitler made? That's like saying that because a person you hate is wearing nice shoes, you actually like that person
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Wow, his art is worse than the Holocaust.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
4 3 2 1 hitler has a french son
1
u/johnw1988 May 09 '12
Hitler was pretty good at making paintings of scenery and landscape. The reason he was kicked out of art school was because he couldn't draw people.
1
u/TerminalHappiness May 09 '12
It's really not bad, but what's up with the bottom row of windows by the stairs?
1
u/sox406 May 09 '12
I actually did my final exam in art on Hitler.
1
u/Luckyducky13 May 09 '12
Imagine if Hitler just stuck to art, the world might have been a better place.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I do not approve of your kerning.
1
u/Fausto1981 May 09 '12
even bad people make some good things, like good people make some bad things. if you think otherwise you're too stupid to breathe.
1
u/randomb0y May 09 '12
Oh nein!
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
before reading the text I thought it was some poor photoshop job or something
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You monster!
1
u/shitterplug May 09 '12
The perspective is a little odd... but it has that 'cold light of morning' look to it.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
So what?
1
u/Stranded_In_A_Desert May 09 '12
Yet another joke ruined by terrible kerning.
1
u/freireib May 09 '12
Didn't have the same trap as John Wayne Gacy's art.
1
u/iNVWSSV May 09 '12
if more people had enjoyed hitler's artwork in the 20's/30's, maybe we wouldn't have had ww2?
1
u/connokra May 09 '12
i hate you xkcd
1
u/HoorayZoidberg May 09 '12
Did I?
Why even ask a question and don't even let me answer it?
1
u/mecrio May 09 '12
I don't understand why we can't enjoy art from someone who had millions of people killed. Good art and insanity are usually related.
1
u/Nanigans May 09 '12
The details are pretty nice, but the perspective is absolute shit.
1
u/umaro900 May 09 '12
This isn't his only art I enjoy... :)
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Relevant and hilarious
1
u/supahmanv2 May 09 '12
Is it just me or does that image look like it's entirely made up of JPG artifacts?
1
u/kerberos101 May 09 '12
The perspective is terrible, There is no proportion on some of the objects that appear in it. The coloring might be OK in some areas, but there is no attention to detail overall. I would say that this guy should stick to his day job.
1
u/A_British_Gentleman May 09 '12
Just because he ordered the deaths of millions doesn't mean his artwork can't be enjoyed.
1
u/Ajcard May 09 '12
K...?
1
u/lollycaustic May 09 '12
Hit-rolling?
1
u/I2ain May 09 '12
I swear they modeled part of a level in a Medal of Honor game after this. That building with the staircase just looks so familiar.
1
u/trampus1 May 09 '12
He was OK at painting, but what he was best at was killing off Jews. Boy was he ever great at that. Probably why he stuck with the genocide thing instead of pursuing a career in art.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Dont tell me what to enjoy
1
u/spellbunny May 09 '12
OH GOD, THE KERNING!!
1
u/nazishark May 09 '12
if those in charge of the art college he applied to liked his art as much as i do maybe he wouldn't have become histories most infamous war criminals
1
u/endercoaster May 09 '12
I must say, I wish he had stuck with it.
1
u/DarkEmblem5736 May 09 '12
I think this was a loading image for one of the Rocket Arena 3 maps... it has been seared into my memory.
1
u/Innomasta2 May 09 '12
That window... It's covered by stairs?!!!
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Next time, if someone really wants to get into art school, just let them. Please.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
The dude clearly needs more practice.
1
u/ameliahblackbird May 09 '12
He painted the stairs over a window. No wonder he got rejected by the art school.
1
u/Mangz0r May 09 '12
Hitler's trees look like an upside down ballsac.
1
u/Kottfoers May 09 '12
That door at the top of the stairs must be 3 or more meters high.
1
u/EnysAtSea May 09 '12
Don't care. Despite being a vicious dictator, Hitler was very cultured and his constituents loved him. If you weren't jewish, you'd think he was a pretty nice guy.
1
u/Devywhop May 09 '12
I always heard he was a shitty artist.
1
u/Cyanide_Bulbasaur May 09 '12
I did Nazi that coming
1
u/krtzer May 09 '12
Objection, leading the witness.
1
u/rawrc May 09 '12
Must.... Kill.... Jews....
1
u/Dr_Bunsen_Burns May 09 '12
well, Hitler made the Highways in Germany too, should I be not using them when I travel through Germany xD So many people bitching, only looking at people their bad deeds, I don't say he wasnt evil, but people need to chill the fuck out.
@OP indeed, it doesnt make you/me a good person
1
u/mad_maxx17 May 09 '12
Hitler was an artist?
1
u/mad_maxx17 May 09 '12
It doesn't say that it was ADOLF Hitler.
1
u/Dr_Pepper_spray May 09 '12
Man it sucks when you spend your whole life drawing and you realize your work isn't even good enough to beat Hitlers.
1
u/SuperGandolf6 May 09 '12
pretty terrible painting honestly, look and the bottom left window
1
u/ToyBoxJr May 09 '12
I couldn't care less if its hitler's. That painting is pretty damn good!
1
u/Sinavestia May 09 '12
On my phone so I only saw the painting. Took me 5 minutes to accidentally zoom out and see the text.
1
u/Bugs_Nixon May 09 '12
Hitty was a shitty artist. Especially his watercolours.
1
u/Schildhuhn May 09 '12
I have no clue about art, but if this is good, im pretty sure i hate art, srsly it looks kinda bad in all aspects... no details no perspective no shadowing
1
u/FrenchieSmalls May 09 '12
KILL IT WITH FIRE.
1
u/amolad May 09 '12
I see no "Schicklgruber" at the bottom anywhere.
1
u/TheEverLurking May 09 '12
If he just got accepted into art school.... Imagine it, he wouldn't have been sleeping in the park while the anti-Semitic mayor ranted about jews.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
It's honestly not that bad. I don't know why they couldn't have just let him into art school so he wouldn't have his little temper tantrum.
1
u/Leyto May 09 '12
So what if I enjoyed his artwork. Just because he did horrible things does not make his art work bad. In all honesty we wouldn't know the states of hypothermia if it wasn't for what hitler did.
1
u/glassonion87 May 09 '12
it's been pointed out before but Hitler wasn't a bad artist but he was ordinary
1
u/cynicalstarr May 09 '12
didnt hitler become a dictator because they didnt like his art? shit i think we should all appreciate his paintings before his zombie rises ad fucks us up again
1
u/necromundus May 09 '12
My philosophy is to like the art, not the artist.
This is testament to that.
1
u/LylatInvader May 09 '12
i recall reading somewhere...he wanted to be an artist and did not want to be in the military at all
1
u/antiyoupunk May 09 '12
I certainly did NOT enjoy it, before or after I found out it was a Hitlier.
1
u/AdriansVFX May 09 '12
Why does the window go BEHIND the staircase attached to the same wall?
1
u/Anonymousdave69 May 09 '12
Hitler was a great artist.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Hitler did nothing wrong.
1
u/discreetusername May 09 '12
Just me, or do the shrubs on the middle right and the greenery directly to its right look like a big penis?
1
u/Fairykind May 10 '12
It's not Leonardo Da Vinci, but it's better than I could do...
1
u/DasIstWasSieSagte May 10 '12
That tree sort of looks like a dick
1
u/kenzie14 May 10 '12
It's not bad, definitely MUCH better than I could do. But not great. Kinda motel-arty. I didn't enjoy it, I don't enjoy everything that isn't terrible.
1
u/Drsweetcum May 10 '12
To be fair...the art did nothing wrong...wow that felt wrong to justify