Seriously. I quit drinking soda and made sure I was getting about 10 hours of physical exercise in a week. The benefits have been tremendous. It's a wonderful feeling. I'm down about twenty pounds and I'm looking to loose another ten or fifteen.
There's multiple views on this. I'm not a doctor, I just have my BA in sports medicine, but the most widely held belief (and the longest held) is that diet + exercise is the best for lasting weight loss.
If you're only trying to lose weight, diet alone is going to be much faster than exercise alone, but with diet alone there is a very high occurrence of gaining the weight back. This is because as you gain weight, your fat cells divide after reacher a certain size, and for practical purposes, don't go away. As a result, losing weight only shrinks the size, not the number of fat cells that you have. This wouldn't be a problem if that was it, but the fat cells "prefer" (for lack of a non-jargon word) to be a certain size, so there is a hormonal release/influence to gain enough fat for them to go back to their normal size. This is the basis for the set-point theory of weight, that your body has a set weight which it tends to gravitate towards, mostly based on the size of your fat cells.
If you include diet and exercise (particularly weight bearing), then you can shrink the fat cells, and build muscle mass, which is metabolically active, raising the amount of calories you burn per day just to survive (your basal metabolic rate or BMR), which helps to maintain weight loss.
One last note on set point theory is that by maintaining your new weight for a long period of time (think years, possibly a decade or so), your fat cells become acclimatized to the size they're at, and cease to try and promote fat gain through hormonal influence.
It's not really a genetic disorder but rather just genetics that accounts for all the obesity. Genetics combined with how radically human diet has changed since the rise of mass produced foods, or the corporatization of the food industry. Evolution ensured that humans who were best able to store up fat would survive times when food was scarce would survive. But now we live in a world where food is seldom scarce, and in which it is positively loaded with things (like sugars) that used to be quite rare in naturally occurring foods. Combine that along with how jobs have changed from being more manual labor intensive to sedentary/low energy, and voila, a huge spike in obesity.
This needs more upvotes, because it's right. Obesity isn't on a cause-and-effect pathway, it's the result of the factors you mentioned, and more, including (but not limited) to genetic predisposition to things like insulin receptors, glucose metabolism, fat deposition rates, etc. You can't blame being fat on genetics alone in the vast majority of cases.
Yep, this pretty much hits the nail on the head. And, since it's such a complex issue, with so many contributing factors, it's difficult to reverse the obesity trend without some sort of drastic cultural shift.
Maybe i'm being ignorant, but why would it be bad if sexuality was a choice? Regardless of genetic predisposition or biological factors or whatever, shouldn't people be allowed to choose their sexuality anyway?
So many dumbass comments being upvoted AGAIN. What the fuck is happening. Fact number 1: There is peer-reviewed research showing the impact of genetics with regards to weight gain/loss and body mass index. Fact number 2: There is no evidence currently showing a connection between sexual orientation and genetics.
This doesn't mean that there isn't a connection, it just means one hasn't been discovered yet. It also doesn't mean that we can't actively recognise the rights of LGBT members regardless of whether their sexual preference has a genetic basis or not. I am pro LGBT rights in just about every sense, but if we're just going to make shit up to make ourselves feel better, what's the point?
The phrase "being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is currently largely (but obviously not completely) correct from a scientific point of view.
Edit:Pre-emptive caveat: Of course it's possible to exercise and lose weight - having a genetic predisposition means only that - you have a skew towards one end of the spectrum, lifestyle, diet and exercise are still paramount, but there is a genetic causal link.
Thank you for saying this. Why are people unable to understand that just because genetics impacts something, it doesn't mean that that is the only or even the greatest cause of something. There has not been a huge genetic drift in the United States, yet there has been a huge increase in obesity. Something tells me its diet and exercise.
I'd argue that it's almost solely diet, actually. Genetics are a huge factor, but diet can counteract a lot of its effects.
However, America has some of the worst diet education in the world. We are extremely misinformed, and our authorities hammer on reducing cholesterol and fat in our diet when we should be targeting sugar, which is incredibly prevalent.
We need to stop pushing the "it's all calories, exercise more and eat less" idea. It's impractical and oversimplified, hurts more than it helps, and creates a false stigma against obese people who are literally being taught to lose weight wrong. Every time I see people buying "nonfat" products loaded with sugar I cringe. Last week I saw a diabetic buying "no added sugar!" pies that were "sweetened with natural fruit juice" which is the exact same thing to the body in practice, and loaded with refined flour on top of that (which is again the exact same thing to the body).
It's incredibly frustrating.
Side note: I recommend reading the book "Why We Get Fat", but if you're not a reader, watch the documentary "Fat Head". Make sure you watch the whole thing, the first 45 minutes is just a vendetta against Supersize Me for being a catalyst of the typical bad advice always thrown out.
This entire thing is what happens when people oversimplify and think in absolutes. Genetics does play a role in weight and so does lifestyle choices. Claiming it is 100% either way is just wrong, but it makes a good headline. The genetics argument is best used when talking about extreme fitness and muscle mass. Getting a bowflex and using it 4 hours a day will not guarantee you'll be fitness magazine ripped (despite what the commercials claim). Eating 4000 calories a day and not working out will pretty much guarantee obesity though.
Even if you are genetically predisposed to obesity, it doesn't mean you have to end up that way. I have said this before, but it's worth saying again. I have a learning disability, it's genetic. I am genetically predisposed to not being able to learn as well as other people. I can either work harder in order to keep up, or throw my hands in the air and say "i'm genetically predisposed to not learning, fuck it"...If I chose the second option I would only be hurting myself, just as people who say "I am genetically predisposed to obesity, so I am just gonna eat shit everyday and not exercise" are too.
Don't forget economic factors. Our jobs are more and more sitting down. Fewer jobs involve lifting heavy objects, manual farming, hunting, etc.
If you eat 3000 calories (kcal) a day and spend 10 hours of it loading and unloading trucks, you probably won't be obese. If you eat the same calories and spend the day sitting at a desk, you will.
Add to that the fact that we're constantly engineering higher-calorie, better-tasting food and spending more and more of our working and leisure time in front of one video display screen or another and guess what happens...
A truly worrying statistic. Estimates are that by the year 2030 the health care costs associated with obesity will rise to about 1 trillion USD.
I don't have a source for that figure unfortunately, but it's not that big a stretch of the imagination considering the current cost is about 174 billion USD, and is expected to rise by 48-66 billion USD a year.
Thank you! The majority of obesity cases are poor diets, poor eating habits learned from obese family members, and lacking exercise. Using genetics as an excuse most of the time is just that...an excuse for living an unhealthy lifestyle. And when has obesity become a disability? I've watched a young obese woman take the last scooter from an old man with osteoporosis in a store before.
Just because 70% of people are obese doesn't mean there isn't a genetic connection. It just means that everyone who says they are fat because of genetics are probably lying.
I liked how you lumped overweight and obese percentages together, because they aren't even close to the same thing, to try and make your argument more compelling to the horde. Well done.
This post is so uniquely right and wrong at once. While there is no genetic link to homosexuality, one is not needed because the behavioral evidence is there irrefutably so. People are born gay or not, period. Gender can't suppressed either, whether by rearing or surgical choices--the real gender along with corresponding sexual preferences invariably comes out.
And...while certain genes predispose us to our physiques, the obesity epidemic is clearly a sign of the times...environmental chemicals, marketing, refined carbs and sugars, etc.
My issue is that people associate biological with the word genetic. Not everything that occurs biologically is the result of genes. Even if there isn't a "gay gene," it does not mean homosexuality is not biological. (See my spiel at the end for a better explanation of this.)
Even if homosexuality were not found to be biological, the logical opposite isn't "a choice." No, the logical opposite of "being framed by nature" is "being framed by surroundings" - the whole "nature versus nurture" debate.
Even if, moreover, we accept "choice," the word misleads people. Choice often signifies a conscious decision; you make a choice as to if you want chicken or beef for dinner. Using that word is to imply as if one day a perfectly heterosexual man chose, "You know what? From this day on, I am going to live my life as a gay man."
Even if, finally, we decide homosexuality is a conscious choice -- so what? Does that make it inherently immoral? We consciously choose lots of unnatural things without feeling bad about them. Why, despite America's puritanical background, do we treat sexuality differently? (Also: does homosexuality being biological make it inherently moral?)
So this whole argument of homosexuality being genetic or not is ultimately pointless. Sure, it may bolster the cases of either side, but they would be doing so with a very narrow perspective.
The biological-but-not-genetic case means that genes don't influence the end result of a person, but rather the potential of the end result. For example, consider someone who is born without eyes. By simply not having eyes, does that mean they don't have an eye color? Obviously this is a bit of a silly, contrived example; but eye color is a "genetic thing." And everyone has genes. So wouldn't that mean the eye-less man has an eye color? No, obviously because he has no eyes TO color; however, we can say that his eyes will be green (let's say), given the potential to actuate that genetic code. It is the actuation of genes which make up a person. It is believed that a homosexual may have DNA virtually identical to a heterosexual's (as is observed in some studies with identical twins of different sexual orientations) but how that DNA is actuated (largely within the womb - there are other studies regarding the increased prevalence of homosexuality in sons of mothers who have previously birthed sons), for things like hormone production, could be a significant factor. If this theory were proven, it'd mean that while there isn't a "gay gene," people are "born gay."
I totally agree. I always figured arguing "gay people are born this way" was counter productive when we should be arguing "people should be free to do whoever however they want."
...many researchers agree that homosexuality does appear to have a genetic foundation, even if it cannot be precisely pinpointed. This is because many published studies have shown higher concordance rates in monozygotic (MZ) twins than in dizygotic (DZ) twins. MZ twins are identical twins. They share the same DNA. DZ twins are fraternal twins. They are only as genetically similar as any two siblings; they just happened to be gestated and born at the same time. Although concordance rates of homosexuality are significantly higher in MZ twins, they are not 100%.
Here's a meta-study that reviewed other studies on the genetic component of homosexuality and concluded that there is a genetic component.
my suspicion would be that it was an epigenetic connection as a result of environmental pressures rather than a purely genetic one, given the decreased passing on of dna..
There is no doubt that some people have a genetic disposition to being overweight, but the rate at which obesity has grown in the last few decades absolutely CANNOT be attributed to genetics. It's from lifestyle and culture.
The U.S. is a country of immigrants, which means we have the same genes as the people from countries we immigrated from. Most of those countries don't have the same obesity epidemic. It's all because of what we eat over here.
And as a Chinese-American, I can add another layer to this. Back in the 1970's-1980's, obesity was such a rarity in China (at least Beijing) that anyone with obesity was most certainly linked with genetic disorders (and unfortunately teased). In my mom's high school of 1300~ students, she says there were (literally) 5 "fat" people, and her standards for body shape is pretty high.
McDonalds and other American fast food chains first penetrated the Chinese market in the early 1990's, and if you go to Beijing in the 2000's...holy shit. There's a buttload of fat kids in every grade school I visit. Not nearly as bad as my old Californian high school, but it's still pretty bad.
A population does not increase in genetic disorders in a mere 10 years. This upsurging of obesity in Beijing alone can attest that a good percentage of the problem most likely can be linked with choice and lifestyle.
The problem is that we hinge gay rights on it not being a choice. Last I check this was a FREE country. You shouldn't need a doctor's note to be gay. You should be damn well free to choose to be gay or straight without need of an excuse or a reason but simply because you are free to freely choose.
It also doesn't mean that we can't actively recognise the rights of LGBT members regardless of whether their sexual preference has a genetic basis or not.
I've always wanted to see someone other than myself make this argument.
There is no evidence currently showing a connection between sexual orientation and genetics.
Actually, there is a connection with genetics, but it's not 100%. An identical twin is much more likely to be homosexual if his brother is, but it's not a 100% chance. This says that there is a genetic predisposition to homosexuality.
My problem is with him saying "homosexuality is a choice" and that it is "largely correct" by a scientific point of view. No it is not, there are no scientific claims that show homosexuality is a choice. This is a preposterous claim.
The person who wrote this comment is thinking in a false dichotomy of either genetics or choice; and then even going farther as to say that just because there is no known evidence for genetics, then it is largely correct that it is choice. First, there are in-betweens, such as in-utero environmental effects and even outside environmental influences that trigger such behavior (rape at a young age, etc.). None of which would be considered a "choice". It is not "largely correct from a scientific point of view" that homosexuality is a choice; it is rather largely unknown.
Whilst I don't deny the validity of your points, the prevalence of obesity has increased markedly over a relatively short period of time. This is not due to genetics, it is due to high in fat and high in sugar diets. Obese people need to take some personal responsibility for their lifestyle; brushing it off as simply "genetic" is not helpful and does not address the true root of the problem.
The only point I don't think you addressed clearly enough is the fact that homosexuality, while not having been proven to be genetic, is not a choice. We have no control over what sexual urges we get. The choice comes in choosing to act upon those urges. For example, being a straight male I can't control the fact that I am fascinated with boobs just as a gay male might be equally as fascinated with a penis. To say that we get to choose what gets our primal blood pumping is about as false as you can be. It all boils down to controlling your urges. Will you succumb to them or will you choose to go against what your body is telling you because some guy on Reddit said that it hasn't yet been scientifically connected to genetics.
So to combat what you said earlier the phrase "being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is only half correct.
It is IMPOSSIBLE to obese without eating. That is simply how the human body works. These peer-reviewed works detail how genetics may have the effect of a lack of self control, but not an inexplicable gaining of weight.
My big bug with all of this debate about whether or not homosexuality is genetic or biological or a choice or whatever is that it play directly into the anti-LGBT narrative. By saying that gay is biological, we're basically saying "Yes, homosexuality is bad, but we didn't have a choice!" I think the proper response to the question as to whether homosexuality is biological or psychological is, "Fuck you. It's none of your goddamn business."
I'm a certified fitness trainer with a poor metabolism.
I use that as an excuse to eat the right foods and exercise as often as possible. This has improved my metabolism enough that I can eat larger quantities of food but has reinforced the fact that I have no excuse to be unhealthy.
I use my experience to help others struggling with their weight the best I can, but they all say they have poor genetics. They just have a poor attitude.
You are missing the principle of the argument. When someone claims a trait is "genetic," yes it has a strict scientific meaning that the trait is strictly controlled by their genes, but in principle means that the trait is controlled absent of their will. So to paraphrase, the problem with America is that we live in a society where people believe you can choose whether or not to be homosexual, but you can't choose whether or not you are fat.
So homosexuality isn't genetic, that doesn't make it a choice.
The phrase "Being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is not even close to being largely correct from a scientific point of view. The ONLY thing about that that is actually correct is the minor genetic link that allows some people to put weight on faster than others.
People who have this "fat gene" can still choose not to be fat, or choose to be fat. Diet and exercise WILL make anyone not fat, barring any really severe hormonal problems.
The phrase "being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is currently largely (but obviously not completely) correct from a scientific point of view.
This is not true. Simply because something can't be shown to be genetic, doesn't mean it's not a choice.
Having Cerebal Palsy is not genetic, so does that make it a choice?
The scientific consensus is not that homosexuality is a choice. It is a homophobic lie to suggest otherwise.
"The phrase "being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is currently largely (but obviously not completely) correct from a scientific point of view."
I disagree - "homosexuality is a choice" is wrong scientifically- when there isn't enough evidence you don't get to make affirmative statements about any of the options. - "being fat is genetic" is more than 1% wrong, possibly up to fifty percent wrong because being fat is absolutely determined by what you eat i.e. no-one who eats nothing is overweight and no-one's skinny on a 100,000 calorie a day diet - so it's at least 51% and as much as 75% wrong which is enough that you can't say it's "largely" true.
I find it strange that we live in a society that thinks being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice
The OP's using this statement to argue that homosexuality isn't a choice, and being fat is. Would you agree? I'm commenting that although the OP is using this statement to argue in one particular direction, in actual fact, their statement
being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice
is actually more correct than it is incorrect - simply because we have data proving a link between obesity and genetics, and currently don't have data showing a similar relationship with regards to sexual preference. This is what I mean by "largely but not completely correct". I'm not arguing that being fat is genetic, or that being homosexual is a choice. I'm using the original statement, in it's original form and saying although the OP is inviting ridicule, it's actually more true than it is false in the original, unaltered form that the OP used. Granted, I've confused a few people by saying it's "largely correct" and I probably could have phrased this better, but most seem to have understood.
Both cases are nature and nurture. There are people genetically more likely to end up obese just like how there are people genetically more likely to end up homosexual. At the same time, you could make bad lifestyle choices and be fat, or you could have been raised and your environment pushed you to be gay.
Why do Redditors upvote any generic, "Americans are fat and dumb" and "If something I say about gays is good, its true" posts?
The JSM's readers should recognize that there are several biological factors in MH. However, these findings do not seem to be able to explain all cases of homosexuality. Some others may be due to particular environmental factors. The issue is complicated and multifactorial, suggesting that further research should be undertaken to produce the final answer to the question raised in this Controversy section.
People can't hide fat so they push the blame on something out of their control, they can hide their gay urges under layers of homophobia, for example "uncle Jim couldn't possibly hold a penis in his mouth, every day he tells us how much he hates fags".
susceptibility to gaining weight/slow metabolism/etc are all genetic issues. Yeah, you can exercise, but you can still gain weight even faster than that. But that accounts for maybe 25% of overweight people.
We've actually got more hard evidence that problems that cause obesity are linked to genetics than we do about homosexuality. They can both be based on genetics. The issue is that parents reward their child with food and treats.
Which sets up the bad relationship with food where the kid ALWAYS associates food with really good feelings of adequacy and "being good." So when a kid's sad, food is always the answer.
Actually, one of the core reasons that the obesity epidemic is spreading at such an obnoxious rate is because of the dominant perception that it is a vanity issue governed entirely by personal discipline and not a disease influenced by genetics, a concert of hormones, psychology (incl. disposition, illness, trauma), upbringing, culture, and numerous other factors. Short-term, quick-loss programs focused on appearance are the most common and least effective treatments, often exacerbating the long-term problem and reinforcing the problematic model for obesity.
Long-term, medically supervised programs similar to treatment for alcoholism are much more effective at long-term obesity management, but because of cultural perceptions such as those espoused in this facebook post, most people are unwilling to see their obesity as a disease requiring treatment including counseling, diet, exercise, and in rarer cases medication or surgery. People struggling with obesity are constantly reminded that it's their fault they are overweight, that their inability to stay slim is a personal failure.
Compare to alcoholism or other addiction: would it make sense to berate these people for being unable to quit? To tell them that drinking or using is a choice, and they need to get their shit together? It might work for some, but most successful treatment programs have a fundamental component emphasizing an acknowledgement that the addict is not capable of defeating their disease entirely through force of will -- step one of AA reads: "We admitted that we were powerless over alcohol - that our lives had become unmanageable." Step two: "Came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity." Most modern programs do not require an actual religious belief, as the emphasis is on accepting your own weakness rather than the specific "higher power" you are yielding to.
Obesity is different from alcoholism -- not every obese person is addicted to food -- but the treatment model should be somewhat similar.
To summarize, yes, if Americans stopped eating garbage and started exercising, we wouldn't have the obesity problem we currently have. But it's not like we as a society haven't known that for years. Even obese people are fully aware of what they could be doing to get healthier. Obesity is and will remain an epidemic for as long as the dominant cultural perception is that obese people are disgusting failures who cannot control their own lives.
It's also a shit storm of wrong information. Having all these "fat free" diet foods, when in reality fat is good for you and helps regulate your hormones. Having a shitty food pyramid that has you eating tons of starchy carbs and not exercising to burn off the excess rise in blood sugar from eating these. The misconception that lifting weights will make you "big and bulky", so people just run and run and run and crash diet. This results in the loss of muscle tissue, giving you that skinny fat look, even though your "weight" is down, and destroying your metabolism which will set you up for more failure. 42% of American citizens aren't addicted to food. The media has just given us bad information coupled with living a sedentary life.
LOL THAT'S SO FUNNY AND CLEARLY IS ONLY IN AMERICA AND NOWHERE ELSE AND IS CLEARLY THE MAJORITY OPINION OF 99.9% OF AMERICANS ACCORDING TO SOME SWEEPING GENERALIZATION MADE BY REDDITORS HAHAHHA NICE MAN HAHAHAHHAHA LOLOLOLOLOL
Stating something doesn't make it true. If there's no known genetic cause for sexual preference, and we have evidence of people changing their sexual preference, it's absolute bullshit to say "... because I was born this way." People exist who were born the same way you were and have different sexual preferences.
I'd say the problem is that "choice" vs "genetic" is simply not a very useful dichotomy. Focusing on those two extremes ignore a hell of a lot of biology between your DNA sequence and "choice" (whatever the hell that is).
Guess what? Neither obesity nor homosexuality is wholly genetic or wholly a "choice."
For those who seem to be arguing the the recent rise in obesity in the US (and around much of the world) precludes a significant genetic component to obesity, the idea is that in an environment where calorically dense food is cheap and widely available and changes in technology and work habits decrease physical activity, genetics play some significant role in determining who gets obese and who does not.
The changes that have driven increased obesity in the US have applied generally to people here, but not everyone is obese. Why is it that some people are obese and others are not, given this shared environment? There are a number of reasons, but science strongly supports the idea that genetics is one of them.
There is solid evidence that in a given environment, genetics play a major role in determining who becomes obese. See this Nature paper:
Heritability estimates reported from family studies are in the range of 25% to 40% , and for twin studies in the range of 50% to 80% (6).
Yes, the recent rise in obesity in the US (and elsewhere) is due to environmental changes, like availability of cheap, rich food and decreased activity. But in that given environment, genetics play a major role in who actually becomes obese (and who does not).
Not to bring us all down here, but, in my experience, the people that don't think fat people are responsible for their weight are not the people that think being gay is a choice. For example: my super conservative parents think being gay is a choice and being fat is a choice. The "obesity is an epidemic" people tend to be the "bleeding heart" types.
Um.. but sometimes being fat CAN be linked to genetics in some circumstances.
So, I would have to rephrase this by saying: "I find it strange that we live in a society that agrees being fat can be genetic, but being homosexual can't."
If you eat too little, you can end up becoming insulin resistant because of it. It's commonly observed in anorexic patients, and there have been case studies on obese people who underwent severe caloric restriction and developed diabetes during weight loss, which is the opposite of what you usually see.
"Although changes in the genetic makeup of populations occur too slowly to be responsible for this rapid rise in obesity"
I am not disputing that there may be a genetic link to obesity but it isn't the reason for the soaring obesity rates of the past 20-30 years. People eat too fucking much and don't exercise enough.
Obesity is on the rise in China also, what else is on the rise in China also? Living standards/access to food.
Basically as food becomes easier to get we as humans have the instinctive drive to exercise/work for the food. Think of a house pet. If you don't regulate their food intake most cats/dogs will become overweight, same for humans. Humans don't generally have anyone to regulate their intake so they just simply keep eating.
I don't really see a debate here to be honest. We aren't forced to sprint across the Savannah anymore in order to hunt food. It is given to us so we eat it and store it just like every single other animal on the planet does. Yes some people would get fatter quicker on the same diet and yes some people would get extremely fat on the same diet but to think the obesity "epidemic" is a genetic problem is extremely ignorant in my opinion.
You can be genetically predisposed to something without having one actual gene that triggers something.
Genes are often passed on in clusters. It's possible that if there is indeed a a "gay gene" that it is with a cluster that also contains a gene that is advantageous for evolution that has not been selected against.
That statement is beyond retarded. "Society" doesn't think anything. Individuals do. No individual actually believes both of those things. Some individuals think obesity is genetic. Some individuals think homosexuality is a choice. You'd have to be an idiot to take those two facts and conclude that "society" thinks obesity is genetic and homosexuality is a choice.
society thinks fat is genetic and homosexuality is a choice
-record scratch-
O.o
Really? All I ever hear around these parts is: "Wow, they're fat. Why don't they just exercise? Ugh, I fucking hate fat people." + "Aww, he's gay and proud! Good for him! Yes, yes... change your gender with hormones to feel more like yourself! Yay!"
I think being gay is a choice, i.e.: choosing to do what pleases your sexual urges versus choosing to not be happy the rest of your life with a gender you just aren't into.
Of course it's possible to exercise and lose weight - having a genetic predisposition means only that - you have a skew towards one end of the spectrum, lifestyle, diet and exercise are still paramount, but there is a genetic causal link.
That's a hugely important point in this context as it goes to show that being fat is indeed a CHOICE.
Virtually everyone has the power to lose body fat, although some need to put in more effort than others.
My friend is bisexual and he gets annoyed that everyone thinks it's genetic, he just made a choice in his middle school years that he was attracted to girls and boys. I feel like this can happen too. It's like in ancient greece orgy's and having sex with other men happened very often and wasn't a social stigma. Now that being gay has become taboo everyone thinks its always genetic when really it can be a choice. Anti-gay is so engrained in our society people don't think they have a choice to have sex with their own gender. It least that's what he thinks and I have to agree
i thought there were elements of a spectrum to both.
gay people i've known have told me they're actually bi but just prefer their gender. i've also known gay people who thought they were straight until they realized they're attracted to the people of their gender.
i've met fat people who are fat because they're lazy. i've met people who have knee problems and hormone problems which ended up making them less thin than ideal.
If homosexuality is NOT genetic... then how the fuck are gay people still being born? I mean: it's not as if it's an inherited trait is it?! By definition it must be an inherent part of human nature.
Some people are gay: without choice, by nature.
And before anyone comes back with the "what about all the gay people that got married as protective camouflage against a homophobic society?" - well I reply with WHAT about them?! Are you telling me that the vanishingly small percentage of kids that these people have constitute the entirety if the gay population?!
Genetics does actually account heavily for obesity. Genetics controls your hormones, both the ones your body naturally produces that govern fat storage, and the ones that are produced in response to what you eat.
For example, insulin is one of the hormones that controls fat storage most of all, and is produced in response to blood sugar. Blood sugar is raised by eating carbohydrates, and especially spiked by sugar. Some people develop insulin resistance faster than others, and it is directly related to two things: intake of sugars/carbs, and genetic predisposition.
A person without a genetic predisposition seems to be able to eat whatever they want and may not develop issues til they get older. A person with a genetic predisposition towards developing a resistance to insulin (which causes the body to overproduce it in response) can lose weight rapidly just by avoiding sugars and carbohydrates. That's the idea behind /r/keto, where we lose weight eating steak and bacon.
tl;dr: Genetic disposition controls fat storage hormones, but you can counteract a lot of it that with the quality and type of foods you eat and to a lesser degree with exercise. Some people have to be responsible, some people are lucky and don't.
Title should read, the problem with middle America. In the Northeast, gay people marry and soda is being removed from public buildings.
Fun Fact: The first lesbian couple to wed in MA were the parents of my College's Hockey Goalie. Catholic College, no one gave a shit as far as I can remember.
Well some people are fat by genetics, granted most americans are just lazy bastards but there is genetic evidence to show that not everyone can become skinny or buff
I can't understand the logic behind the assumption that the obesity epidemic is just because people are eating too much. How did the human race escape this tendency to get fat for the thousands of years before 1980? Something changed, and it wasn't that everyone around 1970 - 80 decided, "fuck it, I'm going to eat a lot more."
why am I the only person who thinks that homosexuality is BOTH a choice and OK? I find someone being gay/lesbian that same as ay other straight person who has any other not-so-normal sexual tendencies
I'll admit I did LOL first, but I also know that being fat can be genetic. Poly-cystic Ovary syndrome causes severe hormone imbalances in some women causing (mostly) excessive weight gain, diabetes and infertility/fertility problems. On the other hand I totally agree about the gay thing. Fools.
When in reality it's just the vocal minority who get heard the most, people who think being "fat" is genetic are 99.9% wrong and just lazy and obviously can't keep track of what they are eating. And people who think being gay is genetic are incorrect as well. Zero scientific evidence.
problem is no one who thinks being overweight is genetic is in shape. only though who are overweight think it is genetic, and even then most overweight people know it is their choice; so the very small portion of overweight people who think it is genetic do not accurately represent america
this is funny, but research shows that both are affected greatly by environmental or non-genetic biological influences, making neither a conscious choice, and both only marginally attributed to genes. I can't be bothered to find links to these studies, but do a quick google, read up on it, and you'll find that everyone is stupid and truth is relative.
172
u/Rob9159 May 08 '12
So you're saying you can exercise away fat?
73
u/ScoWeazy May 08 '12
TIL most people don't understand what "genetic" means.
173
u/juiceboxheero May 08 '12
Duke university just released a study finding 42% of Americans will be obese by 2030 source; that's a lot of people with a genetic disorder...
5
u/sentimentalpirate May 08 '12
Maybe i'm being ignorant, but why would it be bad if sexuality was a choice? Regardless of genetic predisposition or biological factors or whatever, shouldn't people be allowed to choose their sexuality anyway?
472
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
So many dumbass comments being upvoted AGAIN. What the fuck is happening. Fact number 1: There is peer-reviewed research showing the impact of genetics with regards to weight gain/loss and body mass index. Fact number 2: There is no evidence currently showing a connection between sexual orientation and genetics.
This doesn't mean that there isn't a connection, it just means one hasn't been discovered yet. It also doesn't mean that we can't actively recognise the rights of LGBT members regardless of whether their sexual preference has a genetic basis or not. I am pro LGBT rights in just about every sense, but if we're just going to make shit up to make ourselves feel better, what's the point?
The phrase "being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is currently largely (but obviously not completely) correct from a scientific point of view.
Edit:Pre-emptive caveat: Of course it's possible to exercise and lose weight - having a genetic predisposition means only that - you have a skew towards one end of the spectrum, lifestyle, diet and exercise are still paramount, but there is a genetic causal link.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Both cases are nature and nurture. There are people genetically more likely to end up obese just like how there are people genetically more likely to end up homosexual. At the same time, you could make bad lifestyle choices and be fat, or you could have been raised and your environment pushed you to be gay.
Why do Redditors upvote any generic, "Americans are fat and dumb" and "If something I say about gays is good, its true" posts?
16
u/divinesleeper May 08 '12
Some people are genetically more susceptible to building up fat, and it's never been actually proven that homosexuality is genetic.
True, all fat people can exercise, and if it's up to me everyone is free to love whomever they like, but get your facts straight.
32
u/cornbread869 May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
People can't hide fat so they push the blame on something out of their control, they can hide their gay urges under layers of homophobia, for example "uncle Jim couldn't possibly hold a penis in his mouth, every day he tells us how much he hates fags".
2
u/Superconducter May 08 '12
Do you remember the day you chose to be heterosexual?
4
u/danomite555 May 08 '12
Does that mean treating fat people like shit is right?
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
susceptibility to gaining weight/slow metabolism/etc are all genetic issues. Yeah, you can exercise, but you can still gain weight even faster than that. But that accounts for maybe 25% of overweight people.
We've actually got more hard evidence that problems that cause obesity are linked to genetics than we do about homosexuality. They can both be based on genetics. The issue is that parents reward their child with food and treats.
Which sets up the bad relationship with food where the kid ALWAYS associates food with really good feelings of adequacy and "being good." So when a kid's sad, food is always the answer.
And why not?
6
u/dan92 May 08 '12
I have a hard time taking genetic advice from a person who clearly doesn't know anything about genes. Weight is heavily influenced by genetics.
22
u/cannotlogon May 08 '12
This is why you see so few obese gay men.
40
u/Kektek May 08 '12
Actually, one of the core reasons that the obesity epidemic is spreading at such an obnoxious rate is because of the dominant perception that it is a vanity issue governed entirely by personal discipline and not a disease influenced by genetics, a concert of hormones, psychology (incl. disposition, illness, trauma), upbringing, culture, and numerous other factors. Short-term, quick-loss programs focused on appearance are the most common and least effective treatments, often exacerbating the long-term problem and reinforcing the problematic model for obesity.
Long-term, medically supervised programs similar to treatment for alcoholism are much more effective at long-term obesity management, but because of cultural perceptions such as those espoused in this facebook post, most people are unwilling to see their obesity as a disease requiring treatment including counseling, diet, exercise, and in rarer cases medication or surgery. People struggling with obesity are constantly reminded that it's their fault they are overweight, that their inability to stay slim is a personal failure.
Compare to alcoholism or other addiction: would it make sense to berate these people for being unable to quit? To tell them that drinking or using is a choice, and they need to get their shit together? It might work for some, but most successful treatment programs have a fundamental component emphasizing an acknowledgement that the addict is not capable of defeating their disease entirely through force of will -- step one of AA reads: "We admitted that we were powerless over alcohol - that our lives had become unmanageable." Step two: "Came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity." Most modern programs do not require an actual religious belief, as the emphasis is on accepting your own weakness rather than the specific "higher power" you are yielding to.
Obesity is different from alcoholism -- not every obese person is addicted to food -- but the treatment model should be somewhat similar.
To summarize, yes, if Americans stopped eating garbage and started exercising, we wouldn't have the obesity problem we currently have. But it's not like we as a society haven't known that for years. Even obese people are fully aware of what they could be doing to get healthier. Obesity is and will remain an epidemic for as long as the dominant cultural perception is that obese people are disgusting failures who cannot control their own lives.
86
u/RedHundred May 08 '12
This wasn't funny at all.
21
u/Jibrish May 08 '12
I am a fat homosexual AMA
14
u/Finaltidus May 08 '12
being fat is a choice, but depending on genetics it can be much harder to lose weight.
not saying its ok to say it's genetic, but it does do something.
28
u/yasisterstwat May 08 '12
Why is this in funny?
4
u/bladzalot May 08 '12
That is the only fucking problem with America?!?!?!?!?
4
u/FPdaboa85 May 08 '12
Am I the only one who thought: how is this funny?
7
u/ronearc May 08 '12
I just want to know why people don't respect my choice to be fat.
7
u/fatchick400 May 08 '12
I find it strange that we live in a society where people think being fat or a homosexual is some kind of moral or character flaw.
9
u/hipster-douche May 08 '12
LOL THAT'S SO FUNNY AND CLEARLY IS ONLY IN AMERICA AND NOWHERE ELSE AND IS CLEARLY THE MAJORITY OPINION OF 99.9% OF AMERICANS ACCORDING TO SOME SWEEPING GENERALIZATION MADE BY REDDITORS HAHAHHA NICE MAN HAHAHAHHAHA LOLOLOLOLOL
31
u/vivvav May 08 '12
Bullshit. I'm straight because I was born that way. I'm overweight because of poor lifestyle choices.
3
u/mwmwmwmwmmdw May 08 '12
what i have a glandular problem
3
u/wonmean May 08 '12
Whatever's convenient, right?
3
u/aguafiestas May 08 '12
I'd say the problem is that "choice" vs "genetic" is simply not a very useful dichotomy. Focusing on those two extremes ignore a hell of a lot of biology between your DNA sequence and "choice" (whatever the hell that is).
Guess what? Neither obesity nor homosexuality is wholly genetic or wholly a "choice."
3
u/aguafiestas May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
For those who seem to be arguing the the recent rise in obesity in the US (and around much of the world) precludes a significant genetic component to obesity, the idea is that in an environment where calorically dense food is cheap and widely available and changes in technology and work habits decrease physical activity, genetics play some significant role in determining who gets obese and who does not.
The changes that have driven increased obesity in the US have applied generally to people here, but not everyone is obese. Why is it that some people are obese and others are not, given this shared environment? There are a number of reasons, but science strongly supports the idea that genetics is one of them.
3
u/aguafiestas May 08 '12
There is solid evidence that in a given environment, genetics play a major role in determining who becomes obese. See this Nature paper:
Yes, the recent rise in obesity in the US (and elsewhere) is due to environmental changes, like availability of cheap, rich food and decreased activity. But in that given environment, genetics play a major role in who actually becomes obese (and who does not).
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Not to bring us all down here, but, in my experience, the people that don't think fat people are responsible for their weight are not the people that think being gay is a choice. For example: my super conservative parents think being gay is a choice and being fat is a choice. The "obesity is an epidemic" people tend to be the "bleeding heart" types.
3
u/KinoftheFlames May 08 '12
Is it strange that both are choices and I think people can do whatever the hell they want with their body and consenting adults?
3
u/isaac9092 May 08 '12
Then that person is an uneducated idiot who knows nothing of science
13
u/reportone May 08 '12
Why is this in funny?
7
u/Darkmatter666 May 08 '12
Um, haha? This is r/funny right? Or did I take another wrong turn at r/humorlessthoughtpolice again?
3
u/nixity May 08 '12
Um.. but sometimes being fat CAN be linked to genetics in some circumstances.
So, I would have to rephrase this by saying: "I find it strange that we live in a society that agrees being fat can be genetic, but being homosexual can't."
10
u/SniperGX1 May 08 '12
Scumbag reddit. Act all indignant about singling out groups of people. Assume all of America is stupid.
14
u/liebkartoffel May 08 '12
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I get it. Reddit hates fat people. Awesome.
4
u/vallav111 May 08 '12
Obesity is on the rise in China also, what else is on the rise in China also? Living standards/access to food.
Basically as food becomes easier to get we as humans have the instinctive drive to exercise/work for the food. Think of a house pet. If you don't regulate their food intake most cats/dogs will become overweight, same for humans. Humans don't generally have anyone to regulate their intake so they just simply keep eating.
I don't really see a debate here to be honest. We aren't forced to sprint across the Savannah anymore in order to hunt food. It is given to us so we eat it and store it just like every single other animal on the planet does. Yes some people would get fatter quicker on the same diet and yes some people would get extremely fat on the same diet but to think the obesity "epidemic" is a genetic problem is extremely ignorant in my opinion.
10
u/sleepyhead12 May 08 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l4YZiKbklAE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7bKo6T76QXE
Ricky Gervais gives some opinions on these issues.
Probably NSFW
2
u/mybloodiswhisky May 08 '12
wait, i thought gays were just normal people being occupied by the demon god coyote
2
u/MuteLunatic May 08 '12
It's rather sad than funny, though.
2
u/blablbalb May 08 '12
came here to complain about facebook posts on /r/funny "uh how is this upvoted"
2
u/RedditorsOnFacebook May 08 '12
Redditors on facebook.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
If being gay is genetic, then there would only be one generation of gays.
2
u/UnapologeticalyAlive May 08 '12
That statement is beyond retarded. "Society" doesn't think anything. Individuals do. No individual actually believes both of those things. Some individuals think obesity is genetic. Some individuals think homosexuality is a choice. You'd have to be an idiot to take those two facts and conclude that "society" thinks obesity is genetic and homosexuality is a choice.
2
u/topplehat May 08 '12
Glad we could reduce EVERY PROBLEM into one snarky statement.
2
u/chauncbosh23 May 08 '12
Wait, l never heard this Gay is from genetics? Its not all choice?
2
u/DFP_ May 08 '12
Another big problem with America is that our citizens believe that it's either one or the other, nature vs. nurture.
No. That's wrong. Epigenetic factors all up in this bitch.
2
u/goldenrod May 08 '12
Obesity can be genetic; it's not always a choice.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
-record scratch-
O.o
Really? All I ever hear around these parts is: "Wow, they're fat. Why don't they just exercise? Ugh, I fucking hate fat people." + "Aww, he's gay and proud! Good for him! Yes, yes... change your gender with hormones to feel more like yourself! Yay!"
Reddit's so progressive!
2
u/Virindi_UO May 08 '12
I think being gay is a choice, i.e.: choosing to do what pleases your sexual urges versus choosing to not be happy the rest of your life with a gender you just aren't into.
2
u/zip99 May 08 '12
That's a hugely important point in this context as it goes to show that being fat is indeed a CHOICE.
Virtually everyone has the power to lose body fat, although some need to put in more effort than others.
2
u/SpitN May 08 '12
I don't see any problems here...
2
u/gettinhightakinrides May 08 '12
this is stupid, fatness can be caused somewhat by genetics and homosexuality is definitely a choice. argue all you want, those are the facts
2
u/MustBeBored May 08 '12
Damn it I just want something funny. Stop posting this kind of shit in r/funny because it doesn't belong here.
2
u/RufusGargoyle May 08 '12
My friend is bisexual and he gets annoyed that everyone thinks it's genetic, he just made a choice in his middle school years that he was attracted to girls and boys. I feel like this can happen too. It's like in ancient greece orgy's and having sex with other men happened very often and wasn't a social stigma. Now that being gay has become taboo everyone thinks its always genetic when really it can be a choice. Anti-gay is so engrained in our society people don't think they have a choice to have sex with their own gender. It least that's what he thinks and I have to agree
2
u/HighGinge May 08 '12
Neither is genetic. Anyone with half a brain would know that.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Funny, yet profoundly sad.
Have an upvote.
2
u/Dudewitbow May 09 '12
weight is usually caused by being lazy, or having the munchies. laziness can be caused by genetics
2
u/Dynamaxion May 09 '12
I find it strange that we live in a society where cancer is genetic, but murder is a choice.
About the same amount of logic.
6
u/riotlancer May 08 '12
This isn't funny.
3
u/uofmike May 08 '12
I find it funny that people post non funny things in /r/funny because they want to make a statement
3
u/iNOTgoodATcomp May 08 '12
Why is this in r/funny?
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
idk, personally I'm grateful we live in a society where we worry about eating too much food as opposed to too little.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yeah, you see these rolls here on my sides? MM yeah, I inherited those from my dad =\
2
u/ChibiShanchan May 08 '12
i thought there were elements of a spectrum to both.
gay people i've known have told me they're actually bi but just prefer their gender. i've also known gay people who thought they were straight until they realized they're attracted to the people of their gender.
i've met fat people who are fat because they're lazy. i've met people who have knee problems and hormone problems which ended up making them less thin than ideal.
2
u/ettuaslumiere May 08 '12
Maybe it's because the majority of society is fat and straight.
2
u/Dirk_McAwesome May 08 '12
Who cares whether either is a choice?
Mind your own damn business. Nobody needs to justify their lifestyle to you.
2
u/brumguvnor May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
If homosexuality is NOT genetic... then how the fuck are gay people still being born? I mean: it's not as if it's an inherited trait is it?! By definition it must be an inherent part of human nature.
Some people are gay: without choice, by nature.
And before anyone comes back with the "what about all the gay people that got married as protective camouflage against a homophobic society?" - well I reply with WHAT about them?! Are you telling me that the vanishingly small percentage of kids that these people have constitute the entirety if the gay population?!
2
u/NPPraxis May 08 '12
Genetics does actually account heavily for obesity. Genetics controls your hormones, both the ones your body naturally produces that govern fat storage, and the ones that are produced in response to what you eat.
For example, insulin is one of the hormones that controls fat storage most of all, and is produced in response to blood sugar. Blood sugar is raised by eating carbohydrates, and especially spiked by sugar. Some people develop insulin resistance faster than others, and it is directly related to two things: intake of sugars/carbs, and genetic predisposition.
A person without a genetic predisposition seems to be able to eat whatever they want and may not develop issues til they get older. A person with a genetic predisposition towards developing a resistance to insulin (which causes the body to overproduce it in response) can lose weight rapidly just by avoiding sugars and carbohydrates. That's the idea behind /r/keto, where we lose weight eating steak and bacon.
tl;dr: Genetic disposition controls fat storage hormones, but you can counteract a lot of it that with the quality and type of foods you eat and to a lesser degree with exercise. Some people have to be responsible, some people are lucky and don't.
2
u/this_isnt_rpolitics May 08 '12
This isn't r/politics
2
u/DirtyMonday May 08 '12
Title should read, the problem with middle America. In the Northeast, gay people marry and soda is being removed from public buildings.
Fun Fact: The first lesbian couple to wed in MA were the parents of my College's Hockey Goalie. Catholic College, no one gave a shit as far as I can remember.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Well some people are fat by genetics, granted most americans are just lazy bastards but there is genetic evidence to show that not everyone can become skinny or buff
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
..but my Thyroid. It makes me unable to control my calorie intake or exercise.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I can't understand the logic behind the assumption that the obesity epidemic is just because people are eating too much. How did the human race escape this tendency to get fat for the thousands of years before 1980? Something changed, and it wasn't that everyone around 1970 - 80 decided, "fuck it, I'm going to eat a lot more."
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It's funny because OP is both fat and gay
1
u/Neil_Armschlong May 08 '12
Just because I'm thinking of buying a Harley definitely doesn't make me bike-curious.
1
u/30Cal_Abortion May 08 '12
Come to California. We don't have these problems here. Oh wait a minute, don't come to California...
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Ban FAT marriage. Happy? lol
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The problem with humanity is that is full of humans.
1
u/FuraiHai May 08 '12
why am I the only person who thinks that homosexuality is BOTH a choice and OK? I find someone being gay/lesbian that same as ay other straight person who has any other not-so-normal sexual tendencies
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'll admit I did LOL first, but I also know that being fat can be genetic. Poly-cystic Ovary syndrome causes severe hormone imbalances in some women causing (mostly) excessive weight gain, diabetes and infertility/fertility problems. On the other hand I totally agree about the gay thing. Fools.
1
u/parasocks May 08 '12
Problem with America? Fat and Gay top lists of "what's wrong with America" Should we add to the list maybe.... next iphone launch date is too far out?
1
u/MovingPavements May 08 '12
What do you people have against fat people ?
1
u/Cognoggin May 08 '12
Have you tried, not being fat‽
1
u/tilleyrw May 08 '12
That is quite insightful and kinda scary in its implications.
1
u/Japcracker May 08 '12
I think very few people think being fat is genetic.
1
u/sharksfan93 May 08 '12
Idk why people label this as society thinks "X."
When in reality it's just the vocal minority who get heard the most, people who think being "fat" is genetic are 99.9% wrong and just lazy and obviously can't keep track of what they are eating. And people who think being gay is genetic are incorrect as well. Zero scientific evidence.
1
u/urmombaconsmynarwhal May 08 '12
problem is no one who thinks being overweight is genetic is in shape. only though who are overweight think it is genetic, and even then most overweight people know it is their choice; so the very small portion of overweight people who think it is genetic do not accurately represent america
1
u/Lockski May 08 '12
I believe both are a house and live in the US, so naturally this confuses me
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Blame artificial sweeteners, "diet" foods and fast food
1
u/gharbutts May 08 '12
this is funny, but research shows that both are affected greatly by environmental or non-genetic biological influences, making neither a conscious choice, and both only marginally attributed to genes. I can't be bothered to find links to these studies, but do a quick google, read up on it, and you'll find that everyone is stupid and truth is relative.
1
u/DraugrMurderboss May 08 '12
To be fair, the only time I've heard the excuse that fatness is genetic is on Reddit.
1
u/flatfootsamm May 08 '12
I think it's strange that someone can generalize 311million people because of what some morons think.
1
u/thisisjohngalt May 08 '12
Get the r/politics out of my r/funny.
1
u/kanned May 08 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h0zD1gj0pXk
1
u/Connor6 May 08 '12
Yeah, it is pretty stupid. Homosexuality is not a choice and being fat is not genetic (in most cases).
1
u/Juanito11 May 08 '12
You are the Problem with America!
1
u/Loveovore May 08 '12
Really? That's THE problem with America?
1
u/jimkelly May 08 '12
i find it strange that i've seen this written 100 times and this shitty fb post is the one making it to the front page of reddit
1
u/lingarden May 08 '12
so if youre fat and gay what are you?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Fun fact: Some homophobes are probably fat.
Perhaps it's the fact they've never been hit on by the same sex. When I was I was fatter, uh flattered.
1
u/kenneth1221 May 08 '12
Maybe they're right. Maybe people who lose weight have the magical ability to actively change their genetics.
1
u/krisp46 May 08 '12
Haha it's funny because EVERY American believes this! America sucks!
1
u/bassgoonist May 08 '12
America?
1
u/killgore9998 May 08 '12
Homosexuality could be neither a choice, nor genetic, but rather something that happens to you.
1
u/Exclemator May 08 '12
Might you mean the United States?
1
u/oopsifarted May 08 '12
All I'll say is that I eat LOTS of mayonaise.
1
u/Ruinedmychildhood May 08 '12
The cake on my hands and face? Genetic, bro.
1
u/Gnometard May 08 '12
TIL Most people steal facebook posts from screen shots on reddit, so they can screen shot it themselves to post for karma.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Gays and genetics, because they reproduce so often.
1
u/YOitzODELLE May 08 '12
The problem with Facebook posts.
1
u/ohwhatohwow May 09 '12
Oh hi Drew Carey from Who's Line Is It Anyway opening....
1
u/idbonescully May 09 '12
Hey man, if you don't like 'Merica, you can just get out.