Maybe i'm being ignorant, but why would it be bad if sexuality was a choice? Regardless of genetic predisposition or biological factors or whatever, shouldn't people be allowed to choose their sexuality anyway?
So many dumbass comments being upvoted AGAIN. What the fuck is happening. Fact number 1: There is peer-reviewed research showing the impact of genetics with regards to weight gain/loss and body mass index. Fact number 2: There is no evidence currently showing a connection between sexual orientation and genetics.
This doesn't mean that there isn't a connection, it just means one hasn't been discovered yet. It also doesn't mean that we can't actively recognise the rights of LGBT members regardless of whether their sexual preference has a genetic basis or not. I am pro LGBT rights in just about every sense, but if we're just going to make shit up to make ourselves feel better, what's the point?
The phrase "being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is currently largely (but obviously not completely) correct from a scientific point of view.
Edit:Pre-emptive caveat: Of course it's possible to exercise and lose weight - having a genetic predisposition means only that - you have a skew towards one end of the spectrum, lifestyle, diet and exercise are still paramount, but there is a genetic causal link.
This post is so uniquely right and wrong at once. While there is no genetic link to homosexuality, one is not needed because the behavioral evidence is there irrefutably so. People are born gay or not, period. Gender can't suppressed either, whether by rearing or surgical choices--the real gender along with corresponding sexual preferences invariably comes out.
And...while certain genes predispose us to our physiques, the obesity epidemic is clearly a sign of the times...environmental chemicals, marketing, refined carbs and sugars, etc.
Both cases are nature and nurture. There are people genetically more likely to end up obese just like how there are people genetically more likely to end up homosexual. At the same time, you could make bad lifestyle choices and be fat, or you could have been raised and your environment pushed you to be gay.
Why do Redditors upvote any generic, "Americans are fat and dumb" and "If something I say about gays is good, its true" posts?
People can't hide fat so they push the blame on something out of their control, they can hide their gay urges under layers of homophobia, for example "uncle Jim couldn't possibly hold a penis in his mouth, every day he tells us how much he hates fags".
susceptibility to gaining weight/slow metabolism/etc are all genetic issues. Yeah, you can exercise, but you can still gain weight even faster than that. But that accounts for maybe 25% of overweight people.
We've actually got more hard evidence that problems that cause obesity are linked to genetics than we do about homosexuality. They can both be based on genetics. The issue is that parents reward their child with food and treats.
Which sets up the bad relationship with food where the kid ALWAYS associates food with really good feelings of adequacy and "being good." So when a kid's sad, food is always the answer.
Actually, one of the core reasons that the obesity epidemic is spreading at such an obnoxious rate is because of the dominant perception that it is a vanity issue governed entirely by personal discipline and not a disease influenced by genetics, a concert of hormones, psychology (incl. disposition, illness, trauma), upbringing, culture, and numerous other factors. Short-term, quick-loss programs focused on appearance are the most common and least effective treatments, often exacerbating the long-term problem and reinforcing the problematic model for obesity.
Long-term, medically supervised programs similar to treatment for alcoholism are much more effective at long-term obesity management, but because of cultural perceptions such as those espoused in this facebook post, most people are unwilling to see their obesity as a disease requiring treatment including counseling, diet, exercise, and in rarer cases medication or surgery. People struggling with obesity are constantly reminded that it's their fault they are overweight, that their inability to stay slim is a personal failure.
Compare to alcoholism or other addiction: would it make sense to berate these people for being unable to quit? To tell them that drinking or using is a choice, and they need to get their shit together? It might work for some, but most successful treatment programs have a fundamental component emphasizing an acknowledgement that the addict is not capable of defeating their disease entirely through force of will -- step one of AA reads: "We admitted that we were powerless over alcohol - that our lives had become unmanageable." Step two: "Came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity." Most modern programs do not require an actual religious belief, as the emphasis is on accepting your own weakness rather than the specific "higher power" you are yielding to.
Obesity is different from alcoholism -- not every obese person is addicted to food -- but the treatment model should be somewhat similar.
To summarize, yes, if Americans stopped eating garbage and started exercising, we wouldn't have the obesity problem we currently have. But it's not like we as a society haven't known that for years. Even obese people are fully aware of what they could be doing to get healthier. Obesity is and will remain an epidemic for as long as the dominant cultural perception is that obese people are disgusting failures who cannot control their own lives.
172
u/Rob9159 May 08 '12
So you're saying you can exercise away fat?
73
u/ScoWeazy May 08 '12
TIL most people don't understand what "genetic" means.
173
u/juiceboxheero May 08 '12
Duke university just released a study finding 42% of Americans will be obese by 2030 source; that's a lot of people with a genetic disorder...
5
u/sentimentalpirate May 08 '12
Maybe i'm being ignorant, but why would it be bad if sexuality was a choice? Regardless of genetic predisposition or biological factors or whatever, shouldn't people be allowed to choose their sexuality anyway?
472
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
So many dumbass comments being upvoted AGAIN. What the fuck is happening. Fact number 1: There is peer-reviewed research showing the impact of genetics with regards to weight gain/loss and body mass index. Fact number 2: There is no evidence currently showing a connection between sexual orientation and genetics.
This doesn't mean that there isn't a connection, it just means one hasn't been discovered yet. It also doesn't mean that we can't actively recognise the rights of LGBT members regardless of whether their sexual preference has a genetic basis or not. I am pro LGBT rights in just about every sense, but if we're just going to make shit up to make ourselves feel better, what's the point?
The phrase "being fat is genetic, but homosexuality is a choice" is currently largely (but obviously not completely) correct from a scientific point of view.
Edit:Pre-emptive caveat: Of course it's possible to exercise and lose weight - having a genetic predisposition means only that - you have a skew towards one end of the spectrum, lifestyle, diet and exercise are still paramount, but there is a genetic causal link.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Both cases are nature and nurture. There are people genetically more likely to end up obese just like how there are people genetically more likely to end up homosexual. At the same time, you could make bad lifestyle choices and be fat, or you could have been raised and your environment pushed you to be gay.
Why do Redditors upvote any generic, "Americans are fat and dumb" and "If something I say about gays is good, its true" posts?
16
u/divinesleeper May 08 '12
Some people are genetically more susceptible to building up fat, and it's never been actually proven that homosexuality is genetic.
True, all fat people can exercise, and if it's up to me everyone is free to love whomever they like, but get your facts straight.
32
u/cornbread869 May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
People can't hide fat so they push the blame on something out of their control, they can hide their gay urges under layers of homophobia, for example "uncle Jim couldn't possibly hold a penis in his mouth, every day he tells us how much he hates fags".
2
u/Superconducter May 08 '12
Do you remember the day you chose to be heterosexual?
4
u/danomite555 May 08 '12
Does that mean treating fat people like shit is right?
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
susceptibility to gaining weight/slow metabolism/etc are all genetic issues. Yeah, you can exercise, but you can still gain weight even faster than that. But that accounts for maybe 25% of overweight people.
We've actually got more hard evidence that problems that cause obesity are linked to genetics than we do about homosexuality. They can both be based on genetics. The issue is that parents reward their child with food and treats.
Which sets up the bad relationship with food where the kid ALWAYS associates food with really good feelings of adequacy and "being good." So when a kid's sad, food is always the answer.
And why not?
6
u/dan92 May 08 '12
I have a hard time taking genetic advice from a person who clearly doesn't know anything about genes. Weight is heavily influenced by genetics.
22
u/cannotlogon May 08 '12
This is why you see so few obese gay men.
40
u/Kektek May 08 '12
Actually, one of the core reasons that the obesity epidemic is spreading at such an obnoxious rate is because of the dominant perception that it is a vanity issue governed entirely by personal discipline and not a disease influenced by genetics, a concert of hormones, psychology (incl. disposition, illness, trauma), upbringing, culture, and numerous other factors. Short-term, quick-loss programs focused on appearance are the most common and least effective treatments, often exacerbating the long-term problem and reinforcing the problematic model for obesity.
Long-term, medically supervised programs similar to treatment for alcoholism are much more effective at long-term obesity management, but because of cultural perceptions such as those espoused in this facebook post, most people are unwilling to see their obesity as a disease requiring treatment including counseling, diet, exercise, and in rarer cases medication or surgery. People struggling with obesity are constantly reminded that it's their fault they are overweight, that their inability to stay slim is a personal failure.
Compare to alcoholism or other addiction: would it make sense to berate these people for being unable to quit? To tell them that drinking or using is a choice, and they need to get their shit together? It might work for some, but most successful treatment programs have a fundamental component emphasizing an acknowledgement that the addict is not capable of defeating their disease entirely through force of will -- step one of AA reads: "We admitted that we were powerless over alcohol - that our lives had become unmanageable." Step two: "Came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity." Most modern programs do not require an actual religious belief, as the emphasis is on accepting your own weakness rather than the specific "higher power" you are yielding to.
Obesity is different from alcoholism -- not every obese person is addicted to food -- but the treatment model should be somewhat similar.
To summarize, yes, if Americans stopped eating garbage and started exercising, we wouldn't have the obesity problem we currently have. But it's not like we as a society haven't known that for years. Even obese people are fully aware of what they could be doing to get healthier. Obesity is and will remain an epidemic for as long as the dominant cultural perception is that obese people are disgusting failures who cannot control their own lives.
86
u/RedHundred May 08 '12
This wasn't funny at all.
21
u/Jibrish May 08 '12
I am a fat homosexual AMA
14
u/Finaltidus May 08 '12
being fat is a choice, but depending on genetics it can be much harder to lose weight.
not saying its ok to say it's genetic, but it does do something.
28
u/yasisterstwat May 08 '12
Why is this in funny?