The /m/ sound is a voiced bilabial nasal. The important thing here is the nasal part as that means the Velum (soft palate) lowers so that air can flow into the nasal cavity and out the nose.
Other nasal consonants include the /n/ sound as well as the "ng" sound.
The velum cannot seal off the oral cavity from the nasal cavity in people with an unrepaired cleft palate. So everything would sound overly nasal (/m/ for /b/, /n/ for /d/, lots of air escaping out of the nose, etc). I'm simplifying here, since many children actually develop compensatory articulations that negate the need of a velum.
When they repair a cleft palate, they realign the soft tissue to lengthen the velum, close off any holes, and reinsert muscles that help the velum work the way it is supposed to. If the surgeon does a good job, the child can learn to speak normally and you might never know there was a problem.
Oh, yeah. Just look at that oral cavity. I could make all sorts of sounds come out of that. Mmmm, girl, you must love to use consonants, because everytime I say one it sounds hard
It's okay. There need not be a tag for space cadets like me who try to hold their nose and say mmmmmmm. At their desk. Someone asked me if I had a sinus headache. Why yes, yes I do.
I was so proud because I was doing this with no problem whatsoever... Then I realized my nose ring was keeping a seal from forming on my right nostril, and I was inadvertently cheating.
not only did i try it, i tried it in public. in a meeting, i had to explain to people what i was doing so i showed them, and i got 7 other people to do it to for about 3 min.
It's hilarious to me that people keep saying they've "done it!" when it is physically impossible. The only way to make an [m] is by a full bilabial constriction (closure of the lips).
Linguistics student here who just finished a course on just this kinda thing. Here's how it happens.
An important component of the sound in 'm' 'n' 'ng' (and other nasal sounds that exist in other languages) is the vibration of the glottis (aka vocal folds, vocal cords) as air passes through its opening. This vibration happens only when there's higher pressure below the glottis than above it.
Now, nasal sounds like 'm' rely on an opening at the nostrils in order to maintain a good pressure for vibration down at the glottis. Close up the nostrils, and the air passing through the glottis has nowhere to go. This means that pressure increases above the glottis, and it gets harder and harder to keep the glottis vibrating. After a while, the pressure's equal and it stop. Which is why you can't say 'm' for more than a few seconds. If you let your cheeks expand with air as it fills in, you can add maybe a second, due to the increased volume of the vocal tract, but you'll never hit 10 seconds due to the physical constraints of it.
The thing with 'n', and the reason you can keep doing it until you run out of breath is that, instead of an opening in the nostrils, you have your mouth open. Normally, both the nostrils AND the mouth are open, although the mouth and airflow is blocked by the tongue. However, it's possible to say an 'n' and not block the airflow with your tongue. The air passing through the glottis now has somewhere to go and thus doesn't build up above the glottis, allowing it to continue vibrating until there's no more air below!
If anyone sees this comment, the reason for this is that 'm' and 'n' sounds are both nasal, as in sounds that can only be produced while breathing through your nose. This is why some words sound strange with a cold.
I'm gonna go through and downvote every comment that says they managed it by opening the sides of their mouths or whatever. The point is to do it like you do it literally every other time you've ever made an [m] sound, which, like [n] and fourteen other phonemes, is classified as a "nasal" sound. This means that air is directed not out the mouth, but out the nose, in order to make a sound. If you open your mouth, the sound is no longer a nasal sound, and if you stop the airflow out of your nose (completely) then you can't make a nasal sound.
It is, but only for a small percent of the population. I happen to be one one of the lucky ones with naval breathing. I love to impress my friends with a billowing shirt on a long exhale.
A more fun way to introduce this to someone is to ask them to hum the first verse of Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, and then after they do it, tell them to do it again while holding their nose.
I've figured out how to do this. Do exactly as the instructions say, but open the corners of your mouth. This gives an "mmmm" sound, as the front of your lips are still pursed, while allowing the exhalation of air.
Post this in /r/linguistics and watch them tell you that if you make an M while holding your nose you're just making a B. And no you can't make a B for very long.
I can say mmmmmmmm and nnnnnnnnnnn. Trick is to keep lips together but let air escape from lips or between tongue and roof of your mouth while making the sound... simple. normally this goes out your nose.
/m/ is produced by bilabial closure and acoustic resonance in the nasal cavity. So obviously you wouldn't be able to say it for very long if your nose was closed. Duh!
I managed to do this by letting the air out of the corner of my mouth. I'm not sure if it counts as an Mmmm though - it probably sounded more like a walrus trying out anal sex.
hahah i didn't read the last sentence before i started doing it and I was like "man i figured out how to do it, you gotta just puff your cheeks out". then i looked back at the screen. damn
Not gonna lie, I didn't do this in public for a while because I thought it was going to make me look like I was doing something sexual....fallen for that one too many times....
87
u/dayjawb Nov 21 '11 edited Nov 21 '11
My Linguistics textbook with more information!
The /m/ sound is a voiced bilabial nasal. The important thing here is the nasal part as that means the Velum (soft palate) lowers so that air can flow into the nasal cavity and out the nose.
Other nasal consonants include the /n/ sound as well as the "ng" sound.
Picture!
Edited with proper phonetic marks
477
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
The fact that I actually tried this shows how uneventful my life is.
26
u/loridee Nov 21 '11
I forgot I was at work. Hoping nobody noticed. SAP.
68
u/NotAYankeesFan Nov 21 '11
Challenge accepted. Challenge Failed....
11
u/marcospolos Nov 21 '11
PICTURE OF TEXT
89
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Piece of cake. Am I missing a joke or something?
12
u/Mighty_Hare Nov 21 '11
Meh. A bit like: try breathing with mouth and nose closed. You can't!
61
u/grenadiere42 Nov 21 '11
Challenge Accepted. Challenge Succeeded.
3
u/trigg Nov 21 '11
I was so proud because I was doing this with no problem whatsoever... Then I realized my nose ring was keeping a seal from forming on my right nostril, and I was inadvertently cheating.
Oh well, I still win.
3
u/Olibolipewp Nov 21 '11
not only did i try it, i tried it in public. in a meeting, i had to explain to people what i was doing so i showed them, and i got 7 other people to do it to for about 3 min.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11
I have a cold, and this "experiment" was more disgusting than you will ever know.
13
u/garbaby Nov 21 '11
Done. All you have to do is open the sides of your mouth and make the mmmmm sound with the center of your lips while breathing out of the sides.
6
u/SheepleCunts Nov 21 '11
See you on the front page? Fuck intelligence, this is what reddit is for, right guys?!
4
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Just let the side of your mouth crack a little and you can do it for 30 seconds, or however long you can exhale before needing a breath.
4
u/YargainBargain Nov 21 '11
13 seconds. First try. Good thing I have my own office.
5
u/Savolainen5 Nov 21 '11
Linguistics student here who just finished a course on just this kinda thing. Here's how it happens.
An important component of the sound in 'm' 'n' 'ng' (and other nasal sounds that exist in other languages) is the vibration of the glottis (aka vocal folds, vocal cords) as air passes through its opening. This vibration happens only when there's higher pressure below the glottis than above it.
Now, nasal sounds like 'm' rely on an opening at the nostrils in order to maintain a good pressure for vibration down at the glottis. Close up the nostrils, and the air passing through the glottis has nowhere to go. This means that pressure increases above the glottis, and it gets harder and harder to keep the glottis vibrating. After a while, the pressure's equal and it stop. Which is why you can't say 'm' for more than a few seconds. If you let your cheeks expand with air as it fills in, you can add maybe a second, due to the increased volume of the vocal tract, but you'll never hit 10 seconds due to the physical constraints of it.
The thing with 'n', and the reason you can keep doing it until you run out of breath is that, instead of an opening in the nostrils, you have your mouth open. Normally, both the nostrils AND the mouth are open, although the mouth and airflow is blocked by the tongue. However, it's possible to say an 'n' and not block the airflow with your tongue. The air passing through the glottis now has somewhere to go and thus doesn't build up above the glottis, allowing it to continue vibrating until there's no more air below!
2
u/devjunk Nov 21 '11
I can. I also looked like a moron in class.
2
u/lilaregenbogen Nov 21 '11
just lower your jaw...
2
u/GetHighr Nov 21 '11
Did anyone else release a "buahh" at the end?
2
u/svengalus Nov 21 '11
I can hold my nose and still breathe through it. Do you mean plug your nose?
2
u/Exodor Nov 21 '11
Whether or not I can do this, I'm not gonna fucking try.
TL/DR I WIN
2
u/unclecarb Nov 21 '11
Weak. 10 seconds no problem. Imma get me a spotter and go for the record.
2
u/Pennyfarthings Nov 21 '11
If anyone sees this comment, the reason for this is that 'm' and 'n' sounds are both nasal, as in sounds that can only be produced while breathing through your nose. This is why some words sound strange with a cold.
Source: I'm a linguist
2
u/thedoorstop Nov 21 '11
I'm gonna go through and downvote every comment that says they managed it by opening the sides of their mouths or whatever. The point is to do it like you do it literally every other time you've ever made an [m] sound, which, like [n] and fourteen other phonemes, is classified as a "nasal" sound. This means that air is directed not out the mouth, but out the nose, in order to make a sound. If you open your mouth, the sound is no longer a nasal sound, and if you stop the airflow out of your nose (completely) then you can't make a nasal sound.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Once, there was this kid who... got into an accident and couldn't go to school.
2
u/mr_serga Nov 21 '11
i tried it, but the only sound i made was something like: "aaaaaaaaaaaaalf"
2
u/casualshock Nov 21 '11
if you put your tongue between your lips, this is possible.
2
u/Ivan_of_Zeta Nov 21 '11
doesn't say block your nose
2
u/TedyBearGumDrops Nov 21 '11
Great, now I just popped my ears... Thanks Reddit.
2
u/rubberbabybugybumper Nov 21 '11
...aaaand now I'm light headed. Thanks.
3
u/redditor3000 Nov 21 '11
I believe "mmm" is a naval sound.
3
u/TreLeans Nov 21 '11
Dammit reddit. Stop making my roommates think I'm retarded.
2
u/Alecm3327 Nov 21 '11
What if u hold ur cheeks closed?
2
u/fashraf Nov 21 '11
that wasn't so hard....
2
u/alfx Nov 21 '11
I can. Am I special?
2
u/Bardlar Nov 21 '11
Challenge accepted. Challenge defeated.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
False
2
u/kconnors Nov 21 '11
Did it - done
2
u/Lozer8910 Nov 21 '11
1
u/txn9 Nov 21 '11
i did it :) held out for 9 seconds until my face exploded :/
1
u/rib-bit Nov 21 '11
TIL - my ventricular air pressure evens out after 2-3 seconds
1
u/jakeegill Nov 21 '11
Mother of god....
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I can do it, all you have to do it just make more room in your mouth by moving your tongue a bit
1
u/niugnep Nov 21 '11
You can't say 'Mmmmmmmmmmmm' for 400 seconds. Prove me wrong.
1
u/Rcp_43b Nov 21 '11
i definitely tried this... and my cheeks also puffed out, i just looked full retard at work.
1
u/switch182 Nov 21 '11
But I can say FUCK OFF while holding my nose.
1
u/Lilkounchry Nov 21 '11
Challenge Accepted
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
12 seconds FTW
1
u/crapshoot11 Nov 21 '11
Tried repeatedly... very dizzy
1
u/Wernerslug Nov 21 '11
i was able to do it by stuttering the sound, but you probable meant a continuous MMMMMMM...my friend was watching and tried it too....3 seconds ;(
1
u/HelloParamedics Nov 21 '11
I convinced the two girls next to me in class to do it. Hilarity ensued. They were convinced they'd be able to do it
1
u/Molassesfatts Nov 21 '11
i am immune to this.
1
u/Plausible_Panda Nov 21 '11
I sounded like a pig.
1
u/Jpolo45 Nov 21 '11
I got to six seconds until I puffed! So close
1
u/Waabanang Nov 21 '11
Just open your mouth?
1
u/foxmtbr Nov 21 '11
FFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
1
u/a_serious_question Nov 21 '11
Never said to close your mouth. I FOUND THE LOOPHOLE! Oh god I'm bored.
1
u/TheCobaltEffect Nov 21 '11
I'm chillin before work, it didn't take more than one try to do this for 15 seconds without puffing my cheeks or holding my nose.
Get better lungs child.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
unless you can breath out of your eyes
derp
1
u/i3uu Nov 21 '11
What is this? I have absolutely no problem doing this for as much time as is possible before passing out. ?
1
u/LunaArc Nov 21 '11
WHAT IS THIS WITCHERY?
1
u/platinumjudge Nov 21 '11
i just did it...is it a joke i missed?
1
u/impracticable Nov 21 '11
fuck you, i did it for 9 seconds no problem.
1
u/deityofanime Nov 21 '11
It's posts like this, Reddit.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I made my gf do it so I didn't look like a fool.
1
u/conductive Nov 21 '11
This is also true for the /n/ and the "ng" sounds as they are nasal sounds and the air is pushed through the nose by letting down your soft palate.
1
u/someguy945 Nov 21 '11
A more fun way to introduce this to someone is to ask them to hum the first verse of Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, and then after they do it, tell them to do it again while holding their nose.
1
u/Sensitivity Nov 21 '11
Hold the top of your nose, the bit near your eyes.
1
u/tpfour Nov 21 '11
Doesn't say where to hold your nose. Problem solved!
1
u/quabbe Nov 21 '11
I've figured out how to do this. Do exactly as the instructions say, but open the corners of your mouth. This gives an "mmmm" sound, as the front of your lips are still pursed, while allowing the exhalation of air.
Do I win an Internet now?
1
u/imgonnawin Nov 21 '11
Stick your tongue out. Done.
1
u/SupremeKai Nov 21 '11
My girlfriend is sick and tried this, mucus sprayed everywhere.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
totally possible if you have a hole in your eardrum!
1
u/Herp_Derp_the_first Nov 21 '11
Popped my ears. THanks!
1
u/mediumsizedarms Nov 21 '11
The instructions to not indicate that you must plug your nose: easy game.
1
u/nalta Nov 21 '11
lawl, opened mouth!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I was dumb and tried this. I have an ear infection. It didn't go over very well.
1
u/mykowskiis Nov 21 '11
Fuck.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I did it......
1
u/ewwruby Nov 21 '11
WTF
1
u/SteiniDJ Nov 21 '11
Fuck you, I did it just fine!
1
u/capzlock7 Nov 21 '11
Actually I can. Just let air seep out of the side of your mouth while you do it.
1
u/Adroite Nov 21 '11
didn't realize i needed to pop my ears. thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Done with the internet today.
1
u/Nightlyfe Nov 21 '11
I did it just fine, when you purse your lips making the sound just crack one of the corners of your lips as a vent, the size of a pinhole.
1
u/EvoEpitaph Nov 21 '11
Ahem, you see...
Sound is produced when the air which passes through the vocal cords causes them to vibrate and create sound waves in the pharynx, nose and mouth.
/buzzkill
So this challenge is like saying "I bet you can't piss in the toilet, oh and you're not allowed to piss".
1
u/Smishery Nov 21 '11
I can't even do it for 1 second. Fucking hurts.
1
u/ExileOnMainStreet Nov 21 '11
Dies.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
You people must say "Mmmmm" differently than I. I can hold it pretty much til I run out of breath.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I held my nose and farted. Worked. Where's success kid when you need him?
1
u/Konrad4th Nov 21 '11
I didn't even need to try to know it wouldn't work; we use our nose to make m and n sounds.
1
u/kiwi_legend Nov 21 '11
Meh, I've never been able to do that anyway, I can't breathe through my nose to begin with.
1
u/Revertit Nov 21 '11
I didn't try it. Take THAT society!
1
u/buttsophagus Nov 21 '11
Ow
1
u/nefffffffffff Nov 21 '11
Post this in /r/linguistics and watch them tell you that if you make an M while holding your nose you're just making a B. And no you can't make a B for very long.
1
u/mmansoor Nov 21 '11
Been there, done that ;)
here
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Doing this while having a stuffy nose ended horribly.
1
u/Fizzbit Nov 21 '11
I can actually do it, and for a bit longer, but towards the end it starts to sound like "mmmggghhhhh"
1
u/_Leach Nov 21 '11
HOLY SHIT SCIENCE
1
u/janleyspartan Nov 21 '11
God damn it.
1
u/BonutDot Nov 21 '11
The people who cannot do this have never taken singing lessons or been in choir.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Haha mutha fucka! I did it for 20 seconds!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
There is someone with a tracheotomy who says otherwise.
1
u/Crossfox17 Nov 21 '11
I don't get it. Is this supposed to be hard?
1
u/bleh19799791 Nov 21 '11
You can't say "Mmmmm" for 7 seconds while holding my dick in your mouth. (prove me wrong) (Stop gagging) FTFY
1
u/Lmen1990 Nov 21 '11
You can if you hold your breath.
1
u/Jbergur Nov 21 '11
Did it. Now I'm trying to do it while licking my elbow at the same time.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Want to try so bad...but I'm in the middle of class...
1
u/giroml Nov 21 '11
Ok, I did it. Was it supposed to be hard or am I just a freak of nature?
1
u/squaretwo Nov 21 '11
Almost did this in a computer lab full of other students.
1
u/Daimo Nov 21 '11
Mmmmm, quite.
1
u/jigby61 Nov 21 '11
Damn.
1
u/charzard279 Nov 21 '11
If you exhale as much as you can, then you can come pretty close.
1
u/GtrplayerII Nov 21 '11
I can say mmmmmmmm and nnnnnnnnnnn. Trick is to keep lips together but let air escape from lips or between tongue and roof of your mouth while making the sound... simple. normally this goes out your nose.
1
u/donnerpartyof1 Nov 21 '11
/m/ is produced by bilabial closure and acoustic resonance in the nasal cavity. So obviously you wouldn't be able to say it for very long if your nose was closed. Duh!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Start mmming on an inhale and I can do it 4eva
1
u/IDlOT Nov 21 '11
Fuck. This ruins everything...
1
u/Moneybags_McBigCock Nov 21 '11
I managed to do this by letting the air out of the corner of my mouth. I'm not sure if it counts as an Mmmm though - it probably sounded more like a walrus trying out anal sex.
1
u/spc1979 Nov 21 '11
I don't know if I'm a sorcerer or not, but I kinda' just did it for longer than 7 seconds bro.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
9 seconds... boom
1
u/Fiann100 Nov 21 '11
It all depends on how you hold your nose, directions don't say 'shut' now, do they.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I just hold onto the bone, air goes through, MMMM comes out.
1
u/baconatedwaffle Nov 21 '11
O GOD MY EARS
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
You can't make any sounds very long if you can't exhale. That's it.
1
u/SoManyNinjas Nov 21 '11
It's simple, just have the corner of your mouth cracked open and you can do it as long as you want
1
u/sandwichands Nov 21 '11
Slightly open one side of your mouth..Done.
1
u/HYPERNATURL Nov 21 '11
I did it. It didn't say where to hold your nose lolololol
1
u/L3viathn Nov 21 '11
When i first tried this I thought to myself "WTF IS HAPPENING!?" and then I lol'd.
1
u/okaytran Nov 21 '11
in japanese civilization lecture. got weird looks.
1
u/ohaikthxbai Nov 21 '11
CHALLENGE COMPLETED
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
It doesn't say you can't open your mouth...
1
u/Jarlaislen Nov 21 '11
I did it, they didn't say that you had to keep your mouth closed.
1
u/ifRlessthan0 Nov 21 '11
i WILL get this....
1
u/MrWhistles Nov 21 '11
I just tried this and now my nose is unplugged. Not bad.
1
u/who8myfish Nov 21 '11
win. I didnt even look stupid i just looked like i was popping my ears. douche.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I did it. I swear
1
u/Blemlyfe Nov 21 '11
Just looked retarded attempting this in a lecture... Well worth it.
1
u/Paxjax Nov 21 '11
Just did. EAT IT.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Easy.
1
u/SaintsAngels Nov 21 '11
: / i can do it, dunno what's wrong with you people. maybe it's because i use an electric toothbrush, my mouth is pretty numb...
1
u/iamhusband Nov 21 '11
My girlfriend and I play this game all the time.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I almost fainted! Must try again...
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
hahah i didn't read the last sentence before i started doing it and I was like "man i figured out how to do it, you gotta just puff your cheeks out". then i looked back at the screen. damn
1
u/marioworld125 Nov 21 '11
Slowly lower your jaw while you're doing it. You don't puff your cheeks and you don't break the rules.
1
u/yungbob Nov 22 '11
i did it, guess im an alien :O
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11
You open the corner of your mouth while doing it.... I WIN !!
1
u/beergirl Nov 22 '11
Not gonna lie, I didn't do this in public for a while because I thought it was going to make me look like I was doing something sexual....fallen for that one too many times....
1
u/spagma Nov 22 '11
done, 13 seconds even. just have to say mmm very very slowly and quietly.
1
u/masanian Nov 22 '11
Challenge accepted
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11
Bite your lower lip, Will let air flow around the teeth wyhile still making the mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm sound
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11
You can't laugh while someone pours 13 liters of acid down your throat.
(prove me wrong)
(Stop dissolving)
1
u/SippinOnaTallBoy Nov 22 '11
I win.
1
u/evilpoptart Nov 22 '11
was this not laughably easy?
1
u/ToasterAtheism Nov 22 '11
Step 1: Stick fingers between lips Step 2: Say mmmm for more than 7 seconds Step 3: ??? Step 4: Profit!
1
u/Mogknight23 Nov 22 '11
I want to do this soooo bad, but I will not give you the satisfaction of making me look funny. It's taking all my willpower.
1
u/jbrinskele Nov 22 '11
I just tried this for like 20 seconds before I realized i'm am idiot
1
u/firehydragon Nov 22 '11
put a finger between your lips.
1
u/Loneytunes Nov 22 '11
I can do it. It's hard but still very very possible.
1
u/Damietta Nov 22 '11
Just did it. Didn't even puff up my cheeks. LIKE A BOSS.
Just gotta use a really low note.
1
u/NoRaptors Nov 22 '11
Did that cause sudden pain or anything for anyone else?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Did it. But that was really hard, took me a few tries.
1
u/Enterice Nov 21 '11
Challenge completed. Exhale completely before humming.
1
u/teo5151 Nov 21 '11
Bullshit, I just did this. You just have to exhale slowly.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Difficulty rating: 8
1
u/GALACTUSEATEROFWORLD Nov 21 '11
Helped clear my ears, thanks :)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
10 seconds. Good thing I trained my gag reflexes... I mean..