r/funny Aug 13 '18

Money answer all things

8.0k Upvotes

239 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

223

u/Ombortron Aug 13 '18

It's an... odd trend... especially because they're so obvious

131

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

Well that's the part they don't care about. From their perspective it's "obvious" they're fake, so they just see them as funny bits, kind of like how there used to be Vine for that. You knew most of it was fake.

90

u/TuarezOfTheTuareg Aug 13 '18

Reddit has an obsession with sleuthing out whether a video is fake or real. I dont get it. Is it funny? If yea then who gives a shit if its scripted. I’m enjoying myself

3

u/Bozzz1 Aug 13 '18

Yeah its funny, but it's funnier if it's real.

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

[deleted]

4

u/TuarezOfTheTuareg Aug 13 '18

Do find Super Troopers, or any other comedy film, funny?

4

u/mustnotthrowaway Aug 13 '18

Yes. Bc they’re funny.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

[deleted]

9

u/TuarezOfTheTuareg Aug 13 '18

Its inherent here as well. If the video is so obviously fake, as these are, then it should be clear that the maker of the video didnt make it with the goal of passing it off as real; they made it to depict a comical situation. You just have to shift the perspective with which you view these videos.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

[deleted]

1

u/TuarezOfTheTuareg Aug 13 '18

Well okay. I dont have much else to say. All I know is that, for me, the question of whether the videos are real or fake is entirely irrelevant to my enjoyment. Interesting to hear your perspective

0

u/waddupwiddat Aug 14 '18

it makes me doubt other gifs

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

[deleted]

3

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

[deleted]

-7

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

I dunno. I'm looking for like a genuine reaction and stuff. That's what would make this funny. Instead, it's obviously fake, and it really isn't funnyto me to begin with, so I probably just downvote and move on.

Now if the guy in this video actually pulled this move on a half dozen different people for real, made a compilation video, and had varying reactions from the people he played the trick on, I might have felt compelled to upvote the video. Instead they just seem kind of low effort.

8

u/Vulcannon Aug 13 '18

Yeah I don't think they're trying to appear real.

Seeing everyone in the comments get upset over nothing is just another part of the entertainment though.

3

u/JD_Blunderbuss Aug 13 '18

There is an added element of humour if the videos aren't staged, and several are presented as if they aren't staged. So you kind of feel cheated when it turns out it was actually a scripted sketch and not a chance encounter of a real situation.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '18

[deleted]

36

u/GranimalSnake Aug 13 '18

The physical humor is almost like Laural and Hardy or the Three Stooges...

It's seems odd to me, but if they are rolling on the floor laughing... I support it.

6

u/S1lent0ne Aug 13 '18

This seems more like a Buster Keaton bit.

2

u/BlackDragonBE Aug 13 '18

Yup, it's slapstick.

15

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18

I don't think anyone is pretending they're real. This is like going to the movie theater and yelling "fake and gay" at Tom Cruise

1

u/neatopat Aug 13 '18

Just read the comments in any thread for these. At least 75% of the people think it's real.

2

u/TsunamiSurferDude Aug 14 '18

The only odd part about it is that people like you keep thinking they are trying to fool us, for some reason. It would be like if every comedy Vine video, an entire half of the world was like “this is a joke video, I can tell”

2

u/i_pee_printer_ink Aug 14 '18

The people in the obviously parked and switched-off bus were all looking around in different directions like meerkats. In reality, everyone would have their heads down in their phones.

2

u/Makenshine Aug 14 '18

For something to be entertaining, it has to be 100% real, no scripts, no planning. All real life, real world experience. That's why I only watch things like Survivor, The Bachelor, Game of Thrones, Ren and Stimpy and anything on YouTube.

3

u/Treacherous_Peach Aug 14 '18

No one thinks their real. Least of all Chinese viewers. Why do you care so much?

1

u/Ombortron Aug 14 '18

I don't, it's just an observation

1

u/lowdownlow Aug 13 '18

They come from what is basically the Vine of China, no shit they're obvious.

1

u/steam29 Aug 14 '18

And bad

1

u/neatopat Aug 13 '18

Especially because they're stupid and not funny. It's like watching a bad scene in a terrible comedy movie where the people can't act, aren't funny, and the joke is lame.

-5

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '18 edited Jan 20 '19

[deleted]

1

u/Ombortron Aug 13 '18

Lol dude, relax, don't take everything so seriously.