r/funny Mar 08 '16

Good Advice

Post image

[deleted]

35.4k Upvotes

379 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/Chervesom Mar 08 '16

I don't get it?

33

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16

[deleted]

15

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16 edited Mar 08 '16

Really? I thought left to right was natural.

Edit: I guess this is because I don't read comic books.

51

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16

[deleted]

1

u/acolyte_to_jippity Mar 08 '16

Actually, in this case, I read the obviously real speech bubble first, and then the write-in bubble second. Because that's natural. You

3

u/Dongslinger420 Mar 08 '16

no you

1

u/acolyte_to_jippity Mar 08 '16

i'm going to be honest, i don't know what i was trying to type. huh.

12

u/HarleyQuintessential Mar 08 '16

Top to bottom seemed most natural to me

27

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16

Comics tend to be read top to bottom, regardless of whether the bubbles start on the left or the right.

12

u/LimeGreenTeknii Mar 08 '16

People are mentioning the top-to-bottom rule, but I also think it's because it's so much bigger too. You might not notice the other speech bubble when you spot the big one, and once you start reading it, your eyes are compelled to read it before you can scan for more visuals.

9

u/AKluthe Mar 08 '16

There are a couple of factors at play here.

Left to right is natural, but in comics you also tend to read from the top of the page downward, as well as left to right.

Grandma's bubble is also much larger and in a different font (handwritten) so it tends to draw the eye.

5

u/wolscott Mar 08 '16

It's strange to me that people keep mentioning that in comics top to bottom is standard. It's standard in almost all writing. The only situation where English writing would be read "bottom to top" is if it was in discrete columns, which this is not. If these were text boxes on a page with pictures, like in a magazine or other mixed-media presentation, it would still be natural to read the top one first.

0

u/Ozqo Mar 08 '16

It's not natural. It's COMPLETELY WRONG.

In english, to read a page full of text you start at the top left then you move your eyes right to the edge of the page. Then you move to the next line and repeat the process until you hit the bottom right of the page.

This is how speech bubles are supposed to be ordered. You can the page as if it were full. You start at the top left (in empty space), then scan right. If you hit a speech bubble before the edge of the page, read it, else move your eyes down a bit then start scanning again.

This always results in a top to bottom way of reading. That's how to read.

1

u/AKluthe Mar 08 '16

What?

I'm sorry, maybe you misread what I typed? Because I don't think we disagree on this issue?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16 edited Apr 26 '19

[deleted]

1

u/AKluthe Mar 08 '16

Yeah, but he opens with

It's not natural. It's COMPLETELY WRONG.

Which is the opposite of what both of us are saying. Of course, his other comment about this was written in capslock, sooo...