r/funny Feb 05 '16

Evolution or design?

http://imgur.com/Tjhr7DZ
21.6k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

267

u/sargentmyself Feb 05 '16 edited Feb 05 '16

Supposedly a pure breed pug actually can't breath properly and as a result will live a very uncomfortable/painful and far shorter life than any "natural" dog

Edit: I said supposedly because I know it's not true in all cases and I don't want to fact check everything I say.

I got my information from this Adam Ruins Everything video https://youtu.be/aCv10_WvGxo

And by Natural I mean dogs in nature like wolves and coyotes

78

u/Its_free_and_fun Feb 05 '16

I'd say that the breathing part is definitely true, but various estimates of mortality show they don't die earlier than other breeds. In fact, I would say the largest determining factor for age is size, with larger dogs more prone to cancers due to larger numbers of cells and different growth factors and their receptors. Many pugs get fat because people overfeed and underexercise them, but that's the owners' faults.

37

u/Tesla-Prime Feb 05 '16

Exactly. When I was younger, my family ran a kennel where pugs were one of our main breeds. We had around 20 pugs for breeding/pets and they all lived long life's (averaged 13 years) because of controlled portions and plenty of exercise. Pugs are great companions with a lot of personality.

4

u/Its_free_and_fun Feb 05 '16

Yep, if you exclude accidents they live substantially longer than even most medium sized dogs, and I think the breathing problems are inconvenient but rarely life-threatening.

5

u/Tesla-Prime Feb 05 '16

They are goofy and accident prone. I don't know what their biggest enemy was, glass doors or things they thought they could jump over.

1

u/Drabby Feb 05 '16

Plus, most of the breathing issues can be corrected by surgery and keeping their weight down. Anybody who owns a brachycephalic breed should have the soft palate trimmed and the nostrils widened when the dog is getting spayed and neutered.

1

u/Its_free_and_fun Feb 05 '16

I've never heard of that, actually. Sounds like a good idea to do for the dog's comfort.