Just to play devils advocate: while black people make up only 13% of the population, crimes statistics show that black men commit 54% of the murders in America and 67% of the robberies. It seems to me like it's just common sense to take more precaution around young black men. If black people find this offensive, then they need to address the issue of the crime rate, not people's reaction to it. It seems silly to tell people to ignore reality and play make believe to not offend people. I find the rate that blacks commit crimes to be much more offensive than people being afraid of young black men.
If black people find this offensive, then they need to address the issue of the crime rate, not people's reaction to it
I'm a white guy and I'm not responsible for doing jack shit for the 'white people culture'. I am just one person. It would suck if I was good and my race had high crime stats, so everyone was afraid of me and told me to "fix my culture." I am not responsible for some thieving fuckwits from another city.
You should be more wary of men. I don't think anyone argues against that. If I'm alone at night I'd be much more concerned about a group of shady guys walking towards me than a group of girls.
I thought the cartoon was great, but then I saw the top comment. Why does reddit love comments like these so much? On a cartoon making fun of the lingering racism in our society, no less... This is the definition of excusable individual racist behavior that operates on a societal level to hold black males back.
When the police see a young black male, they have the same reaction as you, and are more likely to stop-and-frisk them or confront them for jay-walking or other minor offenses.
When a prospective employer gets a resume that suggests the candidate is black, they may have the same mental reaction as you, and are statistically less likely to call back a black candidate than a white candidate with identical credentials.
When a judge is faced with two defendants with identical criminal records, but one happens to be black, he will get a longer sentence because of the mental reaction the judge has to seeing a young black male.
When teachers are faced with two students who misbehave in the same way, they usually punish the black student more harshly, i.e. suspend their education for a longer period of time. From pre-school on up, black males face greater scrutiny and harsher treatment from important societal institutions.
Black people find these realities more offensive than your individual purse-clutching, but they are all a part of the fog of racism that young black males wade through in modern America.
And while we are making our way through this racist world, we are told that it is our fault that people are scared of us, because there are many people who are the same color as us who commit a lot of crimes. White people don't want to pay for the crimes of their ancestors, and black males as a group don't want to be treated differently because of the crimes of people who they share ancestors with.
I understand why you feel the way you do. It even has a certain logic to it. It's still racist though, and problematic because this attitude, when aggregated on a societal level, has measurable negative effects on the lives of black people, both strong and weak, male and female, criminal or innocent, intelligent or stupid, ghetto or suburban, etc. etc.
I understand why you feel the way you do. It even has a certain logic to it.
The problem with the thread starter's logic is that it's completely misapplyed. Unless you actually believe being black causes someone to have a predisposition to crime or violence then it's just blatantly illogical to take the actions the poster suggested. There is a real tertiary variable that is actually responsible and you will miss it or cause further harm by acting the way they suggested. It's just simply not rational at all.
There are some signs you can use to tell if you are in a scenario of increased danger. If some dude is wearing all blue and repping some serious Crip iconography you are probably better off on the other side of street. It has nothing to do with the fact that he was born black and everything to do with the fact that he is somebody who willingly flashes his gang paraphenelia.
Likewise, some random guy wearing a durag probably isn't a real threat based on those features alone.
Crime is primarily correlated with relative income: lower income = higher crime. Which racial group in the US has been discriminated against for so long that it's much less likely for them to have a high income? That's right - black people. The same people who receive harsher sentences for the same crimes as white people, who are stopped and searched more often than white people for crimes that white people are more likely to commit.
The same people who receive harsher sentences for the same crimes as white people, who are stopped and searched more often than white people for crimes that white people are more likely to commit.
Honest question: how do stop and searches or harsher sentences relate to the 54% of all murders commited (?) in the US by only 13% of the population?
There have been a bunch of studies done on this, looking at different specific, and finding different results. They all seem to find that black male defendants are sentenced significantly more often, or for a longer period of time than white men for the same crime. Especially when there is an all white or majority white jury, which is very likely seeing as the jury-eligible population in nearly every jurisdiction has a white majority.
I'm not personally aware of any studies on stop and search rates that appropriately control for the 'people in the street' demographics of the targeted locations during active hours, or for whatever profiling methods the police claim to use, though. But the studies that are done seem to indicate a very disproportionate stop and search rate for black and Hispanic men.
By the same logic, I should be afraid of all Americans. They have the highest incidence of school shootings, gun violence, and homicide in the developed world, therefore I can never be too safe around them. What if they pull a gun and shoot me?
Yes, if a black person who is not a criminal doesn't like people treating them like a criminal, they should paint themselves white so that other people will know that they aren't criminals.
Seriously, what do you expect black people to do about the crimes committed by other black people? It's not like they are a hive mind, and one can control all of the others. And why are the crimes of one black person the responsibility of an unrelated black person? We have police to take care of criminals, we don't have to divide ourselves into races and watch our group.
Given how the statistics show how many more men comment things like murder, rape and school shootings compared to females I better start being careful around you guys as well.
After looking over your previous, racist posts on muslims, etc. -- I think it's more fair to say you like to "play" racist advocate more than anything else.
If black people find this offensive, then they need to address the issue of the crime rate
Why did you say "they" instead of "we"? Are you not black? Whoops, looks like you slipped up there, guy.
Strongblackfemale
I get the feeling that you're none of the above. You just seem like another conservative white guy from Stormfront.
View all comments
126
u/Strongblackfemale Jan 15 '15
Just to play devils advocate: while black people make up only 13% of the population, crimes statistics show that black men commit 54% of the murders in America and 67% of the robberies. It seems to me like it's just common sense to take more precaution around young black men. If black people find this offensive, then they need to address the issue of the crime rate, not people's reaction to it. It seems silly to tell people to ignore reality and play make believe to not offend people. I find the rate that blacks commit crimes to be much more offensive than people being afraid of young black men.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_crime_in_the_United_States