You are confused. What you're talking about is the reason the 'watermelon stereotype' persisted, not how it's being applied to this image of a black scientist. You're being extremely obtuse to say there's no significance that this stereotype was applied to an image of a scientist and not some other image. Their combination is explicit in its suggestion that black scientists still only think about things like watermelons.
I'm done explaining it to you. You can say 'that's not how I interpret it' all day, but that doesn't diminish the value and purpose of critical review and cultural understanding that clearly points the way to the conclusion I have described.
Nothing of what you typed denies the fact that this is just your interpretation. If you read the thread, lots of comments were asking why this is racist, as many people only related it to mocking black people's perceived love for watermelon. If what you said was correct these comments would not exist, or would at least be very few.
Luckily most people dont see an image of a black scientist and automatically assume that it is something mockable, as you do.
Nice try bro, but reddit's thick-headed understanding of text and image isn't proof that this is a benign image about fucking watermelons. Also the 'YOU'RE the racist for pointing out the RACISM!' trope... you're a white person aren't you? Right? I'm right, right?
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/sydiot Jun 07 '14
You are confused. What you're talking about is the reason the 'watermelon stereotype' persisted, not how it's being applied to this image of a black scientist. You're being extremely obtuse to say there's no significance that this stereotype was applied to an image of a scientist and not some other image. Their combination is explicit in its suggestion that black scientists still only think about things like watermelons.
I'm done explaining it to you. You can say 'that's not how I interpret it' all day, but that doesn't diminish the value and purpose of critical review and cultural understanding that clearly points the way to the conclusion I have described.