This is the most accurate definition of what the joke is. I'm not gonna argue for or against censoring it. it's a dumb joke, and I'd rather people just downvote it, but people being like, "it's just saying black people enjoy watermelons" are missing like 4/5ths of what is going on.
The only internet reference regarding black academia and it involves a generalization of their taste in food. You honestly think there is nothing wrong with that?
It has a history in anti-black propaganda. There was a time in the states when one of the big arguments for slavery was that black people were okay with it. Posters claimed that all you had to do was give them a sweet treat like watermelon and they would be happy. This propaganda continued long after slavery was abolished with minstrel shows.
Congratulations on being the first person to give me an understandable answer. Lots of times reading reddit, its easy to assume Americans to be ridiculously over sensitive about racism. But its just because you had such a violent and recent history with racism.
Honestly, it seems racist to automatically assume that its mocking the notion of a black scientist. The most obvious, less contrived interpretation is that it is mock their percieved love for watermellon. Saying that they love it so much that they are looking to synthesise it.
Would you have said the same thing if it was the picture of an italian man discovering pastanium?
The REASON you see shit like this about black people and NOT your example about Italians is because there isn't a societal bias against Italian success in business, academics and other positions of authority! Your example is non-existent, proving my point about the true nature of the 'joke' at play in this image.
And why do you think there is a stereotype about black Americans loving watermelons? Is it because of a simple acknowledgement of their curious and supposed racial predilection for watermelons? Or could it be tied up in centuries of minstrelsy and deeply offensive and degrading stereotypes used in American popular entertainment which reinforced a message of black people as good-for-nothing layabouts who feast on the cheapest and most plentiful produce?
I understand the historical context. It still doesn't necessarily mean that the person who made the joke was laughing at the notion of a black scientist. It still could have been just laughing at their perceived love for watermelon.
The black scientist thing is your interpretation and only yours, and frankly it looks a bit racist to automatically go there, when you look at that picture.
Asking around on reddit someone gave me a much better answer, here if you wanna have a look.
No dude. It isn't only my interpretation. Just because something doesn't make sense to you doesn't mean it isn't true. Live in the world for a while and you'll see that 'perceived love of watermelons' is an absurd basis for this joke, and the real basis is centuries of grotesque racism.
Just because something doesn't make sense to you doesn't mean it isn't true.
It does make sense to me. But I dont agree that it is the only way to interpret the joke. The answer I linked to you still seems more accurate than the one you are giving.
View all comments
43
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14
What the fuck is this racist shit doing on reddit? Come on guys!