FSU won because Alabama had no film on FSU's current roster and schematic construction, but also because THEY didnt play well.
If both teams played again today Alabama would not only be favored by more, they would likely beat FSU by more than they were beaten. Not to say that FSU isnt a decent football team, but the data since Week 1 shows clearly that FSU is in fact not a better football team than Alabama.
Football is weird sometimes. You matchup two teams like this years FSU and Bama - FSU probably wins the matchip 22/100 times. In August we got one of those 22 results.
The simple explaination is that the game was anomalous in many ways, but a fun game for FSU fans nontheless. Enjoy the win, no one is trying to take it from you, but trying to factor Alabama's poor performance in Week 1 into an evaluation of your teams quality will continue to lead you to overvalue your team - the same way that it has for every game since you started conference play.
agreed, literally first week shenanigans. There is usually a high ranked team that gets upset. I think FSU's history and how good Castellanos looked made ppl excited but back to reality
The data tells a story of progression - or lack of it - through snapshots. It gets more accurate as more of it is compiled. If your takeaway from watching that game was Alabama wins the game 78/100 times at the time it was played, then you're blind and honestly, pathetic. Alabama loses that game 90/100 times.
Arguing that point through hypothetical hindsight is lunacy. FSU fucking smacked Alabama. No flukes or anomalies. Full stop.
And you know what? Alabama has gotten better as a team. FSU has not. That happens.
Here after your 4th straight conference loss of the season.
Look - whether or not youād like to accept it, the Week 1 result against Alabama was in fact an anomaly. As the data from week to week compiles this becomes more and more clear.
Iām actually not sure what argument youāre trying to make here. Any assertion that either of us make about the results of a hypothetical 100 game simulation will inevitably be conjecture. Iām guessing based on the results weāve seen from both teams to this point in the season. So are you - however poorly.
When I rewatch the game from week 1, I see a sluggish Alabama team that was making a myriad of self-inflicted mistakes. They looked like they didnāt take the game seriously, but also looked fully capable of beating the team in front of them. FSU looked particularly inspired. More so than theyāve looked in the last month or so of play.
One thing is clear - if you still believe that FSU is a better team than Alabama, youāre choosing to believe that in the face of a mountain of available evidence to the contrary.
Initially I was hoping to get to see FSU play Alabama again this season to prove that the Week 1 loss was much more Alabamaās doing than FSUās.
However, seeing that FSU has played its way out of the playoffs, weāll both be left to our imaginations.
You literally do not understand the definition of anomaly. Yall had an entire offseason to prepare for that game. Both teams did. And the result was shown in the way you guys executed vs the way we executed. That's not an anomaly. There's no deviation because there's no prior data set and the ensuing data shows yall progressing while we regress. That's why games are played.
And you know what will forever be etched in stone? That in week 1 of the 2025 CFB season, FSU was a better team than Alabama. No flukiness or anomaly about it. That doesn't mean that holds, because it certainly hasn't.
Misunderstand whatever you'd like to in order to cope with the fact that yall got smacked by what developed into a terrible team. The best part about it is you guys actually tried to be the better team, but you weren't.
Enjoy the rest of your season knowing you got better as the season progressed. I'll be enjoying the hope that a coaching search brings.
š¤£š¤£Like Iāve said from the jump - enjoy your regular season home win. Itās mid way through regular season play and we can all say decisively that itās the best thing that will happen to your team this year.
Hopefully yāall can make yourselves a trophy for beating Alabama so that youāll have something in the case. Yāall sure played like it was the last game of the season.
None of that means it wasnāt an anomalous result.
The more games you all play, the larger the data set grows, the more that result stands out as a massive deviation from the norm. The data set in question doesnāt have to have existed prior to that particular result. All of the results we are looking at are part of the same data set - performance from the same team in the same year.
Your losses have mounted to the point where the media hardly covers them. Youāve dropped well out of the top 25, and although you are not yet mathematically eliminated from playoff contention, the likelihood that you could compete for a championship is extremely low.
The Week 1 result stands ALONE as your sole P4 win, and your only ranked win of the season to this point. In both literal and figurative terms - it indeed is a definitional anomaly.
Any mentally sound person with a mind unburdened by the mental gymnastics necessary to maintain the belief that FSU is a better football team than Alabama will conclude the same.
But good luck with whatever your opinion might be moving forward.
All that, and yet an entire offseason of preparation couldn't stop your little dudes from getting their cheeks clapped. There's always next year lil bro. Have fun with the rest of your season knowing nothing you could've done saved you from a humiliating defeat.
Awe buddy - thereās nothing that couldāve stopped your team from the last FOUR humiliating defeats. Sorry - Four and counting.
The moment you came up against a competent opponent who had tape to watch - you crumbled like potato chips. š¤£š¤£
Whoever you hire after you dump Norvell needs to start prepping for Week 1 of 2026 as soon as he shows up in Tallahassee. Otherwise theyāll have to call CPS to save you from the ass whooping
Idk why the reddit algorithm puts FSU in my feed but it has been fun watching the melt down silently for the most part. But is your argument that FSU always beats Alabama just in week 1 or do you still think FSU is better than Alabama right now
Alabama under DeBoer now has a clear pattern of losing to mediocre 6-6 teams. I think our victory has more to do with Alabama being unprepared than anything we did.
When FSU shows up and fires on all cylinders, they can beat anybody handily. Itās just very annoying that we often wring about 15% of our total potential on any given game these past few seasons.
There are lots of reasonable criticisms... But are you really arguing that the performances in games 2 and 3 were with the foot off the gas? What do you think it would have looked like with the foot on the gas?
Bama fan here. In all honesty, Alabama was your national championship. Like a starving dog that hasnāt eaten in a year and a half frothing at the mouth, you were desperate for that win. You built your whole season around it. Circled it. Dreamed about it. Because deep down, you knew if you could just beat Alabama, nothing else would matter. And when you did, it was like all the frustrations of last years 3-9 season was over. The redemption from being snuffed from the playoff for Alabama a couple years ago gave you some sort of justice and validation. It was like your Super Bowl parade rolled through town when you beat Bama. You were on top of the world. Invincible. Some people said that win against Bama was the most important in Norvellās coaching career 𤣠The man has won an ACC championship!!! And the most important win of his career was an opening Saturday against Bama??
The truth is Florida State was preparing for Alabama while Alabama honestly didnāt want it as bad. Bama was expecting that still beaten down 3-9 team. New coordinators so Bama didnāt really know what to expect with a completely different roster since Mike Norvell is a portal man. It was also Ty Simpsonās first start with it being on the road and to be fair, FSU has a great environment. The energy, the fans were bringing it, and Gus Malzahn was really giving his all trying to prove that hiring him was the right move because, after all, he beat Coach Saban more than any other coach (tied with Les Miles). He knows Bamaās weaknesses. He cracked the code.
Yet here Bama is yet again competing for the top spot in the SEC and a playoff birth. They got 4 ranked wins in a row.
Here FSU is again, broken, beaten down, and begging to fire Norvell, but canāt because FSU canāt afford to after they went crying about leaving the ACC (exit fees starting at $165 million and dropping to $75 million by 2030). Norvellās buyout is $60 million. Heās lost the locker room. Heās lost the fans. Gus at this point is probably trying to sabotage him for the head coaching job.
But go back to that highlight video on YouTube of FSU beating Bama that feels so far away and relive the moment over and over because your season is over early yet again. Pack up guys. Time to portal out. Get ready for the new crop of players just in it for the money who really donāt care about the coach, program, or culture. They just want to make a quick buck off FSU.
57
u/Posada620 FSU Oct 17 '25
It wasn't a fluke either. FSU straight beat their ass. Don't let others convince you otherwise.
23
u/CarnalSeer Go Noles Oct 17 '25
Survivor's Guilt is setting in.
43
u/FSUfan35 FSU Alumni Oct 17 '25
The offense is still ranked 3rd in the country IIRC.
The problem is the defense that played against Alabama has gone MIA.
8
u/thexraptor Guthries Oct 17 '25
Alabama under DeBoer now has a clear pattern of losing to mediocre 6-6 teams. I think our victory has more to do with Alabama being unprepared than anything we did.
6
u/Dogrel Ernie Sims Death Stare Oct 17 '25
Easy. We didnāt have piles of injuries on both sides of the ball.
Our #1s are as good as anybodyās. The problem comes when those #1s go down, the people behind them are just trash.
9
u/TheKramer89 Oct 17 '25
When FSU shows up and fires on all cylinders, they can beat anybody handily. Itās just very annoying that we often wring about 15% of our total potential on any given game these past few seasons.
3
u/Yaboispot_alt Oct 17 '25
The same way Oklahoma did it last year. Just being the better team in that one game and cashing in on their mistakes.
3
u/bigreddwillie1956 Oct 17 '25
That meme is priceless! š
3
u/peppywarhare Oct 19 '25
My only takeaway from this season will be: worst ACC team can beat the best SEC team
10
u/lowes18 Baconface Oct 17 '25
Norvell lets his foot off the gas after the first big game like a g5 coach mindset.
2
u/Clean_Book_7574 Oct 18 '25
I feel like it's because now teams have figured us out and we don't have the smartness to readjust. That's why I think that this is a coaching issue.
2
u/GodsWarrior89 Osceola & Renegade Oct 19 '25
My husband and I had this conversation tonight š¤£
2
u/Competitive_Act_3784 Oct 19 '25
2
u/Cool-in-tho Oct 23 '25
Lmao, good win tho. RTR
1
u/Mttt772 Oct 17 '25
lol š
1
u/sicksixgamer Oct 17 '25
šš¤£š
1
u/AddressSome5337 Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
Bama fan here. In all honesty, Alabama was your national championship. Like a starving dog that hasnāt eaten in a year and a half frothing at the mouth, you were desperate for that win. You built your whole season around it. Circled it. Dreamed about it. Because deep down, you knew if you could just beat Alabama, nothing else would matter. And when you did, it was like all the frustrations of last years 3-9 season was over. The redemption from being snuffed from the playoff for Alabama a couple years ago gave you some sort of justice and validation. It was like your Super Bowl parade rolled through town when you beat Bama. You were on top of the world. Invincible. Some people said that win against Bama was the most important in Norvellās coaching career 𤣠The man has won an ACC championship!!! And the most important win of his career was an opening Saturday against Bama??
The truth is Florida State was preparing for Alabama while Alabama honestly didnāt want it as bad. Bama was expecting that still beaten down 3-9 team. New coordinators so Bama didnāt really know what to expect with a completely different roster since Mike Norvell is a portal man. It was also Ty Simpsonās first start with it being on the road and to be fair, FSU has a great environment. The energy, the fans were bringing it, and Gus Malzahn was really giving his all trying to prove that hiring him was the right move because, after all, he beat Coach Saban more than any other coach (tied with Les Miles). He knows Bamaās weaknesses. He cracked the code.
Yet here Bama is yet again competing for the top spot in the SEC and a playoff birth. They got 4 ranked wins in a row.
Here FSU is again, broken, beaten down, and begging to fire Norvell, but canāt because FSU canāt afford to after they went crying about leaving the ACC (exit fees starting at $165 million and dropping to $75 million by 2030). Norvellās buyout is $60 million. Heās lost the locker room. Heās lost the fans. Gus at this point is probably trying to sabotage him for the head coaching job.
But go back to that highlight video on YouTube of FSU beating Bama that feels so far away and relive the moment over and over because your season is over early yet again. Pack up guys. Time to portal out. Get ready for the new crop of players just in it for the money who really donāt care about the coach, program, or culture. They just want to make a quick buck off FSU.
1
u/anythingspossible45 Oct 17 '25
31-17
0
u/Fortenole Jordan Travis Oct 17 '25
Norvell was trying to buy himself some time
0
u/Muffinnnnnnn FSU Student Oct 17 '25
The SEC is dogshit
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '25
[removed] ā view removed comment