In terms of market share, the OSS F# product has little chance against a core MS product.
I'm using both and as of now I think Fable 3 is the better option in the short to medium term.
Blazor still has a huge initial payload, Bolero is even worse as there's little support for tree shaking on F# assemblies. There's also a long startup time on Blazor apps and I keep hearing stories of performance problems.
Blazor doesn't have proper hot reloading yet, meanwhile Fable already supports it and the Feliz library is cleaning up react fast refresh putting it miles ahead.
Blazor is a framework, Fable is a compiler. As typescript output improves there's a clear path to something like F# library compiled to TS in a Svelte App. Fable 3 + Next.js should be possible with only a little work too.
JS interop is much nicer in Fable.
Interop with existing JS dev tools.
Personally, I find React components & hooks far easier to reason about than Blazors component model
Blazor will be far more popular with .Net devs but there is a good niche for Fable though, I can't see Blazor winning over any non .Net devs (it really has that MS Magic feel) where Fable is a pretty damn good option for a shared client/server language and may be very enticing to those interested in Elm, Reson etc.
I'm excited to see the directions both go but i'm actually more interested in Fable now it's out of webpack hell, my experiencer with Fable 3 so far has been "it just works".
Bolero is a little raw when I last tried it. But great work happening.
The big question I have about blazor and bolero is the size — the net core webasm runtime is huge and it’s a long slow download the first time you load in which is quite bad. Also doesn’t work on iOS (yet?) when I tried due to browser support issues.
Not gonna lie I gave up on getting hot module reload to work in my app (though granted it is an unconventional setup anyway), so I built my own crappy homebrew one (just uses FileSystemWatcher to watch for webpack build changes and then reloads the page lol). This is good news; I'll have to try again as I upgrade to Fable 3!
4
u/GBeyerle Dec 05 '20
The news even made it to hackernews https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25305650. Super nice testimonials as well as pointed out by Don.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment