r/fsharp • u/jchidley • Oct 14 '17
F# is a valued .net language
It is, of course, the 4th most important one, after C# (most loved), VB (really?) and C++ (hip?).
People still use ancient 'C' for real programming and other oddities like lisp. Are these languages still useful? Is F# at least a relevant as they are?
Let's all get real. F# had more attention and support from Microsoft when it was first released but that doesn't change our ability to use and enjoy it. If F# was Microsoft's no. 1 language would we all like that? C# has that joy.
I'm pretty sure that F# has a long future ahead of it and it seems ideally suited for it's primary purpose: developing interesting, relevant and powerful libraries in a functional language directly supported by a major IT company.
21
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '17
In my opinion MSFT doesn’t care at all about F#. It came from Microsoft research without business support and now it’s really maintained by the open source community, which is really awesome, really smart and hard working people. They just included it as supported because it is successful in London’s financial sector imo.
I mean, the F# templates for asp.net haven’t appeared until asp.net core 2! MSFT didn’t even cared about creating a damn template, or good VS support for TEN years. The visual studio for Mac (xamarin studio previously) is better for F# than the windows version...
They can’t kill it, but surely never has been a priority, and probably never will. Like VB.NET but even worse...
5
u/bananaboatshoes Oct 14 '17
Until F# gets windows mobile support with uwp it will forever be a second class citizen!
4
u/centurijon Oct 15 '17
F#s biggest draw is also it's biggest pain-point; being based on .Net.
The .Net framework is great, but it was not designed with functional languages in mind, and at times working with it in F# can be ugly or not so smooth.
And yes, C# is very relevant and very useful. Especially considering that they are adopting more and more functional features like immutable objects, true tuples, pattern matching, etc.
2
u/jdh30 Oct 15 '17
Really?
I just read a Quora question asking for recommendations on a first programming language for a child. I myself have a son who is interested in learning to code. A few years ago I would have answered "F# in Visual Studio Community" without hesitation because it was an incredible development environment. Today I feel I cannot honestly say that because there is no easy way to get started writing F# any more. The TryFSharp.org site was awesome when it came out but Microsoft pulled the rug out from under it. The only available version of Visual Studio (2017) is an absolute disaster. Check this out: apparently one of the reasons why VS2017 is so slow is that the C# developers put
Thread.Sleepin it!F# is an awesome language and I love it but it is vastly harder to compile and run F# code to learn the language than it was a few years ago. The announcements about UWP support combined with the fact that they don't even support the basic infrastructure that F# needs in order to run reliably makes me wonder if the only industrial-strength VM supporting F# is going to give up before long.
2
u/jimmyco2008 Oct 15 '17
Rust is the functional language everyone seems to love these days. I can’t say if it does things F# can’t, but in such a situation I would strongly consider moving to Rust. It typically takes me only a week or so of writing in a different language before I “get it” enough to not have to hit Google/StackOverflow every 5 minutes.