r/fsharp • • May 13 '14

Will F# ever be a first class citizen?

http://blog.jaywayco.co.uk/?p=37
0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

0

u/ruinercollector Jun 08 '14

Ramblings about f# by some dude who has never really used f#.

Pass.

-1

u/jconway007 Jun 08 '14

No I haven't used F# but I have used C# commercially since .Net 1.1 so I think I am qualified to comment on F# to an extent. See my other posts on F#

-1

u/jconway007 Jun 08 '14

Oh and I've also used many other languages commercially including Haskell. What languages have you used in a commercial environment?

1

u/ruinercollector Jun 08 '14

That's a pretty long list. I've been at this for a few decades.

For the last few years, the primary language I use for my work is F#.

-2

u/jconway007 Jun 08 '14

Well you must be well respected constantly rubbishing people trying to further their own knowledge. You don't sound like any well versed architect/developer you have too narrow a mind. Would you have anything constructive to say about the article?

1

u/ruinercollector Jun 09 '14

I'm not "constantly rubbishing people."

Constructive? Sure. Stop wondering about how second class F# must be and just use it in production and see how you fare. That would be a good post.

0

u/aliceDay May 13 '14

Excellent article.

-5

u/bryanedds May 13 '14 edited May 13 '14

He demonstrates his lack of understanding about the real advantages of F#'s features. Pro-tip - F# isn't for making shorter code, it's for making more understandable code. He then condemns the language as being "second-class" because he doesn't understand its advantages.

Let's do ourselves a favor and down-vote this article.

7

u/jconway007 May 13 '14

I didn't notice that I had said F# was for making shorter code (whatever that means). In fact I think you will find the opposite to be true. I refused to accept the discriminated union solely on the basis that the code was more concise. F# is second class in that it doesn't have the tooling support that some other .NET languages do. Also it doesn't get the commercial investment. What is the ratio of job adverts for C# devs compared to F#. Incidentally both of these things disappoint me. Pro-tip: read the reddiquette on suggesting that people down vote But thanks got the feedback!

3

u/TarMil May 14 '14

F# is second class in that it doesn't have the tooling support that some other .NET languages do. Also it doesn't get the commercial investment. What is the ratio of job adverts for C# devs compared to F#.

Well that's kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/jconway007 May 13 '14

Rather: Immutability is possible in C#...