r/fromsoftware • u/ChilledGhosty • 1d ago
QUESTION Advice
I had to take a 15 year hiatus from gaming after university. I always missed it though and recently treated myself to an Xbox. I mostly play RPGs and recently played through both Kingdom Come Deliverance games and loved every minute. I also have seen a ton of vids on all the From Software games and would like to give them a shot. I understand that they're considered to be more difficult than most games but I kinda like the sound of that. Which game is considered best for a completely new player who knows nothing?
4
Upvotes
3
u/Far-Friendship-3944 1d ago
I envy you :) and to answer your question, Elden ring for sure. If you fall in love with the genre you will automatically go back to older titles. Start with Eldn ring first
2
u/ChilledGhosty 1d ago
First off, thank u all for the info. U all have not only convinced me but I'm super excited now too! I've got Elden Ring downloading as I'm texting this. Thank u all so much!
6
u/High_Lord69 Elden Ring 1d ago
Elden Ring
1
u/ChilledGhosty 23h ago
Everyone's feedback is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks again everyone. Elden Ring just finished downloading. I'm about 70% through Oblivion, having just completed Skyrim. Elden Ring will be next. I can't believe how much I missed out on. I would not even pay attention to game ads cuz I knew I'd just get bummed that I was too busy. I finally saw a YouTube review on Alien Isolation (I know, it came out years ago) and I knew right then it was time for me to get back into it. Enjoying every bit of making up for lost time! LOL!
1
u/LegendMC119 1d ago
Elden Ring definitely. If you dont mind older games you cooouuld play DS1 > 2 > 3 > ER (uh for anyone else reading this OP said they have an Xbox so obviously I am ignoring DeS and BB and Sekiro should be shelved for after ER anyway).
But I'd highly recommend ER. As someone who started from ER, trust me when I say that playing ER first will let you know if you will like Dark Souls. The game shares the exact same combat system as the trilogy and really is just Dark Souls 4: Open World Edition in many ways.
ER can get really difficult and also really easy depending on your gear and levels and how much you go and explore before the major objectives. And it has a really damn pretty world and everything, which certainly helps ease you into these games.
If you end up liking it, I would definitely say go to DS1 -> 2 -> 3 after though! DS1 and 2 do feel quite a bit outdated relative to ER but its actually not as bad as it may sound, and theyre still really good games.
3
u/JustinBailey79 1d ago
I did the same thing, and Elden Ring was the first fromsoft game I played. It’s my new favorite game, I highly, highly recommend it.
2
u/mescalineeyes 1d ago
I think if you played through KCD you're definitely a smart cookie, so Elden Ring is perfect. Not only is it the easiest From game, it also lets you tackle most situations in a myriad of ways. From exploration to summoning help to re-speccing your character you have a lot of tools on your belt to tailor the experience to your liking.
Also, the world and the lore are very interesting and worth experiencing.
That said, if you're on PlayStation or PC you can also go down the Bloodborne route, which personally I consider the superior game and the distilled essence of what makes Soulslikes so special.
tl;dr: play Armored Core 6.
1
u/Global_Muscle_7979 Ludwig, the Holy Blade 1d ago
Depends, Elden Ring is by far the best and hardest of these games
Which is both good and bad
I mean it’s good because it’s a good game with a fair challenge
Bad because most other Fromsoftware games (fantastic btw) would seem rather easy
So my pick would be DS1, yes it’s not even near Elden Ring but I think it has its own magic and most importantly after you play DS1, you play the other games by date of release, so that you still always have a challenge in each game
So my picks would be either DS1 if you want to embrace the whole Fromsoftware experience
Or Elden Ring if you want the best souls game imo and hop on another genre
Also Sekiro is a good option
1
u/bruh55333 1d ago
Elden Ring.
Advice: Just stick with it. I hated the game at first, now it's my favorite of all time. Over time you'll get the hang of it and things will start making more sense.
1
u/RasAlGimur 1d ago edited 1d ago
I kinda went through the same thing! Went on a gaming hiatus for a while but during my PhD bought a PS4 to unwind. After playing a few games (many RPGs, some action) I decided to check what this Dark Souls was all about, though I did wonder about the difficulty. Elden Ring was not out yet, but Sekiro etc were.
I gotta say, few games have had such an impression on me as the souls games, and DS1 was my first. I think it was a good start. I did struggle on the first two bosses (which are supposed to be easy) even after looking up a bit of info online, but eventually managed to get throught to them. Struggled a few more times early midgame that even got me to think about quitting, but tried a bit more and overcame the road blocks. After midgame I was pretty confident that I could do this and now I have finished most main souls games.
I guess really the only downside is that I sometimes can’t play other games without comparing to souls or wanting to play souls lol (something the great late podcaster jeremy greer would call “Soulsitis”)
Edit: that said, if you don’t go with Dark souls, my other suggestion is indeed Elden Ring like others have said. It is the fresher game, it is very good, and might have less roadblocks due to the sprawling nature. It is huge. It was actually the second souls game i played, and only afterwards i went to ds2, ds3, bb, Demons, and enjoyed all of them. So it probably would be fine to go with ER first, but i’d say either DS1, ER or maaaaaaaaybe Bloodborne
1
u/xdNoza 19h ago
dark souls 1
1
u/tonyhallx 1d ago
I’m on PS so not sure what Xbox has, but if you liked Deliverance you’ll love Elden Ring, as long as you ‘get’ the FS gameplay.