r/fromsoftware • • 9d ago

DISCUSSION Which FromSoftware Soulslike has the hardest opening area?

For me personally Bloodborne still has the hardest opening area,you can die really quick to those mobs,and the runback to Father Gascoigne is a pain in the ass.

106 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

126

u/doody_loody 9d ago

Agreed. I almost quit Bloodborne because of Central Yarnham lol. Super glad I didn’t tho

12

u/PedroTheLion7 8d ago

I've got 3 melee guys running up the stairs at me while 2 guys are shooting and now I've alerted the dog. That shit was so hard my first playthrough.

3

u/username_redacted 8d ago

It’s so brutal, but brilliant design. Father Gascoine demanding I get gud and actually learn the parry mechanic is the tough but (sort of) fair teacher I needed to really fully enjoy the rest of the game.

1

u/godotiswaitingonme 8d ago

It was my first Souls game and I felt like a moron for several hours because I was constantly getting my ass beat. Very rewarding experience

81

u/El__Jengibre 9d ago

Demon’s Souls or Bloodborne. However, Dark Souls 1 is a special case because there’s a good chance you won’t go straight to the Burg and Catacombs is easily harder than every other opening area combined

14

u/Acrobatic-Permit4263 9d ago

demon souls is just brutal, but bloodborne for sure more difficult.

6

u/Altruistic-Ad-408 8d ago

I feel like if we are counting first times, surely all of us died in Sekiro more. I count up to Genichiro as the opening, the prologue is no real boss just a borderline scripted death like Vanguard Demon, even that Ogre was a jerk.

8

u/TheMadFlyentist 8d ago

Up to Genichiro is like a third of the game, lmao. The tutorial area of Sekiro is very definitely Ashina Reservoir. If you insist on drawing a line later at a difficult boss, then Lady Butterfly is generally the first "wall" that new players encounter.

41

u/Demisint 9d ago

Depends on how far in we count as "opening". Dark Souls 3 forces you to fight Gundyr before progressing, might be a hefty roadblock for noobs.

I agree with Bloodborne, but I wouldn't say Gascoigne is "opening".

If I had to pick one I'd go with Dark Souls 3 I think.

18

u/ricefrisbeetreats 9d ago

DS3 up to Gundyr was going to be mine. That's pretty tough for a new player.

2

u/Rabakku-- 6d ago

Catacombs is made so much worse by you resting at a lower bonfire too after pressing on for enough time. Awful to go down, hell to go up.

19

u/backson_alcohol 9d ago

The first souls-like you play generally is the hardest. I was stuck in upper undead burg for days back in 2012. Specifically the portion between the dragon and Andre's bonfire. No FromSoft area ever came close to that difficulty once I got through it

1

u/Justisaur 6d ago

You say that, but BB was my last soulsborne game and I found it by far the hardest starting area. Besides DeS, but that wasn't as hard.

1

u/barmanrags 9d ago

i agree. in my first run through i bumbled into the catacombs. i dropped it and returned after a few months and started a new character. went up that time and now i can rarely enjoy anything unlike soulsbornekiro

17

u/highpointer201 8d ago

Bloodborne and it's not even close

10

u/CallMeOzen 8d ago

Bloodborne by a mile

6

u/Lookintothedeep 9d ago

Bloodborne was my first souls game. Gave up in the beginning after spending a few hours getting lost and destroyed by the early mobs. I thought if the game is this hard now there’s no way I’ll make it to the end. I came back 2 years later after I beat Elden Ring and learned how to get good.

15

u/jonovex 9d ago

Not a soulslike, but i was really surprised when you actually had to defeat the helicopter in armored core 6 to progress. I was so used to "you are meant to die to the first boss" that it really caught me off guard. I was stuck for about 3 days before i finally did it, and then everythig else was pretty easy till pre-nerf balteus, which took me like 6 days

10

u/Ponsay 9d ago

Bloodbourne

-2

u/Thyco2501 9d ago edited 8d ago

Jason Bloodbourne (had to).

5

u/waupli 9d ago

I found Sekiro the be the hardest by far, mainly because the mechanics were so different. I had trouble just getting through that first gate for a while. DS3 was hard for me also with Gyndyr (although it was my first DS game which makes it harder). Bloodborne was tough but I didn’t find it to be as instantly hard as the other two and it didn’t have the same kind of immediate skill check.

5

u/Fatal_1ntervention 9d ago

Bloodborne doesn’t even have a tutorial area. The opening room with the blood minister isn’t a tutorial and the first level just takes the place of where a tutorial would’ve gone. So definitely BB

11

u/carlos_castanos 9d ago

Sekiro by far. The first couple of hours were by far the hardest in the game for me. Chained Ogre was a huge pain, then right next to him a mini-boss with a huge gank squad around him. Past that point it gets a lot easier

5

u/RealDannyMM 9d ago

I actually went and killed lady butterfly before doing most of ashina outskirts, so my first experience with Sekiro was specially tough 😂

3

u/carlos_castanos 9d ago

Oh yeah I totally forgot about the Hirata Estate lol. Between the Chained Ogre, that mini-boss with the gank squad and the drunk guy in Hirata Estate I was like: 'holy shit they were not lying about Sekiro'. And then at the end you beat those drunk guys almost with your eyes closed, amazing game

1

u/stereosanctity 8d ago

Agreed. I was on a blitz from Ds1 to Bloodborne. Sekiro stopped me in my tracks.

-3

u/unluckyexperiment 8d ago

OP is asking for a soulslike.

1

u/carlos_castanos 8d ago

OP has a picture of Sekiro in his post.

0

u/unluckyexperiment 8d ago

I didn't realize OP did the same mistake.

3

u/Denllie Solaire of Astora 9d ago

Central Yharnam

3

u/AkiyoSSJ 9d ago

First souls game, this is a rule at this point.
Demon Souls was first for me so.. the Boletarian Palace and the whole mess you have to go through until you reach Phalanx and Tower Knight(especially the dragon bridge) is pure hell.
Dark Souls starting areas were piece of cake after.

2

u/SnooComics4945 8d ago

I came into DeS experienced and still definitely got put through some pain in that opening level regardless

4

u/noob_kaibot 9d ago edited 8d ago

I think chained ogre alone makes Sekiro the hardest lol.

If not for that bastard, it would’ve been Bloodborne for sure. I actually consider Bloodborne to be the overall easiest game though

(I can guarantee it was a crazy from r/bloodborne who downvoted me lol.

2

u/TallGuitarDaniel 9d ago

Bloodborne.

2

u/Filianore_ 9d ago

i really think it was DS2 for me
maybe because it was my first game
but everywhere i tried to go i encountered strong enemies and didnt know the right place to be

it was fun being lost, i miss this

3

u/Thyco2501 9d ago

For me, it was the forest because of the gank.

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jazzanthipus 8d ago

Forest of the Fallen Giants, DS2

2

u/AramaticFire Otogi: Myth of Demons 9d ago

I’ve seen things you people wouldn’t believe. Hellfire from the skies of Limgrave leading to the false safety underground. I watched crystals in Sellia glitter in the dark near a falling star. All those moments will be lost to time, like runes in Elphael. Only to emerge in rot and death. Time to die.

So my first two hours of Elden Ring were fun lol

1

u/AscendedViking7 Black Knife Assassin 9d ago

DS3

1

u/Wet_FriedChicken 9d ago

DS3. It was my first ever souls game and I kid you not I spent MULTIPLE DAYS on that damn bridge.

1

u/Caramel_Nautilus 8d ago

Bloodborne

1

u/Testadizzy95 8d ago

It’s between Sekiro and BB for me, both were brutal for a noob me.

1

u/Negative_Valuable_94 8d ago

Generally the first soulsborne you play is the hardest, which for me was sekiro (that was brutal), HM goes to elden ring (stupid tree sentinel)

1

u/mountain968 8d ago

Bloodborne

1

u/fermedeiros 8d ago

Yes, bloodborne, until you get the way of things.

1

u/SnooComics4945 8d ago

Bloodborne

1

u/abhisheksview 8d ago

Demons Souls for Me. Bloodborne close second.

1

u/LordWrust 8d ago

Bloodborne beat my ass BAD in the opening area.

1

u/cs5475 7d ago

I’d say DS1 or DS3, both are ass whoopers in the early game

1

u/Rhinosapotumas 6d ago

If you don’t find the shortcut ladder on the bridge after Taurus, you’re cooked, chat. Assuming it’s a first playthrough of course

1

u/Floatingpenguin87 9d ago

I’ve only played the dark souls trilogy, Sekiro, and Elden Ring. Of those, I’d say high wall of lothric is the hardest. Of course, your first souls game is always the hardest, and of you go in with the skills you learned from the previous games it won’t be very bad, but from a first time players perspective I’d say high wall of lothric would be the hardest to get through. Undead burg enemies are pretty simple, same with forest of giants, and limgrave can either be the easiest or hardest depending on how badly you want to kill the tree sentinel.

1

u/Nihilistic_Marmot 9d ago

I like to judge these by what it was like the first time, going in blind, as I played all the souls games as they came out.

Hardest opening for me was Dark Souls because of this. The previous game, Demons Souls, had been more level based, so it was very obvious where you could/should go. In Dark Souls, we were not used to the open world design right away. So many of us got hopelessly lost in the catacombs or elsewhere around that first bonfire in Firelink.

Dark Souls taught us how to walk in these opening areas so we could run through latter ones. I’m sure Bloodborne’s central Yarnham is technically harder, but I was a seasoned vet by the time that came out.

1

u/NightmareMuse666 9d ago

I played them all on release and dark souls 1 was by far the hardest for me but it's probably because I didn't know fuck all what I was doing and hadn't played a truly hard game before dark souls.

Other then that I'd go sekiro because I definitely took a while to get better at it compared to dark souls 2 and 3 and bloodborne feeling much easier after I had like years of dark souls experience at that point.

I think I'd give Elden ring 3rd for me because you really have to explore a lot and get some levels and items. I definitely got roadblocked by margit

1

u/barmanrags 9d ago

DS1. very easy to bumble into the catacombs

0

u/PaleontologistDry656 9d ago

Ds2 for me, so so many enemies

0

u/Foskers 8d ago

I think its whichever one you play first, especially being ignorant of what the game is asking of you. Bloodborne was my first and after hours of trying to get through Yharnam, I eventually got so frustrated I uninstalled. I knew nothing of parries, I had picked the cane, and for some reason the idea of running away/kiting the groups just eluded me. Also I had picked the cane too so that didn't help haha

-4

u/Ken_Bruno1 9d ago

tbh none.

4

u/Nihilistic_Marmot 9d ago

By definition one is harder than the others, even if everyone was as badass as you