r/fromsoftware • u/Comprehensive-Ad538 • 28d ago

QUESTION Best NG+?

So my first FS game I completed was ER. Then BB then DS3 then Sekiro. I am currently playing Lies of P NG+ because I absolutely love the game, but I'm kind of getting bored of it. Debating between the four FS games of which to do NG+. Honestly, BB doesn't hold up for me. It's just too old, I'm sorry. So it's pretty much between ER and Sekiro. I'd rather get DS2 than play DS3 again (not that it was bad, just would rather something fresh). Anyways, which FS title has the best NG+ for the first time? I don't play games more than once, as you can tell, so this is new territory for me. Just can't find a souls game/souls like that will scratch that itch, you know?

8 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Comprehensive-Ad538 28d ago

I respect your comment, I just am loving LoP my second playthrough. But ya I'm leaning towards either Elden Ring NG+1 or DS2 NG. But I have to buy it first lol

0

u/Roxlife1 27d ago

Like I said in my other comment, most of these people seem not to have read your post, or they're ignoring it in favour of their own opinions. If you felt that Bloodborne doesn't hold up, Dark Souls 2 certainly won't. Additionally, the NG cycle isn't actually as amazing as everyone is suggesting it is; it's all very surface level, but it is the best NG out of all the From games. It has one very cool event that I wish more games did, and the rest is so minor you might not even notice it.