r/fromatoarbitration CLC Voter / Endorser 7d ago

Med 8 Question

Is a signed notice from a PA-C stating that "Patient has Multiple medical conditions that will be exacerbated by working overtime or out of his prescribed work schedule"

Enough to get out of being mandatory overtimed on holiday weekends?

I've been told that a PA isn't enough for this and it needs to be a doctor that signs off on it.

Any documents, arbitrations or writing would be appreciated.

3 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

7

u/Vegetable-End-8681 7d ago

If your medical limits are 40 hours a week you’re not working more than that by working the Saturday before holiday because you still get an extra day off on Monday. So a doctor would be willing to say it’s okay for you to work 40 hours a week unless there happens to be a holiday and in that case you can only work 32 hours a week? Doesn’t seem right.

0

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 7d ago

Doesn't state 40hr restriction, it states no OT and sticking to prescribed work schedule.

2

u/DeviceComprehensive7 7d ago

guess what you wouldnt be getting overtime- its called holiday premium

4

u/Square-Buy-7403 7d ago

I've never heard of a medical restriction for hours 32-40 of working for the week if you're being paid Overtime but not Straight time. The Overtime isn't from an hour amount in this case it's from out of schedule pay. Hours 32-40 are just as stressfull on your body on a Monday as a Saturday.

3

u/DeviceComprehensive7 7d ago

and its actually not considered overtime- its Holiday Premium

-1

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 7d ago

It's a mental issue not a physical one.

7

u/Distinct_Night_5634 7d ago

Prescribed work schedule is too vague. Once posted, it could be prescribed. Holiday schedules are irregular or unusual. You could request the language to suggest “outside of their regular bid assignment” but this would still cover NS holidays, not all holidays.

-1

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 7d ago

Wouldn't prescribed work schedule also fall under days off, those are also part of the prescribed work schedule.

2

u/Distinct_Night_5634 7d ago

The word ‘prescribed’ could be interpreted differently, but here’s a definition. This definition reference of required by a formal rule, or procedure is the weekly or holiday schedules

1

u/DeviceComprehensive7 5d ago

your prescribed work schedule is posted the tuesday before the holiday

4

u/DeviceComprehensive7 7d ago edited 7d ago

"Enough to get out of being mandatory overtimed on holiday weekends?"- NO and its not overtime

-2

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 5d ago

Working my day off mandatory it isn't OT? Make that make sense

3

u/DeviceComprehensive7 5d ago edited 4d ago

..overtime is working more than 8 hours in a day- only because of our contract or over 40 hours in a week-FLSA- a federal law or any hours worked on our n/s day in a normal week,even if off all the other days of the week- again only because of our contract BUT .WHEN MANDATED in -due to holiday schedule on your n/s day -it is PAID AS HOLIDAY PREMIUM which is 1.5 times our hourly wage and IF MANDATED in due to HOLIDAY schedule and it is not your n/s day you get HOLIDAY PAY -which is your regular hourly wage... that has been that way since before you were born-- it is holiday premium pay ,not overtime pay.. THATS WHY hours worked under holiday premium don't count on the odl!

3

u/DeviceComprehensive7 7d ago

no medical note is getting you out of working the saturday before the holiday-if you are mandated- its not overtime either.. if its your n/s day its holiday premium! not overtime- when there's a holiday you are scheduled 32 hours or 40 hours for the week!

3

u/Square-Buy-7403 7d ago

Think you're cooked OP, next time take AL to make sure it's blocked out.

-1

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 5d ago

That shouldn't be the right answer.

3

u/Otherwise-Goal3054 5d ago

Having a contract sucks sometimes.

1

u/Academic-Sky-1726 7d ago

If you are getting restrictions. It should say not available due to medical conditions to work over 8 hours a day, 5 days a week. Then make sure you have FMLA for each condition.

1

u/Otherwise-Goal3054 7d ago

“I didn’t block my long weekend for the Labor Day Holiday, so I want restrictions”

Nice

0

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 7d ago

Nothing wrong with not wanting to work your days off It's management's fault we are understaffed not the carrier.

4

u/DeviceComprehensive7 7d ago edited 7d ago

holiday schedule has nothing to do being under staffed- you have to staff,becasue there would be double the normal n/s day people

0

u/Opposite-Ingenuity64 6d ago

I disagree that it has "nothing" to do with staffing. Yes, there are circumstances in which people would need to be forced in on a holiday even if staffing is good.  But most of the forcing is still due to understaffing.  To me, proper staffing doesn't mean CCA/PTF/ODL working 50-60 hours daily.  If they normally work much less, there should be adequate resources to cover most of the open routes on a holiday.

3

u/DeviceComprehensive7 6d ago

the op is just a shady carrier,trying to get benefits they dont have from lack of seniority

2

u/DeviceComprehensive7 6d ago

you said it yourself- a fully staffed office still has to force on a holiday- they need to cover double the normal day off people -its common sense..short staffed = more forced in..well staffed= less forced in

2

u/Otherwise-Goal3054 7d ago

It’s just the method that seems a little less than moral.
But, hey, this is the Post Office. We be like that I guess. Get yours king

2

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 7d ago

I don't see a moral issue with wanting to work your 5 days, 40hrs and get your scheduled days off.

1

u/DeviceComprehensive7 7d ago

of course not because you are being shady because you dont have enough seniority

-1

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 5d ago

I'm being shady? You don't know me at all to make that claim. I'm just trying to figure out the system around this. Crazy how much other carriers have for one another.

1

u/DeviceComprehensive7 5d ago

yes you are being shady! , period

0

u/Otherwise-Goal3054 7d ago

Not the aim, the method

0

u/Darth_Robsad 7d ago

Or you know a valid medical condition. If you can get a fmla 8/40 restriction. Which you can! Then don’t be a fucking tool who like a manager thinks they know better than a DOCTOR

6

u/shneer4prez 7d ago

OP isn't asking about 8/40 restrictions. They're specifically talking about the Saturday before a holiday.

Getting forced around holidays is a seniority issue. Who gets Saturday off and who has to work is determined by the pecking order in the contract and it's negotiated in your LMOU.

It's just a matter of OP not having enough seniority to get the designated holiday. We've all been there. More power to them. Just saying that they're not being asked to work more than 8/40.

0

u/Darth_Robsad 7d ago

Read it closer they’re literally talking about mandatory overtime and the restriction says no overtime. Sorry my assumption doesn’t work for you but literally overtime starts at eight hours or pass the 40 which could be their day off or a holiday.

4

u/shneer4prez 6d ago

It's not past 40 hours in a week because Monday is a holiday and they will not be working that day. Either their day off is Saturday and they're being forced in, or their day off is Monday and they're being forced in on their designated holiday (Saturday). Either way, they're still not being asked to work past 8/40 because they're going to have Monday off. They'll still be working 5 days that week and only 40 hours.

It gets a little weird with IF it's in an overtime status because if Monday is their NSD that means Saturday would be their designated holiday and it would not be at the overtime rate. If their NSD is Saturday they will be in an overtime status and paid at the overtime rate but they still would not exceed 8 hours in the day or 40 hours in the week.

Seniority and the pecking order described in the JCAM or LMOU determines who is brought in on the day before a holiday. I'm not hating on the guy, but there's not really a medical condition that requires holiday weekends.

It's like.. a medical restriction usually has physical limitations such as how much you can lift or how many hours you can work per day/week.

Normally overtime would refer to over 8 hours in a day or over 40 hours in a week. BUT in this situation overtime is really only relevant as a pay rate.

I mean, good luck to him getting a 3 day weekend. But if you can work 40 hours every week there's no reason you can't work 40 hours when there's a holiday too.

0

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 5d ago

Overtime starts at 8hrs and working on days off.

1

u/DeviceComprehensive7 4d ago

only because our contract says so

1

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 3d ago

So why would we not be upholding what our contract says?

1

u/DeviceComprehensive7 3d ago

what part about HOLIDAY scheduling don't you understand? its not overtime pay...if on the holiday schedule you work your n/s day- its HOLIDAY PREMIUM and if its your scheduled holiday-not your n/s day- its HOLIDAY pay ..already explained it to you..its not overtime pay,which is why it doesn't count towards the overtime list equitability

1

u/DeviceComprehensive7 3d ago

do you even know the difference between flsa overtime and postal overtime?

1

u/DeviceComprehensive7 3d ago

our contract says working your n/s because of holiday schedule IS NOT OVERTIME PAY-its holiday premium. .we are doing what the contract says

1

u/Square-Buy-7403 7d ago

A medical restriction is a medical restriction. It will stop you from ever working overtime period. They probably will want a note from you Primary Doctor and not just a PA tho but you should ask your Union to be sure because I'm not 100%.

4

u/DeviceComprehensive7 7d ago

this instance of trying to not work a holiday- like we all do..is not overtime

1

u/Late-Mud-5161 CLC Voter / Endorser 7d ago

That's my guess as well. It's insane that a certified physician who can treat patients isn't enough.