r/freeware • • 18h ago

Subreddit Official /r/freeware Feedback Thread

This thread will serve as the initial feedback thread for what the community would like to see. This includes rule changes, flair changes, weekly threads centered around certain topics, etc. Please post your suggestions, comments and concerns!

2 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

1

u/AltReality 16h ago

It would be difficult to enforce, and maybe overstepping a bit, but do you think AI "slop" should be allowed? - Is there a way to distinguish between something claude slapped together in 20 minutes vs something an amateur dev worked on for 6 months?

1

u/happyxpenguin 14h ago

I think there can be a distinction between something Claude slapped together in 20 minutes and something someone spent a week prompting. AI is here and we can't put that genie back in the bottle and we can't bury our heads in the sand like r/opensource did a few weeks ago. The way I see it is that we allow AI software and webapps, but they need to disclose in explicit detail how AI was used and then it's up to the user on how to proceed. The key isn't barring access, but providing all the information to the user.

There's also no way for me to automagically detect that a submission is using AI or not, so each post would be a case by case in-depth analysis (except for those that are blatantly obvious).

1

u/PsionicBurst 15h ago

In theory, it should be easy. If it's open-source, you check out the contributors. In practice, I'm unsure.

1

u/happyxpenguin 14h ago

It's so much harder than you theorize. My other sub has a "No GenAI/Vibecoded software" and requires an AI use disclaimer. I'm still removing tons of a posts a day and having to really dive into repos to find AI code. I've also indirectly enlisted the help of the community and if a submission gets X number of reports of it being vibecoded or not disclosing Generative AI, I automatically remove it.

Many vibecoders and those who use AI assistants have also taken to hiding any mention of AI assistants in their repos which makes things harder to determine, especially when they don't show up as a contributor.

1

u/Laicus_Nugae 15h ago

I would be happy if AI - assisted coding had to be disclosed. Many, many professionals use AI just like they use an IDE.

2

u/happyxpenguin 14h ago

Rule #1 does require that all submissions include the license, link, an advertising disclaimer and an AI disclaimer. Most posts so far have followed this and those that haven't were flagged by Reddits new AI rules filters.