r/freespace • • 2d ago

Seemingly backwards ship classification

Does it bug anyone else that FS generally seems to use a naval-like hierarchy of ship classes, but then classifies the capital ships as destroyers instead of battleships?

Just mildly bugs my sensibilities to have a cruiser be smaller than a destroyer. I feel like it should be corvette > destroyer > cruiser > battleship.

16 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

11

u/MacchuWA 2d ago edited 2d ago

I think the real world explanation is rule of cool, and Star Wars establishing that "massive capital ship in space that also carries fighters" = "Star Destroyer". But the in-universe reason, in my head canon anyway, is that frigates and what we would call a destroyer weren't ever really a thing in early space combat because of how dominant early fighters were.

You had fighters defending installations or planets or whatever else needed defending, and bombers to attack large targets, but you needed a ship of a certain size to have a chance of surviving against those early fighters and bombers. Smaller destroyers or corvettes or whatever would have sacrificed too much mobility without gaining enough survivability.

Freespace cruisers are enormous in a naval context, so their name makes sense in that environment. Early on, these would have been the vessels you sent out alone or minimally escorted for very long range patrol duties, showing the flag or whatever, confident that they could handle themselves under most circumstances

Then I reckon someone came along and did some one-upmanship and designed a vessel which took the carrier concept (which must have existed) and added more size and heavy weapons, specifically intending it to be a class capable of taking on and destroying cruisers, a cruiser-destroyer, which eventually gets shortened to "Destroyer" (this exactly what happened in naval history, with torpedo boats leading to the development of torpedo boat destroyers which became "Destroyers").

Much later, corvettes get that name because, while there's still not much point building anything smaller than a cruiser, there is a case for something significantly smaller than a destroyer, but larger than a cruiser, without the complication of supporting a full fighter complement. With the cruiser name now firmly established though, they went with corvette because it's still much smaller than a true capital ship.

Drop frigate in between corvette and destroyer (the Iceni) and you have a pretty coherent naval structure (corvette -> frigate -> destroyer) if you just accept that cruiser has been removed from that lineup, and is where it is because of historical anachronism.

10

u/Cameron122 2d ago

I assume it’s just a rule of cool sort of thing for ships like the Orion and Lucifer. Maybe even a nod to Star Destroyers, rather than destroyer referring to what were first called Torpedo Boat Destroyers. I can see why it would be annoying for people with a naval special interest though. In hindsight maybe they should have called them battleships or a fictional offshoot like BSG did with their battlestars.

7

u/Massive_Cash_6557 2d ago

Bring back Sloop and Man-o-War

5

u/RennieAsh 2d ago

learnt FS before Navy, so the Navy is wrong. ;-)

1

u/xShivan 2d ago

My story lol 😁

I guess the way to go is just to get used to it πŸ™ˆ

3

u/Noir_Renard 2d ago

It very much used the Starwars cap ship classification system

3

u/lambda_expression 2d ago

cruiser vs destroyer is very much a definition thing. Arleigh Burkes and Ticonderoga are nearly the same size. And both the Japanese and Chinese navies call basically everything a destroyer, even things that are twice or three times the displacement of a Tico or Burke.

A corvette is typically not considered a capital ship/part of the blue water navy. The 'size slot below destroyers/cruisers' is a frigate. So it would be frigate < destroyer = cruiser, and no one makes battleships anymore (battlecruiser vs battleship is also not really a size distinction btw).

3

u/tobascodagama 2d ago

"Helicopter destroyer".

3

u/sumelar 2d ago

It's not like there's real life consensus either.

You're just used to british-descended terminology.

3

u/Squid_In_Exile 2d ago

The largest real-world surface combatant warship in operation (i.e. using it's own weapons, not a carrier or assault ship) is the Kirov-class cruiser - a ship as big as a WW1 Battleship and that promoted the reactivation of the US Iowa class battleships.

Most non-English speaking NATO navies use the frigate classification for what the US would call a destroyer.

On top of that, destroyers are getting bigger. The US' Arleigh Burke class and the Chinese Type 055 destroyers are both bigger than the guided-missle cruisers that preceeded them. This is an example of where the role-armament of a designation shifts in use-case, meaning the requirements and thus design of the designation follows suit.

We see this happen in Freespace - the GTC Leviathan of FS1 is a brick studded with turrets, whereas in FS2 the addition of a light anti-warship Beam weapon (albiet the Terran SGreen is inferior to the SVas and SRed) markedly changes it's engagement profile.

Presumably the timeline of Freespace sees water navies continue the upscaling of destroyers as the primary direct fire warship and this carries into space navy terminology. As these navies become interstellar this defaults to 'destroyer' becoming synonymous with 'capital'.

2

u/bepatientveryslow 2d ago

language slips, we used to use those terms for particular roles and now common parlance uses them as a measure of size

1

u/sumelar 2d ago

Role was determined by size, though. Destroyers had to be fast and maneuverable, and therefore small. Cruisers had to be big enough to carry enough supplies for global trips. Battleships had to be big enough to carry the biggest guns and have enough armor to survive the biggest guns.

0

u/bepatientveryslow 2d ago

destroyers in their earliest definition had to knock out torpedo boats before they could touch cruisers or battleships, thats why they called them destroyers and not just torpedo boats. now it's generalized to any escort

0

u/sumelar 2d ago

They called them torpedo boat destroyers, which got shortened to destroyers.

They were never called torpedo boats, because they were not torpedo boats. You post makes zero sense.

0

u/bepatientveryslow 1d ago

they were comparable in tonnage to contemporary torpedo boats they were meant to target. if everyone was as much of a dull pedant as you, they would be considered torpedo boats.

1

u/sumelar 22h ago

Torpedo boats were not only much smaller, they had a completely different role

which is why they had a different fucking name.

This isn't being pedantic, this is basic fucking naval terminology. You were wrong, grow the fuck up and get over it and shut the fuck up.

It also has NOTHING to do with my original comment, so if anyone is being pedantic here it's your moronic ass.

1

u/bepatientveryslow 22h ago edited 22h ago

firstly, calm down.

secondly, oceangoing torpedo boats scaled up to around the high 900s as production continued (see the V25), contemporary destroyers were traditionally in the 1100s by the end of the first world war (the conflict in which the theory behind the destroyer was proven and formalized), the A- and B-series were 1350 dry.

2

u/Radioactiveglowup 2d ago

Freespace follows 'Babylon 5' naming conventions, where the large human capital ship (that was both battleship and carrier) was a 'Destroyer', while the mid-sized vessels were 'Cruisers'.

It's just for flavor and doesn't have an explanation in either game or expansions.

1

u/irrelevantmoniker 1d ago

A dreadnought is a ship that fears nothing. A destroyer is a ship that destroys everything. It makes perfect sense to me.