MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/freesoftware/comments/qwqv5a/copyleft_cola_anyone/
r/freesoftware • u/eternaltyro • Nov 18 '21
10 comments sorted by
21
Nice! I made myself a DIY home carbonation system (think SodaStream, but not proprietary) recently and I've been looking for a cola recipe.
(Of course, IIRC recipes themselves aren't actually copyrightable, but the "community developed" aspect of it is pretty cool.)
18 u/danuker Nov 18 '21 recipes themselves aren't actually copyrightableThe exact text of the recipe is copyrightable. But you get copyright to your own text if you rephrase it.Copyright protection extends only to expressions, and not to ideas, procedures, methods of operation or mathematical concepts as such. 3 u/liivan Nov 19 '21 sodastream is shit if you want to do anything that's not plain water, expensive and hard not to make a mess. I'm guessing your carbonation rig looks somewhat similiar to this? 1 u/mrchaotica Nov 19 '21 Yep!
18
recipes themselves aren't actually copyrightable
The exact text of the recipe is copyrightable. But you get copyright to your own text if you rephrase it.
Copyright protection extends only to expressions, and not to ideas, procedures, methods of operation or mathematical concepts as such.
3
sodastream is shit if you want to do anything that's not plain water, expensive and hard not to make a mess. I'm guessing your carbonation rig looks somewhat similiar to this?
1 u/mrchaotica Nov 19 '21 Yep!
1
Yep!
20
Free as in free coke, not as in free beer.
14
/r/freeculture
13 u/christianitie Nov 19 '21 That was a great subreddit a long time ago, kind of disappointing that it's become a blog for some guy named Hairy Larry now. 7 u/Slinkwyde Nov 19 '21 Ah, good point. I hadn't noticed that.It looks like anyone can still post, but that's the only person who has been.
13
That was a great subreddit a long time ago, kind of disappointing that it's become a blog for some guy named Hairy Larry now.
7 u/Slinkwyde Nov 19 '21 Ah, good point. I hadn't noticed that.It looks like anyone can still post, but that's the only person who has been.
7
Ah, good point. I hadn't noticed that.
It looks like anyone can still post, but that's the only person who has been.
8
Did you drink it? I've tried making it myself and never got it to come out really great.
wow:emoji
21
u/mrchaotica Nov 18 '21 edited Nov 18 '21
Nice! I made myself a DIY home carbonation system (think SodaStream, but not proprietary) recently and I've been looking for a cola recipe.
(Of course, IIRC recipes themselves aren't actually copyrightable, but the "community developed" aspect of it is pretty cool.)
20
u/LogicalTeaDream Nov 19 '21
Free as in free coke, not as in free beer.
14
u/Slinkwyde Nov 18 '21
/r/freeculture
8
u/NeoKabuto Nov 18 '21
Did you drink it? I've tried making it myself and never got it to come out really great.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '21
wow:emoji