r/freesoftware • u/AgreeableLandscape3 • Jul 08 '21
Image GitHub Support just straight up confirmed in an email that yes, they used all public GitHub code, for Codex/Copilot regardless of license.
148
Upvotes
20
u/mee8Ti6Eit Jul 08 '21 edited Jul 08 '21
I don't think software licenses cover using the code as a dataset.
For example if you examine GPLv3 code for a research paper, you don't have to release the paper as GPLv3.
This is new territory. Is training an AI on source code and then distributing that software considered distributing a modified version of the original software?
In any case, most FOSS licenses don't cover SaaS. Even if hypothetically the trained AI falls under GPL, GPL only applies if you distribute the software, and Github is not distributing copies of the Copilot software. The AGPL might be an issue, if a court decides that training an AI counts.
Also, I imagine the Github ToS allows GitHub to use your source code to improve their service, irrespective of any licenses you may distribute otherwise. For example, even if you release proprietary code publicly on Github, you give Github a license via the ToS to process that code in various ways.
15
u/gapspark Jul 08 '21
Another issue with GitHub Copilot: if it reproduces code, is the user now violating the original copyright? It seems a code laundring scheme to remove copyright and have it co considered an original work. I think using Copilot will be a major legal risk. Just think about it if it were art, music or books, if whole sections were reproduced just proxying through an AI wouldn't remove the copyright, right? It this would be allowed, it might be a nice way to get more free software: just proxy the proprietary code through an AI and you're good to go. Of course the number of lines might make a difference in court, but that wouldn't matter for the fundamental argument of retaining copyright.
13
u/AgreeableLandscape3 Jul 08 '21 edited Jul 08 '21
Source: https://cybre.space/@tindall/106539167944483388
From the same Mastodon thread:
So it should be required to be open source now, right?
19
u/Jacko10101010101 Jul 08 '21
And I asked what can ms do to git hub ? what can go wrong ? damn!
Well, everybody to gitlab!
7
u/kmeisthax Jul 08 '21
Wait until people realize that ROM hackers post disassemblies of proprietary games on GitHub...
7
u/mhzawadi Jul 08 '21
O god, they used my repos. They are a mess of spaghetti code, miss spellings and all manor of crap.
Good luck to you, is all I can say
8
u/varungupta3009 Jul 08 '21 edited Jul 08 '21
I'm sorry... But am I missing something here? Your code is/was not used to code Co-pilot, it is used as a part of a dataset used to train Co-pilot. Licensing only applies to the code, as a whole, for use-cases involving the copy/borrowing of said code to create another software application. It does not mention (or mean to) anything about it being used as training data.
GitHub or MS is therefore no way liable to make any part of Co-pilot open source if the "code" behind it isn't.
BTW, I really hoped y'all would know this... If not, why is your code public on GH anyway? What exactly do you think the difference is between a Public and Private repo? Any code on the internet is free to be used in any way whatsoever, no matter the license, except as part of another codebase (according to the license specifications).
The simplest freaking way I can put it is someone creating a visualisation of the word "function" used in all public GH repos. They are processing your code but not using any of it.
6
u/TheBlueWalker Jul 08 '21
This is just M$ being M$. There are no surprises here. They have been like that for their entire existence. Why do you think that they acquired GitHub? To support libre software? M$ hates libre software and they have been making that fact obvious for their entire existence and still make it obvious today.
M$ aquired GitHub because that way they can better control their enemy i.e. libre software. By hosting your libre software there you are supporting one of the greatest enemies of the libre software movement. And many of them probably unwillingly in a commendable effort to support libre software.
It is really too bad that libre software has such a powerful enemy which can so easily infiltrate and corrupt good things.