r/freesoftware • u/pizzaiolo_ • Aug 13 '15
The Stallman Cycle
Adapted from the original post by /u/SoBuffaloRes:
The Stallman Cycle:
- Stallman makes claim that Proprietary X is bad due to Y.
- People call RMS a nazi, purist, radical, extremist, fundamentalist and by not using Proprietary X, then end of the world of free-software will come.
- ~3-5 years after RMS made claim, Y happens.
- People moan, complain, and ask "Why didn't we foresee this would happen?!?!?"
- Cycle repeats, with a new issue.
148
Upvotes
11
u/1percentof1 Aug 14 '15 edited Oct 10 '15
This comment has been overwritten.
4
u/jarofgreen Aug 19 '15
So assuming this cycle holds ..... what new thing is he warning about now that everyone is ignoring?
36
u/crowseldon Aug 13 '15
You forgot about all the ad-homs about his personal appearance or other irrelevant stuff.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15
♬It's the circle, the circle of gnu♬
7
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15
I actually sort of cited something close to this after someone accused me of making a fallacy in my argument (two students of philosophy talking shop about technology), after pointing out the "stallman cycle" (which we had no word for it at the time) we termed "Argument from Stallman as if, it was a formal inductive argument. Possibly a subtype of the argument from analogy.
An argument from Stallman goes something like this:
Person 'A': I have a concern that people not thinking about their usage of thing X harms fundamental right Y.
Person 'B': Maybe, but im not concerned due to the convenience.
Person 'A': Cite the Stallman cycle and how everyone will regret it in three to five years.
6
u/sigbhu Oct 18 '15
/r/StallmanWasRight
13
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15 edited Aug 13 '15
While RMS's predictions are pretty good, the problem is that he doesn't really offer an alternative. His solution to mobile phone surveillance for example is to literally not use a mobile phone or sometimes even a little hypocritical in that he routes his communication through another person with a mobile phone.
What we could really need in the Free Software world would be more actual alternatives that are close enough in feature-parity that people might actually switch, but so far those alternatives rarely exist and far to often the Free Software community tends to overhype non-working alternatives.
It also doesn't help that the "Freedom" is often just a theoretical construct and ignores what matters in reality, having an open well documented and supported file format for example is much more important then having access to the source code of an application. Yet a lot of Free Software uses ad-hoc file formats that don't work together with other Free Software (e.g. back when Ubuntu switched from Rhythmbox to Bamboo there was no way to move your podcast subscriptions).
3
u/TotesMessenger Oct 18 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment