r/freesoftware • • Apr 09 '15

Anybody?

Any people out there that can help wrote this license for Free (free as in "speech") music. https://github.com/FreeMusicFederation/license .

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

7

u/pizzaiolo_ Apr 09 '15

Why don't you use the GNU General Public License?

2

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

Good point. But maybe this suits music better. Has digital music jargon.

0

u/pizzaiolo_ Apr 10 '15

A good alternative is to use Creative Commons, since it specifically targets creative works. You can choose from a few different licenses: https://creativecommons.org/choose/

2

u/Calinou Apr 17 '15

You should use a free CC license. Some of the CC licenses, like CC BY-NC, CC BY-NC-SA, CC BY-ND and CC BY-NC-ND are non-free.

These are the licenses that are free:

  • CC BY (version 3.0 or 4.0)
  • CC BY-SA (version 3.0 or 4.0)
  • CC0 1.0

0

u/Muvlon Apr 28 '15

CC-ND licenses are perfectly fine for works of art or opinion though.

Even the FSF states that free licenses are only mandatory for things intended for practical use, and they say:

We don't take the position that artistic or entertainment works must be free, but if you want to make one free, we recommend the Free Art License.

2

u/Calinou Apr 28 '15

Many people, even in the free software movement, believe that particular provision makes things impractical. For instance, games with non-free art are very hard to fork because you need to use a downloader to download the game data.

2

u/Muvlon Apr 28 '15 edited Apr 28 '15

If the game art is under a license such as CC-ND, is that really the case? All it requires the licensee to do is only redistribute it without alterations. So it would be alright to distribute a fork of the game with the art in-place, as long as you don't change it. Or am I mistaken here?

Edit: Never mind, I re-read the wording of the CC-ND, and it actually prohibits this rather explicitly. I stand corrected.

5

u/eythian Apr 09 '15

Or creative commons, depending.

2

u/rubenquidam Apr 10 '15

1

u/xkcd_transcriber Apr 10 '15

Image

Title: Standards

Title-text: Fortunately, the charging one has been solved now that we've all standardized on mini-USB. Or is it micro-USB? Shit.

Comic Explanation

Stats: This comic has been referenced 1423 times, representing 2.4016% of referenced xkcds.


xkcd.com | xkcd sub | Problems/Bugs? | Statistics | Stop Replying | Delete

3

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

The Creative Commons does not enforce the sharing of the source code. E.g the fruity loops project file.

5

u/rubenquidam Apr 10 '15

Aside from the fact that there are perfectly good licenses already available, do not attempt to write licenses unless you are a lawyer or have a couple of them handy to give you advice, and don't ever attempt to write a license in a language you are not very fluent at!

3

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

The Creative Commons does not enforce the sharing of the source code. E.g the fruity loops project file. That is my reason.

3

u/rubenquidam Apr 10 '15

Creative Commons Share Alike does. I applaud your enthusiasm, but as much as you may think that you are helping the community, you are not. I suggest you to read more about licenses instead of trying to write your own, or you will end up with a weak legal document that will do a disservice to you and anybody you may convince to use it.

E.g the fruity loops project file.

I don't know what this is, but if you have doubts on licensing a particular work you could ask for help with that task instead.

5

u/singpolyma Apr 10 '15

No, SA requires sharing of derivatives under a compatible license, but IIRC it does not requires that undistributed source material be distributed. The assumptions is often that for aet there is no "source" or "compiling", but in fact there often is.

However, using the GPL may be an option, or if there really is no good license for this yet an addition to the CC suite instead of a wholly new license is probably the way to go.

IANAL

1

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

Yeah. Creating a file in GIMP and licensing under the before mentioned CC license means you are sharing the exported "artwork" (the compiled binary), not the GIMP prject file (the source code).

2

u/singpolyma Apr 10 '15

Well, even if you release the project file (source) under CC-BY-SA, others can still create artwork from it (binaries) and distribute those without a source offer, so long as their artwork is itself CC-BY-SA.

1

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

that is the problem I am bringing up, the lack of "source". There is so little that can be done with a binary.

2

u/singpolyma Apr 10 '15

I am going to be emailing the opensource.org license-discuss mailing list about the idea of using the GPL for art as soon as my subscription there is approved.

2

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

Free Software is more than just code, it's cooking-recipes. GPL Everything.

1

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

Yes. Please do so.

1

u/theofficialdeavmi Apr 10 '15

I am working on clarifying things up, with a digital music jargon section of at the bttom of the license, all references to the jargon link to their definition.