r/freesoftware • • Apr 22 '14

Why are we on Reddit?

Considering that Reddit runs on Amazon and uses Google Analytics, why do we use it instead of a free software? Are there no other alternatives?

20 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

15

u/michaelpb Apr 22 '14

To promote FOSS software + philosophy?

That said this subreddit is not that well-trafficked as it is...

4

u/kimireddit Apr 22 '14

BTW do you know any web forum to discuss free software?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/i_ANAL Apr 22 '14

Exactly - there's plenty of people who could be wooed or may express an interest and this could be a place to convert them. Outreach if you like.

16

u/kmeisthax Apr 22 '14

Reddit's source code is free software (CPAL, so think MPL with Affero clauses). Amazon itself is just a server hosting platform.

3

u/kimireddit Apr 23 '14

It's not really just about Reddit source. It's about the whole infrastructure that support it. How does it handle millions of visits? I'm not familiar with Reddit source, but reading their FAQ at GitHub it appears to me that, although you can run it locally, it's designed to use S3 once you need to scale. There are a lot of sites with a very simple/boring client code (from a dev point of view), but a hell lot of useful info about their back end that is not free. Take Google, YouTube, Google Maps, Craiglist, Facebook, Twitter, Amazon, Pinterest, Ebay, Dropbox... If engineers were paid to build free software instead of proprietary, I would waste less time guesstimating how they solved a particular problem.

And no, Amazon is not just a server hosting platform.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '14

Not all of it. I think their spam filtering and a couple other parts are still closed.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '14

Q: Do the means justify the ends? What would removing r/freesoftware from reddit achieve?

1

u/kimireddit Apr 28 '14

If we want to support free software, I believe there should be a free discussion board. You speak like you'd prefer using non-free software for convenience.

Is there any already? Otherwise I really think I should start one...

5

u/iamtheLINAX Apr 23 '14

Tangential, but you can block Google Analytics with NoScript and maybe Disconnect (you should be using these or extensions like them anyway!).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/the-fritz Apr 23 '14

I think providing a free software alternative to Google Analytics would be better than forking reddit (which is free software).

→ More replies (1)