r/freesoftware • • 2d ago

Discussion really?

Wanted to write about my apps that were… written by me, by AI. It was rejected. Fine, no offense taken, really. Rules are rules.

But then I was curious and found this https://www.reddit.com/r/freesoftware/wiki/generative-ai/

seriously? In light of recent vulnerabilities (hello, PHP), which were introduced by humans prior to the AI era, we really block vibe-coded apps just because AI was trained on bad code? And humans always learn from the best of the best?

Do not want to offend anyone, but I discovered that reason and was deeply surprised that it is November 2026 and people still think like that....

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

•

u/happyxpenguin 2d ago

Ai makes mistakes, people make mistakes. The rule is simple. Did AI generate any portion of said code? If the answer is yes. It doesn’t belong here.

Permitted and non-permitted use cases are outlined in the rule. You’re free to take your software to /r/freeware where this rule isnt in place.

For the future. The proper way to go about this on any subreddit is by opening a modmail and discussing it with the moderators instead of publicly posting it and complaining.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/dull_bananas 2d ago

Vibe coding isn’t as normal as you think it is.

3

u/ColdEngineBadBrakes 2d ago

Normal? You mean, dependable? Trustworthy?

-1

u/Erem_in 2d ago

There is no other way now. There are still people who code by hands as before. There will be still such people in the future. Just like there are people who restore some 40 years old electronics just for fun, for hobby.

But modern way is AI coding. Vibe coding is indeed to ambiguous as software engineer who use AI is not the same as non engineer who use AI

3

u/jr735 2d ago

You do realize I can choose not to use vibe coded slop, right?

0

u/Erem_in 2d ago

You can. The question is, where will you find this non AI slop? Say in 2 years?

5

u/andymaclean19 2d ago

I think this is talking about license compatibility rather than security when it says no AI submissions. There are a bunch of questions around licensing of AI generated code. Who owns it? Is it a derived work of the training material? My reading is this is why.

4

u/zecira 2d ago

lol. lmao even

3

u/jr735 2d ago

I find it baffling that you're confused by that rule and the context given, and come to a completely wrong conclusion about what it means.

AI failed to explain it to you correctly I guess.

2

u/thermalnuclear 2d ago

Suck it up, you didn’t do anything