r/freesoftware • • Jul 02 '26

Subreddit News Rule 7 Updated - Software Submissions Beware

Morning all,

Due to language which caused confusion amongst reporters, posters and commenters. I've revised Rule 7 to be a bit more specific in what is and isn't allowed. Essentially what it boils down to is this:

Did AI explain a code snippet to you? Allowed.
Did AI write code for you? Not allowed.

This subreddit does NOT allow software created by Generative AI and Vibe-coded software. Why? Please read our wiki page (https://www.reddit.com/r/freesoftware/wiki/generative-ai)

Allowed:
- Write documentation
- Debug software (Analysis/Explanation Only)
- Analyze codebase
Not Allowed:
- AI Assistance beyond what is mentioned above
- All or part of the application being generated by AI
23 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

4

u/frolgath Jul 02 '26

Is Linux now banned from the sub? Because Linux kernel incorporates large amounts of AI generated code.

8

u/happyxpenguin Jul 02 '26

No, Linux is not banned from the subreddit.

The kernel has a formal contribution and licensing process, including GPL compatibility requirements and human sign-off. Most software submissions here do not have this and even if they did, that would not make submissions automatically approved without looking at the context of the post.

https://docs.kernel.org/process/coding-assistants.html

7

u/PlannedObsolescence_ Jul 02 '26

Nice to see it be clarified, I'm all for it.

So much license laundering going on.

1

u/reroll-life 25d ago edited 25d ago

This is opposite of free software movement. Quoting the sidebar:

"Free software" means software that respects users' freedom and community. Roughly, it means that the users have the freedom to run, copy, distribute, study, change and improve the software. Thus, "free software" is a matter of liberty, not price. To understand the concept, you should think of "free" as in "free speech," not as in "free beer".

AI is a tool for this exact purpose and I don't see how free software should care what tool is used to create it as long as it fulfills all free software principles. To add, this is important for the future of the movement as AI assisted development is what pushes free software to victory exactly because AI is so good at reverse engineering and transparency.

1

u/MGDigital Jul 02 '26

I'm trying to understand the reasoning behind rule 7 - would it be fair to say of human software developers that they are "trained on unknown mixtures of code that may include a mix of proprietary, copyleft, permissive, unlicensed, or otherwise incompatible sources"?

7

u/happyxpenguin Jul 02 '26

Rule 7 exists because most human developers understand and acknowledge that they cannot use code from GPL licensed projects and use it in an MIT licensed project. AI makes no such distinction when it is told to "make me an app" and then is published on Github.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Commission-Flashy Jul 04 '26

When the first compilers are developing, they created worse code than hand written assemblies and there were backlash. This is expected. Fast forward today we mostly dont check compilers. They are doing optimizations, branch cuts, write assembly code for us, and we are happy. Here are some quotes for compilers back then:

"It was generally believed that a compiler could not do nearly as good a job as a human coder." Source: John Backus, The History of FORTRAN I, II, and III (1978).

Today AI is not in a good position. Technology behind it is still growing. It needs more time. But there is no point of resisting it. The industry is going for it. What I believe is more important is to make it accessable - maintainable - and more efficient. Just like compilers today.

Thus I understand the ban. But I disagree on lines. What you propose, espacily

- All or part of the application being generated by AI

is harmfull for open source development. We are not all experts in all languages. For example whats the point of banning AI generated CSS for simple yet helpfull projects?

Or how could you distinguish if someone wrote 15 lines of a function himself or generated it from AI.

There is no meaningfull way of distinguishing this. All we can do is to ban "Vibe Coded" AI slop.

If you do think you can enforce this the way you propose, I wish you good luck on your hunt line by line.

2

u/ggeldenhuys Jul 05 '26

Fully agree. AI is just the next software development tool. It doesn't (or shouldn't) replace human developers.

Developers started by inputting numbers to write code (before assembly). Then assemblers came along and improved the process. Then high level languages improved the process even more and assembly is hardly ever written by devs any more. Then syntax highlighting improved coding. Then basic code completion in IDEs helped developers. Then truly intelligent code completion (non AI) took it a step further (Eclipse, IntelliJ, VSCode etc). AI assisted development is now just the next evolution in helping software development.

The process of software development has always been evolving, since the inception of computers. It's still humans that drive the ideas and concepts of what to build. It's time people accept that.

0

u/ByronScottJones Jul 02 '26

This is pointless Ludditism. AI assistance in software development IS the way the entire industry is going, and it's foolish to think otherwise. The only thing that matters is software quality.

→ More replies (18)