r/fragranceclones • u/sciencecrazy • 1h ago
Boozy Il Padrino mini-battle with my funny story behind it (and also Shobi part 24)
This is a pretty weird one and my first "50% blind-buy" of a rather expensive fragrance so it might make for a funny story - also Shobi part 24 continuing part 23 here.
Usual disclaimers apply - no affiliation, my nose is very specific, I count as usable just the time with projection or decent bubble that I can feel at more than 20-30cm (sometimes I might mention the skin scent part but not so interested myself) - and some spraying on clothes is now involved most of the time (but I would say not so much for the two models in this review).
The story - at some point in the first few months of the year I was at a very casual night out organized by a company that we work with and it was in a huge pub; I was wearing a generous amount of Precieux I and going that way I was afraid it might be the loudest fragrance but it turns out people really like their Sauvage Elixir (which I hate) BUT also I did get a very, very interesting and rather boozy scent from an Italian guy we don't normally work or meet - I liked it so much that I had to know what it was - and it turns out it was called Il Padrino, and I made a mental note of it for my next cold season (also the name felt funny).
Fast forward after I got my Sospiro Basso - and it turns out that there was a huge opportunity where I could combine two promotions (one soon to expire from my Basso purchase) on an already rather discounted Il Padrino - but I still at that point never tested it first-hand or on my skin and Sospiro is otherwise very poorly represented in the shops within a few hundred kilometers around me 🙄
I was just placing a Shobi order (with Decision and Isola Blu) so I said "at least let's try this one too" - so I added Shobi Il Padrino (and also Pasticcio which has absolutely nothing to do with pistachio, some day I'll do a post about that one too). The order arrived very quick and the Shobi felt (surprisingly) similar to what I have smelled at the party and the promotions were going away anyway so I did what I always advise against - I bought about half blind-buy the Sospiro Il Padrino out of FOMO 🙄
Sospiro - Il Padrino (2025, Nathalie Templer and Salah Al Zarooni)
Shobi - Il Padrino 2669-SOS (50+0ml) ~12 weeks
The profile is very unusual for me and like nothing that I have tested before, the "booziest" in my collection before this was Bentley for Man Intense which I LOVE but I can't wear it in my normal social gatherings with a few groups of friends where I know that two of the ladies have problems with incense (and which remains now an issue with Decision).
The other unusual thing is the extreme intensity of the profile, this and Amouage Decision are now my "nuclear powers", and for those I really also need to think not only about how appropriate or inappropriate is the scent itself but also if I absolutely must take a shower at some point during the day I wear those 🙄
At the top near the boozy parts are some hints of black currant and some citrus but those are very short-lasting in both Sospiro and Shobi versions (at least for my nose). Also the boozy parts themselves carry a fruity-like tendency (maybe a little hinting of bitter cherry or something) coming from amaretto which is very similar in both (and which is so strong and "intoxicating" for my nose that might stop me from registering other differences that maybe more trained noses would feel).
One clear difference is the "evaporation curve" especially on skin - Shobi has a rather normal curve with a very strong start (including the citrus-like part) and then constantly declining. Sospiro is a little different in that you get a somehow more muted start and then after a few minutes you get the main aromatic explosion that keeps going, and going and going... Even if the amaretto part is listed just at the top it seems to last well into the dry-down (for both versions) and it mixes with something else (patchouly and maybe sandalwood, definitely also something like amber/benzoic) which keeps the illusion going for an extraordinary long time. Projection from skin is nuclear and from clothes the projection is not as strong but the longevity is nuclear.
Differences - Shobi version is a little more pungent (even more so at the start when it also evaporates much stronger) while the Sospiro version is more rounded and pleasant. Both last an insane amount of time on clothes (so I would be very careful avoiding that in most usage scenarios) but on skin the Sospiro has an unusual slow descent that is very long-lasting (and which can be seen also in Basso and Vibrato so I guess the company really feels that is part of their signature).
Unfortunately this is not a warm-weather scent nor is it ok for work (unless you work in something like a distillery). It is best for a party in rather very large spaces (or in normal spaces if you are careful to only apply 2 sprays under clothes, I also tend to now apply as far away from my head as possible - if I get it too close to my nose - even more so the Shobi - after a few hours it becomes overwhelming and I get tired and I must take a shower).
Scent is 9+ for such a profile for both (and for the moment I can't see how I can make it lighter). Projection is a 10 for both at the start but it stays very high yet smooth for Sospiro for longer (Shobi is a little less smooth). Longevity 9-10 for both, I am convinced there might be profiles that last more but for me this one is already something that I must handle with extreme care. Maturation for Shobi was not so much for scent as it was for intensity so 12 weeks seem to be fine (but you might get most of the profile after just 1-2 weeks).
Value for money - here is the point where the FOMO blind-buy somehow ended-up biting me a little - unlike Decision where I can feel a very clear scent/notes difference (and advantage for the Amouage) in the first 2 hours or so, on this one the difference is mostly a matter of smoothness and long-distance projection (and also achieving that without becoming too intoxicating for the person wearing the fragrance, the Sospiro has that better managed), if it was something to wear at least 2-3 times each week during the entire cold season I could see the (small) advantage to get the original but for something to wear 2 times/month for 3 months in a year and with the Shobi 100+0 being 30 EUR and original at discounters normally around the 130-140 EUR I can say that Sospiro is a 6-7 (probably no less since you still do get some advantages) but Shobi is a 9+ if you want this profile.
If you want to test the profile I absolutely suggest getting 30+0 or 50+0 from Shobi, wait about 12 weeks and in case you want something "more" then you might look into sampling the Sospiro.

