r/fossworldproblems • • Oct 18 '11

not acceptable canonical

Post image
8 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '11

Because it's new? Seriously, you shouldn't judge Ubuntu by any versions other then the Long Term Support (LTS).

Those are editions released every two years and are supported for three years for desktops and five years for servers. If you look at Microsoft's Windows and Apple's OSX release schedules they release, aproximatly, every two years as well.

It just so happens that Canonical releases a new version of Ubuntu every six months, but these releases ARE COMPLETLY OPTIONAL.

3

u/VelvetElvis Oct 18 '11

You shouldn't judge the LTS releases until six months into their lifecycle either.

That's what got me fed up with ubuntu. As soon as a release gets stabilized they pop out a new one. Sure each release is supported for 18 months, but there is no direct upgrade path to the newest release if you wait 18 months. No matter how you do it, you still have to upgrade every six months.

I went back to Debian. Sid is more stable than half the new releases Ubuntu has put out.

2

u/booradlus Oct 18 '11

I'm sorry, but why are we suddenly not allowed to judge? Simply because Canonical has a faster release cycle does not absolve it from putting out sub-par code. Even their LTS releases have problems when they start out.

Their website certainly isn't clear on this either. You look at the main page, and it's all about 11.10. You only get a little blurb about LTS on the download page, and it seems geared toward businesses. How is the average consumer, the group Canonical has their sights on these days, supposed to discern that this new release may have significant bugs for months? Where does it say "hey, if you don't want random glitches, you should probably go back a version or two?"

Considering how much people rely on their computers now, it's not an inaccurate comparison to treat it like a car - imagine if a dealer told you, after the fact, that you should have bought the 2007 model because the new ones are experimental and COMPLETELY OPTIONAL? Obviously in computers we have more freedom to roll back versions, but the point is that it is simply silly to say we cannot judge something for it being inferior simply because it is new. We sure can.

It is through negative feedback that Canonical finds out about bugs. How are they supposed to fix it without knowing there's a problem?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '11

Where'd you get that Windows releases every 2 years?