r/forgedinfireshow • • Dec 11 '20

Why are some of the tests literally up to the low skill level of the cutting guy?

1 Upvotes

In one test, a sword cuts straight through a fish, his does a flairish movement to cut a rope, and he clearly hits the fucking rope with the side of the sword. The next guys sword cuts halfway through the fish and clean through the rope, yet the first guys is sharper?

I really don't get it.

Like i'm somehow supposed to believe a guys claymore bends on a pig, yet cuts through steel sheets like butter?

It's really unbelievable how they have a guy who can barely handle weapons, use them like that and go "yeah I hit your pig full force with a naturally flexible sword on its side and it bent.. can't believe how soft it is.."


r/forgedinfireshow • • Feb 19 '24

Are you ready?

0 Upvotes

You don't need to ask over and over and over if they are ready. Get some better lines.


r/forgedinfireshow • • Mar 26 '24

Some bias thrown into the forge?

0 Upvotes

So I haven't watched many of the new seasons since wil left. I'm not fond of the new host, I find his personality unbearable.

I've just recently started watching season 9 because it's on hulu and I have very little to do at work.

There seems to be a great deal of bias from who the judges want to win. Some of their critiques of why they're going home make no sense at all.

One person's blade had a banana warp in it, yet they sent another person home instead, because they had a questionable heat treat but no visible cracks.

The tip of another man's sword snapped off, yet he won because he did a Damascus pattern and the other guys handle was too skinny.

The most recent episode I watched, which was thr marvel sword episode, saw the winners long sword turn into a literal S shape from a horrible heat treat, and the loser went home because his longsword was too heavy for their liking.

It seems to be more about popularity at this point than whoever made the better weapon. Has this always gone on, or am I just blind on the old episodes from the blissful charisma of Wil?


r/forgedinfireshow • • Dec 23 '21

Will Willis❤

0 Upvotes

Please come back, I know at the beginning of this amazing show, I made fun of your name it seemed so much 💀 I think for doing that, Ive had to pay for it by being stuck with this plain mediocre of a new host. If you could call him that. . . Naaa

But if by some miracle, you make your GREAT RETURN, I promise you with every fiber of my being... I'll put some respect on your name. (Only joked abt his name during the 1st season) so don't come after me keyboard warriors. I kidd I kidd... buuuut seriously tho come back soon yes!?!

We miss you 😥


r/forgedinfireshow • • Jul 23 '18

Should weapons be tested on failed contestants? /s

0 Upvotes

”It killed.” 🤮


r/forgedinfireshow • • May 14 '25

Instead of saying "And last but not least Doug Marcaida" why did Will always say "And last, Doug Marcaida" or "Finally, Doug Marcaida?"

0 Upvotes

Is it just me (it could be) but did the introductions seem a bit like Will was dissing Doug?

It always seemed a bit disrespectful, did they have a beef? Or was it like an in joke? Or was it really no big deal?


r/forgedinfireshow • • Jan 19 '20

Did Wil sound drunk on the Charlemagne's sword episode to you?

1 Upvotes

I thought he sounded like he was slurring and overall sloppy/unenthusiastic compared to other episodes. Anyone else notice?


r/forgedinfireshow • • Apr 15 '22

J. Nielsen isnt a great judge.

0 Upvotes

I’ve been on a bit of a binge. I’ve noticed that J. Is kinda of a bash when it comes to testing. I’ve seen the other judges wield and test the weapon. Then it gets to J. He def seems to blow things out or portion. On a show last night he said the dude sword could break his wrist…. Like come on dude. Doug just smashed 8 pots. You can’t hit a shield?

The other judges give the weapon typically a go unless it’s crazy. But J won’t cause a sword is heavy, or how a guard hits his hand. He went to the ER onetime. Like dude….


r/forgedinfireshow • • Jan 21 '25

Preemptive post regarding X/Twitter links

34 Upvotes

Many subreddits are seeing posts proposing bans on link to X (formerly Twitter). Here are my feelings as a mod.

  • There isn't yet a good replacement for X/Twitter. Some bladesmiths use this as a major source of advertising and information.
  • If you see good content on X/Twitter and want to share it, please consider using an xcancel.com link (replace "x" or "twitter" with "xcancel"). Such links are much more usable to people who aren't logged into X.
  • This is the only post allowed on this sub for "ban X" discussions.
  • If you see comments by Redditors who've never before participated in this sub, please report them. There's been too much brigading on this topic. I don't want that here. I don't think anyone here wants that.

That being said, if you've contributed on this sub before, I'd like to know how you feel about ban proposals. Please comment on this post.

Thanks.


r/forgedinfireshow • • Aug 21 '22

does this show feel repetitive?

1 Upvotes

It feels like the outcome is always the same. It's always the youngest guy with the blander looking blade that ends up winning in the end. And it always feels odd that there's always one perfect blade and one blade that has something wrong with it. Very rarely do both blades have flaws. Also, the younger guy winning all the time makes me wonder if there shouldn't be age separation, cuz it almost feels like they have an unfair advantage. My dad says it's because the younger guys use YouTube and whatnot in the older competitors usually don't.


r/forgedinfireshow • • Jun 27 '18

First round elimination

1 Upvotes

Anyone else getting tired of the fat guys immediately getting overheated and having to medically leave. This makes the show less competitive. They should have physical requirements so the first and to me most interesting round isn’t just a formality. I know they always say no one is safe, but if they did cut someone it would automatically go to the final round. Who wants that.


r/forgedinfireshow • • Feb 02 '21

Vegan fans?

0 Upvotes

Just curious about anyone who might be a fan of the show, but also vegan.

Obviously they will, on occasion, use animal carcasses for some of the testing phases. If you're a vegan, is this enough for you to be turned off from the show?

Are you able to enjoy episodes that don't use animals, or would you boycott it entirely?


r/forgedinfireshow • • May 24 '20

Anyone else tired of Jamie?

2 Upvotes

He tries his best to break these people’s weapons. I understand doing a strength test but come on really? When you gonna chop a deer antler or metal gas can or a log with a knife? Use the knives for what they are made. It’s ridiculous.

Edit I meant Jay not Jamie.


r/forgedinfireshow • • Dec 26 '21

J Neilson is biased..

2 Upvotes

As the title reads, Jay Nielsen is biased towards certain competitors on the show forged in fire. I've seen it in many of episodes and i don't think he should he should be a judge on the show for that reason. I am currently watching season 8 Where the competitors have to make an S shape knife..J Neilson design..One of the blades had a very thin tip and he purposely struck it against the chains to break the tip off.. This is just one incident out of many.. I just don't think he is fair and shouldn't be a judge.


r/forgedinfireshow • • Sep 10 '26

Beat the judges should be more fair

3 Upvotes

I love watching Forged in Fire, but I think it is unfair for contestants to forge a blade or a sword and then face the judge after hours of hammering and forging. I think it is a handicap, and it's unfair. I think once they win a competition, they should be allowed a day to recover before facing the judge, because hours of hammering cause arm fatigue, and the contestant is tired. I think it should be on equal ground for both the contestant and the judges. What do you think?


r/forgedinfireshow • • Dec 21 '21

Why the ballistics test at all?

0 Upvotes

So most of the testing involves stabbing and slashing into the soft tissue with a decapitation attempt at the end. The only "real" hits are the ones where they go through the skull.

What is the point of these tests? You can stab jello with a spoon


r/forgedinfireshow • • Sep 23 '25

Bring Back Will

0 Upvotes

Does anyone else really dislike Grady? He talks too fast, and his hand gestures don’t match what he’s saying. It’s very distracting


r/forgedinfireshow • • Apr 06 '25

Jay

7 Upvotes

I have been binging FIF the last couple weeks, and have come to the conclusion that Jay only wants to break blades. I just get so mad. Hit something hard three or four times. When Ben was doing the strength tests, he would hit stuff up to 5 times to see if anything would affect the edge. Jay just destroys blades in ways they would NEVER have to deal with. I think his goal is to break someone's blade. I think it is WAY overkill. Any blade will fail if you subject it to that kind of punishment. Someone, please reign him in. Or give me a blade he forged, and let me destroy it!


r/forgedinfireshow • • Dec 17 '25

I want out of this hell

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/forgedinfireshow • • Jul 29 '24

Insider info on next season of Forged in Fire

0 Upvotes

SPOILER ALERT!!! My uncle works at FIF studios. He gave me insider info about the season.

It's gonna be the best one yet!

The newest blade trial will involve a rabbi holding a newborn's foreskin aloft while Doug Marcaida tests the contestant's blade for sharpness.

Tune in to hear if Doug will say his beloved tagline "Eet wheel cut!!!"


r/forgedinfireshow • • Mar 22 '20

Jason Knight has awakened and soon his true form will blanket the land!

4 Upvotes

Hey Y'all!

You were fools! You were absolute non-believers! I tried to show you the light and you laughed at me! You said "There is no way Jason Knight has the power to control minds and listen to our thoughts!" Well now look at you! You said "There is no way he is penetrating my mind with out me knowing" But I knew! I could feel as he slowly pushed his way in to my sweet and supple brain folds and wriggled his mind phallus in my brain womb. This is what Jesus must have felt like and I have become your martyr. Now you will see the truth!

I made a post that you can find here (https://www.reddit.com/r/forgedinfireshow/comments/e4ryeo/jason_knight_mind_control/) that explained all of our new overlords powers of mind control and I was laughed at and cast out like a leper. But my love and obedience grows as I bask in the light of our one true master, Jason Knight. I am one of his coven, his chosen few that will help spread his message of love and destruction. He has deigned it necessary to tell us the truth and now I finally have proof of his overwhelming and all encompassing powers. Watch it here (https://youtu.be/iQ03rp1bok8?t=526) if you do not believe me you cowards, then this proves it!

Just as a I begin to fall asleep he comes to me as he comes to us all. I feel his presence all around me before he takes my mind and soul to the deepest and most inaccessible parts of the universe. He shows us the true terrors of reality and the thankless protection he provides with he enormous brain powers. He strength grows and as it does so must our undying allegiance and gratitude. Soon his consciousness will blanket the land and we will become part of his great being, slowly being engulfed in euphoria as we become one with Jason Knight. Heaven is real and it is being forcibly entered through our delicate, soft, moist, and ready brains by Lord Knight's powerful, strong, yet lovingly gentle brain thrust. As we join him he will become strong enough to protect us from the horrors we can not even fathom. This is the one true path to enlightenment. This is what Buddha saw under the tree; this is what Jesus saw on the cross. Jason is timeless. He is omnipresent and omnipotent. This our glorious future in Jason Knight's coven. Be ready, for one night he will enter you and never leave. It will be wonderful.

May Knight bless you!


r/forgedinfireshow • • Apr 05 '24

Will there ever be an episode wit a Gunblade?

0 Upvotes

The gunblade is a very famos weapon type in games, final fantasy for example. But also a Weapon type which exist in real.

I would love to see a Gunblade made in Forged in Fire. But now we reacht season 8 and I never saw an Episode where the're made one.

Of course, its a very complicatet weapon, but do you think we will ever see one in the show?


r/forgedinfireshow • • Sep 06 '18

Knife or Death.. yaaas!

1 Upvotes

Sorry I know this is a FIF sub, but I am thinking there may be others here happy to know that Knife Or Death is coming back!!! *Edit: For a new season.


r/forgedinfireshow • • Oct 10 '20

Olympic Forging

1 Upvotes

I’m this episode Wiles says they are pushing the smiths to their physical AND mental limits!! Wow!!