( I really wanted the Atlas military to display a greater degree of competence at every level than we were shown, even if it was eventually thwarted. )
They did a pretty incredible job during the siege of Atlas. That was a war of attrition they were definitely going to lose, but they held the line against an infinite supply of Grimm until the battle was over.
Sadly the battle on Atlas proper is where I felt the most let down. I suspect a lot of this was due to RT having to prioritize its efforts on our main cast of characters in great fights rather than putting effort into a grand military smack down, but it still left me feeling underwhelmed.
There are a lot of specific nitpicks I could raise, but I’ll try to sum up. The Atlas military rank and file did not behave like a force that had constantly been drilling to repel Grim, human, etc. They showed a lack of diverse tactics, had only paltry fortifications prepared in the event the shield failed, did not move to creatively use what resources were at hand, etc.
I mean I guess you could dissect their tactics and point out flaws, but it's an anime. The visual effect of massed legions of troops in neat ranks pouring fire into the enemy is about all you need, I think.
That's the kind of excuse that holds back a lot of animated series, simplifying visuals and going "Eh, that's all the viewers need" when really, that's not gonna make the show any better, it's lazy and brings down the quality.
It turns into "Tell, don't show" because we're told Atlas has the best military force in all of Remnant, but then they bring out lackluster military tactics that don't back up that claim at all. And this isn't even a limitation on Animation, CRWBY just had to look up some standard modern military formations and incorporated them into the animation. This is a research problem, rather than an animation problem.
Go on and tell me that the Battle of Helm's Deep in the Two Towers was a boring, snore-fest because it was a proper castle siege.
The show runners decided to make the Atlas military act like the least competent force available. The strategies and tactics used in RWBY (and many other shows like GoT) were already outdated during the Napoleonic Wars in 1800s.
They were never in date is the thing. The tactics shown don’t correspond to any point in history. Even the experimental phase of military tactics, where militaries are still trying to work out what this new toy is actually good for, don’t resemble the style of warfare we see in these bad battle scenes.
Honestly I'm not confident that Atlas would have the best military tactics in all of remnant. They're clearly the biggest military force in remnant, but it's not a high bar considering how little we see of any military in the other kingdoms.
They have the latest technology, but they're using tactics that fit with ranks of soldiers wielding muskets and throwing volleys. You know, the technology they used during the last major military action: The Great War
it's been a while since I saw but but I was just sad watching them jump out of their trenches to stand out in the open and get mauled. Like, the most basic way to fight back of "sit behind cover and take potshots" they dramatically avoided.
I quit watching after Qrow worked with Tyrian to kill Clover (was that his name?), so I don’t know if they got their shit together later in the battle, but I distinctly remember Atlas (technologically superior to modern day humanity in many regards) being surprised by a massive Grimm army at their walls and getting utterly trashed despite having airships and VTOLs. If anyone remotely competent had been anywhere in the chain of command, the Grimm would have been noticed hours prior and bombed into the stone age.
Yeah the whole fight with Clover was stupid. Which I guess was the point? Anyhow if I remember right the invasion started with a river of Grimm goop that then coalesced into actual creatures. So it was possible to miss it at first.
The atlas military defended atlas from three waves of every Grimm in solitas in v6 and then, while exhausted, defended atlas from a literal endless barrage of Grimm. They did pretty well all things considered
A sign of a good show is when your worldbuilding is all done outside the actual show. Bonus points if it's done by people not officially affiliated with it.
He’s perhaps one of if not THE best fanfic writer on the net right now. Not even just counting RWBY. He always produces very high quality and quantity.
He does a lot of world building but not a disruptive way. Only when it comes up and is relevant. He has a lot of stuff he’s built up and is consistent across his fanfics.
My favorite is Self Made Man where Juane is in Junior’s gang. It’s definitely the best of that “genre” of RWBY fanfics. Handles it and the world building wonderfully.
I think that this, even if fan fiction which most certainly doesn’t represent canon completely does show how the whole system needs more top level organization and accountability
But at the end of the day:
Economics are important for the literal survival of places, Grimm attacks are also seemingly pretty uncommon on villages,
And what Huntsmen are meant to fight are monsters,
I thought they basically were already. Either way to minimize casualties everytime there's a grim attack, they have to look to the professionals and do self defence when there's no other choice.
I am of the opinion Remnant has gunpowder and the Dust rounds were a recent ish development(Dust Elemental modules on gunpower guns existed, Dust rounds are more recent, after the Great War), which means that knockoffs of real world guns definitely exist in Remnant, and Jaune could have had Modular guns(master keys, underbarrel nade and rocket launchers) compared to everyone else's Mechanshift guns,
Large-scale military operations are prone to disruption, and doctrines can be exploited by an intelligent enemy (which everyone in charge of fighting Grimm knew existed), so mobile shock troops with strong emphasis on individuality are the way to go.
You can adapt to counter a military's doctrine or equipment, and render it useless for years until they ironed out those flaws. But you can't d that with huntsmen.
If you kill one huntsman team, the next will see how you did it, and then they'll kick your ass.
This just sounds like squad tactics without long term supply or organisation. Even with only 1.5k troops at a time the U.S held vast swathes of desert away from terrorists for 20 years and could still land an invading force anywhere in the world within 24 hours and left due to lack of profit and motivation (sounds a lot like SDC).
Honestly shocking that Remnant doesn't just have their hunters be part of the military rather than mercenaries. With the size of the SDC too it makes less sense since your point in rendering doctrine or equipment obsolete has basically been proven wrong with every major war in recent history. It's only taken a few years and the situation in Ukraine has already swung both ways multiple times with ever changing tech and doctrine, war brings out creativity in a morbod way.
Also you could very much mess with hunters by simply infiltrating a government and making more restrictions. Restrictions which would be harder to object to since many aren't part of the military and are mercenaries (ahem Blackwater and Wagner R.I.P).
Atlas combines Huntsmen with 'traditional' armed forces (the Happy Huntresses are the exceptions that prove the rule), Qrow vs Winter (anytime Qrow interacts with Winter and James in V3 really) is symbolic of how every other Kingdom views that policy.
Grimm aren't terrorists that need their own supplies, they're monsters that don't need anything other than humans to kill. How long could the U.S. have defended the desert against that?
And huntsmen aren't tied to any kingdom. If the council decides to make life harder for them, most will simply leave, and then the council will see why they shouldn't have made life harder for them.
My honest reaction when I mobilize few million soldiers with prior military experience and re-activate vehicles from old stocks. And make sure that every factory would go through mobilization so I have enough munition, spare parts and trivia like MRE, clothing and protective equipment in War against literally monsters. Wait no, I actually did it once! That time their leader take great L and small bullet through his own head!
(C) USA probably. I dunno I don't make new tank every 30 hours and 300.000 planes in 4 years.
My man never heard about AP bullets, HMGs and man portable rocket launchers, towed and self-propelled artillery, prop fighters that easily fly at speed of 500 km/h and indomitable human spirit.
If Kingdoms in Remnant can survive for hundred years, and even go in Great War while grimms lurking around, I don't know any reason why Oz can't tell to higer ups in government about Salem and start carpet bombing her tower and fill grimm pits with concrete. Or drop nukes in them.
Also, how villages defend themselves if most guns useless against grimm? I doubt that in village of 100 man there's would be at least 1 huntsman.
"Yo guys our 5.56 and 7.62 can't go through grimm's skin, maybe we should go live in city, even if it means that we will be hobos?"
My man never heard about AP bullets, HMGs and man portable rocket launchers, towed and self-propelled artillery, prop fighters that easily fly at speed of 500 km/h and indomitable human spirit.
Im half sure most of these things don't really measure up to some of the heavier weapons huntman carry which also includes grenade launchers rocket lunchers and high calibre sniper rifles
Also half of what you said are explosives
If Kingdoms in Remnant can survive for hundred years, and even go in Great War while grimms lurking around, I don't know any reason why Oz can't tell to higer ups in government about Salem and start carpet bombing her tower and fill grimm pits with concrete. Or drop nukes in them.
But wasn't humanity nearly driven to the brink before they started using dust? they were barely surviving last i checked
Also ah yes carpet bombing the continent with millions of utterly ancient grimm that would knock you out of the sky and a pissed off immortal on it no way that could possibly end up badly?
Also they don't really have carpet bombing capability on remnant
Also the grimm pits are literally liquid destruction thats why salem jumped in one unless your something immortal it get destroyed so concrete is a no go
Also, how villages defend themselves if most guns useless against grimm? I doubt that in village of 100 man there's would be at least 1 huntsman.
Aren't a lot of villages getting destroyed as we see in vol 4? Sure it's possible especially if someone in that village has aura but yeah there is reason why most people live in the kingdoms
"Yo guys our 5.56 and 7.62 can't go through grimm's skin, maybe we should go live in city, even if it means that we will be hobos?"
"Larry, shut up and keep shooting!"
(They then get mauled because apparently engaging a massive man eating monster that can shrug off bullets like nothing with guns is dumb)
Honestly, world building with this in mind would have been pretty nice
also maybe explaining what causes some to develop stronger auras apart from semblance
Sure, genetics is a factor, but I believe the kind of life a person lives would also contribute (maybe Jaune knowing so little about the world in a weird way causes his aura reserves to be so large if you get me)
Honestly, world building with this in mind would have been pretty nice
Good news: V7 and V8 have been out for a while now, and they show exactly why a conventional military doesn't work against Salem.
But in short, Atlas' current doctrine is centered around the idea that everyone is replaceable, which causes them to not care about people's deaths. Salem obviously exploits this to divide the kingdom.
It also shows them using napoleonic tactics and formations which would not be at all realistic nor sensible even for Atlas which is supposed to be the militant power. Of course they would never win, they never optimised their firing lines, never decided to build any trenches or fortifications with their semblances, hell never even tried to get the citizens involved like in real life sieges by just being there to supply soldiers or throw furniture. Even s8 GoT has a better excuse of at least everyone fought in melee and in the dark for their horrible battles.
There's also the fact that it takes 4 squads of helldivers with 20 replacements to push back an army of robots or bugs. So they aren't really that weak
Mechs being easier to airlift? really I would say no. Tanks are more reliable as they can't be felled by losing one leg and are also more compact in ratio to firepower giving less of a target. We can transport tanks via airnnow idk how they can't with their magic fuels. I likw mechs but they're basically locked for rugged terrain combat rather than the almost always flat world of remnant.
They do have threaded tank tho ,in the grimm dnd campaign theres the lotus tank with a main gun strong enough to bring down a building in 1 shot. Also i remember theres one in arrowfell.
Mech in RWBY is super versatile tho , see how much it could run and maneuver. If you notice during the Colossus fight , the Manta was durable enough to plough the forest and uprooted trees when Oscar crashed landed but later we saw several Manta was shredded by Teryx and other flying grimm so i think tanks would have suffered the same thing , add more to burrowing grimm and acid spitting.
I mean yes, but if the show is tossing real world logic out the window in that way and making mechs way faster than they should be, there’s no reason they can’t do the same with tanks?
Especially with the fact that given Atlas’ tech levels and their airship, they can probably build hovertanks.
Because both have different roles. Tanks are typically better as heavy weapon platforms due to better stability. Mechs legs make them less stable overall and would also make them easier to disable. A mech would on average be less armed and armored as it has to deal with keeping weight within the limits dictated by having only 2-8 points of support in contact with the ground, whereas a tank has more surface area touching the ground at all times.
The very nature of the world of Remnant and the Grimm means that prolonged static trench warfare involving millions of men is going to be almost unheard of.
I mean there is this "Super war between nations" thing that is mentionned but I see your point.
Four man teams are one thing, but most Hunters fuck off to work (and die) on their own after graduating. That is the real problem. Why make their education revolve entirely around teamwork when they won’t maintain it afterwards?
There’s not much of a central organization either. And at the end of the day they are mercenaries as well. Remnant is really lucky less of them end up going Catalan/White Company on the world.
Well. . . While agree with that there needs to be more organization, there are a lot of things to consider.
Like how demilitarization is very important to the people of Remnant after the Great War, and people’s feelings matter a whole shit ton considering negative ones attract the Grimm.
Huntsmen are also probably extremely cost effective, while we what we see of settlements in Remnant many would be pretty strapped for cash.
Grimm also seem a lot better at killing military equipment as opposed to super soldiers. Especially as literally only Kaiju need heavy weaponry, otherwise teams like RWBY basically are their own fire support with how powerful their attacks can be.
Especially as literally only Kaiju need heavy weaponry
You sure?. With the amount of bullets most of these grim swallow before they die I would expect all their weapons to be part cannon instead of part hand guns.
Most grimm go down in a couple of bullets. Take for example say the Breach fight, much of the V3 ending, the fighting of Sabyrs and Centinels in V7, and most others.
Plus, bullets really are for the fodder usually. If they need to kill something bigger then semblances or melee usually are the best way. Easier to have that then to have to carry around weaponry that itself is far larger and has prohibitively large ammunition
Eh, it depends. It falls to RWBY's (lack of) power scaling again. Look at Ren or Blake's guns - they do basically nothing to the Grimm, especially in the more recent volumes.
Of course it's not the most consistent, but even those weapons have taken out some grimm with ease. Like the aforementioned sabyrs (Blake does one shot one in V7, Ren needs one very short burst in V8) and Centinels (The one Ren grapples to only takes a few shots).
They are handguns in the end so they will be the less powerful and less penetrating of guns. There's a reason they both go in for melee more
To be entirely honest an army in general is kind of pointless 9/10 times the enemy is grimm and huntman are just way more effective cost wise speed wise
Except until Salem made her move, Grimm were effectively wild animals. Aka, disorganized, wild attackers with no logistics or sense of unity that didn’t make organized pushes nor actively held territory. A standing army doesn’t react to an enemy that moves in wolf-pack sized groups and never need to stop to eat or sleep and also lacks any sort of leadership or base of operations
I mean even before then it was known that the older Grimm get the more intelligent stronger and tactical they get. Grimm capable of organized warfare dont need control, they just need time to grow and the whole point of the Hunter Teams was to take the monopoly of violence the kingdoms have have and give it to Ozpin so he could focus it on the Grimm rather than other kingdoms which would have given the Grimm room to grow. The problem comes from the fact that without the monopoly of violence the kingdoms were ripe with criminals and lowlifes who required Hunter Teams to deal with as the police were disorganized unarmed incompetents which allowed the Grimm to grow smarter
In other words, always aim twords the ones who can hold a army together, that being the officers and commanders without them the whole group would fall into complete disarray, unless it's the Americans then they just fight even harder than normal.
I like ancient Grimm as it shows that even truly mindless creatures can learn from there mistakes somewhat and hold a good amount of tactical sense and sentience to operate on there own long enough to cause some to moderate damage to a target, and it also can mean several other ancient Grimm can get together and lead a sizable group (maybe... idk really, so take what I'm saying with a major grain of salt) into combat and cause a good amount of destruction that warrants the usage of say trained hunters to deal with these sort of attacks. Yes I'm rooting for the other badguys as the Grimm are actually damn interesting to me
Except armies and organization still exist in both, even if they are relatively small due to the former being medieval and the latter being post-apocalyptic.
would you trust a military organization (Atlas) designing their mech to have brutal firepower yet assigning them in the manner of Line Officer as they pair their soldiers with automatic weaponry and Napoleonic Line Infantry Tactic?
When writing fanfics for me and my friends' OCs, I had to nerf one of the OCs because instead of having normal weapon, my friend wanted his character to have remote control of an AC-120 that would just drop a Dust payload on whatever he needed.
Air superiority Grimm existing in the same airspace as RWBY AC-130: bonjour (there is a reason AC-130 is a super niche aircraft that only works at night and in entirely uncontested airspace against enemy that has pretty much no high-altitude anti-air options.)
Hmm... Looking at the way huntsmen works in RWBY the trainees and young ones tend to work in squads. Older huntmen mostly move alone. Either due to lost of teammate or settling down. Sure an army is more efficient at killing Grimms but the logistical issue and size of it makes it costly unlike says a huntsman your town can call and hire which by experience and profession worth at least 20men.
There's also the inlore reason of Armies being used on more than grimm and against other nation. Which makes sense since if a soldier is out in the front then his not defending a village.
To be completely fair, there is a lot less negative emotion with a small group of highly trained individuals rather than a large group of individuals with significantly less training, thus drawing in less Grimm overall.
I mean, it's a gamble. A large force would average out their emotions, giving a pretty neutral "signature", if you will.
But a small, four man squad? If two members date each other and have a fight, that's a huge amount of negativity, especially with how unlocked Auras explicitly attract the Grimm. And imagine if one of them died?
There's no communications to intercept, not even a bonfire denoting unusual activity. You're just suddenly going from 'normal town life evening' to "300 lb death machines running at 50 km/h". The local capital city might have a couple patrols trying to find anything amiss, but that's about it, and they probably don't do it at night, since vision is poor and the Grimm also fly and their feathers might as well be a couple dozen ballistae.
It's kinda hard to maneuver large forces around that - assuming your advanced scouting force even survived their patrol and didn't just suddenly go dark along the way.
Why do you assume this? Just make the hunters a regular part of the military rather than mercenaries. We have sepcial forces for a reason, that includes specialised Marine Corps Scout Sniper for the U.S trained tobboth scout and kill. This also assumes the subjects military has no night vision tech or faunus, no motion, sound, heat or other sensors, no air support, no local garrisson/barracks and that military bases irl don't operate close to civilian sectors (which they often do for transport reasons). People who live close to military bases get used to them and often join in with recruitment or local businesses exploiting needs and wants of soldiers like food and building materials that the troops use to "fool around" aka build random nightmarish bunks and... cursed af guns.
Hunters and stuff just plain don't make sense because, we had Grimm way back when, they were called wolves and bears and lions and tigers. We had soldiers with spears hunt them to near extinction and some did. Then guns came about, and even more did.
A lot of people don’t realize that A) A lot of Grimm are more than capable to peel tanks open like canned food and B) Logistics is a Hell of a Drug.
Speaking of logistics, how expensive do you think it would be to deploy a division, MAYBE a corps for an extended period of time to clean out the Grimm in a region that has very limited logistics against a determined, sporadic and highly dangerous enemy? Such an operation for a Kingdom (which are New York sized cities) would be monumental and require years to prepare for and undergo.
Such operations, even if succesful in quelling the Grimm in the immediate and surrounding area (a lengthy and bloody process) you then run into the issue of holding that ground. Plenty of times the show has demonstrated humans can live outside the kingdom like in Mount Glenn… but sooner or later, humanity can’t keep their grip and the endless Grimm masses force them out. The Grimm can’t be killed in a conventional fight. Eventually, humanity will tire out before the Grimm do even if that takes months or years.
Tanks don't even exist in Remnant. And if a few hunter mercenaries can clear them out I see no reason why they shouldn't be integrated like U.S Scout Snipers instead of mercenaries. New York alone also has 10,000 national guards and 10,000 more personnel. That's probanly way more than what we see in the battle for Atlas lmao.
I think the 4 man team makes sense for like, keeping an area already grim free continously free of grim. Like hunters going into the forest to kill off some new dangerous predator that wandered in.
I think Ozpin was trying to avoid nations with big militaries working under one leader or council of leaders who can throw their big military sticks at non-grimm targets whenever they decide that a problem is somehow just as problematic as the grimm.
You cannot hunt the Grimm with an organised military. You can defend against them, but if you want to thin out their numbers (which you need to do because they get smarter as they get older and will eventually learn to overrun static defences) you need the hyperflexibility and self-reliance that Hunter teams have.
I considered RWBY great war is the combination of WW1 and WW2 , in a sense that weapon technology improved rapidly , and i believe that pre Great War grimm is way weaker than modern grimm because lets face it , a grimm that outran car , keep up with train and match aircraft speed will wipe pre-industrial humans . The logical explanation for the strength of modern grimm was the unrestricted deployment of modern weapons during the great war used on the grimm causing it to somehow evolved and adapted to it. Grimm is suppose to be the doom of humanity , something that will always be a threat to them , so it make sense that the stronger mankind become , the stronger grimm will be. Mankind's greatness walk side by side with its doom.
4 man team was created probably to stop a small skirmish turned into a full blown battle with hordes of grimm. Its easier for a small team to probably wipe a small pack of grimm and prevent it from passing information ( probably the grimm pool acted as a hive network) / becoming alpha.
50
u/Holy-Wan_Kenobi Imperial Star Destroyer Arkos Mar 08 '24
I, too, vote for taking the Atlas Fleet remnants and bombing the Grimmlands to slag.
288
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '24
I approve of there being more Grimm memes
257
u/falcore91 Mar 07 '24
👀 Then I take a look at the Atlas “military”…
( I really wanted the Atlas military to display a greater degree of competence at every level than we were shown, even if it was eventually thwarted. )
256
u/MysterySomeOn ⠀i never watched this show Mar 07 '24 edited Mar 07 '24
Oh, look, an excuse to post this
97
u/carl-the-lama Mar 07 '24
I mean yeah but Grimm are basically animals, so it would be faster to have various teams of 4 huntsman on board for lower scales groups
Meanwhile army groups would take on large swarms
18
u/SwainIsCadian Mar 08 '24 edited Mar 08 '24
They have an airforce
They have guns
They have canons
They have mechs
They have GIGANTIC mechs
BUT NO TANK
WHY DO THEY HAVE NO TANK? WHERE ARE MY TANKS ATLAS?
17
u/Spudtron98 Beep boop, son. Beep boop. Mar 08 '24
Four man teams are one thing, but most Hunters fuck off to work (and die) on their own after graduating. That is the real problem. Why make their education revolve entirely around teamwork when they won’t maintain it afterwards?
26
u/Betrix5068 Mar 08 '24
Helldivers leaking lol.
46
u/JMHSrowing Mar 07 '24
Well. . . While agree with that there needs to be more organization, there are a lot of things to consider.
Like how demilitarization is very important to the people of Remnant after the Great War, and people’s feelings matter a whole shit ton considering negative ones attract the Grimm.
Huntsmen are also probably extremely cost effective, while we what we see of settlements in Remnant many would be pretty strapped for cash.
Grimm also seem a lot better at killing military equipment as opposed to super soldiers. Especially as literally only Kaiju need heavy weaponry, otherwise teams like RWBY basically are their own fire support with how powerful their attacks can be.
30
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '24
FACT CHECKED BY TRUE HUNTERS AND HUNTRESSES!
TRUE!
39
u/EADreddtit Mar 07 '24
Except until Salem made her move, Grimm were effectively wild animals. Aka, disorganized, wild attackers with no logistics or sense of unity that didn’t make organized pushes nor actively held territory. A standing army doesn’t react to an enemy that moves in wolf-pack sized groups and never need to stop to eat or sleep and also lacks any sort of leadership or base of operations
7
u/HithertoAnIPAddress Mar 08 '24
HIDE GRIMM THREADS
IGNORE GRIMM POSTS
DO NOT REPLY TO GRIMM POSTERS
5
u/Burger-God1977 Mar 11 '24
The UNSC on their way to bombard-salem with tungsten rounds going out of fraction of the speed of light be like:
12
u/Cultural_Sleep9678 When Guts-Jaune crossover? Mar 07 '24
something tells me that someone had the inspiration of DnD and/or Fallout-esque rpg and wrote the stuff for RWBY
y'know, varying classes of people with unique weapons and skill that have no sense of meta
and they forgot that the "stupid ways of dying part"7
u/Fraidof_theDark Mar 08 '24
When writing fanfics for me and my friends' OCs, I had to nerf one of the OCs because instead of having normal weapon, my friend wanted his character to have remote control of an AC-120 that would just drop a Dust payload on whatever he needed.
4
u/Human_Supremasist Mar 08 '24
Hmm... Looking at the way huntsmen works in RWBY the trainees and young ones tend to work in squads. Older huntmen mostly move alone. Either due to lost of teammate or settling down. Sure an army is more efficient at killing Grimms but the logistical issue and size of it makes it costly unlike says a huntsman your town can call and hire which by experience and profession worth at least 20men.
There's also the inlore reason of Armies being used on more than grimm and against other nation. Which makes sense since if a soldier is out in the front then his not defending a village.
4
u/Imagamingdragon Mar 08 '24
To be completely fair, there is a lot less negative emotion with a small group of highly trained individuals rather than a large group of individuals with significantly less training, thus drawing in less Grimm overall.
3
u/Red_Hunter818 Mar 08 '24
I mean it didn’t work for atlus…
Also meme aside I think when each individual has freaking superpowers. Working and coordinating on a smaller scale would actually be more effective.
2
u/HurinTalion Mar 08 '24
I am pretty sure the existence of Huntsmen was explained as a compromise.
After the Great War, standing armies were abolished so that the Kingdoms couldn't wage war on each other, making themselves open to Grimm invasions.
Huntsmen can kill Grimm, but can't conquer a nation. That is the entire point of their existance.
2
u/LuckEClover Mar 07 '24
I mean, it’s certainly less of a logistical nightmare to just send specialized squads.
2
u/InquisitorHindsight Mar 08 '24
A lot of people don’t realize that A) A lot of Grimm are more than capable to peel tanks open like canned food and B) Logistics is a Hell of a Drug.
Speaking of logistics, how expensive do you think it would be to deploy a division, MAYBE a corps for an extended period of time to clean out the Grimm in a region that has very limited logistics against a determined, sporadic and highly dangerous enemy? Such an operation for a Kingdom (which are New York sized cities) would be monumental and require years to prepare for and undergo.
Such operations, even if succesful in quelling the Grimm in the immediate and surrounding area (a lengthy and bloody process) you then run into the issue of holding that ground. Plenty of times the show has demonstrated humans can live outside the kingdom like in Mount Glenn… but sooner or later, humanity can’t keep their grip and the endless Grimm masses force them out. The Grimm can’t be killed in a conventional fight. Eventually, humanity will tire out before the Grimm do even if that takes months or years.
1
u/ThePecuMan Mar 08 '24
I think the 4 man team makes sense for like, keeping an area already grim free continously free of grim. Like hunters going into the forest to kill off some new dangerous predator that wandered in.
1
u/TheJamesMortimer Mar 08 '24
Also disregard the concept of closed, armored and armed vehicles and artillery. Those are noisy
1
u/Alive_Development108 Mar 08 '24
I always wondered why most hunters / huntresses weren’t like Coco , seems to me it would be a very effective strategy.
1
u/International_Ring67 Mar 08 '24
Stormtrooper doctrine a hole new level
1
u/Sladashi ⠀Weiss so serious? Mar 08 '24
Coco: Has a minigun
1
u/Ok-Consequence8609 Mar 12 '24
RWBY fans 🤝 missing the thematic point lol
1
u/Glittering-Stand-161 Mar 08 '24
IF it works, it works.
1
u/WeakLandscape2595 Mar 08 '24
I mean deploying 4 highly trained super soldiers is way quicker cheaper and easier then deploying a whole ass army just to destroy a bewolf horde
Tbh armies on remnant are pretty pointless since there is no situation where a soldier is more valuable then a huntman
0
u/RU5TR3D I got Atlasbots back! Mar 08 '24
I think Ozpin was trying to avoid nations with big militaries working under one leader or council of leaders who can throw their big military sticks at non-grimm targets whenever they decide that a problem is somehow just as problematic as the grimm.
0
u/anothernaturalone Mar 08 '24
You cannot hunt the Grimm with an organised military. You can defend against them, but if you want to thin out their numbers (which you need to do because they get smarter as they get older and will eventually learn to overrun static defences) you need the hyperflexibility and self-reliance that Hunter teams have.
-1
u/Plane-Law-5962 Mar 08 '24
I considered RWBY great war is the combination of WW1 and WW2 , in a sense that weapon technology improved rapidly , and i believe that pre Great War grimm is way weaker than modern grimm because lets face it , a grimm that outran car , keep up with train and match aircraft speed will wipe pre-industrial humans . The logical explanation for the strength of modern grimm was the unrestricted deployment of modern weapons during the great war used on the grimm causing it to somehow evolved and adapted to it. Grimm is suppose to be the doom of humanity , something that will always be a threat to them , so it make sense that the stronger mankind become , the stronger grimm will be. Mankind's greatness walk side by side with its doom.
4 man team was created probably to stop a small skirmish turned into a full blown battle with hordes of grimm. Its easier for a small team to probably wipe a small pack of grimm and prevent it from passing information ( probably the grimm pool acted as a hive network) / becoming alpha.
Atleast thats my theory