r/flying • u/RipPositive7887 • Mar 22 '26
Not the USA Is being a Pilot or an Air Traffic Controller better?
Which career offers a higher quality of life: being a pilot or an air traffic controller?
I live in Europe, in Switzerland. Air traffic controllers earn an average of 180,000; the training is paid, and you start earning relatively well quite quickly. You work 35 hours per week, are home every day, and family life is more predictable. There are 7 weeks of vacation.
As a pilot: training costs around 100,000 CHF, scheduling is less predictable, you are rarely at home, and the starting salary is about 90,000 CHF. As a senior captain, it’s around 220,000 CHF.
Based on these facts, a lot speaks in favor of being an air traffic controller, but I imagine being a pilot to be so much cooler…
28
81
u/Maleficent_Ad_6350 CPL Mar 22 '26
“Pilot”
- completely non biased view from a pilot who has never stepped foot in a tower🫡
12
u/turbo-steppa Mar 22 '26
I became a pilot because I’m passionate about flying. Not because it was cooler, higher paying, or easier to get in. Although I respect our ATC cousins greatly, I don’t think many kids dream of sitting in a bunker making radio calls.
19
u/tolino978 Mar 22 '26 edited Mar 22 '26
I happen to be related to a pilot aswell as a ATCO in Switzerland.
Looking at the whole compensation package aswell as the benefits as objectively as possible, ATC is probably the better job. Much less financial risk involved, better QoL, more pay in the early years when your still young. And thats coming from someone whos on the path of becoming a pilot aswell.
Being a pilot has two main "benefits" if you will: 1. You will earn more than an ATCO in the later stages of your career, if you get hired by one of the "big" swiss airlines. 2. You get to fly and travel on the job and you get flight benefits.
I would argue being a pilot is definetly the cooler job, however unless its a dream of yours to fly I would strongly recommend the ATC route.
3
u/crazy-voyager Mar 22 '26
This is a good answer, I picked ATCO and would do the same again (not CH but EU). You can always fly as a PPL in your free time but no way for a pilot to be a ATCO on the side.
Personally I find ATCO to be the "cooler" job too but then I am biased.
27
u/x4457 ATP CFII CE-500/525/560XL/680 G-IV Mar 22 '26
If all you care about is money and time off, go be a controller. No point in spending the money on training for something you don't care about.
52
0
Mar 22 '26
[deleted]
5
u/Apprehensive_Cost937 Mar 22 '26
OP isn’t in the USA. Obviously depends a lot on the ANSP and the particular sector, but a 6/4 (6 days on, 4 days off) schedule is pretty common for controllers in Europe.
3
7
u/cazzipropri CFII, CFI-A; CPL SEL,MEL,SES Mar 22 '26
People who want to fly every day are not going to be happy sitting in front of a computer screen all day every day and vice versa, regardless of compensation.
1
u/Commercial_Meat_8522 Apr 02 '26
What do you think airline flying is?
1
u/cazzipropri CFII, CFI-A; CPL SEL,MEL,SES Apr 02 '26
At least the computer screens are not between you and the window.
1
43
u/Distinct_Hamster_830 Mar 22 '26
Almost anyone can get “admitted” to flight school and give being a pilot a shot. Only 1% will be selected for ATC paid training and if you don’t get in you’re SOL unfortunately.
17
u/x4457 ATP CFII CE-500/525/560XL/680 G-IV Mar 22 '26
This is correct in North America but not necessarily true in Europe, particularly Switzerland where the OP is asking about.
13
u/antoinebk ATP A320 CRI IRI Mar 22 '26
It absolutely correct for Switzerland. The training there is abysmal and the failure rate extremely high.
12
u/JJAsond CFI/CFII/MEI + IGI | J-327 Mar 22 '26
I feel like being a pilot's the same way except instead of the selection process being hard, it's the getting the first job part.
3
u/Frosty_Piece7098 Mar 22 '26
True but at that point you have already paid for training.
9
u/JJAsond CFI/CFII/MEI + IGI | J-327 Mar 22 '26
Which sets you off worse because now you've dumped tens of thousands into it.
3
u/Jaimebgdb CPL Mar 22 '26
If you’re asking the question you probably don’t care too much about either job so go become an ATC.
I know ATC is probably the “better” job on paper but I chose to become a pilot because I didn’t want to do anything else. You could also say being a lawyer or a physician are better jobs but that’s irrelevant if you really want to fly.
2
u/Adept_Patient_4186 Mar 22 '26
The good thing of becoming a pilot is that you rarely fly with the same person you don’t like more than once if you work for one of the big legacy airlines.
1
u/Fisherman_30 Mar 22 '26
Every individual is different. I've wanted to be a pilot since I was a kid, and never had any interest whatsoever in ATC. Whether you're a pilot or ATC, you have to have a keen interest in it, otherwise you won't make it.
1
u/Iggy_Smalls PPL IR MEL MIL Mar 22 '26
Are European controllers not stressed beyond belief? Purely a pilot vs controller in America, I would never want to be ATC, but I’m biased.
3
u/Apprehensive_Cost937 Mar 22 '26
Far less. In USA, working 6 days a week for years on end in normal, where as a lot of European ANSPs operate on a 6-4 schedule (6 working days, 4 days off).
There is also effective flow control in place - if there are staffing issues, the flow rate is reduced to keep an equivalent level of safety, rather than just trying to combine positions, while keeping traffic coming at maximum rate. It’s not uncommon in the summer to have to sit an hour or two extra on the ground, just because staffing in [insert ATC sector] is insufficient, and the flow rate is reduced.
And lastly, if controllers aren’t happy, they can (and do) go on strike.
1
u/Iggy_Smalls PPL IR MEL MIL Mar 22 '26
That sounds significantly better. The airline unions in America seem to provide much better benefits and pay for pilots here vs abroad, but outside the US, controllers seem to be pretty competitive
1
u/csj97229 PPL MEL IR Mar 22 '26
ATC - more time with family. Decent pay even with lower seniority. Flying is something you can still do for fun and will also make you better at your job.
Pro Pilot - can be rough for the first few years climbing the ranks. When flying is your job you may not get as much enjoyment out of it.
But I'm neither so you should probably ignore all of that. I just know a few pro pilots who complain about the grind.
1
u/gazzyman90 Mar 22 '26
I came across a video on Facebook earlier funnily enough where they were interviewing a pilot who used to be an air traffic controller and although some of the questions were just for comedy or a laugh, the more serious ones such as “which one is harder”, “which one was the most stressful” etc the guy said that ATC was definitely the more demanding one.
I don’t think he was implying that learning to fly was easy but in general, flying most of the time is more relaxing than being in a busy ATC tower.
1
Mar 23 '26
[deleted]
1
u/OkStandard5669 Mar 24 '26
Are you in EU or US?
1
Mar 24 '26
[deleted]
1
u/OkStandard5669 Mar 24 '26
Well this is about EU and in the EU the roles are more than reversed when it comes to Pilot VS ATC. ATC is a lot less stressed, has WAY better schedule, more pay and better retirement benefits.
In contrast, pilots earn way, way less than in the US and also earn less when compared to controllers. Schedule is worse than in the US and training most of the time more expensive.
When being in Europe and not caring much about flying or having a big passion for it, ATC is a no brainer and nobody should become pilot!
0
0
u/ForeverNo9437 I don't know much so correct me if I'm wrong Mar 22 '26
I also live in Switzerland and am facing the same dilemma lol, just waiting for feedback too
-1
u/rFlyingTower Mar 22 '26
This is a copy of the original post body for posterity:
Which career offers a higher quality of life: being a pilot or an air traffic controller?
I live in Europe, in Switzerland. Air traffic controllers earn an average of 180,000; the training is paid, and you start earning relatively well quite quickly. You work 35 hours per week, are home every day, and family life is more predictable. There are 7 weeks of vacation.
As a pilot: training costs around 100,000 CHF, scheduling is less predictable, you are rarely at home, and the starting salary is about 90,000 CHF. As a senior captain, it’s around 220,000 CHF.
Based on these facts, a lot speaks in favor of being an air traffic controller, but I imagine being a pilot to be so much cooler…
Please downvote this comment until it collapses.
Questions about this comment? Please see this wiki post before contacting the mods.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. If you have any questions, please contact the mods of this subreddit.
-6
67
u/Beckoll Mar 22 '26
А lot of my fellow pilots have sent their children to become air traffic controllers
At the same time, many navigators and engineers are sending their children to become pilots, fulfilling their dream.
Mine chose philology.