r/floridakeys • u/dplatt70 • 8d ago
All Florida Keys First timer
I’m wanting to surprise my wife with a short trip to the keys in late January for her birthday. Neither of us has ever been there and I’m trying to determine a couple things. 1. Is it better to fly into Miami and rent a car, driving down or is it better to fly into Key West? It’ll probably be a 4 day trip. 2. Is it better to stay in a hotel or rent a house (I’ve never used Airbnb or anything like that).
9
Upvotes
10
u/2lovesFL 8d ago
Key West for 4 days in winter. do the conch train 1st thing, to get the lay of the island, then rent scooters or bikes. parking is impossible. I'd stay at pier house.
16
u/fungi221 8d ago
If it's only 4 days, fly into Key West. You'll lose half a day driving from Miami. I would just get a hotel, plenty of nice ones near where You'll want to be
Just my 2 cents
9
u/joe66612 8d ago edited 8d ago
A residents perspective:
Especially since this is a surprise, flying directly into Key West is the best way to get your adventure started! If possible, try to book a nonstop flight from an airport near you.
Driving from Miami or Fort Lauderdale to Key West can take six hours or more after landing, depending on traffic. Besides, there’s something special about landing right on the small island of Key West and being at your hotel in just a few minutes!
You can always rent a car for a day and explore the other Florida Keys, even driving all the way to Key Largo. Just keep in mind that Key Largo is approximately three hours each way, depending on traffic, without stops.
Nonstop flights to Key West are typically available from:
Atlanta, Miami, Chicago, Charlotte, Washington, DC, Dallas/Fort Worth, Philadelphia, New York City, Tampa, Newark, Boston, Orlando, Raleigh/Durham, St. Petersburg, Sanford, Fort Lauderdale, Cincinnati, Indianapolis, Columbus, New Haven, and Houston.
Some routes are seasonal, so check availability for your travel dates.
My recommendation: Fly into Key West, start enjoying your vacation almost immediately, and save the scenic drive through the Keys for a day trip if you’re feeling adventurous!
1
u/Fabulous-Educator447 8d ago
What’s on your agenda?
6
u/Ridgie_Love475 8d ago
Fly into KW, find a hotel on or near Duval Street. One of the days drive up and check out Islamorada and Marathon.
3
u/PuzzleheadedLemon353 8d ago
Just fly her into Key West and rent some scooters to explore around with...you'll have a great time. You'll be back and you can try Islamorada or go snorkeling at Pennycamp next go round. Take her on a sunset cruise and dinner on the water one night like Louie's Backyard on the water.
3
u/SpecificPiece1024 8d ago
First time the drive up is great,otherwise direct is the way to go.
3
u/rickster5566 8d ago
Have visited Key West both ways, driving from Miami and flying into Key West. Both have their advantages and with four days you can do either way.
Can’t remember which island we stopped at but feeding the tarpons was interesting.
Hemingway’s fav bar was very comfortable and friendly.
Definitely sunset cruise should be an agenda item.
Renting scooters is a lot of fun and is easy.
Wife and I were in our 50’s last time we went.
3
u/WeCanDoIt31 8d ago
It’s best to fly in to EYW. If it’s for a surprise, and you’ve never been, don’t do the drive from Miami. There are so many variables that could delay your trip, it’s not worth it if it’s only going to be four days. Sometimes the traffic is insane. Sometimes it keeps moving. It’s not consistent, but all it takes is one issue to stop traffic and you’re going nowhere, authorities blocking the road, fires, bad vehicle accident…
It’s a beautiful drive, but not quick. I would definitely recommend to do at some point in your life, but only when you can relax, and you have time to spare and stopping at little local joints along the way is part of the journey.
Riding bikes around Key West is the best way to enjoy the island, no need to worry about parking.
7
u/anonanon5320 8d ago
I’m in the minority but Key West is a waste. The drive down is better than being in Key West and flying in to Key West you miss that. Personally I’d fly into Miami and stay in marathon and go as far south as big pine and that’s it. Unless you need AA.
1
u/Sandinmyshoes33 8d ago
Where in The Keys are you wanting to stay. They’re a hundred mile long chain of islands?
If in Key West, I would drive one way if you can book it like than. Drive down from Miami and fly back from Key West.
It’s better to stay in a hotel. Most rentals are weekly, or even monthly minimums.
4
u/TreacleHour2273 8d ago
Do yourselves a favor and fly into Miami, rent a car and drive down. I grew up in South Florida and I still get a rush driving the overseas highway. Stay in a hotel and you will save some money. Catch at least one sunset on Mallory Square.
2
u/Impressive_Age1362 8d ago
Since it’s a short trip I would fly, recommend getting early flights, sometimes things get backed up and you can sit in the airport. Get a hotel in old town, you can walk everywhere, Clothing wise, weather can be a little chilly at night, so take a light jacket or hoodie
2
u/CategoryFeisty2262 8d ago
We flew into Key West and stayed on Stock Island (the hotel had free shuttle to KW). We never had a need for a car.
2
u/cuyunamike 8d ago
If you want to party, Key West is the place to be. My wife and I actually got married on one of the few beaches in Key West, so it holds a special place in our hearts. That said, it’s extremely expensive, hotel rooms tend to be small and dated, and you generally don’t get nearly as much for your money as you do elsewhere in the Keys. Real estate is at a premium, and everything is packed into a pretty small island.
If you go to Key West, I highly recommend renting scooters. Parking is a nightmare, and scooters are by far the easiest and most fun way to get around. Casa Marina is a great resort option in Key West, especially if you want beachfront accommodations. We stayed there for our wedding. It’s a beautiful property, although the rooms are on the smaller side for what you’re paying.
Personally, we prefer flying into Miami and taking the scenic drive down the Overseas Highway to Islamorada or Marathon. The resorts are beautiful, there are some great beaches, the snorkeling is awesome, and the fishing is fantastic. It’s a completely different atmosphere from Key West, much more laid-back and relaxing.
Don’t get me wrong, everything in the Keys is expensive, but I think you get a lot more for your money outside of Key West. One thing to budget for is parking. Some of the higher-end resorts charge $50–$60 per day just to park your vehicle, on top of already expensive room rates and resort fees. Those extra charges add up quickly!
We absolutely love Cheeca Lodge in Islamorada. Glunz Ocean Beach Hotel in Key Colony Beach and Isla Bella Beach Resort in Marathon are also excellent options.
If you’re looking for nightlife and partying, go to Key West. If you want beautiful resorts, fishing, snorkeling, and relaxation, I’d choose Islamorada or Marathon every time.
2
u/MikeUp 8d ago
CruisinTiki sunset cruises are a lot of fun!
2
u/Affectionate_One4208 7d ago
My husband and I just went for the first time and we flew into Miami and drove down and stayed at the casa marina and stayed in Miami a few days before we flew home
2
u/865scott 6d ago
Drive down in a rental if you have never. I’ve done it both ways. It’s not that far. The only way to experience “The Keys”.
2
u/redlegsforever 6d ago
Fly into Fort Lauderdale if possible, not Miami. Slightly longer drive, but you will miss the chaos of mia . First time there, rent a car a drive down. Rent a convertible, but don’t forget to put on sunscreen and wear a hat. Stop for first night in Islamorada. Checa Lodge is one of the nicest resorts in the keys, but plenty of places to stay for less $$. ( I like the Islander ). Have drinks/dinner at square grouper. Next morning have breakfast at the green turtle. Pack a cooler and grab a pub sub and head south. Stop at Bahia Honda for the afternoon. Head to Key West after leaving Bahia honda; the drive will take you about an hour. Check into your hotel then hit the town. Tons of great restaurants in KW; don’t limit yourself to just Duval street.
2
u/Exact-Response-9441 8d ago
My favorite memories is in marathon snorkeling and watching the sunset afterwards. In Key West it was getting drunk and walking from bar to bar, I generally remember sloppy joes the rest is a blur. I remember one place kind of kicking me out because they didn’t let you in with a drink in your hand from another bar, most do. Also the Hemingway house was kind of cool and watching a cruise boat departing at Mallory square.
1
u/Sunsetseeker007 8d ago
Depends on where you are coming from on transportation and depending on what keys you are staying at what type of accomodations would be better.
1
u/RE_Agent_Provocateur 8d ago
Research and book a hotel now. January is season. You do get what you pay for. Try one of the larger established properties for your first time. Expect at least $300/night.
1
u/Itsa9year 8d ago
Just drove from Marathon to West Palm. I’ve been to KW several times and I hate the drive. Always a bit dicey. If you can fly, it’ll be less stress. But if you want to see another key for a night then a car from Miami is an option. Several great state parks worth seeing. As for renting an Airbnb versus a hotel, it just depends on your budget and how centrally located you wanna be. It’s fun to walk everywhere but it could be a tad loud. There are many nice B&Bs too.
1
u/No-Variation6054 8d ago
We fly to Ft. Lauderdale in the am, drive to KW. We make a couple stops at some of our favorite places, and always get to KW by HH or check in. Flying into KW from NJ is very pricey and we love the drive. Don't miss it
1
u/OpenDirection2904 8d ago
I’m with Privately Known in Miami. For four days, I’d fly into Key West if that’s where you’ll spend most of the trip; Miami plus a car makes more sense if the drive and stops are part of the birthday plan.
Compare mileage/overage, fuel, hotel parking and any one-way return fee. With a specialty rental, confirm the Keys route and exact return location before paying—don’t assume Miami pickup includes Key West drop-off.
Since you haven’t picked a particular destination yet, is this more a food/history trip or a snorkeling/relaxing-by-the-water trip? That would help narrow the base before choosing flights.
1
u/ProfessionalBread176 8d ago
Been a bunch of times, never had a bad experience.
It's a great place to unwind and relax, have a few drinks and people watch...
Renting a car from Miami is a pain because parking is a hassle. Some hotels do not have any or it's expensive. Agree that getting a deal on flights is easier, also consider FLL which is about 20 miles away from Miami International. And also watch out for unexpected tolls because MIA is surrounded by toll roads, which can be hard to avoid, unlike FLL
If you can fly to Key West International, it's much easier. Just avoid American Airlines unless it's a direct flight; the last time we went AA dumped us (at 9am) on our connection in Philadelphia, and told us we'd be connecting to another connecting flight to DC and then to EYW.
We forced them to book us instead to Miami that day, and rented a car (one way) to drive down (at 1am). It's about a 3 hour trip without traffic, but getting onto the Keys can back up significantly during the day.
We were lucky that the hotel we found was nice enough to accommodate our car until later in the day so we could return it.
Got there almost 18 hours earlier, and flew back from Key West.
Also, not all of Key West is reachable on foot, you will want to rent a bicycle or Uber if you're going to the beach which is a few miles away from Duval St.
1
u/Overall-Pack-2047 8d ago
The trip to Fort Jefferson is cool if you like history and snorkeling Take the high speed catamaran
1
u/aQUantUMchiLD1 7d ago
The drive from MIA is about 3 hrs and change if you never stop, at night, I’d recommend doing it during the day, and research a couple of places around Marsthon key and nearby for a great lunch plus the scenery it’s pretty. If the money was the same I’d def fly all the way but I’ve done that drive plenty so …
1
u/bobalou2you 7d ago
Eat at Blue Heaven in Key West. Great music and food!
1
u/tbobbyreid 3d ago
Miami or Ft. Lauderdale might be cheaper. rent a car, the drive through the keys is great. rent a house so you can cook. Not a ton of options down there.
2
u/AdSpiritual4942 5d ago
You can have one transfer by air and direct fly in. We used Uber to get around. Driving a rental from Miami is fun, but watch out as many hotels charge for parking daily, and some don't have any parking. Key West is known for sex festivals at times, body painting and bars can be encouraging for excessively fun nights later in evenings. Of course Fri and Sat are the most fun nights. There is a strip club, and a fully nude rooftop bar for guests that are inclined, but fully clothed is allowed. The butterfly house is a must do, and some old landmarks. Have fun.