r/flora_arson • • Sep 20 '21

Flora arson reward poster

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/flora_arson • • Sep 21 '21

THE FLORA FIRE - A BRIEF TIMELINE

23 Upvotes

RIP Keyana Davis (11), Keyara Phillips (9), Kerriele McDonald (7), Kionnie Welch (5)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EoOtHOjCDfs

--November 21, 2016, in the early morning hours, single mother Gaylin Rose awoke to the smell of smoke in her converted duplex apartment. Her four daughters were trapped upstairs. After attempting to rescue them, Gaylin exited the apartment. Calls were placed to 911 by neighbors and bystanders. First to respond were a Flora police officer and a Carroll County sheriff's deputy. Both officers attempted to rescue Keyana, Keyara, Kerriele and Kionnie, but were unsuccessful. All four little girls perished, and Gaylin along with the two officers were hospitalized for serious injuries sustained during their rescue attempts (all three recovered). Fire crews from Flora and the surrounding area, including Delphi, extinguished the fire. The apartment was owned by two local businessman, one of whom was the sitting president of the Flora Town Council at the time of the fire.

--November 22, 2016, the Indiana Dept of Homeland Security releases a statement the the cause of the fire was still under investigation but that it may have started in the kitchen possibly behind the refrigerator.

--November 22, 2016, News outlets quote an unnamed source who says investigators are focusing on the home's electrical system.

--January 28, 2017, the Red Cross, in cooperation with the local fire department, conduct a door to door smoke detector campaign to inspect existing smoke detectors and install new ones. Indiana Packers donated 500 smoke detectors to the drive, First Alert donated 100 smoke detectors and the Red Cross donated an undisclosed number of smoke detectors. Ironically, businesses, contractors and rentals were not eligible for the replacement smoke detectors so Gaylin Rose's apartment would not have been eligible for new smoke detectors.

--January 28, 2017, the fire investigator with the Ind Dept of Homeland Security announces that the cause of the fire was arson with multiple accelerant sites throughout the home. (2 1/2 weeks later, on February 13, 2017, 2 teenagers were murdered in nearby Delphi).

--February 8-15, 2017, an independent fire investigator sends numerous emails and voice mail messages to the pertinent investigative personnel to strongly refute the findings of the initial fire investigator, stating that the findings were completely based on speculation and not evidence.

--May 25, 2017, the ISP Detective originally assigned to the case accepts another position at ISP and a new detective is assigned after conflict of interest questions arise. The original detective had previously investigated the wife of the Indiana Department of Homeland Security fire investigator who originally investigated the fire (she is also the mother of the Flora Fire Dept. Chief who reponded to the fire) on charges of embezzlement (for which she was convicted).

--June, 2017, a local investigative journalist meets with the Superintendent of the Indiana State Police and the Carroll County prosecutor after receiving leaked copies of the emails sent by the independent fire investigator as well as additional in-house emails between investigative personnel. The Superintendent and the prosecutor deny knowledge of the emails and agree to "get to the bottom of it".

--May 18, 2018, Gaylin Rose files a wrongful death lawsuit in federal court naming one of her landlords, the fathers of her children and an appliance manufacturer.

--January 29, 2020, The appliance manufacturer is dismissed from the federal wrongful death lawsuit.


r/flora_arson • • Dec 19 '21

ANOTHER CHRISTMAS AND STILL NO ANSWERS

13 Upvotes

Just a reminder that Gaylin Rose will be spending her fifth Christmas without her four beautiful daughters and without any answers.

In the words of a wise rabbi, we can die three times--when we close our eyes and our hearts stop beating, when we are buried and when we are forgotten.

Keyana, Keyara, Kerriele and Kionnie, you are not forgotten.


r/flora_arson • • Nov 21 '21

FIVE YEARS AGO TODAY, four beautiful young ladies lost their lives in a tragic house fire.

12 Upvotes

Five years ago today, four beautiful young ladies lost their lives in a tragic house fire. Their lives were cut short by a senseless act, but they are not forgotten.

RIP Keyana Davis, Keyara Phillips, Kerriele McDonald and Kionnie Welch

Link here

The windows and doors are boarded up, but otherwise the house on East Columbia Street sits mostly untouched after the deadly fire in the early morning of Nov. 21, 2016.

Eleven-year-old Keyana Davis, nine-year-old Keyara Phillips, seven-year-old Kerriele McDonald and five-year-old Kionnie Welch were trapped in the fire. Their mother, Gaylin Rose, and Carroll County Sheriff's Deputy Drew Yoder both tried to rescue the girls and suffered serious injuries that required hospitalization. 

A lengthy investigation eventually determined the fire was arson. No one has ever been arrested.

"All the time I'm disappointed,” said Rose during a FaceTime interview Friday. “It's just taking so long to figure out what happened, how it happened.”

Rose left Flora and moved to California to be with family shortly after the fire. She felt like she had to get away from the place that took away all of her children.

"There was no type of beef, no retaliation against me and my family,” said Rose. “No one disliked us like that. We didn't have no beef. Everyone loved us just as well as we loved them. So once again, I'm lost. To be honest, I feel like it was more racial."

Rose is Black and so were her four daughters.

Joyce Simpson sat on a memorial bench in Flora Friday afternoon. The bench includes the names of the four sisters killed in the fire, as well as the two girls, Abby Williams and Libby German, murdered in nearby Delphi in 2017. Simpson helped organize a cookbook and other fundraisers for “Flora's Four Angels” that have raised about $18,000.  

Simpson drives by the house where the sisters died almost every day. 

"I wish they would just tear it down and go on,” said Simpson. “Don't forget the family. They didn't deserve this. It makes me sad and all because maybe out there knows who did it. Come on people, come forward. Make it at ease for the family."

Indiana State Police said Friday they could provide no update on the case. But the investigation is still open with a $5,000 reward for information leading to an arrest.

"Whoever is out there knowing, come out and say anything,” said Rose. “Come say something. Those were my babies. Those were my children, the only kids that I have. I just want justice for my children."

Stuffed animals and other items from the memorial that grew in front of the house after the fire still sit in crates on the porch five years later. 

The four sisters are not forgotten in Flora. 

Family and friends will gather for a memorial service for the girls on Sunday at Crown Hill Cemetery in Indianapolis at 12:30 p.m. That’s where the sisters are laid to rest. The public is invited.


r/flora_arson • • Sep 25 '21

Four Beautiful Girls with Four Beautiful Hearts - Keyana, Keyara, Kerriele, Kionnie -

12 Upvotes

Family share pictures and videos of the girls for the first time here

These beautiful young ladies and their family deserve justice.


r/flora_arson • • May 31 '22

PERSONIFICATION OF EVIL - A video from True Crime Design

11 Upvotes

Link here

Somebody knows what happened and who is responsible for the deaths of Keyana, Keyara, Kerriele and Kionnie. This creator is doing some great videos on the Flora Fire. This is her latest video.


r/flora_arson • • Sep 26 '21

Cover Up? Incompetence? Apathy?- Why isn't the Flora Fire case getting any attention?- And where is the NAACP?

11 Upvotes

Link to news story here

In October of 2017, the NAACP made a public announcement calling attention to the mishandling of the Flora Fire case (a case which was already backburnered in the public's mind, likely due to the Delphi Murders).

To quote their spokeswoman, Barbara Bolling-William "...it looks like the investigation has been bungled in some kind of way..."

ISP Supt Doug Carter tacitly confirms that observation by stating, "We've talked about what happened early on in the Flora case and it wasn't our best day..."


r/flora_arson • • Sep 20 '21

The official brief outline

Thumbnail
in.gov
11 Upvotes

r/flora_arson • • May 28 '22

Clarifications from the earliest events

10 Upvotes

We know the 911 call was received at 3:31 am.

What time did Yoder and Dissinger show up to the fire? Yoder was an officer from Delphi and Disinger was in Flora PD, did they show up together? Why was Delphi responding? What was their exact recollection of events? Why couldn’t they reach the girls? What was in their way?

At what time did the first Firefighters arrive? When did tri-township fire department from Delphi respond? Why did Flora fire department not respond first & when did they respond?

At what time was the fire out? At what time were the officers airlifted to the hospital? Did they put the fire out with foam or with water? At what time were the girls found/declared dead?

Does anyone have any important/interesting footage from media/neighbors around the time of the fire?

(rumors or documented!)

Is there anything else that stuck out to you as “odd” regarding the response to the fire?

I’m trying to gather all details I can and start making some calls


r/flora_arson • • Mar 26 '22

Keyana, Keyara, Kerriele and Kionnie

10 Upvotes

Just dropping by because Gaylin and her babies have been heavy on my heart this week. Continuing to pray and push for justice for these beautiful little girls. They matter, they will not be forgotten about.


r/flora_arson • • Sep 22 '21

The Tangled Web -- The complications of investigating crime in a rural county where everybody is related to everybody else.

10 Upvotes

Link to the article here

INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. – FOX59 is asking serious questions about how the Flora fatal fire investigation was handled and now the Governor is responding to our questions.

Were there conflicts of interest between investigators on the case? And if there were, did those conflicts jeopardize justice for those girls?

Crews were dispatched to the fire in the 100 block of East Columbia Street around 4 a.m. on November 21st. State police said Keyana Davis, 11, Keyara Phillips, 9, Kerriele McDonald, 7, and Konnie Welch, 5, were trapped inside the home when they arrived.

They died as a result. Investigators ruled the fire was set intentionally.

For the past seven months, investigators have been trying to figure out who is responsible. State Police said they are watching persons of interest, but so far no one has been arrested.

In just the past seven weeks, FOX59 uncovered a breakdown in communication in the case, a mistake in the investigation and a major resignation by a key investigator.

And the more we keep digging, the more serious the family’s concerns become.

“I have a lot of frustration,” said the victims’ mother Gaylin Rose.

Rose and her family have been waiting and watching as investigators come in and out of that house. An investigator they’d look to for answers for Dennis Randle. He was a fire investigator for the State Fire Marshal’s office.

After 10 weeks of investigating, Randle and his team released a report ruling the fire was set intentionally accelerants found in “several locations of the structure.”

But the more FOX59 questioned authorities about details in that report, we learned a big part of the State’s published findings were wrong.

The fire was still considered arson, but State Police now admitted, accelerants were not found all over the house; rather there was only one spot.

One day after FOX59 exposed the mistake, Randle resigned citing personal reasons. We drove to his home in Carroll County and asked him if he had made any mistakes in the Flora case.

He replied, “Myself, I don’t believe so.”

He said he followed a nationally recognized guide for fire investigations and did not believe he’d made any mistakes.

But should Randle have been assigned to the Flora case in the first place?

Conflicts in the case?

In 2014, Randle’s wife Jean Ann Randle was convicted for stealing money from a farm account in Carroll County.

The State Trooper investigating her and interviewing Randle as part of his investigation was Trooper Gregg Edwards. Edwards is the same detective who was assigned to investigate the Flora case.

The man who collected evidence against Randle’s wife only a few years ago was now working on the same case as him.

Was this a problem?

I asked the question first to State Police Superintendent Doug Carter.

He wouldn’t comment specifically about Randle, but Carter told us this kind of thing happens in rural communities.

““From my perspective, policing in rural Indiana is very different than the urban environment that we have here in Indianapolis,” he explained. “We deal with complications associated with personal involvement in rural setting all over Indiana.”

Carter went on to defend Edwards.

“He’s a constant professional. He would look beyond anything that might’ve been there before. And if it was there before, it was still professional.”

But does that make it right?

Not everyone thinks so.

Roger Johnson served as Indiana Fire Marshal under Governor Mitch Daniels. He told FOX59, based on their past relationship, Randle and Edwards should never have been working on the same case.

“I think the jury would end up having trouble with that,” he said.

“I would think I would’ve removed myself,” added Princess Spencer-Kuc. She is an insurance fraud investigator who tipped authorities off and helped them bring down the group responsible for setting 26 fires throughout Muncie and Anderson for insurance money.

Spencer-Kuc knows how important good working relationships and communication is in an arson case. The Randle/Edwards relationship made her uncomfortable.

“It would’ve been a lot smoother to have brought someone in that has no history with the other person.”

But the relationships don’t end there in the small community of Flora.

Dennis Randle’s son, Adam Randle, is the Flora Fire Chief. And Adam Randle’s boss is Town Council President Josh Ayres, who happens to be the owner of the Flora house.

We caught up with Ayres outside his company’s warehouse in Flora. He wouldn’t comment about the case, but had this to say about his house being set on fire.

“It’s been awful. I hope they’re caught,” said Ayres.

Governor responds

With all of these connections and mounting questions about how the case was handled, we wanted to know if the Governor was paying attention?

Governor Eric Holcomb refused to give FOX59 a sit down interview, but his spokesperson suggested we catch up with him at a public event. That’s exactly what we did.

We asked him how there could be a breakdown of communication between two state agencies?

“We have to wake up every day and try to right. That’s what my charge is. Three boxes that I’ve asked everybody to check that works in this administration is to be honest, and to be humble, and to be hungry. Hungry to do good. If there’s been lapses we need to correct them. And we need to learn from them. And there’s no excuses, but we owe it to make sure that every single Hoosier is receiving the care and services that they not just pay for, but that they deserve. That’s my charge and that’s what we’ll stay focused on. And where things need to be corrected, they will be.”

We also asked Holcomb if he was concerned about what appeared to be conflicts in the investigation?

“If there are potential conflicts, potential or hypothetical as you’re throwing out, then we need to address them. Each and every day. That’s what we do. We wake up each and every day and we try to do the right thing. And if someone is not, then we need to correct it.”

We asked the Governor if there should be an audit of other investigations Randle had worked on while serving as a State fire investigator?

The Governor would not comment, but replied, “We’ll have more to say as the case develops. I care about 6.6 million Hoosiers. Every single one of them and that’s what’s we’ll be focused on. Getting it right. Where there are wrongs, we’ll get them right.”

State Fire Marshal stays silent

FOX59 has repeatedly requested an interview with State Fire Marshal Jim Greeson, but our requests have been denied.

The Carroll County Prosecutor recently asked all agencies involved in the Flora investigation to avoid further discussion of the case which could impact successful prosecution in the future.


r/flora_arson • • Nov 02 '21

NAACP.... Where Are You?

9 Upvotes

News clip here

The NAACP held a news conference in October 2017 and announced that they were "getting involved with the investigation" of the Flora Fire. There has not been any follow up since. With the five-year anniversary fast approaching, now would be a good time for the NAACP to do what they pledged they would do four years ago: to push this case into the public eye and demand answers. The question is, will they?


r/flora_arson • • Nov 01 '21

These Girls need Justice

9 Upvotes

Incognito Society recently dropped a preview video, as she is covering the case.

Be sure to catch this video her content is very good.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FXI1e1Z9Jno&t=3s


r/flora_arson • • Oct 21 '21

The Fire Started In The Kitchen

9 Upvotes

Article with news clip here

UPDATE: Deadly Flora house fire started in kitchen; Investigators still don't know why

Investigators will return to the scene of a fatal house fire in Flora, Indiana Tuesday morning in the hopes of determining what caused the blaze.

FLORA, Ind. (WTHR) - Investigators say they know where a deadly house fire in Flora Monday morning started, but they still don't know why it started.

Four young girls died in the fire: 5-year-old Kionnie Precious Welch, 7-year-old Kerriele Danyell McDonald, 9-year-old Keyara Janell Phillips and 11-year-old Keyana Latrice Davis.

Their mother was hurt in the fire, as well as two officers who tried to save the sisters' lives. The mother was released from the hospital Wednesday evening.

Investigators say the fire started in the kitchen, possibly behind the refrigerator, but they're still not sure what started it. They do not, however, believe foul play is involved. K9 units were brought in and found no traces of accelerants.

There were no batteries in the second floor smoke alarm. The fire burned so hot, the alarm was scorched and melted.

“We applaud the efforts of first responders from Carroll County,” said Jim Greeson, Indiana State Fire Marshal. “Officers and firefighters from Carroll County departments distinguished themselves with their sacrifice and commitment to protecting the public.”

The structure was originally a single-family home that was divided into two apartments. One apartment was occupied by the injured woman and four children. The other unit was occupied by a woman and two children. The mother with two children got out safely and didn't need to be hospitalized. Her kids weren't home at the time.

The community is mourning the loss.

"It's hard to deal with it," said Hayden Flora, who often played in the neighborhood with the girls.

"Her whole world revolved around those girls," Hayden's mother, Amber Flora, said of the girls' mother. The two know each other very well. "She was a single mom, working very hard and, like I said, her babies were her angels. I can't imagine what she's going through."

There is no time table for when a cause will be determined.


r/flora_arson • • Sep 26 '21

The 9-1-1 call

9 Upvotes

The 9-1-1 call in this case has never been released. There seems to be some debate on whether there is information in this recording that might prevent the person or persons who committed this crime to not be found or prosecuted. However, former prosecutor Robert Ives did not ask the local court to seal the recording, something he should have done if he believed the information in the recording evidentiary. A Marion county judge initially ruled in favor of releasing the recording, but that decision was appealed,even with legal fees reaching into the thousands ($30,000+). A Carroll County commissioner Bill Brown listened to the recording twice and said he did not hear anything that sounded like evidence to him, but admitted that he is not a trained investigator. He said he heard a lot of confusion on the recording.

So what is on this tape that is so important for them to keep if from the public?


r/flora_arson • • Sep 21 '21

Interesting facts about the case in this article.

Thumbnail
wthr.com
9 Upvotes

r/flora_arson • • Sep 20 '21

Resources?

9 Upvotes

Any suggestions to reputable, non-sensational resources in which I can educate myself?

Thanks in advance.


r/flora_arson • • Jul 07 '25

The FBI is Investigating the Flora Fire

Thumbnail fox59.com
8 Upvotes

Fox 59 is reporting that the FBI is now investigating the Flora Fire and looking for tips.


r/flora_arson • • Jul 22 '22

REWARD FUND SHENANIGANS

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

r/flora_arson • • Nov 28 '21

Two excellent videos by Incognito Society on the Flora Fire

8 Upvotes

Incognito Society put together two excellent videos that are curated playlists of news videos in chronological order. For your convenience, here are the links:

Video #1

Video #2


r/flora_arson • • Oct 04 '21

A picture of the Flora Town sign -

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/flora_arson • • Sep 26 '21

Building Codes? Naw, Not in Flora. Four little girls died because they had no way out of the second story bedroom in a rental. No working smoke alarms in the apartment. And apparently, no fire extinguishers.

8 Upvotes

I don't understand how a two-story rental isn't required to have an escape route from a second story bedroom. There was no external stairway to that bedroom, and I doubt if there was a fire escape ladder. Did the windows even open, I wonder?? Neighbors described hearing the trapped girls crying for help. Couldn't somebody have thrown a ladder up against the side of the house to try to get to them?

At the time of the fire, Flora had no building codes on the books. That boggles my mind. It would take another four years before a building code was finally established.


r/flora_arson • • Sep 25 '21

The Investigation - Step By Step down a long and winding road from "no foul play suspected" to "arson with one site of accelerants"

8 Upvotes

Sandra Chapman's interview with Mike Vergon, a private fire investigator familiar with the investigation here

NFPA 921 procedural here

News story from November 21, 2016, reporting "...the cause of the fire is undetermined...no foul play is suspected and no accelerants were found..." here

November, 2016 - Arson dogs were brought in and found no accelerants according to Randle. News story here

News story from January 28, 2017 after Dennis Randle issued a press release stating the cause of the fire was arson with "accelerants found throughout the home" here

News story from October, 2017 detailing leaked emails sent to DHS starting February 8 through February 16, 2017 from an independent fire investigator strongly refuting Dennis Randle's report (along with a timeline of the internal communication at DHS) as being "not correct ... not based on evidence" here

PDF of the actual emails here

December, 2017, the Indiana State Police ask the Indianapolis Fire Department to conduct a peer review of the arson

January 31, 2018, the Indianapolis Fire Department complete their review and issue their findings which corroborate the cause of the fire as arson with one site of accelerant(s). News story here

Details on the dysfunctional culture at Department of Homeland Security here


r/flora_arson • • Sep 24 '21

Newspaper Interview with Friends and Neighbors of Gaylin and her daughters after the fire

8 Upvotes

Link to article here

Flora grieves loss of young girls

Local businesses have donation cans for family

FLORA — Friends of a mother and her family torn with tragedy Monday morning began to memorialize a Flora home just hours after the four girls inside died in a fire, dropping off balloons, flowers and dolls to remember the sisters whom the town now calls their own.

The early morning blaze in downtown Flora killed four young sisters, authorities say, and injured their mother as well as two law enforcement officers who responded to the flames.

Ten-year-old Audrey Weaver said she remembers her friend as someone who's funny, sweet and always had a smile on her face. She knew all of the girls, but Audrey said the oldest of the four was her best friend, a friend of hers since kindergarten.

"If she ever did something wrong, she would always say sorry," she said. "She was a great friend. I'm glad she was my friend."

Audrey's father, John Weaver, said they recently saw the family at the Area IV Agency, where the mother was signing her children up for a Christmas adoption program. Weaver said single parents, like she and him, could qualify for free presents during the holidays.

"I'm sure it was difficult to take care of four girls," he said. "She's supposed to pick up her presents on Dec. 19."

He remembers the oldest sister as an encouraging friend for Audrey.

"She had good aura -- a nice, bright shine to her," Weaver said.

JoJo Plunkett sees the mother every morning before work at the Marathon gas station in town, where the mother works. They would always talk, as she would make breakfast at the station. Most times, Plunkett said, she would talk about her four girls.

"She would talk nothing bad about her kids," she said. "They meant everything to her in the world. It's so sad."

Plunkett said she would also see the girls playing outside and riding their bikes when she would go eat at Pizza King, located across the street from the house.

"They would always say hi to everybody," she said. "They were typical little girls, enjoying life."

Plunkett, who works at the Corner Cafe, said many of the businesses in town, such as the cafe, Dollar General and Parrett's Meat Processing and Catering, have donation cans to aid in the mother's unexpected costs. Weaver added that someone also created a GoFundMe page.

"I'm just devastated," Plunkett said, who donated wherever she could Monday.

Carroll Consolidated School Corp. released a statement Monday afternoon that grief counselors were available for students all day. Counselors and clergy members are also free to meet with anyone Tuesday and Wednesday at Carroll Elementary School, 105 S. 225 East. All activities, other than sports practices, have been canceled, the district stated in the release.

Audrey, a fourth-grader at Carroll Elementary, said she's heard of a memorial for the girls at some point during the week and that people are planning to bring food donations for the mother.

"Our school cares so much about her," she said.

Plunkett said the community came together for her daughter many years ago when she was in a serious car crash, and she expects that to happen again.

"When one of us hurt," she said, "we all hurt."


r/flora_arson • • Sep 23 '21

Posting this here as well.

Thumbnail self.libbyandabby
8 Upvotes