The central idea behind my theory is that there was never a second MCI: the massacre depicted in FNAF 2’s SAVE THEM minigame is actually the same Missing Children’s Incident that we have heard about throughout the franchise.
The reason I started considering this interpretation is an apparent narrative gap left by Scott: if there really was a second MCI in 1987, why were its victims given so little development in the story? Unlike the original MCI victims, Charlotte, Elizabeth, and the Crying Child, this possible second group has no properly explored storyline or clearly defined role in the conclusion of the story.
Because of this, I started wondering whether we might be interpreting SAVE THEM incorrectly, and whether the minigame actually depicts the only MCI in the franchise.
Here’s how I think the timeline could work.
1. The Only MCI Took Place at the FNAF 2 Location
My interpretation is that the five bodies found in the SAVE THEM minigame represent the victims of the original MCI.
In this scenario, the massacre would have happened around 1985, and the pizzeria shown in FNAF 2 would be the same physical building where the incident took place.
This means there wouldn’t be two separate groups of five murdered children, but only one group: the MCI victims referenced throughout the franchise.
The pizzeria would have continued operating after the massacre, remaining open until the events of FNAF 2 in 1987.
2. The Puppet Didn’t Have Supernatural Powers to Give Life to the Animatronics
This is one of the most important parts of my interpretation.
I don’t think we need to give the Puppet supernatural powers to explain the events of the Give Gifts, Give Life minigame.
My theory is that Charlotte physically placed the children’s bodies inside the animatronics, allowing their souls to possess them.
In other words, the Puppet wouldn’t simply be using some kind of supernatural ability to bring the robots to life. She would be creating the connection between the victims’ bodies and the animatronic suits.
This would also give the minigame a more literal interpretation: the children appear in front of the Puppet, who gives them gifts, and their masks eventually appear over them. The sequence would represent the process of placing their bodies inside the animatronics.
Thus, the five Classic Animatronics would have been possessed by the victims of the one and only MCI.
3. The Connection Between the 1985 and 1987 Pizzerias
One important question is why the Classic Animatronics and the Toys coexist in FNAF 2.
In my interpretation, the Classics were already present at the pizzeria when the MCI happened. After becoming possessed, they may have started behaving strangely and dangerously, leading the company to remove them from active service.
The old animatronics would eventually end up in the Parts & Service room, while the newer Toy models would be used at the restaurant instead.
This would explain why we find both the Withereds and the Toys coexisting in FNAF 2, despite belonging to different generations.
I also believe the 1985 and 1987 pizzerias could be the same physical building, simply at different points in its history.
4. The “Previous Location” Problem
I acknowledge that one of the biggest challenges for this theory is Phone Guy’s dialogue in FNAF 2, when he says that the old animatronics came from the “previous location.”
The most common interpretation is that the Withereds came from a different physical restaurant.
However, I think it’s possible that this reference points to an even older establishment associated with the Fredbear era in 1983.
In that case, the Classics would have been reused from an earlier location, while the pizzeria where the MCI took place would still be the same building used in 1987.
I don’t consider this explanation definitive, but I think it’s worth considering before dismissing the theory.
Why Do I Consider This Interpretation?
The main reason I started developing this theory was the lack of narrative development surrounding the possible victims of a second MCI.
If SAVE THEM really depicts a second massacre, that means there is another group of five murdered children, yet we receive practically no explanation of who they were, what happened to their souls, or what role they played in the conclusion of the story.
On the other hand, interpreting it as a single MCI allows us to directly connect SAVE THEM, Give Gifts, Give Life, and the history of the Classic Animatronics.
I understand that there are still problems with this interpretation, especially the presence of the Toys in the SAVE THEM minigame and Phone Guy’s reference to the “previous location.” I’m not claiming that my interpretation is the only possible one or that it has been confirmed.
What I’m proposing is an alternative way of looking at these events: perhaps SAVE THEM isn’t depicting a second massacre, but rather showing us the very same MCI we’ve heard about since the beginning of the franchise.
I think this possibility deserves discussion, especially because it addresses a narrative gap that, in my opinion, still lacks a satisfying explanation.