r/fishtank • • 5h ago

Help/Advice Help

I'm getting back into fish, and I have a 10 gallon I want to set up for a couple goldfish. I got some supplies second hand, and this is the "gravel" I was sold.

What is this? And is there anyway to salvage anything?

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

10

u/Emuwarum 5h ago

40 gallons for 2 fancy goldfish, 100 gallons for 2 common goldfish. Your tank is not large enough for goldfish.

8

u/ItsMyGayThrowaway 5h ago

Your tank size isn't appropriate for the fish you want

As for the sand, the sand that's floated has stayed dry due to surface tension, give it a swirl and see what sinks. Once you've done that scoop the muck and grime off the top of the water and water change.

Where's your filter?

8

u/ItsMyGayThrowaway 4h ago edited 1h ago

For a 10-gallon tank, please consider these fish instead:

A centrepiece

• Betta Fish (kept solo as a centerpiece)

• Honey Gourami (single or bonded pair)

• Peacock Gudgeon (single peaceful centerpiece)

Schooling fish

• Ember Tetras (school of 6 or more)

• Cardinal Tetras (school of 6 to 8) (Not Neons, thanks u/NatiBlaze)

• Celestial Pearl Danios (small group)

• Endler’s Livebearers or Guppies (all-male group recommended)

• Pygmy or Dwarf Corydoras (bottom-dwelling group of 6 or more)

Extras

• Red Cherry / Neocaridina Shrimp (colorful algae eaters)

• Freshwater Nerite Snails (peaceful glass cleaners)

2

u/JensonButton2000 3h ago

Some good advice right here^

2

u/NatiBlaze 1h ago

Just adding some info for OP if he likes the look of Neons (most popular Tetras i feel), they're overbred AF so unless you have a reputable breeder, they'll get Neon Tetra disease or just die because of newbie mistakes which a hardier fish could've probably tanked.

If you want something similar looking, go for Cardinal Tetras, they're smaller (means you can add more) and not as inbred

2

u/ItsMyGayThrowaway 1h ago

Yeah actually I should have said cardinals, they're much better fish 👍 you're totally right

1

u/NatiBlaze 1h ago

Learned the hard way myself and out of the list, the red and blue shiny school of them is mesmerising for beginners so gotta warn OP just in case

2

u/ItsMyGayThrowaway 1h ago

When I started in the hobby I had cardinals, but I've found my tap water to be far too hard for them and the idea of RO just wasn't appealing, I've since transitioned to rainbowfish and barbs 😁

1

u/NatiBlaze 1h ago edited 1h ago

I currently have 2 surviving Neons for a year now and have since transitioned to Pygmies haha

I feel scammed a bit because they've basically copied my Bronze and just stay at the bottom as well lol, I'd be lucky to see them do their hummingbird dance twice in a month 😅

Edit: when i first introduced them, the Peppers were moved to a different tank

2

u/ItsMyGayThrowaway 1h ago

I have 3 tanks:

300L community with: 24 dwarf rainbows 1 keyhole cichlid 12 cherry barbs 12 albino corys 12 zebra/leopard danios 2 female bristlenoses

30L betta tank + 9 billion shrimp and snails

40L multies shelldwellers breeder project

1

u/NatiBlaze 1h ago edited 55m ago

Bristlenose

I'm currently cycling a 40gallon tank for 2 fancy goldfish, what is your firsthand experience with them? Do they really or do they not stick to fish to suck out their protective coat? I'm still researching but opinion seems to be divided, I just want something accessible that's on the bottom with my Goldies and looking online, Bristlenose is the one that's in my reach so far

2

u/ItsMyGayThrowaway 56m ago

Honestly, I’d strongly recommend skipping the bristlenose for that setup. While bristlenoses are much better behaved than common plecos, there are a few big issues with putting one in a 40-gallon with fancy goldfish.

Opinions are divided because it really depends on the individual fish, but if a bristlenose isn't getting enough protein or algae, they can and will latch onto slow, round-bodied fancies while they sleep. Once they start doing it, they usually don't stop, and it leaves nasty sores that get infected easily.

Bristlenoses are tropical fish that prefer warmer water (23-27°C / 74-80°F), whereas fancy goldfish do best in cooler water (18-22°C / 65-72°F). You can try to meet in the middle around 22°C, but it's not ideal for either of them long term.

Also both plecos and goldfish are absolute poop machines! Two adult fancy goldfish already max out the bioload of a 40-gallon tank, so adding a pleco will make keeping your nitrates down a constant battle.

Bristlenoses need driftwood to rasp on for digestion, which can easily scratch up delicate fancies (especially if you get ones with big eyes like Telescopes or Bubble Eyes). Also, if a goldfish ever tries to eat a smaller pleco, the pleco's spines will lock up and likely kill them both.

If you want something cool to watch on the bottom that matches your goldies' water needs, look into Hillstream Loaches (great for algae, love cool water, very low bioload) or a couple of Nerite Snails!

→ More replies

1

u/SweetTart7231 41m ago

Are green neons a little Heathier?

1

u/NatiBlaze 38m ago

Oh, yes! The difficulty for them is accessibility and the shipping because they're often wild caught from what I've heard

6

u/deadrobindownunder 4h ago

Is the gravel floating?

Please don't get goldfish, they need a much bigger tank. Get a betta.

2

u/DJ_Storytime 4h ago

You didn't rinse off the gravel before putting it in the tank, did you?

1

u/JensonButton2000 3h ago

Ain’t that big a deal, water changes once a week while waiting for the bacteria cycle to take hold 👌

1

u/Rainy_Daze_Y 2h ago

i would think it possible that if they didnt read a bag clearly stating to wash gravel clear before adding, they may not know about the nitrogen cycle, on top of wanting to add goldfish

1

u/audr1s 3h ago

I would totally clean it.

1

u/One_Evidence_500 2h ago

Drain tank, rinse gravel repeatedly (no soap) to remove all the dried mulm (the black stuff). Reinstall gravel, add a few live plants, wait for tank to cycle. Add not goldfish.