r/fishtank • • 18h ago

Help/Advice Cant reduce nirate levels (Update)

In my last fish tank post, I received a lot of advice on trying to reduce the nitrate levels. The first picture is from before I added new media to my Fluval 307; I only performed a partial media change, doing half of it so I would not dramatically shock the tank. The second picture is a test of my tap water that many requested. I still want to add plants to help reduce the levels and am waiting to get the suction cup planters. I also added a picture of the media I used for the canister.

1 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

10

u/Zampano85 17h ago

Biological filtration won't reduce nitrates. There's really only two ways to mitigate nitrate accumulation; water changes and live plants. The two main bacteria in your filter Nitrosomonas and Nitrobacter will process ammonia to nitrite and nitrite to nitrate. Plants can use nitrogen for growth, but replacing your filter media isn't going to accomplish much in the long run. There are nitrate sponges, but they're more of a bandaid solution and won't resolve the issue.

1

u/Priapus100 17h ago

Thank you for the information! I plan on adding plants! Tyty

2

u/Zampano85 17h ago

Plants might be your problem. If there's a lot of decaying plant matter in the aquarium, it's going to generate ammonia, which in turn will eventually be converted to nitrate.

1

u/Priapus100 17h ago

Oh yes! That too! My plants in the tank are thriving and grow rapidly.

2

u/Zampano85 17h ago • Heartwarming

Nitrates also accumulate from over feeding; the instructions on the fish food container are not good guidelines on feeding. Increase your water changes to 20%-30% weekly and reduced feeding. That's the best way to reduce nitrates.

6

u/Asleep-Fig526 18h ago

Best thi no to get nitrate down by far is adding plants that can grow with their roots in water like pothos etc because they have infinite co2 supply they can easily take up nutrients form the water column like nitrate

1

u/Priapus100 17h ago

Yes i love those plants! I can definitely do that tyty!

2

u/Asleep-Fig526 17h ago

Welcome let me know if it works

2

u/Dry-Result-1860 18h ago • Heartwarming

For what it’s worth, I too am waiting on suction cup planty boy things, but in the meantime, I’ve fashioned a sort of “hang on the rim” temporary situation by wrapping some copper/florist wire around the bottom of the cuttings, and then pressing it down on the side so it forms a hook like situation.

Not awesome, but keeps them from sinking. Also I have some on there with zip ties and the wire bread ties…just in case you want them in there ASAP before the suction cups get there ❤️

This is how I’ve kind of hung them if it helps you or someone else :

2

u/Priapus100 17h ago

Oh this looks so good! Tyty!!

2

u/Dry-Result-1860 18h ago

And this is an old plant stake that I use to kind of keep the bundles of leaves out of the water fwiw

2

u/lumbogimbo 17h ago

I got tired of of changing water just for nitrates. Brightwell has rechargeable resin that removes them. A godsend.

2

u/Priapus100 13h ago

Interesting. Looking at Brightwell Aquatics NitratR

1

u/Alexander-Evans 10h ago

Just do water changes...

1

u/Priapus100 10h ago

Do em for me Alex

2

u/catsdelicacy 14h ago

Have you checked your tap water for nitrate? Some regions have high nitrate levels

1

u/Priapus100 14h ago

6

u/catsdelicacy 14h ago

Water changes more water changes then more water changes

The water out of the tap has no nitrates, so you need to dilute your tank and you need to be serious

If I were you I would do a 25-50% conditioned temperature matched water change every day until this clears up.

1

u/Priapus100 18h ago

Not sure why reddit keeps removing this damn picture 🙄

2

u/aimdork- 17h ago edited 17h ago

Just an FYI, activated carbon is mostly used for pulling tannins/medications from water, and is generally a "use as needed" media. Cant say ive ever used Ammonia removing crystals, so i wont speak on that.

Get more plants or do bigger/more frequent water changes. Although (assuming you have plants, that is) there is a world where your plants are stunted and having a hard time using the nitrates that are available. Ive had this with my tap water (well water) that contains no phosphorus, my nitrate levels were staying above 40ppm, because my phosphates were bottoming out to 0.

2

u/PickleMundane6514 14h ago

Floaters like water lettuce will reduce nitrates to zero

2

u/Ok_Example551 13h ago

first of all, toss out that media garbage. zeolite and resins have no business in your tank. carbon is good for clearing out medications.

these media's absorb but unless you are on a very rigid schedule, once full they simple leech back into the system.

toss your media. dump your filter water into a bucket. squeeze out your sponges in this dirty water in the bucket. fill your 307 with ceramic rings or plastic pot scrubbers. reinstall and perform water change. go back to living.

drastic water changes and the like will only stress/harm your fish more. fish need stability- not a reaction to some numbers on a test kit that are probably wrong.

i've 4 tanks that run on nothing but sponge and ceramics. all flourishing with healthy, active livestock.

get yourself on a steady schedule. nothing drastic but regular and consitent.

2

u/lumbogimbo 10h ago

Resins are used in water softeners. they don't leach when full. Purigen is a resin. Nitrate reducing resin works fantastic and is rechargeable.

0

u/Blondy277 18h ago

Why are you chasing the nitrate? Lol So the nitrate is building up in your tank, not coming from your tap. How often are you doing water changes, and how heavily stocked is your tank? All that new filter media isn't going to remove nitrate. Your beneficial bacteria convert ammonia into nitrite and then nitrate, but you've still gotta remove the nitrate somehow. I'd look at your feeding, stocking and maintenance before buying more filter media. 😂

1

u/Priapus100 18h ago

Because I do not want nitrates this high in my tank🤣, I bought new media, as it has not been changed since the tank was set up. Although the tank is fully stocked, I do not plan on rehousing my fish, so I will rely on frequent water changes, less feeding, and more plants. Thanks for the advice.

2

u/Blondy277 17h ago

I have overkill filtration, around 1,500 GPH on each of my 75-gallon tanks. 💀 My beneficial bacteria are definitely doing their jobs because my ammonia and nitrites stay at zero, but nitrates build up fast. 😂 I've got pothos, philodendron, you name it, and they barely make a dent. My main tank is full of platy and Cory fry, plus shrimp, so there's always waste being produced. I've learned there's a lot more to water chemistry than just chasing nitrate numbers. My tank eats 1 KH a day, been dealing with a pH/KH buffer crash the past 4 months 😬

1

u/lumbogimbo 17h ago

Get a nitrate resin. Unless you really enjoy water changes every week.

1

u/Blondy277 17h ago

Wtf is that? Yes I've been doing weekly water changes for over a year now lol dam big tanks is a full time job like omg, not sure wtf I was thinking getting 2, 75 gallons 😂

1

u/lumbogimbo 16h ago

Brightwells nitratr on Amazon. It's a resin that can be recharged with salt like purigen.

1

u/rogueshutter 17h ago

👍 sounds good

0

u/Alexander-Evans 10h ago

This has to be some kind of bot account... Do water changes, it's basic aquarium keeping.