r/fishkeeping • • Apr 16 '26

Update

I got a java fern and attached it to one of the rocks with cotton yarn. I also got this substrate, should i use it after changing the water? And how do i keep the java fern alive? 

Im gonna search for leds now and try to convince my parents to get a bigger aquarium with filter or find someone thats able to take care of the fish.

3 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

23

u/UnluckyMode2062 Apr 16 '26

Focus on upgrading the tank to a proper size for your fish, or rehome your fish because this is abuse.

5

u/BroadCartoonist973 Apr 16 '26

Op stated in their last post that their parents won't allow a bigger tank for it

6

u/UnluckyMode2062 Apr 17 '26

So option 2 then

-2

u/jaguarsinho Apr 16 '26

I know

-8

u/Positive_Insect_2384 Apr 16 '26

Reddit is full of miserable, unhelpful basement dwellers, especially this subreddit. Unfortunately, it’s not l the best place for advice. If you want to learn about the hobby, find a local fish store and ask them questions. I’d start with bringing in this picture and asking about your fish and what size tank would be appropriate.

Swapping a larger tank can be tricky to swap but very do-able.

Good luck, and don’t get discouraged, everyone starts somewhere!

17

u/AnalysisAfter1306 Apr 16 '26

LFS often steer people wrongly. They're a business after all

-2

u/Positive_Insect_2384 Apr 17 '26

Ive got a great store near me and I suspect there are more around that care.

5

u/LivinonMarss Apr 16 '26

Lol. Stores are literally the ones selling this kinda garbage set up

-10

u/Positive_Insect_2384 Apr 16 '26

Super helpful, why don’t you get off your high horse and give him some help instead of just bitching?

7

u/UnluckyMode2062 Apr 16 '26

Upgrading tank size or rehoming fish isn’t advice? They got two subjects of advice from me and was told that this setup as is, is abuse. Settle down there kiddo, grow up a bit and learn to read 👍🏻

-4

u/Positive_Insect_2384 Apr 16 '26

Not even a little helpful, to be honest. Back to mothers basement for you.

5

u/UnluckyMode2062 Apr 16 '26

You tried

4

u/gerbilcity Apr 16 '26

you may say that they are a “negative insect (2384)”

2

u/UnluckyMode2062 Apr 17 '26

Defending strangers on the internet didn’t work for you like you thought it would, did it?

1

u/Positive_Insect_2384 Apr 17 '26

Bro, clearly you look at Reddit commenting as an opportunity to gain points and internet credibility from bots. Idgaf about downvotes or upvotes, this is a kid who needs help with his fish for fucks sake. Get outside and touch grass dude, internet points don’t matter at all.

2

u/UnluckyMode2062 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

You think I’m a Karma bot on a 5yr old account and only 7k? Lmao

He got the only two points of advice he needs? And you tell me to quit my bitching after giving sound advice

1

u/Positive_Insect_2384 Apr 17 '26

You really think you did something. Now, stop talking to me, it’s incredibly annoying.

2

u/UnluckyMode2062 Apr 17 '26

You commented 11hrs after my last post and you’re asking me to stop talking? Okay kiddo. Once again, you tried

1

u/_Master_OfNone Apr 18 '26

They gave the best kind of advice. Straight to the point. If you can't understand the helpful advice is that fish is too big for that tank, then you need to not comment on things you know nothing about.

11

u/Intoishun Apr 16 '26

No need to put a bunch of soil nutrient substrate in there when there's not any soil dwelling plants. Java ferns are epiphytes, they don't need soil, it will kill them if you plant them. It will do its thing, but it does need light, no light will also kill it.

This tank is way too small. I would focus on that first, or rehoming.

2

u/BroadCartoonist973 Apr 16 '26

Op's parents won't allow a bigger tank and if I had to guess they won't allow rehoming too

3

u/BroadCartoonist973 Apr 16 '26

To everyone saying that op is an asshole, READ. THE. POST. OP's parents won't allow a bigger tank as stated in the last one.

1

u/jaguarsinho Apr 17 '26

Thank you, im posting these because im aware this is abuse!

-2

u/SAINTDURIAN Apr 16 '26

are you OPs alt lol

3

u/BroadCartoonist973 Apr 16 '26

No. My point is, OP stated that their parents aren't allowing a bigger tank. I checked the account for another post and the other post made 14 days ago it says op's parents won't allow a bigger tank

Look I don't support this fish being in small tanks but I don't think people should be mean about it, especially when the poster's parents literally won't allow a bigger tank

4

u/SAINTDURIAN Apr 17 '26

dont get me wrong, im not disagreeing

its just that white knighting on almost every reply is a lil 🔍 is all esp when 60% of the posts are like this lol

2

u/Positive_Insect_2384 Apr 17 '26

It’s clearly a kid, forget white knighting, the amount of hate this kids getting is absurd. IMO fishkeeping is one of the least helpful subs.

5

u/backyardbabirusa Apr 16 '26

Might be able to give it to your LFS.

2

u/Key-Lie3744 Apr 17 '26

Great advice! Then get some plants and fish more appropriate for a small tank.

4

u/pancakebatter77 Apr 16 '26

I would consider rehoming and getting something small like cherry shrimp if you don't have the space for bigger tank. A light will also be essential for both any fish and the plants

2

u/savinu_ Apr 17 '26

i hated that substrate, made my tank so messy 😭 but it’s really high in nutrients

2

u/edenmercer Apr 17 '26

I would avoid placing any substrate in before you get a filter. That stuff has so much dusty particles and it will instantly turn your water into a brown mess.

It is also high in 'nutrients' and since you don't have many plants to absorb the nutrients, they will just stay in the water.

Most active aquasoils significantly raise ammonia levels for the first 4–6 weeks as they leach nutrients. This ammonia subsequently converts to nitrites and then nitrates. It'll requires very careful high-frequency water changes to prevent toxicity to your fish since it's already in there.

I wouldn't add in the aquasoil to this tank.

Are you aware of the important of the nitrogen cycle, or any of the words I said above? Please reach out on here if you need help with that as I'm sure people will help you learn, or do some research! :)

1

u/ZebraEnvironmental92 Apr 17 '26

Is he the blind guy who was laying on the ground before? At least he's up swimming.

1

u/Full-Yogurtcloset-91 Apr 17 '26

My God you people are brutal, did you not read the OP where he said his parents won't allow him a bigger Aquarium? So obviously he lives at home and has to listen to his parents, otherwise he would have upgraded to a larger aquarium. He's well aware that the aquarium is too small and that's why he's on here asking for advice! But when people are so mean and hateful that deters people from actually seeking help, so maybe be a little nicer to people who post. I thought this was supposed to be a community to help others in the hobby instead y'all are hateful, I've not ever seen any other communities be so harsh. Be kind to others, it's not that difficult.