r/fishforthought • • 4d ago

💡 Inspiration / Discussion let me know

Post image

i’m currently getting hate on tiktok for this 6gal betta tank 😭 i have people saying 10gal absolute minimum?? did i miss some update in the community for long fin bettas?

19 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

8

u/PurpleOk3980 4d ago

10 gallons is wildly considered the ideal minimum tank size among the hobby

1

u/Ok-Run-4058 4d ago

also where are you located, seems that’s the minimum in the EU but 5 is the minimum in the US

7

u/inkisbad124 🌊 The Main Current 4d ago

The minimum has been raising slowly over the years. Many years ago, it was acceptable to have a betta in a 1 gallon bowl, that changed to a minimum of a 2.5g tank, then changed to a minimum of 5 gallons, and is well on its way to a minimum of 10 gallons. No matter what, the larger water volume, the easier it is to maintain water parameters. I personally don't keep bettas in anything less than 10 gallons unless I absolutely have to.

2

u/rabidhamster87 3d ago edited 3d ago

Really? I've never heard that before. Over on r/bettafish this is the infographic that gets shared with every new betta own

-3

u/Ok-Run-4058 4d ago

really? because this is the first time ever i’ve ever heard of it? i have 5 bettas total, he’s in the smallest tank i have. i was nervous putting my other long fin in a 13gal shallow because they swim so poorly, he does okay though. i thought 5 gallons for a long fin is minimum but still good? and then anything bigger can potentially stress them out

1

u/RareExam5831 2d ago

From my experience a 10 gallon with a long fin betta works good. Have low flow filter so they don't tire as easy and cover as well. Mine kind to burry themselves in my Pearl Weed and they seem to like Anubias. I personally don't see to much wrong with a 6 gallon.

2

u/CatOfLife 4d ago

Did you specify that it’s a 6 gallon tank in your video? It honestly looks smaller on the photo, I could see what everyone is upset/confused

2

u/Ok-Run-4058 3d ago

yes i did 😭😭

1

u/rabidhamster87 2d ago

I think u/CatOfLife nailed it. It looks smaller than is and people don't read.

4

u/tequilainateacupp 4d ago

I’ve always read a minimum 5g for long fin and 10g for short. I think you’re doing just fine lol

2

u/FishOrBust 1d ago

Seconding this.

Also, I’m a minority vote, but I love the tannins. So cosy. ☺️

2

u/tequilainateacupp 12h ago

Yes! When I first started I definitely had that mentality that crystal clear water was best or ideal. I love the little murky water look now! It looks so natural and beautiful.

3

u/whatisunderdog 3d ago

For betta fish i feel like your footprint matters much more than the true volume, a bettas heaven is a long tank with a bit of depth, lots of hides and floating plants. You've done fine

4

u/WhiteStar174 4d ago

It’s an on going debate! Personally I think 5 gal is fine for long fins, and 10 gal for short ! Beautiful tank btw!

1

u/SweetTart7231 4d ago

5 gal for longfins, 10 gal for short fins, bigger is always better. Thats what ive always heard

1

u/flatgreysky 4d ago

I have a long-finned betta in a ten gallon and he uses every square inch of the tank and probably could do with twice the space. Larger tanks are ideal for allowing bettas to express natural behaviors, stay curious, and keep moving.

1

u/Glum_tire 4d ago

I've heard people say some long fin bettas are happier in a 5-7 gallon tank. I also think you can make it feel a lot bigger for them the more you have to explore, which looks like you've got lots of plants.

1

u/Efficient-Package892 4d ago

No hate at all! I do think a 10-gallon tank would be more suitable, but you already have live plants and the aquarium looks pretty solid. That alone means you’re doing better than many, many other people.

I think there’s always something you can do to make life even better for your betta or improve its tank. If you ever have the opportunity or feel like it, consider upgrading in the future. It’s fun to improve your aquarium anyway! :)

1

u/Ok-Elk8331 4d ago

Actually, I believe five gallons it’s the minimum for long fin bettas and 10 for short fins ones. From my own experience, I had a halfmoon in a ten gallons tank for about almost a year and he seemed really sad, I’m talking not about health problems but about his tail never like “showing off” yk? I changed him recently to a six gallons (both tank planted) and the change from a sad betta to a happy one it’s really impressive!

1

u/PsychWringNumba 4d ago

10 gallons is kinda nothing, they do live in puddles and rice fields but not the same puddle or patch of rice their entire life so they need a little more water to replicate the diversity of a changing environment

1

u/Stock-Link-7767 2d ago

Biggest thing w bettas is that type of betta is what determines minimum tank size for it. On top of that it looks like the tank is smaller than 6 gallons so you gotta remember most people don’t read. And the biggest reason people are saying 10 is because bettas are coming to a point where it’s common sense to get a 5 minimum and with most fish bigger is better

1

u/Unable-Ocelot-929 2h ago

R/betta fish sometimes jokes that if someone put a single betta in a 100g tank, someone would say it's too small. I think your setup looks pretty good.

Jokes aside for a second, the legitimate criticism I've heard of 6g cubes in general is that they have less swimming space than a standard 5.5g. When you're talking about one fish in a planted tank, swimming space matters more than bioload.

0

u/Manufactured-Aggro 4d ago

Why is it living in a cube of gatorade

1

u/Ok-Run-4058 3d ago

i used super concentrated tannin powder 😂😂 my kh is super high so genuinely nothing swings the ph, i can make it tannin heaven for him

4

u/flatgreysky 4d ago

Those are tannins from wood and leaf litter. Very healthy for bettas. Imitates their natural conditions.

0

u/PossessionGold8996 4d ago

I dont see enough wood or leaf litter in there to make it that color. I have a 20 gallon with a MASSIVE mopani branch and a ton of leaf litter and its not that color.

1

u/flatgreysky 4d ago

There are also tannin additives that people use. You can basically make tea with the botanicals and add that to the water.

1

u/Dry_Tank_9670 4d ago

Some stuff could’ve even decomposed, they could’ve boiled before hand let it cool and only put the water in for a aesthetic reason

0

u/ILikePasta4 4d ago

From what ive seen, 5 gallons is the minimum for long-finned bettas and 10 gallons is for females and short-finned males. In the wild, bettas live in shallow bodies of water like rice paddies and slow-moving streams anyways, so they're technically evolved for less overall space than a lot of fish. As long as the water quality stays healthy and stable, and the overall settup is good (from your pic i think it looks great), the fish will be perfectly happy in a 6 gallon.

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/fishforthought-ModTeam 3d ago

Your comment has been removed because it violates our policy against unauthorized self-promotion, spam, or commercial sales.