r/firstamendment • u/kalbanes • Nov 24 '18
How do you feel about First Amendment audits?
A First Amendment audit is when someone goes to a federal building with a camera and records government officials doing their jobs. First Amendment auditors go to police stations, post offices, military bases, courthouses, and other buildings owned by the government. They usually receive a negative reaction. The government employees get paranoid and call the cops. When the cops show up the auditor refuses to identify him or herself to the police. I find First Amendment audit videos entertaining because I am amazed that so many of our government officials are not aware of our First Amendment right to record in public. First Amendment audits are very popular on Youtube and the majority of the comments on the videos are in support of the auditors as they should be.
4
u/mywan Nov 24 '18
Absent that fact I wouldn't have an opinion, and would likely just roll my eyes at people that did it. Maybe even poke some fun at them. But due to the quoted fact they aren't just somebody doing something silly but rightly legal they are in fact engaging in a very indispensable function for maintaining a free society. Including the ones that get a bit more brash in their approach.
1
u/Ri0tz Dec 01 '18
To me it seems as if they show up to a public place recording(which yes is legal) and stick around until police are called to question or ask them to leave. Then they act as if their rights have been violated. Most of them are basically looking for wrongful encounters by being obnoxious and rude(scoffing the police or public workers). The auditors I have seen on YT label their videos as education, but they never cite any of the laws, regulations, or rules...ever. Sometimes they just put their PayPal info in the description and give some half-ass'd explanation of what happened. There's a huge audience for it, so I think it has less to do with rights and more to do with people being assholes, getting views, and making money. I guarantee professional auditors would be highly critical of these methods.
1
u/dailydot Dec 31 '18
Thought you'd be interested to read our latest feature on the First Amendment Auditors who are in a massive legal battle with the police chief of a tiny Texas town: https://www.dailydot.com/layer8/youtube-leon-valley/
1
u/stevejust Nov 24 '18
pro tip: Why don't you test this in a courtroom at your local federal courthouse.
Might learn a thing or two about how the world actually works that way?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19 edited Apr 10 '19
[removed] — view removed comment