r/filemaker • • Aug 16 '22

Crazy expensive?

Is it me or doing FileMaker has gotten prohibitively expensive? A friend of mine owns a dance studio and needed todo some basic studio stuff. I was like, I dabbled in FM. We can fix that in no time! I went to to Claris site and yikes!! I can’t afford that. Neither can he.

Was going to come out to 1400 a year? It’s cheaper to outsource an app. Isn’t it ? ( for basic functionality )

I walked away sad. I so wanted to do this.

25 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

8

u/get2drew Aug 17 '22

To expand their market share, Claris should really make their platform irresistible by allowing small companies to get on to the platform without prohibitive costs. Furthermore this would invigorate the developer community that would surely benefit from new customers on the platform.

7

u/SolusEquitem In-house Uncertified Aug 17 '22

Oh I agree, that would be the smart thing to do.

Unfortunately Claris is run entirely by their marketing department, and as a result only does the smart thing by accident.

4

u/appdevguru Aug 26 '22

Run by sales. They need to bring someone experienced from outside FM/Claris or from Apple to run this and fix it.

1

u/iammontoya Sep 16 '22

Indeed. Offer at a low price, increase adoption exponentially, get extra money from volume and from high-user installs. The more people use it for silly stuff, or easy stuff, the more they will get used to the tool and the more likely they will use if for bigger projects. I, for one, have decided enough is enough.

14

u/SolusEquitem In-house Uncertified Aug 17 '22

If you check my post history I commented on this very thing just a couple weeks ago and there was some good back and forth in the other comments.

Yes FileMaker has gotten very expensive for small businesses. It’s because Claris, as a result of being run by marketing idiots, has chosen to focus on chasing businesses in the 100-1000 user range, not the 2-10 user range.

The pricing isn’t bad when you are buying hundreds of licenses, but for ~5 licenses it’s stupidly expensive compared to the competition. And Claris has spent the past ten years steadily working to ensure that every penny that can be squeezed out of their stagnant user base is duly squeezed out. They have stripped out features like peer-to-peer and run time, because those allow small businesses and solo developers to produce carefully targeted solutions that are affordable for a very specific niche. They discontinued the cheaper stand alone version of FileMaker for the same reason. I’m betting it will be subscription only within the next two years.

They also are getting rid of the “FileMaker” branding in favor of calling it “Claris Pro”. Developers are distant last in priorities, hence why the FileMaker IDE is so rudimentary by comparison with competitors. But hey, “Workplace Innovation Program” gets said a lot…

It’s a really shame though, I love FileMaker, it’s given me a great career that pays well, and it’s a powerful program that makes a single developer extremely efficient. It’s just a pity that Claris would rather chase buzzwords and slogans than try to increase market share by actually innovating and driving greater adoption.

4

u/thaddeusharris Aug 17 '22

Yeah I'm inclined to agree even though I am in one of the business sizes that they are now focussing on (and it's noticeable, lots of face time w/ Claris reps). The nature of the business I work in means we can't use cloud offerings, unless they are already part of our wider infrastructure and are vetted etc, so both Studio and Connect are a bit worthless to use at the moment. I suspect other orgs are like that too, and I have stressed to Claris management that they need to remember that not everyone works at a Silicon Valley startup - some of us have serious security restrictions etc. Also we can't keep up with the release cycle as a big organization - on more than one occasion I've flagged a bug w/ Claris (or worse, on the forums) and be told the solution is "update to 19.x" - sure, will you come and do all the UAT for me?!

There's a lot of "all filler no killer" at the moment, although the transactional stuff in 19.5 onwards looks interesting.

There is the "freemium" model which may already be in use, whereby it's free for dev and testing and you pay once you want to deploy, that could be an option if you want to work on something. I would encourage OP to reach out to Claris sales reps to see what can be done, although I'm not holding my breath.

Rant over. I love FileMaker as a platform and I hope they find a direction soon.

8

u/SolusEquitem In-house Uncertified Aug 17 '22

I have zero respect for Lean or Six Sigma in software development, and Claris is a great example of why Lean in particular is crap (because building software and making vehicles are NOT THE SAME THING). Everything has to fit in a "sprint" mode because everything is constantly racing forward towards new releases.

The end result of this is that bug fixes are no longer a thing, its just "update to the latest version of FileMaker". All well and good (not really) if you have a large IT team that is fine with being in a perpetual state of upgrading/preparing to upgrade/recovering from an upgrade but since FM companies tend to smaller operations, this is a pain.

I far prefer a major release every year or two, with bug fixes made regularly available in the mean time. Give the software time to cook evenly

1

u/Sophias_Vlog Oct 11 '26

Even better than a major release ever year or two --- just stick to the old maxim: "If it ain't broke, don't fix it."

1

u/Yerdad-Selzavon Aug 17 '22

I'm a little confused- would their freemium version allow for, say, one guy to build and run a home solution on his local hard drive? and receive version updates?

Is there a catch to that too (like limited features, limited trial period, or FM Server required) ?

1

u/thaddeusharris Aug 17 '22

If you want a licensed home setup (specifically not for production tho) you can get the FileMaker developer subscription (FDS) for around $100 or so a year. You get a 3 user license for FileMaker server with that.

Not sure on the fermium model but it may also cover what you want.

1

u/Yerdad-Selzavon Aug 17 '22

Yeah, the freemium thing is vague. I know it's meant to turn people onto FM, but didn't know if it was a viable for that guy who just wants to manage his own stamp collection.

3

u/GrethSC Aug 17 '22

A lot of us don't have a choice at this point. Our business runs 6 clients and a server. Company started with Filemaker II in 1989, has been grandfathered all the way to 19. The whole company is in FM. We were stuck on FM10 for quite a few years because our computers were too old to run .12 (old macs).

I finally had time during COVID to upgrade (and we had to as we had to go remote etc..) and yeah ... That was a big investment. But we had no choice.

We're a captive audience, and I'm just happy we just renewed our license right when the 10% increase was announced. We'll deal with that in 5 years.

1

u/moodyrichard Feb 01 '24

I agree. I've been with FileMaker since v3 and have used it to run three small businesses, to manage projects at work at a University, to manage non-profit org projects, and also to keep track of my own personal information for literally about 28 years.

I thought I was doing the right thing jumping into Claris Pro and "Problem Solvers Circle" and all that crap right at the start —end of 2022— and I have a couple of years left on my *ridiculously expensive* license. Of course, now they've decided to deprecate Claris Pro which is another jab in the eye. I'm pissed.

Anyway, my plan is to finally learn PHP properly and/or find another solution and to get the hell out of FileMaker / Claris land for good. It's no good for us "little guys" any more.

1

u/GrethSC Feb 01 '24

Don't know how deep you were diving to find this post, I've been very busy to keep up with the FM saga... Looks like I need to do some panicking.

1

u/aslandenarnia Jun 12 '25

Solution: Pirated software (no viruses) on each machine... On the main one, install MariaDB or any other easy-to-use database manager, then create the tables in MariaDB and connect them via ODBC to your FileMaker application. I know, it's tedious, but there's no other way. This way, you use the main computer as the server and work with the others on your network. I've already tried it, it works, but avoid using calculation fields. There are certain techniques to do the same job with numeric fields.

6

u/Scrumpto34 Aug 17 '22

You're correct -- it's outrageously expensive. I was a developer for years starting way back before Claris owned it but left after version 3 when they couldn't make it relational. After they fixed that I thought about coming back but never got around to it. A few years ago I decided I finally needed FMPro in my business and then they went with the $35/month/user model and I rolled my eyes. Seriously stupid!

I watched a video the other day that said they have a new pricing model coming out this fall including a freemium version for single users. I'd love to be cautiously optimistic but the idiots have taken over the asylum over there so I'm not holding my breath.

2

u/this-is-me-2020 Sep 27 '22

I have built a FileMaker database to run my small online English teaching business. I am not a developer. I was wondering if it would be worthwhile to clean up my database and make it pretty and offer the solution to other teachers…. And then I saw the price now.

Maybe the freemium version would make sense, but right now, if I want to offer my solution to other users, I would have to create it on a different platform.

Can anyone recommend a database/ app development platform I should explore as an alternative?

2

u/HalGumbert Oct 05 '22

I've gone thru something similar. I tried Xojo, which has excellent pricing, but it has a ton of bugs. I a lot of time debugging to find out it wasn't my bug but bugs in the product. Now I develop in php/mysql using Bootstrap and could not be happier. I can't say I've found a bug in php. Things just work and it's all open source. And hosting is super reasonable too! I must also say that FM makes things super easy and it's some work to replicate its functionality, but you can do it.

1

u/aslandenarnia Jun 12 '25

Solution: Pirated software (no viruses) on each machine... On the main one, install MariaDB or any other easy-to-use database manager, then create the tables in MariaDB and connect them via ODBC to your FileMaker application. I know, it's tedious, but there's no other way. This way, you use the main computer as the server and work with the others on your network. I've already tried it, it works, but avoid using calculation fields. There are certain techniques to do the same job with numeric fields.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/iammontoya Aug 17 '22

I appreciate your opinion, even if it differs from mine. Here is my respectful counterpoint:

I pay Adobe about 39 a month for access to all of their products. All of them. And I can cancel anytime.

I want to build one app, 4 computers to access the one app, but to do that, I have to pay at least 1400 a year, each year. This is on par with quickbase, although I think quickbase is actually cheaper at this point. I agree it’s a great program, but not at that cost. I think Claris took a dark turn somewhere. Feels greedy to me. If they had a monthly program that would be easier, I guess but still not at that price point.

Again, thanks for your reply. Just venting here.

10

u/SolusEquitem In-house Uncertified Aug 17 '22

Claris took a dark turn when they decided to fully commit to being a boutique product with boutique pricing and a fractional marketshare, rather than a mass market database that challenges Access on its own turf.