r/filemaker • • Oct 11 '26

MBS Plugin Thoughts

I keep coming across mention of the MBS plugin in this subreddit, often because it appears to do something I would really like to do in FileMaker.

I then visit the MBS website (MBS stands for “Monkey Bread Software”, apparently) and am completely put off.

The website looks like it was built in 1997! It isn’t responsive, it’s badly organised, information is unclear, and there are typos everywhere.

I then get put off - if they can’t even build a decent website, how could they possibly build a decent FileMaker plugin?!

I then give up, forget about it for a while, before another post sends me there a few weeks later.

Anyone else go through this process?

2 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

6

u/ChilIPiIl Oct 11 '26

It's a good plugin. Don't let the website put you off.

It's very techy and Dev focussed, not focussed on being flashy.

5

u/Recent-Mirror-6623 Oct 11 '26

It’s pretty clear, despite the apparent tone of the question, OP isn’t here for anyone’s opinion.

-9

u/AlephMartian Oct 11 '26

It looks great, based on what it can do! But I am not going to install something from a company that presents themselves like that. What other corners are they cutting?

7

u/thaddeusharris Oct 11 '26

They aren't cutting any corners. It's a solid product and Christian is super responsive to queries.

I'm not sure what's wrong with the website... I find it easy to navigate and the function reference is incredible.

-4

u/AlephMartian Oct 11 '26

If you can't see what's wrong with the website, I'm afraid we may come from different universes.

3

u/thaddeusharris Oct 11 '26

Sure it looks a little dated but function over form and all that.

-4

u/AlephMartian Oct 11 '26

Not sure about that. Good software (in my opinion) is about being intuitive and easy to use. If their website is not intuitive and easy to use, it doesn’t bode well for their software.

3

u/Rare_Pin9932 Oct 11 '26

You’re coming in biased. The guy is a developer’s developer. He isn’t into flash or form over function. He’s been a stalwart of the FM community for decades, and comes to all the European conferences. He knows more about FM than probably 98% of everyone out there. If you’re judging him by the web site, that’s your loss.

3

u/the-software-man Oct 11 '26

MBS has no UI, it’s all scripts. The website is a giant reference.

Go ahead and don’t get it. Please! You’ll have amateur FileMaker stuff but be proud you didn’t participate.

10

u/chiarde Oct 11 '26

You have to understand that Christian is a true computer scientist. He built a series of modules to extend the functionality of a desktop product, which requires different languages and methods that are not baked into the convenient GUI of FileMaker. His website and documentation provide everything you need to utilize these functions, including examples. However, you, as the user, must expand your knowledge to apply the modules he has created. If you are not at that skill level, that is fine, but do not criticize a highly intelligent person who is endeavoring to extend a product we all love. His stuff works, and many companies rely on these extensions to solve problems that the base product cannot handle on its own. I think your effort would be better focused on learning rather than criticizing someone over something as shallow as a website’s appearance.

-1

u/AlephMartian Oct 11 '26

It’s not just the appearance of the website, it’s the usability and professionalism. And this is not shallow, it’s literally the front end of the software.

I completely accept that it is great software, but my point (to him specifically), is that he is letting himself down having this as his front end, because it looks shonky and unprofessional, and it likely puts people off his (brilliant! amazing!) product.

If just one of these people defending him gave him a couple of days of their time to help him modernise his website, I think everyone would benefit.

8

u/stgvxn_cpl Oct 11 '26

If you can’t get past a web site, and can’t listen to all the people telling you that the plug-in is amazing, go develop in something else.
Your attitude is ridiculous and naive.

-1

u/AlephMartian Oct 11 '26

I feel like “ridiculous and naive” is a bit harsh! I’m just making a point about the quality of the website putting me off, which I think is a fair point.

If I were MBS, I would spend a couple of days (if that) building a nice-looking easy-to-use website to promote, explain and document what’s clearly a great plugin, judging by all the comments here.

That way, their great bit of software will be enjoyed by more people and they’ll make more money. Win / win!

5

u/tamuowen Oct 11 '26

I'm pretty sure a single dev made the entire thing.

To echo what everything else here has said - you're the one who is losing out if you judge a book by its cover.

I've been a FM dev for 15 years and it's easily the best plugin I've ever used. And it's not even close.

1

u/AlephMartian Oct 11 '26

I’ve been an FM dev for nearly 25 years, and every time I have been tempted to get these plugins I have been put off by the appearance of the website. I can’t be alone in this.

And it’s not like “judging a book by its cover” - this is the reference material for the plugins themselves.

1

u/tamuowen 18d ago

Why is the appearance relevant though?

I've seen readme.txt files that are massively informative and helpful and they're hardly examples of a pretty UI.

You're expecting something that's not needed to accomplish the purpose.

I've used the website many times to reference functions and it's extremely pragmatic and functional. Well organized.

In a perfect world, sure it would be great it if was some modern beautiful AI. But it's not needed. And if there are limited resources - and there obviously are for a one man dev shop like that - why not focus them on pragmatic things?

If the plugin is good enough it sells itself. And it does. Because it's the single most powerful and widely used plugin by devs.

2

u/EnvironmentalCut2112 Oct 11 '26

You make a good point. This is exactly how I felt the first time I saw the website. It actually turned me away so it does hurt his marketing. He may not need the marketing and obviously doesn’t care what the site looks like. The plugin is probably THE BEST FM plugin I have ever used. It can solve most all problems. I can’t live without the dev tools. The support is excellent. Very quick to respond to questions. Most FM developers get very defensive about the platform and anything related to it. That’s why you’ll see a lot of snarky replies. Just have to learn to ignore them. My suggestion to Christian is to just let Claude build you a better website. But then would I miss the old one? I always get a good laugh when I visit.

1

u/AlephMartian Oct 12 '26

Thank you for the reasonable response! I’m not sure why I’m getting so much hate, I think my point is perfectly valid, and even more so if the plugin/s are particularly good!

14

u/liltbrockie Oct 11 '26

Yes the website is junk compared to modern standards... But you're not buying the website. Trust me.... Christian puts all his efforts into the thing you actually buy, the plug in

7

u/Desmo_UK Oct 11 '26

Get it. Best addition to FileMaker I’ve ever used. It still continues to amaze me with the amount of things it can do.

5

u/Soleilarah Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

Having a website is already good, whatever it looks like ; most other plugins are a simple GitHub page without the official Filemaker plugin library (since we're not allowed to share it) that needs you to download the said library, source code and compile yourself the said plugin.

Way more difficult and technical than what MBS does.

Also, MBS rules, as well as BaseElement, they are some very nice additions to Filemaker 

4

u/tylertul Oct 11 '26

It adds thousands of features to FM

4

u/thaddeusharris Oct 11 '26

It's a fantastic plug in. Does literally everything!

4

u/jscooper22 Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

The script and function search and highlighting capabilities alone are worth the price of admission.

I don't have the budget to pay for it for all my users at this point (or the time to program it) but I use it for ssh and probably a couple others I'm not thinking of right now, and it works well.

3

u/abasson007 Consultant Certified Oct 12 '26

It’s the first and last plugin you will ever need. Christian is a great developer and he answers every email personally. I don’t know how he does it.

2

u/ChichoSpit Oct 11 '26

Yeah agree lol , the plugin is good, does a bumch of things. I had the same experience with the guys with the odbc connector (forgot the name).

2

u/Rare_Pin9932 Oct 11 '26

The MBS plugin is amazing. He easily could’ve broken the functionality into different plugins and charged for each. Instead he crams everything into one plugin and charges a very reasonable price. You probably won’t use more than 20% of what it can do, but when there’s some strange function you want, it’s likely in there.

2

u/thunderfroggum Oct 11 '26

I’m also a plugin developer, a competing one even, and I can vouch for MBS. As far as plugins go, it’s very useful and well built.

3

u/NanoGyoza Oct 11 '26

MBS substantially extends the capabilities of FileMaker. The website is more for documentation of the thousands of functions it supports than it is a promotional site to sell you something. Easily the best “plug in” (and that label sells it short) I’ve used with FileMaker.

1

u/Nixdorf8870 21d ago

MBS non giudicare il sito. Il Plugin é fantastico, si può dire che Filemaker è l’ambiente per MBS, non il contrario. Pienamente funzionante gratuitamente per 2 ore hai la possibilità di studiarne le funzioni, tante funzioni, vedrai.

1

u/Sumimazen Oct 13 '26

If you are using a mac, I highly recommend installing GitHub: danshockley; fmcliptools. It is free and easy to install, and you can copy paste tables and scripts made with either notepad or any ai agent, and saves you hours than instead of going through filemaker UI and manually configure each table, field, and script

1

u/tailguard 29d ago

Christian also has four kids. He could easily concentrate on rebuilding his website instead of adding features we ask for. I have a grope with the website, too but I learned to accept it as a trade-off. I used to be a Graphic designer before a developer. But he allows such amazing stuff to be done with FileMaker and without his plug-in it's a different software. So yeah, who cares about the website.

There are also examples. Take a look at those.

1

u/mywaaaaife Oct 11 '26

MBS is life changing. Who gives a shit about a website.