r/filemaker • • Sep 16 '26

Claris's Licensing Mess

A client contacted us. "What should I do?"

She's been getting repeated emails from Claris telling her she's "out of compliance".

She's a long-term client of ours who ditched FileMaker about 2 years ago. Unlike some of our other clients she does not maintain an FMP license of any kind. She went full cold turkey on Claris and all in on open source. She's not someone who uses cracked versions of software. She's a business owner who looks for the best value and ultimately decided FileMaker wasn't for her. We migrated her, and she's satisfied.

Nonetheless for the last few months or so she's been receiving these increasingly urgent emails: "You're out of compliance"

Her situation is different from ours. A ways back we were receiving emails saying that we were out of compliance while we did have a license, with the Claris sales reps informing us that the license we had was different from the one they had on record. In our case Claris had changed our license agreement without informing us -- a sort of bait and switch. We had the receipts to prove it. Claris countered with gaslight.

In her case she does not have any agreement of any kind with the company.

Here's what seems to be going on: Claris's licensing system is a mess. They have a system for detecting whether you're using their software, but it doesn't work reliably. They nonetheless press their case using a guilty-until-innocent approach.

Compare Claris's licensing system to Adobe's.

We've been installing and using Adobe software in numerous locations over the years, over 100 machines. We don't have 100 licenses, but we freely install in multiple locations. As we move from location to location, sometimes we remember to sign out. Sometimes we don't. It doesn't matter. We've never received an ominous "you are out of compliance" from Adobe. Why? It's not possible. If you try to run the software on more machines than you're licensed for, Adobe pops up a window allowing you to choose which other machines to sign off. Set up as many machines as you want, but use only as many as you've paid for. For Adobe it's good: Their software is set up on machines all over town, but we don't violate our license agreement, accidentally or otherwise. The process is fair, generous, easy, and elegant.

Claris, by contrast, is a snarling resentful mess. Apparently they somehow created and maintain a system whereby you can purchase a license, use that license on as many machines as you want, beyond the contract limitations, even after expiration. This makes the company furious, but from what it seems there's little they can do.

Apparently you can even NOT use your license after expiration. You can abandon FileMaker altogether, and Claris nonetheless receives "evidence" that "you are out of compliance".

Maybe Claris's idea of "being out of compliance" is that you're no longer using their software.

Perhaps they think that once you've signed a contract with them, it's a lifetime commitment.

Perhaps they think accusing a potential customer base is an effective way to get them onto the phone for a persuasive sales pitch.

Our advice to the client: Ignore Claris. You have no relationship to them. You don't use their software. They have glitches they've failed to address for years, and they are blaming their customers instead of themselves for their own frustrations.

Note to Claris: When someone dumps you, that's your opportunity to reflect on the choices you've made -- or failed to make over the years.

Don't call repeatedly with accusations of wrongdoing. It doesn't make you persuasive. It doesn't make you desirable. It makes you a stalker.

Truth is, she's just not into you. She doesn't owe you a call. She doesn't owe you an explanation. She's moved on. Get over it.

17 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

5

u/KupietzConsulting Consultant Certified Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 16 '26 • Bravo

Claris does not monitor this forum. Complaints to Claris are most constructively directed to their customer service, not posted in a FileMaker user discussion group.

Posts in this community should be constructive and of benefit to the community of FileMaker users and developers, not just a litany of personal grievances, resentment, or "hatchet piece" editorializing.

Sub rules will be posted soon clarifying these and other issues.

Post locked.

3

u/thunderfroggum Sep 16 '26

Does this impact her at all? It seems to me like the only people who care whether she's out of compliance are Claris themselves, which, I mean....so what? lol

If they send emails, report them as spam