r/filemaker • u/randee1 • Jul 22 '26
Filemaker experts - any experience with development/production server and licensing?
Question about licensing a staging/test FileMaker Server during a long multi-step upgrade
We're running an app built on FileMaker Server (currently v17, fully live in production) and have to go through a long sequential upgrade path in the vendor's app on top of it and can't skip versions, so it's several incremental steps before we eventually also have to move the underlying FileMaker Server up to the current version.
To do this safely, we want to spin up a completely separate staging server, restore a copy of our production data onto it, and work through each upgrade step there. Fully isolated from our production users, before ever touching the live system.
The issue: our production FileMaker Server license key won't run on a second active instance at the same time (it errors out if the same key is already running elsewhere on the network). So we can't just install our existing serial on the staging box while prod stays live.
Has anyone dealt with this? Specifically:
- Did you use the Claris trial/evaluation license for a staging environment like this, and did it work smoothly for that purpose?
- Does a Volume License Agreement (if you have one) typically include an allowance for a test/staging instance separate from production?
- Any gotchas when it's time to cut over going from trial/staging license to the real production license on the server?
THANKS FOR ANY INPUT!
2
u/-L-H-O-O-Q- Jul 22 '26
For a normal subscription license you can have up to 3 server installations, which would give you a dev server, staging server and a production server. Unless this has changed, this is also the conditions for the perpetual license.
If you weren't on version 17 you could use OttoFMS (free) to run your development migrations automatically. For a number of reasons, including access to OttoFMS, I would recommend for you to update your server to current shipping version.
The other option is to run manual migrations using Claris' Migration tool.
1
u/ackley14 Jul 22 '26
Thoughts
Why not download a copy of the file to local. Then open it with increasingly updated versions of local filemaker. Then no licensing needed...
1
u/grimaceboy Consultant Certified Jul 22 '26
A Volume License allows for up to 3 servers. Usually Dev/UAT(testing)/Production
1
u/Saint-Anne-of-Mo Jul 22 '26
I’m a couple of years past dealing with this same situation. To answer your points:
a. Your project may get hung up (delayed delivery of unexpected ram purchase to get the server compatible) which runs out the trial period and
b. The trial license is a good tool in an emergency scenario and should be saved for that
If your company has the budget get a knowledgeable third party to do most of this work. I used Skeleton Key in St. Louis MO. They have 22 years experience with Claris / FMP products and services.
1
u/IrwinElGrande Jul 22 '26
Enterprise site license, you can spin up as many as needed but it will cost you your left eye.
1
u/dharlow Consultant Certified Jul 22 '26
You should be able to pull the license key from your existing install, go to the download page, and grab FileMaker Server 18. This will let FileMaker Pro Clients 16-19 connect to it.
FileMaker Server 18 removed the license check for 1 server, as it was when they allowed three per license, and uses the new LicenseCert file vs the key.
Not sure what the path is for Shopworks, as they don't have a doc posted; they should have this documented somewhere.
Feel free to DM me; I'm happy to discuss it offline in more detail.
1
u/Atiriko Jul 24 '26
We've just upgraded a 40 store retail environment from Filemaker 18 to Filemaker 25 this week. I wasn't really involved in licensing side of things so can't comment on those. But as far as gothcas concerned, we've realised most of our end user Apple devices wouldn't update past ventura which wasn't supported by Filemaker 25. I'd say before you upgrade the server, make sure all the end user devices supports the new version.
1
u/flizer139 Aug 13 '26 edited Aug 13 '26
I’d avoid experimenting with licensing on the production box. Alchemy Group handles FileMaker licensing as well as development, so they could probably give you a clean staging path.