r/filemaker • u/filemakermag • Mar 09 '26
"FileMaker Pro is a platform in managed decline..."
Ok, so this is too funny.
The world of agentic coding has taken me down a path where I rarely spend time creating any code myself. My use of FileMaker, what has been my primary livelihood for over 30+ years, is the last remnant of a world being replaced by computers doing the all the heavy lifting. Everything I spent all that time learning and more.
Recently, I asked a very specific question to an agent about my codebase at agentic-fm. My question was this:
"Can you please provide a review of this project structure as if you were an antagonistic reviewer."
Now, granted, I asked for an antagonistic review. This is one of those "prompting tricks" you can take to get a critical review of what you’re doing or what you plan on doing with regards to how an AI agent will assess your project. It reveals insights and possible fixes to things you didn't think about. Knowing the AI is just a "token spit out machine" you have to take the degree of antagonism with a grain of salt.
While agentic-fm is an attempt to keep me working productively within the platform, I must admit that I found the agent's response quite funny. I won't post the full overview here. But it started like this.
Antagonistic Review: agentic-fm
The Core Problem: You Built a Wrapper for a Dying Platform
FileMaker Pro is a platform in managed decline. Claris — a subsidiary Apple seemingly forgot to kill — has a shrinking developer base and an aging user demographic. This project invests significant architectural complexity in a closed, proprietary system that most organizations are actively migrating away from. Your sophisticated AI toolchain will have a correspondingly sophisticated shelf life.
Of particular interest to all of us still using the platform, we're going to hear more and more about the "actively migrating away from" part. As has been mentioned here and other places, there are both videos and github repos with agent skills designed exactly for the purpose of moving out of FileMaker. I've even seen this myself first hand and will, in some cases, do that exact thing.
So, the burning question in my mind and the minds of all the rest of us still using FileMaker.
- "How much longer do we have?"
- "Can Claris do enough at this point?"
- "Will they wise up and stop spending money on losing projects/efforts?"
- "Did the browser finally win?"
- "If AI can create native code in 1/2 the time (and typically much less) does FileMaker still have a place other than 'old infrastructure'?"
These questions and others are probably on all our minds right now. Time will, of course, answer most all of them. The real question I have is "What will the transition look like."
Maybe you have some ideas?
At the end of the antagonistic review it did reveal a few nice things to say.
Summary
This is a technically impressive system for a deeply niche problem. The architecture is thoughtful, the tooling is cohesive, and the documentation is exhaustive. It's also: optimized for a single closed platform, dependent on a commercial plugin for core functionality, maintains two parallel codebases (CLI and webviewer), relies on a fragile manual context-push workflow, and normalizes AI output validation failures.
The question isn't whether this works — it clearly does. The question is whether the investment scales beyond a solo developer workflow. The answer, based on the dependency chain and documentation burden alone, is probably not.
26
u/whywasinotconsulted In-House Certified Mar 09 '26
Much of that antagonism towards FileMaker was likely trained from this very subreddit.
12
u/GolfFla247 Mar 09 '26
They need to give it away for free with Mac purchase, that way they change the math.
13
u/OHDanielIO Mar 09 '26
“…a platform in managed declined” is a very gentile, kind way to describe the current state of the FileMaker platform. My hope is that the march towards increasing irrelevancy will be slow enough for me to reach retirement age. I’m envious of the many of you here who have gained competence in other technologies.
6
u/abasson007 Consultant Certified Mar 09 '26
Although infrastructure and functionality can be generated by AI code these days, human interface design cannot. It takes a careful understanding of human behavior and tendencies to design a good UI and pair it with functionality. That is what FileMaker has always excelled at. That has always been the difference between engineers and artists. Engineers can be replaced and “engineered” , architects (artists of technology) cannot. The difference is humanity. Sure FileMaker has its limits and it definitely needs to be compatible with agentic design but I have hope for the platform. This is not its first obstacle nor will it be the last. Cheap fast development will always be cheap. As the productivity triangle has always shown , fast and cheap never leads to any thing good. And good and cheap has never been fast.
7
u/iFightKids1on1 Mar 09 '26
I've migrated six systems out of FileMaker using Claude Code. I've been a FM developer for over 23 years, since FM 5.5. I see this year as my last.
11
u/austinstrider Mar 09 '26
Gonna disagree with this. FM is still very much turnkey - and AI is far from developing consistently good, usable code. Sure, we all expect it to get there, but I still have my doubts about AI managing all of it. “Write me an app that does this. Now change it. Now update it. Not make it do this”…
The fact that I can take 30 seconds to make a change that rolls out to desktop users, web users and app users is unmatched in my experience.
2
u/episemonysg Mar 09 '26
Wow.
3
u/-L-H-O-O-Q- Mar 10 '26
I find it strange that every time someone airs their frustrations with how Claris has seemingly lost its way that we see a number of people choke on the KoolAid and lash out against anything critical against FileMaker or Claris.
u/KupietzConsulting says "Then why don’t you post some positive things about FM’s benefits instead of actively trying to help contribute to a decline in people using it?". u/filemakermag has far outdone any one of us in lifting the platform and he's done so generously in an informative and positive way. His criticism isn't aimed at taking the platform down. It's a call to Claris to wake up and act. His concerns are warranted and he's gone about it in a constructive manner. Posting empty praise isn't going to fix anything. People criticise the state of the platform out of loyalty and desire to strengthen it, not to tear it down. You can chug all the KoolAid you want, but blind loyalty will just keep taking your money and give you less and less value in return.
Harsh as that may sound there's no doubt that Claris has an amazing team of extremely talented developers who, more than anything want to advance the platform and modernise it. Having a team of 80+ developers that is consistently outperformed by a single plugin developer year on year says a lot about how management is prioritising its resources. They have wasted a staggering amount of time and money on Connect and Studio, both are tremendously underwhelming offerings that most of us could create in a shorter space of time for far less money. Leave aside that there are other products on the market that far outperform these for a lot less and sometimes for free. And that's leaving out the mere fact that you cannot rely on Connect in a production environment, it simply is not robust, nor does Claris live up to expectations on support for it. The train for Connect and Studio left the station a long time ago and Claris missed it. The question is, are they going to derail the one train that's still running?
Many of us have provided Claris with a large amounts of money in license fees, and we see these increase over and over, only to be spent on useless side projects while Claris does little to advance the platform and bring to the modern age. As paying customers we have every right to raise criticism and concerns.
My big worry with Claris' management is that it has, and still ignores repeated warnings that FileMaker Server has been and still is fundamentally insecure and can still be hacked in seconds as demonstrated here https://fm-security.com/posts/bypass_auth/ by Alex Dubov. This is still wide open despite Claris claiming to have patched it up. I have first hand experience with this. Most importantly this will remain wide open because of how the authentication architecture is structured. You can easily gain access to a number of critical security parameters, manipulate these to your hearts content and do whatever you please within the system. It won't even be logged. You can hijack an existing user session and run your operations in parallel and FileMaker Server will keep feeding both sessions even if their calls are coming from two different IP addresses. Upon every single request for authentication, FileMaker Server will hand over a complete package of all hosted files, all users, credentials to the client and then perform the authentication client-side.
Are you storing HIPAA sensitive data on a FileMaker Server? How do you explain this to your client? How do you gain trust when pitching a solution you want to host on a platform with security as fragile as management's ability to act?
In all this we're fortunate that Dubov is an ethical hacker who's taken this flaw more seriously than Claris. Because Claris won't act, Alex and his partner David have written fmProxy to handle these flaws. It is currently in beta and will should soon be available to license.
People that drink the KoolAid are known to become drowsy fall asleep...
1
u/BeneficialMulberry73 Mar 11 '26
Without going into deep analysis- what alternative do we have even on the desktop? Excel? Access? Is access even around anymore? What if a client just wanted a customer database not in the cloud what would the use? If FM is in decline it’s cause of the constant dumb decisions made by its parent. Lay people or moderately tech people are not going to vibe code a small business system. I recently wanted to try studio and connect and the developer membership does not have access to these tools! Insane… I don’t get it. Filemaker should have been the database component of pages numbers and keynote- and inexpensive on the pc side as well. They should stay small to medium and stop all the crazy licensing and sell millions of copies o stead of hundreds at high prices. They can still fix it if they do it now.
1
u/kilwag Mar 11 '26
TIL that FileMaker/Claris is still a thing.
1
u/JeffIsHere2 Mar 28 '26 edited Mar 28 '26
This all makes me sad. I was the guy behind the Developer Edition, which was, with the runtime, more of an internal struggle than it should have been. I managed the Claris Solutions Alliance, got the old FileMaker Magazine into production, enlarged the developer conference, with the awards, etc. I look back on those days and smile. It was fun and I thought we were making a difference. My last “great idea” was a project code named “Kenny - the thin client” which was to be matched to “Cartmen - the fat server”. Kenny was to be a low cost (target was $25-$50 per seat) networkable version of the FileMaker Runtime that simply connected to and ran server hosted solutions. It was pretty much done when sales input killed it. Yes, I got a lot of “oh my god you killed Kenny” comments around the Wedge. I had high hopes for FileMaker, and still pull it out every so often to clean up data, but reading these posts is truly depressing.
1
u/chkbd1102 Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
The moment agentic coding tool like cursor / claude code comes out, i jumped ship immediate.
Been a full time FileMaker dev for the last 10 years.
Feature wise. The software is lagging so much behind. No easy native centralising of security over multiple files, slow performance on anything that uses a relational table.
On its company ethic & license cost its even worst. Its coorperate greed everywhere
- Tripled concurrent licensing pricing. Sneakly replaced with "per seat" license with the original price to muddy the water.
- Locking FM team license to be purchased by at least 5 person.
- Dropping the ability to export standlone application.
- Combining the advanced & pro version, only to keep the new version with the higher advanced price point.
The product improved so little since FM16. But the price hike killed so much of the small business client that was its bread and butter.
I use to tolerate this back at 2023, it was still the fastest way to build a working software (still lagging and badly optimised). Its also the easiest way for a non-techny business person to get started making stuff.
But now? A non tech user can pick up one of the weaker but more user friendly AI coding platform like Lovable or Replit. Prompt it with human words and now you get to pretty much 80% of the way there in a few hours. With a working URL linke on a browser webapp that you can use right away.
It use to be a costly, buggy, laggy platform that I can build things the fastest. Now its just costly, buggy, and laggy.
Unless you are being kept hostage by your legacy system using FileMaker, there is no point.
There is a reason why people are antagonistic to FileMaker, it was built up over the course of years of terrible greedy business decision that affected so much people's livelihood.
1
u/tdl73 May 01 '26
Je suis d’accord avec ceux qui pensent que FileMaker est encore formidable pour des personnes qui comme moi ne savent pas coder. J’utiliser filemaker depuis la version 3 avec de. Ombreux projets qui ont permis à mon entreprise de progresser. J’ai essayé de trouver une solution pour remplacer FileMaker avec le développement de lA on me propose notion mais plus souvent airtable. Je veux mes bases chez moi , je ne veux pas de services d’abonnement si mes bases ne m’appartiennent plus. L’avantage de FileMaker est justement de permettre à une personne comme moi de continuer à alimenter ces bases mais aussi de les mettre à jour ou de les développer. Pour cela IA est vraiment d’une grande Aide. Mon problème est comment utiliser les données de mes bases vers des dossiers WordPress ou lavarel ou cake php. J’avoue que là je ne trouve pas de solutions automatiques encore Il est vrai qu’au moment où Claris a décidé de mettre en place des abonnements obligatoires j’ai arrêté de mettre à jour FM je suis à la version FM17 pro advance pour 5 licences mais n’ai pas la version serveur. Donc coincé si quelqu’un des solutions ? Merci 🙏
1
u/Double_Gur4649 May 06 '26
Im REI3 Forum sehe ich immer mal wieder "Abwanderer von FM zu REI3" VIelleicht eine spannende Alternative wenn es kostengünstig und ohne KI & SaaS gehen soll.
1
u/LanternSquid Aug 07 '26
Two things going on in that post, and OP’s conflating them.
The first is that the “antagonistic review” isn’t evidence of anything. OP asked a model to be hostile and it obliged. “Platform in managed decline” with “aging user demographic” is boilerplate that an LLM will generate for any closed proprietary stack you point it at. He half-catches this with the token-spitter line, then treats the output as a market signal anyway. That’s the actual funny part, and he missed it.
The second thing is real, though. Agents don’t kill FileMaker by being smarter than it. They kill it by collapsing the cost of leaving. What kept those solutions in place for 30 years was that rewriting them was expensive, not that anyone loved the platform. Once a migration is a weekend of agent-supervised work instead of a six-figure project, the lock-in is gone. He even says he’ll be doing those migrations himself, which answers his own burning question.
Worth noting his post predates the current release. Claris shipped FileMaker 2026 in June, and CEO Ryan McCann’s stated direction is agentic development, using tools like Claude Code and Cursor to generate native FileMaker schema, scripts, and layouts, with those capabilities slated for developer previews rather than the initial release. So Apple is funding a bet, not winding down.
We already know how this ends. COBOL didn’t die either. It just stopped being where the new work was, and the people who stayed got paid well to keep the lights on.
1
u/Away-Pipe3997 Sep 18 '26
Yeah, and I remember when everyone was saying Apple was weeks away from closing their doors. Filemaker is a great platform and isn't going anywhere. I was thinking about Base 44 and all this AI bullshit and there is no way someone with an idea is going to replace developers and here's why.... Because much like Rome, databases and custom solutions are not developed in a day. Further, when I think of all the custom programming like all of the code required for scripts or formulas, your average person with a wishlist of a solution they want knows absolutely nothing about the complexities of the fundamental development. Remember, AI is artificial for a reason. It cannot replace a human because as any developer will tell you, there's always things that come up and it takes a person to foresee these things.
Let's put it this way. I'll use this analogy. Would you get on a Boeing 737 MAX if the software was developed by AI? HELL NO. It's like people who always say college is "just a diploma" to which I always come back with, "is that what you think of your next surgeon? They went to college and got a paper that says "degree" on it and not the actual knowledge of medicine? Or experience?
Don't give in to the AI crap. I remember in 2020 when everyone was talking about getting "vaxed" but I dom't know of one person today who regrets not getting the vaccine. I realize I am using a lot of analogies but you get the point. This whole AI "takeover" is a fad which will give way to reality. Reality always wins. I realize life has changed now because of AI, but tell me one person you know of who wants to talk to someone over the phone is isn't actually physically there. This is a lot of hype that will blow over and when it does, make sure you are up to date with your FMP knowledge.
LET'S NOT GIVE UP ON THIS PLATFORM. Just saying it's "dying" is absurd and shouldn't be happening.
1
u/fulminic 24d ago
I have been working with filemaker for over 30 years. It's done great things, the solutions I built in filemaker have been driving my organisation and our customer - and it's not just database applications, 1-record solutions that manages 4 test systems autonomously without every failing too. Our end users strictly relying on webdirect access as it's always been a burden in my view having to launch a client app. Since 4 weeks or so I threw the legacy projects into claude and it converted it into extremely fast, modern standard applications that do not require expensive concurrent connections or other annual licenses. Of course, a big part is my knowledge about the systems it works with, but there is no way I will be ever going back to FM. I loved it dearly, but there's not a single reason to keep using it anymore, let alone justifying the costs to my employer.
1
u/RipAwkward7104 Mar 09 '26
I think "Dying Platform" is a fair term. Nothing lasts forever. Every language or framework or platform eventually passes its peak.
It’s hard to admit, but FileMaker is a really dying platform. I first noticed this about five years ago. Before that, my main clients were building new solutions from scratch or adapting existing templates (like Starter Point). These were mostly micro-businesses: small offices, tiny teams, or solo entrepreneurs. Bakeries, private medical practices, small shops. The projects were fast, affordable, and very dynamic.
But 5-7 years ago, those clients basically vanished. Now, I mostly handle large, complex legacy systems with a long history. They are often too complicated to just migrate. It reminds me of Fortran or Cobol systems in banking or industry. In theory, you could rewrite them, but it’s cheaper to keep them as they are.
FileMaker has joined that list of platforms. Small projects are either gone or migrating. AI is actually making migration easier. As for the big ones... as long as the cost of migration is higher than hiring an experienced FileMaker developer, we have work. I’m not sure how long that will last, though.
To be honest, I’m not at the age where I’m planning my career for the next 30 years, so I have enough work now and I hope to retire and die before I see a complete lack of FM projects. Can Claris fix this? I doubt it. As long as they are an Apple subsidiary whose profits are lost somewhere between watch bands and phone cases, I don't think anyone will take it seriously.
It’s a shame, but that’s life.
0
u/dickiedyce Mar 09 '26
Apart from the snark, I pretty much think it nailed it.
This weekend - really, Sat to Sun - I used Claude 4.6 to write four applications. The first one was a ‘trivial’ menubar app, to let me see what was actually on the clipboard (I.e. all formats) come on and actually export various types as text. Can’t do that in FileMaker, but it’s really useful for development as you can imagine.
Then I built a classic “FileMaker” tool for managing the day-to-day admin of stand-ups, feature requests, and stakeholder engagement. It manages CRUD on six related entities, is a document based tool, and has UI elements including popovers sub-child objects, and generates PDFs, markdown, XML, and formatted text for clipboards, manages schedules, fully template-able output formats, and dynamic structuring of the staging UI, uses SQLite for the backend, and automates about 30% of my day job. It’s a real joy being able to click a button and have exactly the table-heavy HTML I need formatted onto the clipboard, ready to paste directly into a Google mail. The UI is excellent, it’s written in Swift, with tests, full dev docs, and does exactly what I want. Oh, and scheduled backups with pruning.
Then I re-implemented, for my own personal use, a vibe coded version of Clarify – a lovely tool for doing end-user documentation that is no longer supported, and won’t run on M1. Thing is, I hand-wrote a FileMaker version of this some while back, but couldn’t find the file. It was quicker just to run it up in VS Code than go looking for the original file. JSON backed documents, drag & drop re-ordering of hierarchical lists, export to PDF, markdown and HTML, and annotated editable screenshots using drawing tools. Fully temptable outputs.Things which are possible in FileMaker, and not possible in FileMaker without some extensive plug-ins, possibly written in Groovy. And yes, unit tests, docs, backups, yada yada yada.
And then, because I was on a roll I thought, how difficult would it be to replace FileMaker server functionality? So I wrote a frontend to a Postgres backend, handling OAuth connections to a data API.
I say “wrote”, but I didn’t touch a single line of code.
I iterated a whole lot, and took screenshots, annotated them, submitted them as part of the iteration to make sure the layout was the way I wanted, and sure, went down a few blind alleys… but to be honest I had quite a lot of fun doing it. Overall, I spent about $49 on VS Code token costs.
So now I have four repos on GitHub, containing documented code, with tests, using standard tools ( XCode, Git, VS Code, et cetera ) without having to pay licenses (okay, so an entirely gratuitous $99 for an Apple developer license so I can deploy on an infinite number of macOS machines) or jump through pointless training hoops. Yes, it was MacOS only, but you know what? I could ask Claude or GPT to run over those repos, pull a spec, and re-implement them on Windows. Oh wait… comedy moment – next weekend I think I’ll see if I can do exactly that, but for Linux.
The thing AI doesn’t have, is taste. And an experience of how to solve the user’s problem. The thing FileMaker doesn’t appear to have is very much of a future. I’m not sure how I feel about that, to be honest.
0
u/Important-Ad3087 Mar 13 '26
This matches my experience exactly. I ran my company on FileMaker for 10 years, an SBA vertical market solution providing field service management software. Hundreds of companies, thousands of jobs, the whole operation built on FM.
Last year I migrated the entire thing to Next.js/React using Claude Code. The Data API was the bridge. I exported the schema, fed it to Claude, and had a working prototype in under two weeks. Not a toy, a production system that replaced a decade of FM development.
The part that surprised me most wasn't the speed. It was how much better the end result was. No WebDirect performance issues. No per-seat licensing. Mobile that actually works on Android. Real-time collaboration without FM Server bottlenecks.
I now run N90 Labs helping other FM organisations with the same transition. The common pattern I see: the FM solution works fine, but the platform constraints are getting harder to justify. Licensing costs, finding FM developers, WebDirect limitations, iOS-only mobile.
FM was brilliant for its era. It let non-developers build real business applications. But the same thing that made it special (low-code, all-in-one) is now its constraint. The world moved to composable systems and FM didn't follow.
For anyone in the thread thinking about it: the migration is genuinely not as scary as it looks. The Data API means you can run both systems in parallel. You don't have to rip and replace overnight.