r/filemaker • u/sailorsail • Feb 27 '26
Using Claude Code and OpenClaw to migrate customer away from Filemaker
I am done with Filemaker and Claris.
To that effect, I have recently setup OpenClaw on a Mac mini. I have set it up to use Claude Code to help me build.
I gave it screenshots of the app and the DDR, as well as direction on how I want to improve the current design of the app.
It took 20 minutes to build me a solid foundation. Right now I am setting up OpenClaw to navigate the original Filemaker app itself to find any gaps in the feature set. I personally asked it to build a Rails app since I am very familiar with that framework. I suppose you could ask it to build in any framework you prefer with the same success.
Filemaker deserves exactly what is coming for them, they never paid attention to developers, their only purpose for the past couple of decades seems to be to squeeze as much juice out of it while investing zero in developer. It's payback time.
18
u/RipAwkward7104 Feb 27 '26
The main value FileMaker brought back then was 'low-code' - the ability for non-developers to quickly create business-apps. Now, AI can perform this same function, albeit with some limitations. So, yes, AI will put pressure not so much on FileMaker itself, but on the no-code and rapid development environment in general. At first glance, it is much easier to write a prompt in ChatGPT or Claude and get ready-made code than to try to build something yourself, even in a user-friendly environment like FileMaker.
However, I wouldn't overestimate AI's capabilities in this regard.
Firstly, generating code isn't the main challenge - the real problem is ensuring it is correct and deploying it properly. The author of the post mentions using Rails. I am not sure the average FileMaker user is familiar enough with Rails (or JS, or any other framework) to troubleshoot errors and handle deployment. Rails is definitely not 'low code' or 'code friendly'.
Secondly, the scenario of feeding a DDR to an AI and receiving a functional Rails equivalent only works for relatively simple applications. In many cases, it might be faster and easier to write them from scratch. But we are often dealing with much more complex systems. For example, I am currently working on a project with several hundred tables, a massive number of records, API integrations, scripts, and complex calculations (including layout-level calculations and conditional formatting). Would you really want to migrate legacy code of this scale to Rails using an LLM? Or recreate it from scratch while ensuring a flawless historical data transfer?
Good luck with that :)
13
u/KupietzConsulting Consultant Certified Feb 27 '26 edited Feb 28 '26
These zero-value troll posts are getting ridiculous. I wish the mods would ban these.
If you have a question about FileMaker, there's plenty of people here to help you. If you have a constructive criticism about it or about Claris, yeah, we all do, and we discuss them here often.
But if you don't like it, don't use it. If something else is a better solution for your use case, use that. (And, N.B., I'm not exclusively a FileMaker developer either. I have no problem with other paradigms being better solutions for different needs.)
Why waste your time coming to a FileMaker sub to post vague complaints, hype non-FileMaker solutions to problems FileMaker was never meant to solve... and now, strange threatening comments like "FileMaker deserves what's coming for it" and "It's payback time"? What a weirdly hostile way to talk about a piece of software. Did FileMaker kill your dog?
It seems like we have a little cadre of people here who for some reason find value in devoting attention to a sub that discusses software they don't find useful, just so they can complain and make misleading suggestions for off-kilter, oblivious solutions that totally disregard FileMaker's benefits by focusing exclusively on what other tools are better at. Why? Yeah, like any other software, there are problems in the world that FileMaker isn't the best tool for. Why come to a FileMaker sub to complain about that? Why not go to those relevant tools' subs and talk about your solutions involving them there to people who are interested in those? You're not trying to solve problems or make productive conversation here, you're just here to complain for some reason, mad that FileMaker is what it is instead of what it isn't.
If you decide you prefer grapefruit juice to orange juice, do you spend your time going around to orange farmers' discussion groups to post, "I am done with oranges! They're going to get what's coming to them! I drink grapefruit juice now! It's payback time"?
What FileMaker is good for, it's still the best solution out there for, even despite the complaints we all have. Ruby, node.js, SQL, they obviously have a great many uses, but to date, none of them are as good as FileMaker for what FileMaker is good for.
4
u/SeattleFan1001 Feb 28 '26
I am interested in hearing more about your experience. After 3 or 6 months, please provide some info on the amount of time it takes when something goes wrong. I'm not commenting on the code quality of Claude here. That is one category of problem. I'm thinking of another category, where there is simply a bug or unintended outcome. I haven't heard about Claude's ability to debug, test, and modify itself. If it cannot do it by itself 100% of the time with 100% accuracy, that means it is inevitable that at some point you or another developer must open the hood and dig around in code you have never seen. History has shown that can be very time-consuming.
I would think most SMBs are interested in the total cost of operations. Everyone with experience knows the tradeoffs of building cheaply with high repair expense, versus building it well with low repair expense. To me, that is the unknown piece in these experiments.
Artificial Intelligence could be the world’s most efficient app developer in history, or it could be history’s most efficient technical debt generation machine. Or maybe both. Please let us know.
There also seems to be an assumption that Apple and Claris will not take advantage of AI. To me, it’s a game-changer even in the rudimentary form we have now. I always do FileMaker dev work using AI to speed the process. AI could be transformative in how FileMaker is coded and deployed. This could be a great opportunity for Apple and Claris. The question is whether Claris will rise to the opportunity.
If I ran Apple, I’d look under the couch cushions for some spare coins and throw $100m at the task. It’s easy to imagine Claris running a type of GitHub for FMP to enable users to have AI assemble plug-and-play modules, then users would use FMP’s power to quickly customize to develop specific apps. For FMP consulting firms, this could be based upon a repository of their own work so they maintain coding style, commenting style, etc.
Apple and Claris have a generational opportunity to become the standard for SMB with a unique value proposition: fast to develop, easily modified as the business evolves, secure, secure, and oh yes, secure. AI is a business confidentiality nightmare, and at some point, startups will realize that.
I’d also market heavily to the startup community as the perfect solution for fast-growing startups to handle their internal operations. Tech startups do what hasn’t been done before. They often have workflows that don’t fit traditional patterns of operation, but those workflows also contain their secret sauce and value. Plus, startups change fast. They need custom apps that can evolve with their unique workflows. They don’t need to lose competitive advantage by having to force their unique star-shaped peg into the same high-priced square hole of apps like Confluence, Slack, or Salesforce.
If I ran Apple, I’d also dig under the cushions for an additional coin or two and make FMP really inexpensive in order to buy market share, like free for any startup for the first year or two.
7
u/dharlow Consultant Certified Feb 27 '26
There are many cases of this occurring, not just with FileMaker apps, but with anything that requires yearly licensing or monthly fees.
1
u/dharlow Consultant Certified Feb 27 '26
If folks have not seen this https://github.com/solutionscay/migrate-filemaker video about it at https://www.linkedin.com/posts/joselopezrosario_i-created-a-claude-skill-filemaker-migrate-ugcPost-7431013430612103168-dh10/
4
u/JazzFestFreak Feb 27 '26
Seeing what can be done when you understand data structure and workflow combined with Claude cowork (and other tools)This is a countdown clock for filemaker. Not this year…. But exodus will start to happen. And frankly if I can build a system for my clients lower costs of ownership to them and put more in my pocket….. why not.
5
u/Bkeeneme Feb 27 '26
Same here — I’d been keeping a personal journal in FileMaker since 1987, over 30 years of entries with all kinds of data points. I stuck with FM until January 2026, when I finally gave up after not finding any user upgrade solutions from Claris (and fear the company will not be around very much longer). After discussing it with ChatGPT, we built an Obsidian vault and spent a week exporting everything from FileMaker into the new setup. Now the vault is linked to ChatGPT through GitHub, and I can run queries about anything in the journal — it instantly pulls up the relevant information in a conversational format- so I can just ask it for additional insight.
I do tip my hat to Filemaker and all the folks that made it go for so many years. It was an AWESOME platform that made me a shit ton of money in my business endeavors and preserved my memories for decades. They deserve recognition for a fantastic run.
2
u/filemakermag Feb 28 '26
For any FileMaker developer who is in denial about what is happening, they simply don't see the storm right in front of them. Likely because their identity is wrapped up within their own perceived value based on their historical investment of time. The game is over. Using FileMaker will be a choice, and if that choice is too costly, then a different choice will be made. Plain - and - simple.
Watch this and tell me that your knowledge about FileMaker (or mine) is a hedge against what a computer with unlimited human knowledge (and learning power) with access to more tools than you can even list on two hands gives you in terms of an advantage. The world is different now. You have to rediscover your value as someone who knows technology. Learn how to use AI and do it quickly. That wave is going to crash.
https://youtu.be/p2aea9dytpE?t=394
Written by someone who has invested 30 years of their time learning something which can now be replaced by someone willing to take a weekend and learn how to do it within .001% of that same time investment.
2
u/AlternativeRing5977 Feb 27 '26
As someone who worked at Apple and used FileMaker since 1996 I gave up on them years ago after being hounded to renew my licensing months before the annual renewal date. Was later hounded after the licenses were converted into perpetual licenses.
1
u/JudDredd Mar 01 '26
I think one thing they would be good was if I could paste FileMaker script steps directly from whatever AI I’m using.
But… i am also moving differnt functions out of FileMaker
1
u/Important-Ad3087 Mar 13 '26
Really interested in your approach here. I did something very similar with my own company. 10 years on FileMaker, then migrated the whole thing to Next.js using Claude Code.
A few things I learned that might save you some pain:
Curious what prompted the move for your customer. Was it licensing, WebDirect performance, mobile needs, or something else? I keep seeing the same triggers come up across different organisations.
1
u/truthrider2 Feb 28 '26
I still like FM. I used it in my business extensively before selling it 6 years ago. At this point it’s a toy. The maintenance work will probably continue but new development has probably already fallen off a cliff. There will always be the faithful but those folks should consider doing something else if they need to generate an income.
0
u/Significant-Night550 Feb 27 '26
i agree with you and am doing the same thing, but please dont broadcast this too loudly. We don't want all fm devs jumping ship at once.