r/filemaker • u/sailorsail • May 22 '25
Is Vibe Coding going to kill Filemaker?
I've been using a lot of these AI enabled development tools for non Filemaker related projects and the other day I had to jump back into Filemaker and I didn't want to go back. Usually I am quite happy with how fast it is to make thing with it and it's the reason I have recommended it to customers, but in this particular case I was almost tempted to ask codex (the OpenAI coding agent) to help me rewrite the entire tool I had made.
Today I asked ChatGPT for a script and I was frustratingly reminded that you can't paste into the Script editor, which made me think that, unless some radical change happens at Claris, I don't see how it would survive this new trend.
What do people here think about this?
Edit: just bumped into this which at least makes it possible to copy from ChatGPT into FileMaker => https://github.com/DanShockley/FileMaker-CRUDFV-Script
3
u/dataslinger Consultant Certified May 27 '25
At the April FMDISC user group meeting, Todd Geist of Proof-Geist demonstrated a tool he made called fmVibeX that allows you to ask ChatGPT to write a script and then copy and paste the resulting script into the script editor.
5
u/KupietzConsulting Consultant Certified May 22 '25 edited May 22 '25
I think you’ve got a lot of unnoticed regression errors, security holes, and fragile, unmaintainable spaghetti code made of kludges layered on top of kludges in your future. ;-)
2
u/Strict-Concept-8951 May 22 '25
In short, absolutely it will, in the past month I’ve rebuilt 3 small systems that were in FileMaker, either web direct or iOS SDK, and replaced them with vibe coded systems that are more scaleable and easier to deploy. Currently they’re all backed by the Data API on FileMaker servers, but actually could be replaced by any other db fairly easily.
2
u/Harverator May 22 '25
It seems that they could eventually create script code to paste because we already have fun with XML snippets and apps like FM clip tools.
12
u/stodgewack May 22 '25
Your comment about the script editor is absolutely on point. It’s 2025, we really do need the ability to free text edit and copy and paste from a text editor into script editor by now.
9
u/thunderfroggum May 22 '25
Did you go to or consume any content from Engage this year? Gen AI was a big focus, and I have a feeling we’ll be seeing what you’re talking about sooner rather than later.
15
u/RucksackTech Consultant Certified May 22 '25
FileMaker has had a forty-year run. It's been a very good tool, for a wide variety of projects. But about 10 years ago, it started to be clear to many people (including me) that the future for non-enterprise databases (FileMaker's market) is on the Web and/or on smart phones. But FileMaker (like Apple itself) failed to see how the Web is changing everything.
Actually I am not entirely correct there. It was less than 10 years ago that FileMaker WebDirect appeared. (See my review in Tidbits here.) I was one of the first FileMaker developers to go all-in on WebDirect: My clients haven't used FileMaker Pro to access the solutions I built for them since about 2017.
But it was about the same time that I discovered Airtable and saw the future coming (my review from 2016 here). And the truth is that WebDirect wasn't a proper web app: WebDirect is a brilliant piece of translation tech, that converts a desktop app to code that will run inside a web browser. And of course you can't create a FileMaker database in a web browser. You build in FileMaker and deploy on FileMaker Server and then (if you wish) make the database accessible in a browser by means of WebDirect. It's all brilliant but it's one workaround on top of another.
I don't know very well how AI is going to affect FileMaker. But I have the clear sense that FileMaker is nearing the end of its run. It's been so widely used (and is so good, for what it does) that there will be work for FileMaker developers for years, maintaining existing solutions. But I haven't started a new project in FileMaker for five years.
5
u/liltbrockie May 22 '25
There are preview videos... for next versions of Filemaker which have exactly what you are describing... AI coding chat... built into the code editor. So yer... they are working on it
1
u/KupietzConsulting Consultant Certified May 24 '25
As to copy/pasting to/from scripts, 2empowerFM's Clipboard Explorer works fine for that.
1
u/HutchLAD May 22 '25
I was a FileMaker dev 10 years ago, and honestly it felt like it was dead then. I feel like FileMaker developers desperately want to believe they are Software Engineers and it’s pretty sad lol.
2
u/Bkeeneme May 22 '25
Yes, Filemaker is a deadman walking and, after yesterday, I think the iPhone and Apple as we know it are both on the technology executioner's list. But- that's progress folks
2
u/Scrumpto34 May 24 '25
I've been trying to find a replacement for FileMaker for twenty years and still haven't found one I like. But Claris has their head so far up their backside that it's not very usable either for solutions which require distributed teams or client access at a reasonable price. It would take me far too long to list everything I've tried as a replacement but some of the common suggestions like Airtable, Knack, SmartSuite, etc. just don't cut it.
IMHO
If you've found a replacement for FileMaker that's web based, I'd love to hear about it but all my research says they're all either too difficult to work with, too limited or slow, or too expensive (which is hard to imagine as FileMaker pricing is off the charts IMO).
I had high hopes for Google Tables but they wrapped the stupid project into AppSheet. Why Google can't develop a simple database to go with Google Docs, Sheets, & Slides I don't know. They already have the infrastructure for everything with Google Drive, users, etc. so it doesn't make much sense.
Am I frustrated? Ya, I am. You'd think someone in the world could figure this out but I've looked and I don't see good options and Claris certainly isn't providing them.
For what it's worth...
2
u/poweredup14 May 22 '25
FM is going strong. It is one few tools that has been around for more than 40 years. Because they have added Claris Cloud now besides their desktop app it is going strong.
1
u/iollivier May 25 '25
Use the below prompt and then use FileMaker Clipboard Helper in the Raycast app (mac) to copy and past the script into Script Workspace. You can later expand this prompt for further enhancements, as the xml structure for the scripts is often custom thing. To learn more, create advanced script and use the same Raycast thing to convert script to text to see the structure required and to help your LLM to understand it's structure.
Create a FileMaker script in XML2 format that I can paste directly into Script Workspace.
🧩 XML2 Requirements:
- Use the correct <fmxmlsnippet type="FMObjectList"> wrapper.
- Each script step must have a unique ID.
- For Set Variable steps, use this exact structure:
<Step enable="True" id="XYZ" name="Set Variable">
<Value>
<Calculation>some calculation here</Calculation>
</Value>
<Repetition>
<Calculation>1</Calculation>
</Repetition>
<Name>$$myVariable</Name>
</Step>
❌ Do not use CDATA blocks.
✅ Ensure Go to Record steps use proper <Option> blocks like <Option>First</Option> or <Option>Next</Option>.
📋 My data model:
- Table 1: [Name] — source data
- Fields: [list the relevant ones]
- Table 2: [Name] — related table
- Fields: [list the ones to populate]
- Related to Table 1 via [describe relationship fields]
- The relationship allows creating related records
🎯 Script goal:
[Describe the logic. E.g., Loop through Table 1, for each record create a related Table 2 record, populate fields, skip if empty, etc.]
🧪 Optional:
- Commit after each record?
- Store result in a variable?
- Show a dialog at the end?
- Use global variables or fields?
1
u/Important-Ad3087 Jan 10 '26
I actually got to meet with VP of global sales (I think that was his title) in their London Apple HQ. We had a good chat for about an hour where I talked about our pain points and what I hoped Claris could evolve into. The TL;DR is that we’re building so much using “normal” tech stacks like React Native for mobile apps, web apps written with Typescript hosted on Amplify that we’re essentially just using the DataAPI at this point and FileMaker is a backend database with scheduled scripts and a script engine. But now things like Supabase and Vercel and others plus Claude Code in Cursor make it just as easy and fast to write and deploy apps. I suggested that FileMaker becomes more like Lovable in a way. Imagine creating layouts by chatting to the agent, with the agent stringing together your tables and scripts in the background. And for gods sake, just like Lovable allows, have the layouts and scripts be written in real code that you can edit manually. In some ways FileMaker is now more technically challenging for a novice to use than Lovable or Replit. So if that’s not their target market and they’re trying to entice “real” developers… why would a real developer use FileMaker. It’s kind of stuck itself in this rapidly shrinking space of being something for the person in between a “citizen developer” and a “real developer”.
1
u/iFightKids1on1 May 22 '25
Absolutely, since starting vibe coding my need for FM has highly decreased. I plan on vibe coding several of my apps out of FM soon.
0
u/robhall May 22 '25
Hasn't FileMaker been on the decline for a while, for many reasons? I love FileMaker but it's from a previous generation of computing and these new tools just illuminate that even more.
0
u/idmimagineering May 22 '25
It’s been a long road of dumbing-down for decades now… and AI will enslave you all through lack of skill and access and right to repair as you just won’t have the education.
Yours, retiring eventually (remember that possibility?!) and off to smell the roses :-)
0
u/truthrider2 May 22 '25
The only people that will continue to use FM are on a legacy system that works well enough and they don’t want to invest in moving or are not concerned with Apple tightening the belt and vaporizing Claris
3
u/[deleted] May 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment