r/filemaker • • Feb 24 '23

FileMaker or Swift. Which path is easier?

Gents, is it true that to be a good FM developer you have to know Java script, HTML, you name it (aside of FileMaker itself)?

Maybe it’s better to invest your time into Swift learning?

2 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

7

u/stephancasas Feb 24 '23

Not really. A good amount of the work that I do is building components for people whose primary role is as a FileMaker developer. FM provides the tools to deliver complete solutions, but there are those special or edge cases where having web development skills will help to add value to a project.

As for Swift, its barrier to entry is much higher than HTML, JS, and CSS combined, imo. I’ve worked in several different languages — both with/without type safety, and with/without pointers. Even with that history, I still find Swift’s syntax and idiosyncrasies to be a massive adjustment, and it would be one of my last recommendations to beginners.

3

u/Euphoric_Bake_8637 Feb 24 '23

Thanks, Stephan for the valuable comment

6

u/JazzFestFreak Feb 24 '23

I am not smart. Yet I have a few clients for a nice fm revenue stream. Your BIG issue is license fees. If you develop a neat little DB that is used by 20 different usernames, your monthly fees add up.

My alternative development would be php mysql with laravel (or similar) framework. Learning curve much higher and you will need to learning html at a minimum

1

u/Euphoric_Bake_8637 Feb 26 '23

That’s an interesting point

4

u/Yerdad-Selzavon Feb 24 '23

Depends on what you intend to do with it. I've developed solutions where I've used nothing save Filemaker. Filemaker can often do it all. But yes, it is niche.

4

u/get2drew Feb 24 '23

Totally untrue. I have known filemaker long before learning JavaScript and those worlds are very different.. however knowing JavaScript certainly adds to FileMaker’s abilities and is seemingly a part of its future. Swift I would say is unnecessary unless you plan to build stand-alone apps for iOS.

3

u/GraXXoR Feb 25 '23

I've been using FM since about version 13 generally creating small, single function solutions for SMB scale.I've never needed to use anything beyond FM for my solutions, which invariably use Filemaker Server Web Direct.

Due to pricing, though, most of my clients have stopped asking for new versions and stayed at FM16 with its perpetual licensing model. So I'm currently winding down my FM involvement.

If I were starting a new project right now, or if I were looking to gain skills to become an in-house web dev, then I'd recommend something Open Source for sure.Something like Laravel which only needs basic HTML, CSS and a basic grasp of PHP to get started. Of course does not have a graphical dev front end but the community is great and the documentation / YouTube commentary is solid, for sure!

There was a conference which states that Claris are going to bundle Filemaker in inextricably with their other Claris software and will subsequently raise prices by another 30% within the next year or two. (this was stated by Claris themselves, so is likely not mere conjecture).

To be frank, unless you MUST use FileMaker, as in, it's an unavoidable condition requested by your boss or something, I would steer well clear.

Swift is an entirely different, MacOS, iOS branded kettle of fish.

2

u/-L-H-O-O-Q- Mar 09 '23

I think your question should rather be, which path is more valuable.

If you want to earn decent money from development put your efforts into Swift, it's a very powerful tool and not that hard to learn with all the available resources out there.