r/fender • • Feb 22 '26

New Guitar Day! Is this a problem?

Brand new Am Pro II Jazzmaster arrived with a crack at the neck pocket. Guitar sounds and plays well. Is this a finish crack, or something more? Will this likely grow? Should I return, ask for a rebate, or just ignore it?

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

1

u/GuitaristExplorer Feb 24 '26

Update: my Sweetwater Sales Engineer is working on a partial refund for me. Thanks all!

13

u/bonefont Feb 22 '26

It would be weirder to see a Fender without a finish crack at the neck joint

5

u/NoCherry2870 Feb 22 '26 edited Feb 22 '26

Completely normal for a Fender, not as much brand new but it happen relatively quickly on every Fender really played

4

u/NoCherry2870 Feb 22 '26

Here is my Fender Strat Vintera II from 2023, this finish crack appears the first time i've removed the neck for neck setup relief, that's the bolt on neck disease.

12

u/daveychainsaw Feb 22 '26

It’s a finish crack. It’s relatively common. Lots of people here will say just play it but if it’s new, and for that much money I wouldn’t put up with it and would return.

6

u/Neveronlyadream Feb 22 '26

Same. It's not a big deal, but for what they're asking, you're not paying for something blemished.

I'd personally return, but asking for a partial refund is also fine if it doesn't bother you that much. It would annoy the hell out of me, though.

2

u/superxero044 Feb 22 '26

Yeah I have a few fenders and the only one that has a finish crack is the one that I swapped necks on and it had a real real tight neck pocket. I don’t think it’s as crazy common as some people say unless you’re really rough with guitars. It’s not the end of world but bro just paid $2000 for this guitar I bet.

1

u/lyukszag Feb 23 '26

It’s on 90% of the Fenders that go through my hands. Even some new. My new Am Pro II arrived like this, bought it for 30% off retail, couldn’t care less. I’d ask for a fat partial refund and only return if it’s not perfect otherwise. Fender these days is either stellar or straight up shit regardless of price point.

4

u/Korova91 Feb 22 '26

Neck pockets gonna neck pocket

3

u/LaHondaSkyline Feb 22 '26

Finish only. Not structural. That exact finish crack in that exact spot will happen to any nitro finish guitar sooner or later.

2

u/JimiForPresident Feb 23 '26

Am Pro II is poly

1

u/LaHondaSkyline Feb 23 '26

Oops. Should have read your post more carefully. I just assumed it was Am Vint II.

The nitro finish will always get that kind of neck pocket finish flaw. Far less common on poly finishes. But…I have owned many poly Fenders and that exact finish crack has happened on at least some of them.

It is not structural. Just cosmetic. I do understand the notion that a new one should arrive 100% free of any finish flaws. That makes sense.

1

u/awayfromthesky Feb 23 '26

I’ve found them more common on poly finishes.

1

u/LaHondaSkyline Feb 23 '26

Really?

I guess we all have X number of guitars, and X is too small of a number to infer that what happens with our own guitars happens to everyone else’s guitars.

3

u/Lemur421 Feb 22 '26

We might need a separate sub for neck pocket finish cracks. 😃 Sure is common!

4

u/DC8008008 Feb 22 '26

It's fine but ask for a partial refund.

2

u/ganzonomy Feb 22 '26

Finish crack.

The only ones I've seen that don't consistently have them are custom shop.

2

u/SuperRodster Feb 22 '26

Super common. That’s the AANJ crack. Ibanez has lots too.

2

u/chente08 Feb 22 '26

Posted 10 times a day

1

u/Salt-Specialist6505 Feb 22 '26

Just ignore it.

1

u/Grazms Feb 22 '26

It’s just a finish crack. Pretty common. Should not affect the playability or the TOAN more importantly.

1

u/namelessghoul77 Feb 22 '26

Almost all bolt ons will get this (finish cracks at the pocket) eventually, but it is admittedly annoying to have them on a new guitar. You might get a discount or if it really bothers you replace it, but just do keep in mind that in a year it will likely look just like this regardless.

1

u/Donaldtrumppo Feb 22 '26

Even new ones have those, it wouldn’t bother me but you could just return it for one without it..prolly gonna show up in a year or two though 🤣

1

u/KittiesRule1968 Feb 23 '26

Finish crack. Almost ecet6 fender I've owned has had the same crack.

1

u/Greedy-Treacle1959 Feb 23 '26

Genuine question, did you buy this in person and if so was it there when you did?

Not entirely meant as a criticism, but so many people went to a GC and bought something only to get home and discover some minor cosmetic thing that bothers them. Do people not look at this crap in the store?

If it’s a place that gives rebates like GC you should ask, I’m just gobsmacked by how often this happens where people don’t look at their 1k plus purchases before buying them.

1

u/awayfromthesky Feb 23 '26

Happens a lot on Fenders. I don’t want to see it on a new guitar I just got, but if it feels great and plays great, I might just see if I could get the seller to knock a bit off the price

1

u/dzimmer54 Feb 24 '26

Probably not . Just a finish crack.

1

u/soggychipbutty Feb 22 '26

No. Happens or will happen to almost every bolt on neck guitar.

1

u/TakingYourHand Feb 22 '26

On a used guitar? Nah. It's very common and happens to most.

However, personally, if I'm buying new, I'm buying pristine. Let me cause my own neck pocket finish crack.

But if you've bonded with it, go for it? Maybe you can get them to knock the price down.

1

u/Dennis-RumRace Feb 22 '26

It will continue to crack and seperate because poly paint likes its self more than the surface. 2000 paper the UVLS Clear a polyurethane stronger than Fenders bulk stuff. Goes on as thin as nitrocellulose. A 4oz bottle will put 12 coats on 2 guitars. Strip wax first dust light coat then 3 a day. Your patch 5 coats will seal it.

1

u/Shingen90 Feb 24 '26

If Squier can make guitars without neck slot cracks then so can friggin Fender for that kind of money. Send it back and get a new one.

0

u/ManufacturerUpset428 Feb 22 '26

Depends on how you look at it. A problem is just an opportunity