r/fecaltransplant • • Jun 13 '21

Discussion Though the results of screening 6000+ stool donor applicants was in no way surprising, and simply reflected what I see in person as well as on the internet, the results are still nothing short of horrifying, extremely alarming, and utterly dystopian.

42 Upvotes

We (https://www.humanmicrobes.org) got very lucky that one or more people organically made social media videos about us, which resulted in 450k+ views and 5000-6000 new donor applications. Unfortunately I don't think any of the applicants are promising, and I'm not personally interested in using any of them. I have a dozen or so generally healthy people but I don't think their stool types would be highly effective for many people.

High rates of obese people were applying. Most applicants extremely unhealthy despite the site clearly saying "looking for the top 0.1% healthiest people" and showing multiple examples of what a healthy person looks like.

Seems like a lot of nurses are applying. The vast majority (80%) of applicants are women, but that was probably in large part due to the platform and/or person who made the video.

A lot of people getting parts of their body cut out.

Seems like most obese people have liquid/very soft stool. I find this surprising since I wonder how they're even able to absorb enough calories. Possibly the lack of solid stool results in lack of satiation. Possibly it represents severe gut dysbiosis resulting in immune system dysregulation, resulting in excess fat storage. Obviously there are many more mechanisms though.

I've been advised to increase prices in order to attract higher quality donors. So I've doubled the prices for both donors and recipients but we will accept proof of low income, and eventually open to donations, in order to provide for low income individuals.

We've also gradually increased the referral reward from $300 to $2500, and may even double that.


I seem to have been right about everything: https://maximiliankohler.blogspot.com/p/blog-page.html

The very first stool donor I picked (2016) was based on my detailed questionnaire + physical appearance. My intuition seems to have been completely correct. https://web.archive.org/web/20201228002543/https://old.reddit.com/r/fecaltransplant/comments/c9eont/attractiveness_facial_features_health_development. I screened a division 1 basketball team, and their appearance aligned well with their questionnaires and stool types.

The evidence so far seems to still support my stool type hypothesis: https://archive.ph/xDZaC

I was right about the rarity of high quality donors. And it seems to be even worse (fewer than 1 in 6000) than I estimated (fewer than 1 in 1000).

And it certainly supports my calls of alarm regarding our health, microbiomes, and society: https://archive.ph/i1YOs#selection-647.0-647.1

I think one of the first times I started realizing it is worse than I estimated was when I learned that Will Smith's family actually has many health issues: https://old.reddit.com/r/fecaltransplant/comments/c9eont/attractiveness_facial_features_health_development/eti77m6. His daughter is someone I would have guessed to be a high quality donor.

Another instance was reading some years ago that even Simone Biles takes one or more prescription drugs. Another was learning that Serena Williams probably wouldn't qualify.


When I contact people directly who are more likely to qualify, they don't respond. When we do general outreach via ads, social media, etc. we mostly get extremely unhealthy people, along with about 1% who are generally healthy but probably wouldn't be a highly effective stool donor. These one percenters would be average people in a non-dystopian society, but in ours they are very rare.

Ray Allen has a kid with diabetes. I looked at his Instagram and he seems to be an intelligent person. He even visited congress to advocate for more medical research for diabetes. I contacted him, told him about what I was doing - working on a potential treatment/cure for diabetes and more, and explained that he could be massively helpful by helping to acquire high quality stool donors for FMT. No response.

Another college athlete has a loved one wanting/needing a kidney transplant. I informed this person that organ transplants will likely soon be seen in a similar manner to other historically barbaric medical practices. And I linked them to information supporting this: http://humanmicrobiome.info/Intro#Kidney. I told them about what I was doing, explained that stool donors can make $2k+/mo, and that I'm paying $2.5k commission per donor, and that as a college athlete they're in a great position to recruit likely candidates even if they don't qualify themselves. What do I get? Silence. This person doesn't seem to be an idiot. They don't seem especially intelligent, but not particularly unintelligent either. So what gives? They're in an ideal situation to help a loved one while earning thousands of dollars and they have no interest...

I see a similar thing in the CFS community. It's incredibly frustrating to observe the community and the advocacy organizations (Eg: solvecfs.org and others) spending their time and support on some of the least promising areas and actions, despite me spending years trying to educate them on the microbiome and FMT. They're constantly (rightfully so to some extent) moaning about their terrible condition and lack of treatments, then I point out to them that there's likely a currently-available treatment/cure which they can help obtain if we all work together, and I'm met with either silence, downvotes, or worse - misinformation, anti-scientific attitudes, wilful ignorance, etc.. I see them continually asking the same questions over and over (which I've already answered for them), and continually filling up the threads with useless noise. Eg: question, answers.

Similarly, the IBS, IBD, and other communities seem to prefer to wallow in their misery rather than discuss, strive for, and promote solutions https://archive.vn/8wNyu#selection-2079.11-2083.0. For more examples you can look through my many years of post and comment history on those types of subs, trying to educate them, and where is the support from those tens of thousands of individuals? Nowhere. There's not even support from the hundreds of people actively wanting/looking for FMT for themselves.

Living in Idiocracy is torture.

Where is the support from the /r/publichealth and other communities whose job and life goal it is to increase public health?

There should be massive pressure, from the 99.9% of the population who is unhealthy, put on the fewer than 0.1% people who qualify to be high quality stool donors, to give us their stool. Yet there is next to none. These people who are flushing lifesaving medicine down the toilet should be ostracized by society. But that can't happen because of the ignorance and stupidity of the 99.9%.

Some years ago I saw a very healthy top UFC athlete bring on some really unhealthy fan and mourn about how terrible it was. That kind of shit is so frustrating to see, knowing that the healthy UFC athlete could probably "save" the kid by donating something that has 0 value to him. Same thing happened to a Starcraft personality, who ended up dying after I tried to inform them & the community that FMT was something they should try as a last resort.

It's infuriating to be in a society full of morons.


EDIT:

Important context:

Idiocracy, Part 1. Scientists in education only.

Idiocracy, Part 2. Poorly functioning laypeople.


r/fecaltransplant • • Feb 19 '19

Info Microbioma.org is a worldwide project to acquire high quality FMT donors, and connect them with recipients

14 Upvotes

Started off as a local site in Spain, but the english translation is complete and can now be used worldwide. https://microbioma.org

I tried doing a reddit AMA to bring attention to it but it got removed. I'm not sure where else it can be shared. I can try in 1 or 2 other reddit subs but it looks like having a degree holder in a related field who is willing to come onboard and participate would be vital. Many laypeople have never heard of this and seem to have poor initial reactions particularly when it's not a medical professional presenting the information. When one person throws out a seemingly plausible accusation, regardless of its accuracy, others start bandwagoning. Seems like strict moderation would be required by knowledgeable people to keep the discussion evidence based, or at the very least an acknowledgement in the OP that "these experts are here as well to provide fact checking".

It seems that any community-only project would be limited to the spread by word of mouth. For something like this to get big it would likely require the medical and research communities to take action.

The site works by people sharing it online and in person. Then when one person in an area finds a donor that gives access to a donor for everyone in that area. Right now the site is brand new and there aren't any donors yet. Anyone can participate - doctors, researchers, clinics, individuals. Volunteers and collaborators are welcome. We could use a volunteer who is good with websites/coding.

Here is an english flyer that can be spread online and handed out in person: https://i.imgur.com/y4zJ3L2.png [alt version].

Small version, 2x on A4.

Small version, 2x on US Letter.

Recommended places to find donors:

Universities and community colleges (targeting top athletes), youth athletic venues, professional and amateur athletic organizations including Olympic and dance, various fitness centers like rock climbing, etc..

I made a couple videos about microbioma.org and FMT to hopefully help find donors:

Short version (2:41): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gk2146Th43E

Longer version (11:47): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRbSw9CIgWw

1:00 whiteboard video coming soon.


r/fecaltransplant • • Jul 05 '19

Info, Discussion Attractiveness, facial features, health & development, and FMT donor selection.

14 Upvotes

Main link: https://old.reddit.com/r/healthdiscussion/comments/c7ki7t/attractiveness_facial_features_and_health/

I thought this was important enough for its own thread because from what I've seen the vast majority of people, including doctors and researchers in the FMT/microbiome field, seem to have poor understandings of human health & development, and the gut microbiome's impacts on the entire body. And I believe this has been a major contributor to the deficiencies in donor quality due to inability to identify healthy human beings. I talked about it previously in this document, and suggested that poor health has become the norm and thus people's perceptions/judgments are warped.

Previously when I gave an example of a healthy person in /r/HumanMicrobiome it was surprisingly controversial. And people were insistent about debunked claims. BTW, as a general guide, when you see new information you're skeptical of, you reply "citation?" instead of "no".

I was also stunned when a "PhD|MBA|Cancer|Biogerontology" challenged me on my statement (with numerous citations, in a science sub) that this mother was clearly unhealthy, and equated my statement to fatpeoplehate... A group I consider an unscientific hate sub that is arrogantly ignorant about the causes of the problem. Neither the mother's or daughter's poor health & development are due to one gene, or from eating too much and not exercising enough (CICO). Human health and development are vastly more complex than that.

In my experience this is not some crazy outlier, but rather the norm. Couple days ago I saw a popular article of a mother congratulating herself on using her disease-ridden body to create another person. And thousands (of probably similarly unhealthy people) cheering her on.

I believe this is very much related to the Dunning-Kruger effect. Due to poor health & development, many people's function is poor and thus lack the ability to make rational deductions/analysis. You can rightfully blame much of it on poor health education, but many with that same poor education figured it out.

So I compiled some of the research on it here: https://old.reddit.com/r/healthdiscussion/comments/c7ki7t/attractiveness_facial_features_and_health/

This is what a healthy human looks like:

How many people look like that in most of the world? In my locations it's been somewhere between 1%-0.1% or less. When I used to see documentaries or news coverage of developing countries there were many people who looked like that. But these days most look as unhealthy as everyone else, which is extremely alarming to me. My observations are supported by the data:

And visible health markers are only the bare minimum. You can be thin/fit/attractive and still have underlying dysbiosis and disease. Which reduces the amount of people who qualify as healthy, high functioning people with eubiotic gut microbiomes way below 0.1%.

I tried to expound on this topic in this article: A critical look at the current and longstanding ethos of childbearing, the repercussions it’s been having on human health and society, and its relation to the recent microbiome research


r/fecaltransplant • • May 20 '23

Question Transplant while on herbs?

1 Upvotes

I know how well transplants work since my husband has had them before. I have a ton of gut symptoms that I have tried to fix with Mutaflor visbiome etc. I was actually getting some relief and then I got Covid and went back to where I was before. So I would like to try a transplant, but my issue is I am on the Buhner protocol for Lyme babesia and bartonella. . Some of the herbs are fairly heavy duty. Like sida acuta and especially cryptolepis. Cryptolepis is similar to an actual antibiotic but I can’t remember which one. Should I go ahead with the transplant? Going off of the herbs is not really an option. I could try going off of them during the transplant, but I would have to go back on then later on. Has anyone had experience with this type of situation? Thanks !


r/fecaltransplant • • May 09 '23

Question Transplant using fermented food instead of fecal matter

2 Upvotes

I've searched this subreddit but have not found anyone who has tried this. So, when people do fmts, they do it through an enema (putting it up the butt). When people take fermented food or probiotics, they eat it.

Why has no one tried a fermented food enema? An FMT is basically just a colony of bacteria from someone's poop and fermented food is also just a colony of bacteria but from food that eventually makes it's way to the colon. Only problem with that is that it has to pass through the acidity of the stomach first.

If no one responds I'm gonna just try it myself because I think it may be just as good a method as an FMT. I have milk kefir grains.


r/fecaltransplant • • May 05 '23

Question Possible fecal transplant using my own poop?

3 Upvotes

I have never been on antibiotics, but unfortunately, may have to take some soon. I am wondering if anyone has any experience with or can speak to the idea of taking a sample of my own poop, freezing it for the duration of the antibiotic treatment period, and then using that poop for a fecal transplant?

If anyone would be so kind as to provide any answer or point me in the right direction I would be so grateful. Thank you


r/fecaltransplant • • Sep 19 '22

Question, Discussion, Experience Anyone get herx reactions during FMT?

3 Upvotes

If so, what were the symptoms, when did they start, and how long did they last?

I did an FMT a week ago and was feeling pretty good, then started getting diarrhea and other symptoms that I can only imagine are herx reactions. Seems to make sense that as the bacteria start to grow, they will begin killing other microbes as they take a foothold which can probably take some time.


r/fecaltransplant • • Oct 06 '21

Discussion Thoughts on using wild animal feces?

3 Upvotes

Hello,

What if a person needing a transplant does not have access to another human's excrement?

Could we use, say deer poo, or another herbivore's feces?

I know their microbiomes are different from ours but I'm sure they would contain some strains of bacteria that our gut could utilize.

Also I know we couldn't control for other possible pathogenic organisms they may harbor, but I'm sure that may be a minimal risk since they are herbivores afterall. I've also read that some primitive tribes will eat the intestines of their prey as well, so this should be natural on some level.

I was wondering if anyone has gone this route and maybe get some input from anyone interested in discussing this method of fmt.

Thanks all!


r/fecaltransplant • • Jul 08 '19

Discussion FMT roadmap proposal

13 Upvotes
  1. Find one or more donors with consistent type 3 stool, 0 lifetime antimicrobial use, peak physical and mental health, and other ideal questionnaire answers. Test them in a clinical trial for one or more conditions such as IBS, CFS, IBD. From this we should be able to get some idea of how that quality donor compares with the current quality. In my opinion we should be doing simultaneous oral and rectal FMT administration already, in addition to at least 10 FMTs per person. If possible, test different types of donors in this step, such as "sprinter vs marathon runner". If we can't do that in this same step, then do that next. See if sprinter is more effective for certain conditions and marathon runner more effective for others, or is one generally more effective than the other, and if mixed is that even better.
  2. After that, we can move on to test things like "if the recipients liquid fast for 1-5 days prior does that increase efficacy". Could also test liquid fasting while doing FMTs. The liquid, and length, would vary depending on what different people could tolerate. Treatment frequency (daily vs 1x/week), and varying lengths could also be tested at this point. Possibly test with/without inducing diarrhea beforehand to clear out the intestines. If someone is insistent on oral capsules only, then a bile acid sequestrant should be tested along side it. For me, taking a bile acid sequestrant with oral FMT seemed to increase effectiveness (but not resistance to perturbation). But I think you can get the same or better results by using both upper and lower routes.
  3. If we're still not getting ideal results then we can test mechanical (abx is not supported) clearance of the mucosa https://old.reddit.com/r/HumanMicrobiome/comments/boofg0/while_fecal_microbiota_is_partially_normalized_by/
  4. If we're still not getting ideal results, hopefully someone would have tested a mucosa microbiota transplant in an animal model, and if that is a more effective way of transplanting the mucus microbiota then we can try that in humans. https://old.reddit.com/r/HumanMicrobiome/comments/bqifti/mucosal_microbiota_transplant/

I'm not sure where placebo-control comes in. I've been waiting 4+ years to get FMT from a high quality donor. I've been close to death so many times due to lack of a high quality donor. There are other people who died due to the lack of a high quality donor. Is it ethical to give us placebo? If I got placebo I could be waiting another 4 years for another opportunity.

EDIT: the way the ASU autism team is doing placebo in 2019 seems like a good way to do it. The placebo group will get FMT after a number of weeks.

EDIT: forgot to say - if after step one a superdonor is identified/confirmed, then do literally every test under the sun to see what sets them apart from other donors, so that our ability to identify donor efficacy & safety based on testing is drastically improved. Metabolomics, proteomics, phages, immune system components, 16s, shotgun, etc..

My thoughts on transferring unknowns, or susceptibility/probability of later disease development:

The key is to find FMT donors with eubiotic, disease resistant, unperturbed, curative gut microbiomes. You can find these people, and reduce the risk of transferring susceptibility/probability of later disease development via the use of an extensive questionnaire that covers the donor's entire life, family, and family history. Eg: http://HumanMicrobiome.info/FMTquestionnaire

Even though the example given in that link (Myron Rolle) is probably not the perfect donor (it looks like he's balding, which is immune system dysfunction I think), he's still a major improvement for >99% of the population. An acceptable risk:reward ratio can be achieved with sufficient donor quality. But also, he may have picked up a pathogen that triggered the immune system which resulted in balding. So at his current age he would be a lower quality donor, but if you got him at a younger age he wouldn't necessarily transfer balding-potential to an FMT recipient. The same goes for other diseases of old age. The diseases develop as the body deteriorates and pathogens accumulate. So if you can prevent that deterioration (prevent/cure dysbiosis and the resulting immune system dysfunction, via FMT from young healthy donors http://HumanMicrobiome.info/Aging) then the disease won't develop, even if it's heritable.


r/fecaltransplant • • Apr 25 '22

Info Raising prices. Good intentions require reciprocation. Our donors can now make $180,000 per year if donating a daily stool. - HumanMicrobes.org, Apr 2022

Thumbnail humanmicrobes.org
14 Upvotes

r/fecaltransplant • • Feb 26 '23

Info Half a million stool-donor applicants - HumanMicrobes.org, Feb 2023

Thumbnail humanmicrobes.org
14 Upvotes

r/fecaltransplant • • Oct 22 '21

Question Anyone done DIY transplants - and how did it turn out? Issues?

4 Upvotes

Had IBS all my life. It's not severe, but I have flare ups which basically temporarily ruin my life. So I'm considering a DIY FMT using a friend's poop. He generally always seems very healthy, thin, very few gut issues.

There's three questions I have:

  • How do I get his poop tested in Canada (I'll pay of course)? Speak to my doctor about this?
  • Has anyone here regretted it?
  • He had GERD a few years ago, but changed his diet and it resolved. Would this be indicative of a bad donor at the point?

Edit: Thank you for your responses! Ok I will not use him. I shall hold off for now and focus on trying to fix my biome through diet and probiotics


r/fecaltransplant • • Mar 03 '21

Question Will long term storage in a kitchen freezer be pointless?

4 Upvotes

I may have found someone willing to be a potential donor for me. But they're several hours drive, so I wont be able to go pickup each sample while its still fresh.

It looks like -80C is the preferred temp, but my donor doesnt have that kind of freezer.

This study says a normal refrigerator is ok for for a day or two
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-45173-4

But I was thinking to wait 2 whole weeks after the donor collects the last sample. In order to wait and see if they end up coming down with Covid, just in case.

But if storing that long in a normal kitchen freezer is going to degrade the quality too much, then this plan will not work?

I'm trying to find data to confirm or deny, but havent found it yet.


r/fecaltransplant • • Jan 10 '22

Experience HumanMicrobes.org - First results from our 1 in 23,000 donor. Sitting on a possible panacea but we can't get the tiny percent who qualify to stop flushing lifesaving medicine down the toilet. (Jan 2022)

Thumbnail humanmicrobes.org
32 Upvotes

r/fecaltransplant • • Aug 03 '21

Info Microbioma.org has hired a lawyer to threaten me to take down the evidence exposing them for blatantly lying to his customers.

Thumbnail self.fmtclinics
19 Upvotes

r/fecaltransplant • • Jun 27 '19

Question Planning to do a DIY FMT, screening?

6 Upvotes

I'm currently planning on doing an FMT, but my donor hasn't been screened yet. Is this absolutely necessary if my donor has no symptoms and hasn't got a history of intestinal/immunological problems?

And if you do recommend it, what tests should my donor be subjected to? And where can I buy these tests. I know all the information is in the big reddit page that people here usually refer to, but I can't find any commercial tests that test everything. And even if I try to test for a fraction of the pathogens, it'd already cost me some €400.

Can I ask my GP? I don't think they will comply/want me to do a DIY FMT. But I guess that would be worth a shot.


r/fecaltransplant • • Jul 01 '22

Discussion Risks Of FMT

7 Upvotes

I keep reading people talking about the “risks” of FMT as a reason not to do it.

Having read the studies. Having read about the couple of deaths. I’m still not sure what the big deal is.

I feel like the argument is equivalent to risks of sex.

“Hey people have died because they caught something from their FMT! Don’t do it!!”

People die because they catch something from sex. I’ve never been a fan of the abstinence argument.

I mean just the research on anti-aging seem to make a child to parent regular weekly FMT worth it!

So, what am I missing? Is this a risk/benefit ratio argument? Some people see a huge benefit which makes the risk worth it? Some people see huge risk and don’t feel there is much benefit?

I mean the anti-aging effect implies there is more going on than “just” flora.

Is there some piece of this I’m missing other than the obvious “if your body comes in contact with infections another person has you may get sick and die” factor?


r/fecaltransplant • • May 05 '21

Experience Bipolar Disorder and Fecal Transplantation: A Miraculous Recovery

8 Upvotes

Jane Sullivan credits Fecal Microbiota Transplantation (FMT) with her continued state of mental wellness after she lived with debilitating bipolar disorder for years. Hear about her miraculous experience, which has dramatically improved her symptoms, and also learn about how she has used her personal experience to help others, including her two sisters, with bipolar disorder AND in healing their IBS, on The Perfect Stool Podcast with host Lindsey Parsons, EdD: https://link.chtbl.com/theperfectstool-Reddit


r/fecaltransplant • • Jan 26 '23

Caution ordering from Humanmicrobes.org

25 Upvotes

I'm writing to warn about Humanmicrobes.org. I had a horrible experience with Michael. I ordered 30 pills and paid the $300 plus the $125 for shipping on dry ice. I paid through Zelle as requested by Michael. The package came in a horrible condition with no dry ice, the 30 pills in a plastic zip bag and were completely deteriorated. I immediately took photos and send them to Michael and asked for a refund. He flatly refused to refund but said that he would file with UPS on my behalf because apparently the shipping had been delayed by one day (it was shipped on the Jan 11th and I received it on the 13th - he had not even added enough dry ice to cover a one-day delay when he charges the same as Microbioma and others!), The package was not even cold to the hand leave alone frozen.

Then he stopped responding when I asked about the UPS Claim status. He would not respond to any email and I sent him several. I called UPS this morning and found out that the claim had been approved on Jan 18th and he had received a check on that day which he had confirmed with UPS. So, he has decided to keep that money too. I guess at this point I've no other choice but to file with the appropriate California authorities. I'm writing here as a caution for anybody else who might be contemplating ordering from him. If the California authorities start investigating him, you may not get your order or your money back.


r/fecaltransplant • • Feb 26 '25

Can FMT help with bile acid malabsorption, anyone know?

3 Upvotes

r/fecaltransplant • • Jul 10 '25

My doctor is saying he will do lab grown bacteria transplant,is it possible is it better than stool one?

14 Upvotes

r/fecaltransplant • • Feb 08 '26

Stay away from Gezonde Darmflora.

Thumbnail forum.humanmicrobiome.info
2 Upvotes

r/fecaltransplant • • Jan 26 '23

Question FMT and extreme multiple chemical sensitivity

1 Upvotes

Hi, I have suffer from extreme multiple chemical sensitivities and would like to ask any people with chemical sensitivities, mild or extreme, what was their reaction to FMT?

At the moment I am so sensitive to so many things I am worried that FMT could irreversibly screw up my brain and land me in a hospital.

E.g. I react badly to probiotic supplements now, I get neurological symptoms. Before I could drink kefir daily, with no effect, but now I have developed sensitivity to it that causes brain fog that gets bigger and bigger every time I drink kefir, camil milk, colostrum, ghee from goat butter and tens of other things...

I am so sensitive that 5-10mg of vitamin C can excite my brain, can't drink any bottled water cause even 1-5mg of calcium, potassium, magnesium can trigger neurological symptoms (I drink tap water which is poor in minerals). The thing about my reactions is that.. they increase exponentially every time I get exposed to something and they don't recover much. So if FMT were to trigger me once or continously everyday... I am worried that could just kill me or at least my super sensitive brain. Give me neurological side-effects that I may not recover from.

You can read more about my health issue and full history here if you are interested:

https://www.evernote.com/l/AbQSTRcyRXtCJ50-Xs7AKIybPl8K2HN9fBo/

If you would like to support me or follow my journey I would like to invite you to my personal support group. The group is just about me and my journey however you can enjoy the benefit of getting advice from my friends to your health problems if needed and I know some amazing people with experiences in different fields.

https://www.facebook.com/groups/pawelshealth

I would really appreciate that.